The Trench discussion
Atlas Shrugged - Part 1
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Not Bill
(new)
Apr 01, 2010 03:52PM

reply
|
flag

Maybe we should do a discussion on a group of chapters per week instead of chapter by chapter. At 1000+ pages, we'll have 800 subjects!
Thoughts?

Oh, and I loved Dagny telling Conway she'd help him fight for the survival of the Phoenix-Durango.

Ugh. Of course she is.
Rearden's party was interesting, too. I get how out of touch he is with his family, but all those statists Lillian invited! Yikes! And Francisco throwing James' ideals back in his face...wow.

VJ, you can read this book 5 times and still pick up on new insights. I don't know how many times I have read it, but it must be around 7-10 times (over 10 years). It is daunting for the first read, and it does take a bit to sink in, but have faith, when the moment comes you will be pleased.

I don't know about a 26 hour day, but I am working on inventing a desk pillow... I believe there is a market for it.


SSH - that's Obama's plan, and to date he's been very successful. Everything he's done has been geared toward destroying our economy. He needs the volkes to dependant on the state - even if they hate what he's doing. Right now, he's winning - but stands to lose big in November if we keep active.

I'm about 100 pages away from it. With any luck I'll be there by the weekend.

Okay, now that that's out of the way. Who else wants to bitch-slap Mowen and James? Not to mention Cheryl for being such a starry-eyed dumbass.

Nick stay off Cheryl, Mowen and James are fair game though ;D"
Were we that stupid at 19? Yeah, I guess we were. Damn.

And I'm continually amazed how people today think that socialism is a good thing. I just want to slap people upside the head. Can I do that?

Sounds so typical, but right now I'm identifying with Dagny, probably because she's really the only woman of substance to come out so far. I can't say that I have her drive - that knowing who you were and what you were going to do with your life from that young age - but I like to think I have her straightforwardness.
I'd say I don't differ from my coworkers - I'm luck to work for a very Republican office where everyone speaks the Code.
I differ from about 98% of my friends, though. I'm a theatre wonk, and theatre people tend to be very liberal. I just shake my head and put my little zingers in when I can. We rarely talk politics; we kind of agree to disagree most of the time, shaking our heads at the foolishness of the other.
I'd love for there to be a Republican Meet-Up or something around here.

So Jini - why not host your own Repub meetup?

I don't have the time to do it. I've got a toddler, work full-time, and am the owner of a start-up theatre company (Facebook: Final Word Performing Arts Company). If someone says "Hey, we're meeting here, come on over!" I'm interested, but there's no way I can put one more thing on my plate.
And Nick, where's that clock with the extra hour?
Jini wrote: " And Nick, where's that clock with the extra hour? "
I didn't say I would invent a 26 hour clock, that was VJ.
Also I think Ayn Rand does elude to how things went so bad... Are the first time readers to the Motor company yet?
I didn't say I would invent a 26 hour clock, that was VJ.
Also I think Ayn Rand does elude to how things went so bad... Are the first time readers to the Motor company yet?


For me, right now what I see reflected in the book and in our current situation is the denigration and distruction of ingentuity on the part of the individual. Without this ethos, where would we be? In short, Einstein prolly would have remained in the employ of Nazi Germany. Not good.

Rusty wrote: "Somehow they'll twist it so it's all about global warming.
I have a question, though. Within Rand's philosophy, what is the role of the individual who is not an inventor, or innovator, or a g..."
I meant to respond to you about this before, Rusty. Ayn Rand (IMO) wrote to the industrialist because they are the people with the ability/resources to foster change. They were the folks she was trying to capture and draw attention to what was coming down the pipe.
As to what she wanted from the individual, genius or otherwise was to work toward your dreams. To achieve your own way, by your own means. I don't think it can be boiled down any further then that. Oh and kill anyone that says money is the root of all evil.
I have a question, though. Within Rand's philosophy, what is the role of the individual who is not an inventor, or innovator, or a g..."
I meant to respond to you about this before, Rusty. Ayn Rand (IMO) wrote to the industrialist because they are the people with the ability/resources to foster change. They were the folks she was trying to capture and draw attention to what was coming down the pipe.
As to what she wanted from the individual, genius or otherwise was to work toward your dreams. To achieve your own way, by your own means. I don't think it can be boiled down any further then that. Oh and kill anyone that says money is the root of all evil.


Oh, and is now supporting the new "non-acorn" voter intimidation and fraud program. Find the contributors, dog them and stop this train wreck