Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Halo (Halo, #1) Halo discussion


486 views
Xavier or Jake?

Comments Showing 201-250 of 392 (392 new)    post a comment »

message 201: by Ceia (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ceia ...I bet she secretly wanted a walk on the wildside :L


message 202: by Emily (new) - rated it 5 stars

Emily Ha. I don't know. I guess my next question is did she ever love Jake?


message 203: by Emily (new) - rated it 5 stars

Emily How do you pronounce Xavier. X-avier or Z-avier.


rai ♡ Emily wrote: "Ha. I don't know. I guess my next question is did she ever love Jake?"

I doubt it, I really doubt it. It can't really be called love if it's not returned back. I don't really think Jake loved Beth. What he had for her was an obsession, at least that's the way I see it. I don't feel like he knew Beth well, not like Xavier did.


rai ♡ Emily wrote: "How do you pronounce Xavier. X-avier or Z-avier."

It's a little bit of both an X and a Z. So X-zzzzzzavier.


message 206: by Emily (new) - rated it 5 stars

Emily Marshanah wrote: "Emily wrote: "Ha. I don't know. I guess my next question is did she ever love Jake?"

I doubt it, I really doubt it. It can't really be called love if it's not returned back. I don't really think J..."


Yeah, I totally agree. Jake never loved her and she definately never loved him.


message 207: by Ceia (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ceia I think he did love her, he just didn't know how to show it and then he got a bit desperate because Beth was so in love with Xavier.


message 208: by rai � (last edited May 16, 2012 05:32AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

rai ♡ Ceia wrote: "I think he did love her, he just didn't know how to show it and then he got a bit desperate because Beth was so in love with Xavier."

Yeah, I kinda agree with that. He DID get desperate. He could see that she loved Xavier, but Jake wanted her to want him. I still don't think he loved her, though. It was like she was something he knew he couldn't have, so he tricked her 'cause he knew she wouldn't come on her own to him willingly. Unless he was trying to kill someone she loved to get to her. That'd probably be the only way she would.


message 209: by Ceia (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ceia ...Star-crossed lovers. They couldn't be together. Aw. I still think he loved her just didn't know how to handle the emotion because of what he is and because he's from Hell. I think it's sweet in a twisted way.


rai ♡ Ceia wrote: "...Star-crossed lovers. They couldn't be together. Aw. I still think he loved her just didn't know how to handle the emotion because of what he is and because he's from Hell. I think it's sweet in ..."

Ha! Yeah, in a twisted way.... :P


message 211: by [deleted user] (new)

xavier


message 212: by Ceia (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ceia C'mon. You gotta admit it is just a little bit cute :3


rai ♡ Ceia wrote: "C'mon. You gotta admit it is just a little bit cute :3"

It's kinda cute, but I still think he's crazy. He just happens be a hot psycho. He can't help that.


message 214: by Molly (new) - rated it 5 stars

Molly Zibens XAVIER ALL THE WAY ! He caught my heart when I first read the book..


message 215: by Ceia (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ceia .....crazy but sweet at the same time. He's misunderstood. I feel really sorry for him :'(


rai ♡ Ceia wrote: ".....crazy but sweet at the same time. He's misunderstood. I feel really sorry for him :'("

Eh....though I feel sorry for him, I still like Xavier more.


Elouise I've definately always been more attracted to Jake.
And I don't think it's entirely his fault that he is the way he is.


message 218: by Faith (new) - rated it 5 stars

Faith Flores I'm all for XAVIER


Elizabeth Xavier


message 220: by [deleted user] (last edited Jun 18, 2012 05:01AM) (new)

I dunno. I like beth&Xavier together ;) but Jake's character seems really interesting, I mean he actually fell for beth in the 2nd book, so yeah. I actually don't know the answer to that.


Courtney Jake's an interesting character and all, but he went about it all wrong. He kidnapped her!! Hardly the way into her heart.

I prefer Xavier. I like the innocence of his character and how he unconditionally loves beth. I'm cheering for him!


rai ♡ Courtney wrote: "Jake's an interesting character and all, but he went about it all wrong. He kidnapped her!! Hardly the way into her heart.

I prefer Xavier. I like the innocence of his character and how he uncondi..."


Thatz so right!!! I don't really feel Jake loved Beth either. Xavier obviously loves her and Beth loved him back, unlike with Jake.


Courtney Marshanah wrote: "Courtney wrote: "Jake's an interesting character and all, but he went about it all wrong. He kidnapped her!! Hardly the way into her heart.

I prefer Xavier. I like the innocence of his character a..."



Exactly!! I don't think what Jake feels is love. I think he's just used to getting people to follow him and do whatever he wants, and when Beth rejects him, it hurts his pride. so he wants her to fall for him just because he can.

Xavier's intentions are pure and not selfish like jake's.


rai ♡ Courtney wrote: "Marshanah wrote: "Courtney wrote: "Jake's an interesting character and all, but he went about it all wrong. He kidnapped her!! Hardly the way into her heart.

I prefer Xavier. I like the innocence ..."


I totally agree with you.


message 225: by Arti (new) - rated it 3 stars

Arti Courtney wrote: "Jake's an interesting character and all, but he went about it all wrong. He kidnapped her!! Hardly the way into her heart.

I prefer Xavier. I like the innocence of his character and how he uncondi..."


We're on the same team


message 226: by Neesha (new) - rated it 5 stars

Neesha I like them BOTH! Being a bad boy is definitely sexy. And there's something about Jake that kinda made me attached to him though I dunno what that is yet. Xavier is wonderful and a lot of girls, including me wishes that we somehow find a guy like Xavier.

I think Jake has fallen in love with the idea of being in LOVE. Poor dude.


message 227: by Sophie (new)

Sophie Xavier, because jake treats Beth like she's worthless and someone to play with and xavier treats beth like the angel that she is


message 228: by Rachel (new) - rated it 5 stars

Rachel umm Jake is evil so I like Xavier better


message 229: by Cyndi (new) - rated it 4 stars

Cyndi Goodgame JAKE JAKE JAKE !!! Who cares if he's bad?!!!!!!!!!!!!


message 230: by rai � (last edited Jun 20, 2012 10:47AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

rai ♡ Cyndi wrote: "JAKE JAKE JAKE !!! Who cares if he's bad?!!!!!!!!!!!!"

Ummmm... how could you not care??!! He's practically the villan of the book besides "Big Daddy", the devil, and he almost got away with raping Beth and also he kidnapped her. Their whole relationship was based on Jake getting rejected by Beth becuz she loved Xavier, but not him, and Jake acting all obsessed with her. What he felt for Beth was a stalker kind of obsession, not love. And how can love be love, if it's only one sided. Thatz a miserable existence for a person.


message 231: by Faith (new) - rated it 5 stars

Faith Flores Ummmm... how could you not care??!! He's practically the villan of the book besides "Big Daddy", the devil, and he almost go..."

I totally agree with you. You have to care that just like you said his the DEVIL.


Ashley Marshanah wrote: "Cyndi wrote: "JAKE JAKE JAKE !!! Who cares if he's bad?!!!!!!!!!!!!"

Ummmm... how could you not care??!! He's practically the villan of the book besides "Big Daddy", the devil, and he almost go..."


Well said. I agree with you. Jake was just plain creepy and PURE EVIL!! Evil only wants one thing, Power. He didn't really want Beth. He felt like he did so he could out-do Xavier.


message 233: by Cyndi (new) - rated it 4 stars

Cyndi Goodgame Villian, yes. True. I guess I just want it proven that he really is heartless. Evil, yes. But did he really care for her more than he presented, buuuutttt had a strange way of dealing with it because he'd been bred to be bad? I guess I'm saying I believe in second chances also. He COULD redeem himself...maybe.


message 234: by Ceia (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ceia I think he thought Beth was his second chance. He loved her because he thought of her as his savior- even though he still made bad decisions. I don't think he liked who he was but he didn't know how to change.


Jerneice she should DEFIANTLY be with Xavier. Jake only wants to destroy her and Xavier loves her for her. he doesnt care what she is or how much danger he or she is in, he just wants to be with her for better and for worst and that is what true love really is. i didnt even know there was a second book!!!!!!!!


message 236: by Mara (new) - rated it 4 stars

Mara Smith I think Jake loved her but he didnt know how to express it well and just wanted her to feel the same, but I still think she should be with Xaiver


rai ♡ Ashley wrote: "Marshanah wrote: "Cyndi wrote: "JAKE JAKE JAKE !!! Who cares if he's bad?!!!!!!!!!!!!"

Ummmm... how could you not care??!! He's practically the villan of the book besides "Big Daddy", the devil..."


Also, for the power part, he felt that by having an angel in hell, that'd give him a better standing with the devil.


message 238: by rai � (last edited Jun 20, 2012 11:13PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

rai ♡ Mara wrote: "I think Jake loved her but he didnt know how to express it well and just wanted her to feel the same, but I still think she should be with Xaiver"

She does belong with Xavier. What Jake did, whether an act of poorly expressed love or just plain obsession, was wrong. He couldn't force her to love him. He should've realize that before he ended up being killed. But he didn't. He was blinded by his lust for her and his need for power.


message 239: by Cyndi (new) - rated it 4 stars

Cyndi Goodgame True enough. But sometimes I like to side with the bad guy just to see how others defend the good guy. I think you nailed it when you said he was blinded by his need for power. That describes him in full whether he "thought" he was loving her or not. Still, Mr. Mystery is intriguing.


message 240: by Mara (new) - rated it 4 stars

Mara Smith Marshanah wrote: "Mara wrote: "I think Jake loved her but he didnt know how to express it well and just wanted her to feel the same, but I still think she should be with Xaiver"

She does belong with Xavier. What Ja..."

I know I completely think she belongs with Xavier


message 241: by rai � (last edited Jun 20, 2012 11:14PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

rai ♡ Cyndi wrote: "True enough. But sometimes I like to side with the bad guy just to see how others defend the good guy. I think you nailed it when you said he was blinded by his need for power. That describes hi..."

I guess..... I guess we'll never know if his obsession for Beth was an act of badly expressed love in the "i've never felt this way before and don't know how to deal with it" way or just in the psycho way. It was probably the ladder.


rai ♡ Mara wrote: "Marshanah wrote: "Mara wrote: "I think Jake loved her but he didnt know how to express it well and just wanted her to feel the same, but I still think she should be with Xaiver"

She does belong wi..."


I agree. Xavier and Beth have that true love thing.


Bluesky xavier of course!!! :D :D :D


message 244: by Jenna (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jenna Xav, no doubt. No one likes an evil character...


rai ♡ Jenna wrote: "Xav, no doubt. No one likes an evil character..."

Well, that depends on what the character's motivation behind being evil was. No one likes an evil character, but they can at least try to understand them. In Jake's case though, there's no understanding. He's just crazy.


message 246: by Jenna (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jenna Marshanah wrote: "Jenna wrote: "Xav, no doubt. No one likes an evil character..."

Well, that depends on what the character's motivation behind being evil was. No one likes an evil character, but they can at least t..."


Haha! Totally agree!


message 247: by Sydney (new) - rated it 3 stars

Sydney I like Xavier because of what he feels. I think Jake is creepy, especilly in the second. I haven't even finished it!


message 248: by Casey (new) - rated it 4 stars

Casey Xavier is the good guy who just wants a normal life.
Jake is a mysterious guy, kind of similar to Damon in TVD. I personally like Xavier more for this series.


Jerneice i am currently reading the second book and can jake just take NO for an answer!!!!!! he is like a clingy boy who doesnt know when to stop. i personally LOVE Xavier!


rai ♡ Casey wrote: "Xavier is the good guy who just wants a normal life.
Jake is a mysterious guy, kind of similar to Damon in TVD. I personally like Xavier more for this series."


Me too.


back to top