Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Nataliya's Reviews > To Kill a Mockingbird

To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3672777
Life gives you a few things that you can count on. Death (for all), taxes (for most), and the unwavering moral character of Atticus Finch (for me). "What would Atticus do?" is not just a meme; for eleven-year-old me it became a real consideration after I feigned an illness to cut school and stay home to finish To Kill a Mockingbird � while a decidedly non-Atticus-like move, choosing Harper Lee's book over sixth grade math was probably a wiser life choice.
For my thoughts on the shameless money grab by the money-greedy publishers recently published first draft of the novel inexplicably (or read: cash grab) marketed as a sequel... Well, I think I just said it all.
I cannot be objective about this book - I don't think you can ever be about the things you love. I've read it many times as a child and a few times as an adult, and it never lost that special something that captivated me as a kid of Jem Finch's age.


“[...] Before I can live with other folks I've got to live with myself. The one thing that doesn't abide by majority rule is a person's conscience.�
To me, this book is as close to perfect as one can get.

It found a place in school curriculum because of its message, undoubtedly - but it's not what makes it so powerful. After all, if you have even a speck of brains you will understand that racism is wrong and you should treat people right and that “You never really understand a person until you consider things from his point of view... Until you climb inside of his skin and walk around in it.�

No, what makes it wonderful is the perfect narrative voice combining adult perspective while maintaining a child's voice, through which we glimpse both the grown-up woman looking back through the lessons of years while still seeing the unmistakable innocence and incorruptible feistiness of young Scout Finch. And then there is the magic of the slow measured narration painting the most vivid picture of the sleepy Southern town where there's enough darkness lurking inside the people's souls to be picked up even by very young, albeit quite perceptive children.
"If there's just one kind of folks, why can't they get along with each other? If they're all alike, why do they go out of their way to despise each other? Scout, I think I'm beginning to understand something. I think I'm beginning to understand why Boo Radley's stayed shut up in the house all this time. It's because he wants to stay inside.�
And then there's Atticus Finch. Yes, there may be countless articles all fueled by Lee's first draft about his 'transformation' into a bigot - but I refuse to jump on that bandwagon. I stand behind him the way Lee developed him in the book she *did* publish. Because I sleep better knowing that there are people out there who are good and principled and kind and compassionate, who will do everything they can with the utmost patience to teach their children to be decent human beings.
“I wanted you to see what real courage is, instead of getting the idea that courage is a man with a gun in his hand. It's when you know you're licked before you begin, but you begin anyway and see it through no matter what."
What shines in this book the most for me is the amazing relationship between parent and child. It's the amazing guidance that the Finch children get in becoming good human beings that many of us would give up a lot for. I know I would. Because to me it will never be a story of a white man saving the world (and some, especially with the publication of that ridiculous first draft, would dismiss it as such). To me, it's the story of a child growing up and learning to see the world with the best possible guidance. It's a story of learning to understand and respect kindness and forgiveness and that sometimes you do right things not just because you're told to but because they are right things to do.

I see enough stupidity and nonsense and injustice in this world. And after all of it, what I often do need is Atticus Finch and reassurance that things can be right, and that with the few exceptions, even if I struggle to see it, "[...] there's just one kind of folks. Folks." and that, disillusioned as we become as we go on in life, "Most people are [nice], Scout, when you finally see them.�

Five stars from both child and adult me.
434 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read To Kill a Mockingbird.
Sign In »

Quotes Nataliya Liked

Harper Lee
“Until I feared I would lose it, I never loved to read. One does not love breathing.”
Harper Lee, To Kill a Mockingbird

Harper Lee
“Before I can live with other folks I’ve got to live with myself. The one thing that doesn’t abide by majority rule is a person’s conscience.”
Harper Lee, To Kill a Mockingbird


Reading Progress

May 2, 2010 – Shelved
January 31, 2015 – Started Reading
February 23, 2015 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-43 of 43 (43 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Ronyell (new)

Ronyell Ooh! I can't wait to hear your opinions on this book!


message 2: by Rajabalikapri (new)

Rajabalikapri Raaz Kapri oh good dear


Keith Fantastic review. Atticus Finch is an unforgettable character, a man to admire wholeheartedly. He was kind of the perfect father figure for me, when I was growing up, and it's nice to know he's influenced so many other people, too.


Nataliya Thanks, KK.


Linda Great review. I recently re-read, having not enjoyed it since I was young. Now, as a parent, my love for Atticus skyrocketed to whole new levels.


Ellen Loved your review, Nataliya. I also love TKAM-I don't think I'll read the "sequel" because I don't want my relationship with Atticus tainted (yes, I feel as though Atticus and I have some kind of relationship after all the times I've read this book!).


Jenan Perfect review. You summed up my own feelings about the book wonderfully.


message 8: by Lynne (new) - added it

Lynne King Nataliya, Well this is a perfect review of a perfect book. I've had this book sitting on my book shelves for quite a few years now and must get around to reading it!


message 9: by Samadrita (last edited Aug 23, 2015 09:28AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Samadrita Loved loved the angle you took with the review, Nataliya. It's the precocious child's way of taking stock of a prejudiced town and the moral failings of its residents that seals this work's status as a classic with enduring appeal. Marvelous review.

I wish I had read this as a child.


Steve I like this review a whole lot! The context and contrast you provide vis a vis Watchman is excellent. I liked your point about it being a great piece of writing beyond the simple message of respect, too. You've reminded me that a reread may be in order, and I say that about very few books.


Fajer Nice review!


Nataliya Fajer wrote: "Nice review!"

Thanks!


message 13: by Luce (new) - rated it 5 stars

Luce I've only just started this book and your review has really encouraged and me to see this book in a different light!


Mihaela Baciu I loved the book. Scout is the little girl I wish to have and Atticus the perfect dad.


message 15: by Laura (new) - added it

Laura


message 16: by Sarah (new)

Sarah Amazing and spot on review. I also bought go set a watchman but I can't bring myself to read it because I love the characters too much and it is supposed to shine an entirely different light on them. Not sure I could live with that.


Christine Fantastic, insightful review! I have never been able to express my feelings about this book, and its importance. Your remarks were very eloquent.

(And I will never read Go Set a Watchman. No desire to, no reason to.)


Roberto The words you wrote where nothing but true since many people can relate to this girl since it is told by her and Atticus is close to being a perfect father and is always teaching good life lessons and tries to help everyone when needed and it is one of the best and most perfect books out there.


message 19: by Seattle (new)

Seattle Al Another spot-on review, Nataliya. The core of this book is a child's adoration of her father leading her to wisdom. Wisdom about injustice, hatred, kindness, love, courage, and pain. And the blended narrator--sometimes child, sometimes adult--sweeps us along.


Nataliya Seattle wrote: "Another spot-on review, Nataliya. The core of this book is a child's adoration of her father leading her to wisdom. Wisdom about injustice, hatred, kindness, love, courage, and pain. And the blende..."

Thanks, Seattle! This book has always held a special place in my heart.


message 21: by Seattle (new)

Seattle Al I haven't reread the novel in many years, but I saw the Broadway production last year. Parts of the script annoyed me--they were very untrue to the book. But one change impressed me.

I think it's fair to say that in the novel, Bob Ewell is singled out as the "really bad guy"; the other white townspeople are treated as too easily inflamed but ultimately decent. That's the portrayal at the attempted lynching scene, where Scout pushes through the angry crowd and saves the day, showing us that these white folks can be brought to their senses.

But these same white folks condemned Tom Robinson to death knowing full well he was innocent. So Harper Lee is giving them a pass for deciding Black lives don't matter (that much). The Broadway play, for all its faults, didn't let these people off the hook. They were murderers, and walking a mile in their shoes doesn't change that.

Still, the book was an accurate reflection of the times seen from the point of view of a white seven-year-old girl, and if Atticus shouldn't have been as forgiving of the white murderers, it's also true he had to make a safe life for his children in the town. A hero doesn't have to be perfect.

I can't think of another movie that captured a novel as well as the Gregory Peck movie did.


Nataliya Looks like Harper Lee was hopeful that appealing to the people’s better side would help bring out that better side. Sometimes it works, sometimes it sadly doesn’t.

Gregory Peck was excellent in that movie.


Pooja  Jha Yup I too liked that how being a single father Atticus Finch took care of both his children and especially how he answered their curious questions which other parents would have avoided....


Whitney Kerr I love this book. It was great for our history learning bout racism. But than when they came out with the second one To go set a watchman I didn't like that one at all. that is way I only reaf it once. Because anytime that I like a book I'll read it more than once. See the thing is Atticaus ( don't know if I spell his name right sorry if I didn't) but he was the attorney for that man and than in Go set a watchman it came out that he a don't like black people. Even Scout could not believe it. That is all I have to say because I'm getting mad about it.


Michael Finocchiaro This is a classic. The sequel, however, is horrible. The movie is of course amazing.
Last October, I was in NYC for the first time in 22 years and had the privilege to see Aaron Sorkin’s take on this with Jeff Daniels in the lead role on Broadway. It was spectacular. It actually pulled in a few ideas from Watchman (primarily Finch’s own racism) but was perfect from a casting, pacing, dialog and decors point of view.


message 26: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa What a beautiful love letter to one of my all time favorite reads. I pull this out to re-read when I've been overwhelmed with exposure to cynicism and lack of honor. I appreciate that you find the same solace in this work.


Nataliya Lisa wrote: "What a beautiful love letter to one of my all time favorite reads. I pull this out to re-read when I've been overwhelmed with exposure to cynicism and lack of honor. I appreciate that you find the ..."

Thanks, Lisa! I love it still, even if it’s been almost three decades since I first skipped school to breathlessly read it. It’s such a great book, and it never fails to restore some of my faith in humanity.


Nataliya Michael wrote: "This is a classic. The sequel, however, is horrible. The movie is of course amazing.
Last October, I was in NYC for the first time in 22 years and had the privilege to see Aaron Sorkin’s take on th..."


I decided to not read the “sequel� which seems to have been the discarded first draft but was sure to bring $$ to the publishers. There was a reason it did not see the light of the day while Harper Lee was alive, and publishing it after her death to me seemed like a disrespectful disregard of her wishes in pursuit of a cash grab.


Karen Spot on review of both the book and the movie, Nataliya. I also refuse to read the "sequel" because I don't want it to spoil in any way the perfection of the book Lee did publish. There's a reason first drafts aren't usually published.


Nataliya Karen wrote: "Spot on review of both the book and the movie, Nataliya. I also refuse to read the "sequel" because I don't want it to spoil in any way the perfection of the book Lee did publish. There's a reason ..."

Thanks, Karen! I’m glad you see it the same way as I do. Had she wanted to publish that draft, she would have at some point in her long life. I suspect she kept it out of sentimental attachment � but it was too much for the inheritors of her legacy to resist the promise of huge cash prize from the controversial publication.


Justin Pickett Wonderful review! I love the stars given from both the child and adult perspective! I’m embarrassed to say I haven’t read the book yet (only watched the movie), especially since we named our son after Atticus. Your review is a reminder that I need to get moving on reading this!


Nataliya Justin wrote: "Wonderful review! I love the stars given from both the child and adult perspective! I’m embarrassed to say I haven’t read the book yet (only watched the movie), especially since we named our son af..."

Thanks, Justin! I think you’ll love this book since you loved the movie.


message 33: by Seattle (new)

Seattle Al Again you nail it. This book is first and foremost about a daughter's attempts to understand the world through the morality spoken and lived by her loved and loving father. Racism, Boo Radley, poverty are all pieces of the world that a child must grope to understand (adults too). To have had Atticus as her guide and moral compass fills the reminiscing narrator with gratitude.


message 34: by Seattle (new)

Seattle Al I can't believe I commented again, forgetting I had done so ages ago! Brain rot.


Nataliya Seattle wrote: "Again you nail it. This book is first and foremost about a daughter's attempts to understand the world through the morality spoken and lived by her loved and loving father. Racism, Boo Radley, pove..."

Im just amazed how this book never loses its charm for me - whether I’m closer to Scout’s age or Atticus� doesn’t matter.

Seattle wrote: "I can't believe I commented again, forgetting I had done so ages ago! Brain rot."

Hey, I’m glad you did!


message 36: by Mona (new) - rated it 3 stars

Mona Great review, Nataliya. Yes, I, too wish I’d had a parent like Atticus Finch. Sadly, I did not.


Nataliya Mona wrote: "Great review, Nataliya. Yes, I, too wish I’d had a parent like Atticus Finch. Sadly, I did not."

Thanks, Mona! I wish that, too � but few people are that lucky.


message 38: by Dave (new)

Dave Excellent review. I just yesterday saw the Broadway production starring JohnBoy.


Nataliya Dave wrote: "Excellent review. I just yesterday saw the Broadway production starring JohnBoy."

Thanh’s, Dave!


message 40: by Kaira-Lee (new)

Kaira-Lee wonderful review! very well written.


Nataliya Kaira-Lee wrote: "wonderful review! very well written."

Thanks :)


Tatiana Putra Choosing Harper Lee over 6th grade math was a very Scoutlike think to do. Loved this review


Nataliya Tatiana wrote: "Choosing Harper Lee over 6th grade math was a very Scoutlike think to do. Loved this review"

You don’t even know how happy it makes me to read this :)
Thanks!


back to top