Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Joe's Reviews > The Deep

The Deep by Nick Cutter
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
26876584
's review

it was ok
bookshelves: sci-fi-apocalyptic, sci-fi-first-contact
Reading for the 2nd time. Most recently started July 30, 2022.

The next stop in my end-of-the-world reading marathon was The Deep by Nick Cutter. This is a well-executed thriller by an author whose previous novel The Troop was terrific. Cutter, pseudonym of Canadian author Craig Davidson, returns to gothic horror with style straight out of the Stephen King playbook, with the spectacular body horror of movies like The Thing or The Fly thrown in. But what was terrible and exciting in his previous novel is done to death here.

The novel opens in Guam, where veterinarian Dr. Lucas Nelson has been flown five thousand miles from his home in Iowa City on the dime of the U.S. government. The world has been ravaged by a virus dubbed The 'Gets; beginning with an outbreak of dark specks, the condition spreads (like the bruises on a banana as it turns overripe) until the patient starts to forget things, like where the car keys are. Ultimately, they forget what hot and cold feel like and eventually, why they need to breathe.

Luke is ferried to research station Hesperus which floats atop the deepest point in the ocean, the Mariana Trench, six miles below. Two miles under that in the Challenger Deep is the Trieste, a tube-like station constructed by robots. This is where Luke's brother, the prodigious molecular biologist Clayton Nelson, is working. A primitive gelatinous substance which Clayton has dubbed "Ambrosia" has been discovered on the ocean floor and promises a cure for every human disease, including the 'Gets, as well as immortality.

The Hesperus has received a transmission from Clayton asking for Luke to come home. An animal doctor who is estranged from his gifted brother, Luke's presence on the Hesperus is nevertheless seen as critical. His escort is Lt. Commander Alice Sykes, a jocular servicewoman who asks Luke to call her "Al". Before they submerge, Luke is briefed on an unsettling development. One of the three scientists in the Trieste, or what's left of him, has surfaced. Madness and a high tolerance for pain are the only explanations for what might have happened, along with a message written in the submersible in blood.

THE AG MEN ARE HERE COME HOME WE NEED YOU COME HOME

Luke has agreed to venture to the deepest point on earth because he has nothing left to lose. His son Zachary disappeared seven years ago during a game of hide and seek with his father in the park. Luke's wife left him and then the 'Gets set upon the globe. Luke has a closet full of skeletons. In addition to his missing and presumed dead son, there's emotional abuse he endured from his mother, "Battle Axe" Beth, a prison trustee who went on disability, grew obese and set out to torment her youngest son. Then there are memories of a boogeyman that plagued Luke and later his son, which Zach called the "Fig Men" off his father's assurance it was just a "figment".

The Deep follows a trend in science fiction that I find annoying: bloat. Davidson introduces a worldwide pandemic and abandons it. He switches gears from the apocalypse into gothic horror, with the claustrophobia of the Challenger Deep. The novel steps all over the intellectual property of at least two first contact novels turned film -- Solaris and Sphere -- with scientists encountering an alien entity that manifests their nightmares. Even if Davidson had forgotten about the 'Gets, at best, the novel would've been highly derivative.

Davidson isn't done borrowing from other material, some of it beneath a writer of his talent. The setting has what could be called "Camp Crystal Lake Echo", where a character finds themselves alone in a remote setting and feels the urge to call out to a friend, thereby alerting the killer exactly where they are. I lost count how many times Luke called out, and this is a character who's seen horror movies like Alien. That annoyed me.

My biggest problem with the novel is how much woe and misfortune Davidson dumps on his main character. The battle of wills that take place between a young Luke and his cruel, obese mother might've been the backbone of a much better book. There's a sinister "tickle box" or toy box that Battle Axe Beth buys for her son, with the faces of clowns painted on the side. Creepy box and creepy clowns are scary, but piling a missing child, a failed marriage, an estranged brother and a global pandemic on top of that is overkill.

The Deep is executed with precision. It's spooky in spots, even when Davidson channels Uncle Stevie by relating observations by the main character to some event in his past; this gets repetitive, but isn't what sinks the novel. There were too many ideas, too few characters and something else that bothered me: abuse to animals. I'm not squeamish when it comes to fictional violence, but what was noticable in The Troop (lab chimps and a sea turtle do not fare well) is really made obvious here, with dogs, guinea pigs, mice and ... bees? Like everything else here, it it's too much.
42 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read The Deep.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

July 31, 2014 – Shelved
July 31, 2014 – Shelved as: to-read
March 3, 2015 – Started Reading
March 3, 2015 –
1.0% "He may not have drunk water in days. He'd forgotten to, probably. That's how it went with the 'Gets: you forgot the little things first, then the not-so-little things, then the big ones. Next, the critical ones. In time, your heart forgot how to beat, your lungs how to breathe. You die knowing nothing at all."
March 3, 2015 –
10.0% "Luke's feelings for her changed gradually. Before the incident, he'd loved his mother openheartedly in spite of the worrisome signs--the spankings that left welts, the way her gaze could sit upon his skull like a tarantula ready to sink in its fangs. But during the Bad Years, she became truly cruel. In time, Luke realized that cruelty was an implicit facet of her nature; she'd simply taken awhile to express it."
March 4, 2015 –
19.0% "Felz closed the laptop. "That's the hope. Perhaps there's an abundance of it. Perhaps--and this is an admittedly out there hypothesis--what we've found so far are shreds of a far larger organism. A mother-organism, if you will." A quaver passed down Luke's spine. A mother organism. Huge and amorphous and ageless, lying in darkness at the bottom of the sea. Jesus."
March 5, 2015 –
71.0% "The water wasn't the same down here. Water is what runs out of our kitchen taps or a playground drinking fountain. It fills bathtubs and pools and yes, of course, the ocean--but at a certain depth, water becomes a barrier from all you remember, all you think you know. You're trapped within it, a plaything of it. Focus erodes. Your thoughts mutate. The pressure. The pressure. The soul can't cope with that."
March 6, 2015 –
98.0% "Pitiless. This was Luke's second and overriding sense. Beholding them. Luke realized for the first time in his life that there are things on earth, or beyond it, who are careless in the most quotidian terms: they lack the inclination or desire to care for anything. They are pitiless in the most simplified fashion, as they simply lack the ability to feel it."
March 6, 2015 – Shelved as: sci-fi-apocalyptic
March 6, 2015 – Shelved as: sci-fi-first-contact
March 6, 2015 – Finished Reading
July 30, 2022 – Started Reading

Comments Showing 1-12 of 12 (12 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Licha (new) - added it

Licha This was on my list, especially after having read The Troop, but now you've given me second thoughts. I may try it at some point, but it's definitely not gonna get a rush on my list.


Richard Joe wrote: "My biggest problem with the novel is how much woe and misfortune Davidson dumps on his main character."

I had this SAME exact problem with the book. It felt as if the author was just throwing obstacles around to create more excitement. But instead it just lessened the impact of each. Although I was creeped out in some parts (like the bees), I felt it should've been more focused. And the 'Gets deserves it's own book instead of being cast off in the beginning of this one.


message 3: by Carmen (new) - added it

Carmen This sounds very confusing, actually. o.O I'm confused as to where he wants the horror to be coming from, it seems to be coming from all sides. However, I still think I am going to take a stab at this one and see where I end up. But the animal abuse is giving me pause. Great review, Joseph.


message 4: by Joe (last edited Mar 08, 2015 09:27PM) (new) - rated it 2 stars

Joe Licha wrote: "This was on my list, especially after having read The Troop, but now you've given me second thoughts. I may try it at some point, but it's definitely not gonna get a rush on my list."

Sound strategy, Licha. Most of the reviews on Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ seem wildly enthusiastic. I felt that The Troop was the alpha version of this story while The Deep was the beta version that was published by mistake.

Richard Vialet wrote: "I had this SAME exact problem with the book. It felt as if the author was just throwing obstacles around to create more excitement. But instead it just lessened the impact of each."

I thought that you were a fan of Cutter's, Richard, so your agreement that the novel was deeply flawed comes as a surprise to me. Thanks for commenting!

Carmen wrote: "I'm confused as to where he wants the horror to be coming from, it seems to be coming from all sides. However, I still think I am going to take a stab at this one and see where I end up. But the animal abuse is giving me pause."

I'm from Texas, where some men would be more broken by their dog getting run over than their wife. You just don't hurt a dog in a movie or book. That was actually a very minor problem for me with this book. Give it a try, Carmen. You might like it.


message 5: by Cathy (new)

Cathy DuPont Thanks, Joe. I'll pass on this one but sure thank you for your great review.


Richard Naw that might be someone else you're thinking of Joe. I'm not a huge fan, I've only read this book. You were a little harder on the book than I was but I was very disappointed. I plan on reading The Troop during Halloween time though. I heard that one is great.


Ɗẳɳ  2.☊ I enjoyed the Troop, but there are a few scenes of animal torture in that as well. Hope that doesn't become a trend for Mr. Davidson.


message 8: by Leah (new)

Leah Polcar I was thinking of getting this book, thank goodness I read your review first. I wasn't the hugest fan of The Troop (I know, heresy) so I thought maybe this would be more up my alley, but apparently not. Thanks for saving me time that I can spend on something worthwhile.


message 9: by Patrick (new) - added it

Patrick Holt Your review pretty much summed it all up. Just a huge lack of focus, in the book, overall.


Carlos Bees? I'm reading this book at the moment, and while knowing there'll be violence towards dogs makes me feel annoyed (can't help it, I love animals) your mention of bees brought me flashbacks of Nic Cage's The Wicker Man.


message 11: by Jeanette (new)

Jeanette I dislike that switch you describe too. But never gave it a name. When they have such a prime premise why do they switch and leave it sitting on a ledge? I'll read The Troop. I've never read this author.


Yuzuru I. oh, dear, you just said my fears about the book - I am at the beginning, and they are just explaining the panacea made of unobtanium. I am "ok, they are going down for the rest of the book, what is the relevance of the plague" and as I had deduced, it has none and could be just as easily a cure for cancer. The fact that an author would push an world end epidemy in the first chapter just to abandon it is really trashy, I don´t know why certain books keep getting recommend it, I think horror fans have a really low threashold


back to top