Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Jasmine's Reviews > One Day

One Day by David Nicholls
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
1122151
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: british

** spoiler alert ** There will be spoilers...

I am no longer speaking to this book it has seriously pissed me off. It is imperialist unamerican and majorly depressing. I have done you a favor Mr Nicholls and decided not to kill myself lest it reflect poorly on your book, but you made me want to repeatedly. And yes I understand you are british and that there is something fundamentally wrong with british people that makes you uncomfortable with anyone have a remotely good day in a novel, but seriously. Honestly David I am a bit worried about you and I think it maybe a good idea for you to go see a therapist you seem intensely depressed to me and you don't want to go ending up like B.S. Johnson now do you?

Right so now that I am done ranting about cultural differences on to ranting about the book. This book basically has the plot of an american romantic comedy. Nicholls even knows this and periodically remarks on it (comparing the main characters to Harry and Sally for example). Unlike an American story it's well depressing and not a little bit, all the time. I know it is hard to imagine but this is a book about two people who are basically depressed constantly, okay I lie once Emma is happy and maybe twice Dexter is happy in a course of 20 years, and it is never super happy, just eh okay happy. They are constantly in relationships they hate with people that hate them or generally terrible at whatever they are attempting to do at that moment. Seriously this is why I am getting up in the morning so that I can be miserable once again?

This book seems to me to have two options for trajectories:
The American: They get together and everyone lives happily ever after.
The british: they stay friends but they never seem to slow down long enough to get together.

The second option feels like the direction the book is going for a full 3 hundred pages. Dexter even at one point says something along these lines to Emma. And to be completely honest I was okay with that. I understand the idea that some people just can't slow down enough to make a relationship work. I understand that regardless of how much Emma and Dexter love each other, which is evident in the book, that sometimes things just don't manage to fall into place. This doesn't mean that they don't love each other enough or that there is something wrong with them, it simply means that circumstances are simply unable to create a world in which people like Emma and Dexter end up together. Perhaps they care to much, perhaps in the end we all settle. With passion comes disease and argument, and a relationship of love can never be quite as perfect as a relationship of compromise. Of Dexter marrying someone else and agreeing to become a just good enough husband, of Emma settling for a man who loves her whom she can't manage to change quite enough to love him back. This is where I thought the book was going to go. Perhaps the book still ends up here in a terribly horrendous way but first...

The book goes american on us. They manage to get together, and just in time, whew almost missed that whole biological clock thing, and yes circumstances could be better. I mean that idiot Dexter has a kid that truly belongs to someone else and he has been a loser and a drunk for the better part of 40 years, but at least it finally happens. And Emma fixes him. Yay for an american happy ending.

But wait on their two year anniversary "Emma Morley dies" and I am not kidding that is the amount of play it gets in the book. She thinks she is going to be late meeting dexter to look at a house and she dies. This is where the book and I began our grudge map. I did not wait 350 pages for something good to finally happen so that people could suddenly get killed off. And Dexter becomes a bad person again, but he gets over it and is friends with his ex wife again and dating the manager of his shop, um can you say incest? Serious at least date someone who your wife wasn't making jokes about you cheating on her with.

So seriously David I am worried about you if these are your introjects of the world, please email me I will help you find a good therapist.
49 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read One Day.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

June 16, 2010 – Shelved
June 28, 2010 – Started Reading
June 28, 2010 –
page 77
17.62% "There is something about a good book that makes you feel like your entire life is worthless and everything might be a bit better if you jumped off the brooklyn bridge."
July 2, 2010 –
page 300
68.65%
July 2, 2010 – Finished Reading
October 15, 2010 – Shelved as: british

Comments Showing 1-40 of 40 (40 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Kate (new)

Kate Umm, so I'm wondering why you gave it 5 stars?


Jasmine oh...

because the book is fantastic.


message 3: by Kate (new)

Kate Well you're review doesn't read that way. Quite the reverse in fact.


Jasmine hmmm... I hadn't really thought about it, but I suppose that is why you have the review and the stars. There are plenty of books that I like that I think can be critiqued and torn apart. also I think the thing my review is critiquing is more british culture and such not the fault of nicholls himself.


message 5: by Kate (new)

Kate As a brit I'll try not to take that personally:) I see your point and now that I think about it there have been a few books that I liked but didn't like the premise or the characters. Cheers!


Jasmine thanks.

I don't mean it as an insult to brits. I just noticed that when I said some of the things that ended up here to my ex who is very british, he didn't think there was another reasonable option to make a good novel.

happy reading.


message 7: by Joel (new)

Joel oops, i read this and now i don't want to read the book. even though i already have a copy. but i think it would have depressed me. so maybe that's ok.


Jasmine you could stop 100 pages from the end.


message 9: by Joel (last edited Sep 22, 2010 06:00PM) (new)

Joel yeah. that worked out when i read the twilight saga. i stopped 2,000 pages from the end.


Jasmine is that like 3 books?


message 11: by Joel (last edited Sep 22, 2010 06:05PM) (new)

Joel yes.


message 12: by Joel (new)

Joel although it wasn't so much the ending i was trying to avoid, but the bad, bad middle. and also the ending. i was too late to miss the beginning though.


Jasmine oh well I have a policy that when anyone says "it gets better in the second book" I don't read any of them. so far that has excluded harry potter and twilight. although with harry I was told 4th.


message 14: by Joel (new)

Joel twilight was so terrible that i would never read any more of them. all of the harry potter books are good though. it's not like you have to slog through the first three, they just mature along with the characters. the third one is actually my favorite, but the second one is good too. i mean, and the first.


message 15: by Beth (new) - rated it 3 stars

Beth I just finished this and agree wholeheartedly with your review. I felt like I had been knocked over when I read the "Emma Morley Dies" line! Why couldn't he have just let them live happily ever after -- there's no point to it ending the way it did. Did love the writing and the annual "journal" entry device though. Of course I lived in England for 5 years when I was ages 5-10 so I get British humor.


message 16: by Jason (new)

Jason Brown (Toastx2) i loved what i read of your review, though i had to stop half way as i did not want to spoil my own tortured reading... then i finished the review after beth's comment destroyed hope of that.

i honestly have no desire to add more to my reading list right now.. i am behind as is and wish i were a faster reader. i am a sucker for books like this.. painful yet excellent.

but this? i cant help it, will have to read it..
as such, i hate you, kinda.. (grain of salt)


Jasmine I totally feel your pain, recently I've read william gaddis and I'm halfway through infinite jest now and while I read them I bought like thirty books. I can't keep up.


message 18: by Jason (new)

Jason Brown (Toastx2) inf jest is on my shelf.
it mocks me.. as do all my friends who keep telling me to read it.
i may have to buck up and dive in.


Jasmine I won't mock you, put it off as long as you want


message 20: by Paul (new)

Paul Bryant great review

"With passion comes disease and argument"

I shall be stealing that line at some point. Watch for it in one of my future reviews.


message 21: by Jasmine (last edited Dec 02, 2010 03:06PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jasmine Paul wrote: "great review

"With passion comes disease and argument"

I shall be stealing that line at some point. Watch for it in one of my future reviews."


it's yours. plagurize at will.

the next statement a relationship of love can never be quite as perfect as a relationship of compromise. is probably the saddest thing I've ever said. sometimes I don't believe myself


message 22: by Anja (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anja It was "nice" that it wasn't a happy ending for Emma and Dex, I gueassed I was in that mood were I didn't want happily ever after. And something back in my mind told me that someone would die, but I expected it to be dex or Sylvie, not Emma. But then again, it was a happy ending, in a bizarre kind of way. Dexter really got his act together on his ownl, thoruhg the thaught of Emma. She was his savior, even in death!


message 23: by Paul (new)

Paul Bryant We don't like Hollywood endings!


PeachyTO Umm, just thought I'd let you know you may want to look up the definition of incest.


message 25: by Jason (new)

Jason Brown (Toastx2) Peachy wrote: "Umm, just thought I'd let you know you may want to look up the definition of incest."

each culture has various levels of taboo associated with the term. it is commonly used for the parent/sibling, sibling/sibling relationship paradigms, but is less commonly used to describe profane sexual behavior in other extremes such as J described, also profane behavior NON-sexual..

check out the root word, incestus.

i had to look this up a coupe years back myself, so i know where you are coming from.


message 26: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa I am embarrassed to admit... and perhaps it's because I listened to the book... but I do not understand the ending. The very end when he runs after her and gives her his number. Everyone else seems to understand, but to my mind the ending could mean two things.


Jasmine um. well I read this a long time ago, but isn't the end actually the end of the beginning?


message 28: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Yes, in more detail. I wasn't sure (maybe I've read too many books!) if the author was doing one of those 'if this had happened, then everything would be different' endings. Does that make sense? For example, originally it didn't seem Dexter was quite as interested in Emma as it did at the very end. So I was wondering if it was playing out a different way and then leaving it to our imaginations to guess what would have happened differently.


Jasmine I don't think so, I think it was more that he was revealing something that changed the way the story played out. I mean the book felt more like she was pursuing him for a lot of it. but then he'd drop things like him taking her to the mountain and the phone number thing, and you kind of realize, he loved her too.


message 30: by Lisa (last edited Feb 01, 2011 04:44AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa So I was just being hopeful that it all ended better for them. :o) Thanks for the insight! Now, what to read next? Hmmmmm...


Jasmine well if you like him hornby is good.


message 32: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Love Hornby! I think I've read everything he's written.


Jasmine oh so it's a tougher question.

London is the best city in america and german for travellers are both very good.


Jasmine and among other things I've taken up smoking.


message 35: by Barny (new)

Barny I found the tragic thing about her death was the suddenness of it, the fact that the last time they saw each other they'd argued, and, at the time, it left me wishing they could have at least said goodbye to each other! The book ends with them doing just that; albeit it 30 years in that past. I thought it was a really touching way to round it all off! (a little bit of closure for the reader).

"And yes I understand you are british and that there is something fundamentally wrong with british people that makes you uncomfortable with anyone have a remotely good day in a novel' - teensy bit of a generalisation me thinks!


Kwoomac Love the review. i think I would have liked the book more if Emma died without the two of them getting together and then ended there. I agree that the last hundred or so pages were a major drag.


message 37: by Lulu (new) - rated it 3 stars

Lulu I full heartedly agree that the spoiler you mention SUCKS. I actually did throw my copy against the wall. Only finished it about 10 minutes ago and still feeling extremely PEEVED! RAH! Rather unnecessary, seeing as our man Dave had already made it plainly and painfully clear (300 pages worth!) that life isn't perfect.


Jasmine Lulu wrote: "I full heartedly agree that the spoiler you mention SUCKS. I actually did throw my copy against the wall. Only finished it about 10 minutes ago and still feeling extremely PEEVED! RAH! Rather unnec..."

I have nothing to add. I just like your comment.


message 39: by Kirsten (new)

Kirsten I like that this has five stars... yet it sounds like you hated it?


message 40: by Anja (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anja I've read a couple of books like that myself (including this). You get provoked and annoyed by it, but the author have done it so brilliantly that you just can't stop loving it, even though you just want to chuck the book across the room...


back to top