Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Greg's Reviews > Atemschaukel

Atemschaukel by Herta Müller
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
26552534
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: deutsch, german-fiction

One of my earliest, strongest childhood memories is when my family picked up my uncle, who had been a political prisoner in East Germany, from the hospital where he had been placed after his release, like many others in his position, after his freedom had been bought by the West German government. Although I never personally experienced such treatment, I was inculcated at an early age with a deep, repellant understanding of the fact that there were people like my uncle who had been wrongly incarcerated because of their political beliefs, ethnicity, geographic location, or for just being in the wrong historical place at the wrong historical time.

So I was aware of what was happening in countless places behind the Iron Curtain. And during the Great Leap Forward and the Cultural Revolution in China. And in Cambodia under Pol Pot. And in Uganda, the Congo, Rhodesia, South Africa. And in Chile and Argentina and Central America as people disappeared. And American prisons like Parchman and Angola, for that matter. These were just facts of life in the decades after World War II. Actually, throughout history. But as I read Atemschaukel, it struck me that many young people today have no memory or understanding of these episodes in history and how they were both distinctive and similar to the great socio-political fear of their age: terrorism.

For me, Herta Müller’s book is as much a cultural historical statement as it is a work of literature. This being the third book of hers that I’ve read, I'm warming up to her sparing prose, episodic chapters that almost become short stories in their own right, and inferences about the past and future. The nebulous opening of a young Romanian ethnic German, who has been designated to be a prisoner at a Russian labor camp as a form of collective, representational penance is chillingly cruel. His grandmother’s farewell, „ICH WEISS DU KOMMST WIEDER� (“I know you will come back�) sets him off into an ordeal that will take years, and even when it is over, it never loosens its grip on his subsequent life. The daily torments, tragedies, frustrations, interactions with the other characters, and the ever-present Hungerengel (Hunger Angel) are punctuated and revealed through Müller’s writing.

The title Atemschaukel is more difficult to translate than most German words (especially since the word doesn’t even exist in German). The translators changed it to Hunger Angel, which is a decision I completely understand and accept given the repeated references to it in the novel. But rather than the use the literal translation of “breath swing,� I think the sentiment behind Atemschaukel is closer to “on the edge.� In this case it is the central character being on the edge of so many things—his existence, his identity, his interactions with others, his ability to deal with every contemporary moment of his life. Müller’s story is about more than an account of a Russian labor camp prisoner. Atemschaukel is a microcosm of what millions of people experienced in the latter half of the 20th century—and what countless anonymous persons still do. It is a link joining that era to today's fear of terrorism and the atrocities it can breed.
23 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Atemschaukel.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

November 25, 2014 – Shelved
November 25, 2014 – Shelved as: to-read
November 29, 2014 – Shelved as: deutsch
March 23, 2015 – Shelved as: german-fiction
May 9, 2016 – Started Reading
May 13, 2016 –
page 91
29.93% "Der Hungerengel denkt richtig, fehlt nie, geht nicht weg, kommt aber wieder, hat seine Richtung und kennt meine Grenzen, weiß meine Herkunft und seine Wirkung, geht offenen Auges einseitig, gibt seine Existenz immer zu, ist ekelhaft persönlich, hat einen durchsichtigen Schlaf, ist Experte für Meldekraut, Zucker und Salz, Läuse und Heimweh, hat Wasser im Bauch und in den Beinen. Mehr als Aufzählen kann man nicht."
May 15, 2016 –
page 171
56.25% "Ich träume nur, wenn ich wach bin."
May 15, 2016 –
page 230
75.66% "So war der Lauf der Dinge: Weil jeder nichts dafür konnte, konnte keine was dafür."
May 15, 2016 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-5 of 5 (5 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by david (new)

david Excellent.


Lisa Very well put, Greg! This will be my next Herta Müller for sure. I think you are right about a shift in society, and a loss of historical awareness. I tried to explain to my students what we felt as children in West Germany when the Berlin Wall came down, and some just asked: "What wall? Where was it?" What was our most deeply felt reality is long past now, and I think my reaction to hearing chants of "Build that wall, build that wall!" during Trump rallies is rooted in my incredible relief when the German wall came down without war when I was a child.


Greg david wrote: "Excellent."

Thanks, David. Love that pic you have for your avatar! Googled it and will now have to put Denver on my must visit list. I think it's the largest city in the U.S. I've never visited.


Greg Lisa wrote: "Very well put, Greg! This will be my next Herta Müller for sure. I think you are right about a shift in society, and a loss of historical awareness. I tried to explain to my students what we felt a..."

Thank you, Lisa! I was in Berlin in August 1989 and told people that I thought the Wall could possibly come down in five years. Less than three months later it was down. I remember vividly how I was driving down a highway the night it came down and having to pull over because I was so overcome with emotion. Historical amnesia is truly frightening these days. It's not just those who are young, but here in the U.S. even those who were adults then have forgotten what the world was like when we feared nuclear annihilation. That's a big reason we have our own Dear Leader now.


message 5: by Czarny (new)

Czarny Pies Rumania was a special case. However, the OstDeutsch suffered everywhere.


back to top