ŷ

mark monday's Reviews > The Luminaries

The Luminaries by Eleanor Catton
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
131922
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: into-the-past, rain-man-reviews, fog-and-gears, these-fragile-lives, unicorn, mnemonic-devices

Aries the Ram thrusts forward, discarding the past except as a symbol of what has been overcome. Fearsome, single-minded Aries! This book does not fall under the sign of Aries; it is invested in the past, it is enchanted by it. The past is such an important part of the novel that the narrative continues after its climactic resolution with a series of escalating chapters that take the reader back to where it all began. The Luminaries' characters live under the shadow of their own pasts, they judge others by their past actions as well. Aries is well-represented by Te Rau Tauwhare, a Maori greenstone hunter.

Taurus the Bull is a sign of love, in all of its strength and awkwardness, its earthiness and purity. Obstinate, strong-willed Taurus! This book has a strong Taurean influence: it has at its heart a passionate and moving story of star-crossed lovers, determined to persevere, blind to reason - two parts of a whole that yearn to merge. Taurus is represented - poorly - by the aloof banker Charlie Frost.

Gemini the Twins, sharp and cutting, a sign of the mind, of the air. Impulsive and restless Gemini! This book has a marked Gemini influence in its clever narrative voice, one often sidelined by description and dialogue yet still distinct, full of wit and sly innuendo. Gemini's influence is even stronger when considering the almost dizzying ingenuity of the book's look-at-me structure and its increasingly cheeky chapter introductions. Gemini is represented by Benjamin Lowenthal, a Jewish newspaper editor and a character in need of richer development.

Cancer the Crab moons about in its shell, moody and self-absorbed, yet caring and loyal to the end. Complicated, sensitive Cancer! The Crab has little to do with The Luminaries, except when looking at the novel in general terms. A strong and thick hardcover book, a complicated structure, a soft heart lurking within. Cancer is well-represented by the hotelier Edgar Clinch.

Leo the Lion sits back, the very image of self-satisfaction, a magnet to lesser men, a sun that would have the whole universe revolve around it. Confident and surprisingly generous Leo! The heavy-lidded sensuality of the Lion holds court throughout The Luminaries, its beautiful imagery and its rich descriptive prowess openly displayed; well-hung Leo also clearly influenced this book's impressive length. Leo is represented by Dick (lol) Mannering, a goldfields magnate.

Virgo the Virgin is the sign of this reviewer. It is the most wonderful sign imaginable: critical yet fair, judgmental but only in the most loving of ways, altruistic, well-read, self-sacrificing, practically perfect in every way, the Mary Poppins of the Zodiac. All must bow to the wonder of Virgo! The Virgin is terribly represented by Quee Long, who is about the opposite of any decent Virgo. For shame, Eleanor Catton, you have betrayed the Zodiac with your libelous portrait of a so-called Virgo!

Okay here's the one thing that bothered me about The Luminaries: the way it treated its Asian characters. Perhaps because I'm a hyper-critical half-breed who favors his Asian side, I'm always on the look-out for things to irritate me in the way that Asians are represented. Now I don't think that Catton has an issue with Asians, but it does chafe on a personal level how little they are respected in this novel. I understand the lack of respect coming from other characters, given the time and place. But I resented their actual parts and paths in the narrative - and that's all Eleanor Catton. One Asian is presented as single-minded in the most simple and greedy way possible; another is an opium addict and merchant whose tragic life and grand quest for revenge end in a limp little fizzle, off of the page. I raged (a bit) at the injustice of it all.

Libra the Scales is a sign of beauty, and much like Beauty itself, displays both grace and superficiality, charisma and vanity. Lovely, indecisive Libra! Libra's scales are seldom in balance; this sign seeks to make things equal and often fails. And so it is with the author of The Luminaries, a Libra on the cusp of Virgo. Her favorites among the novel's astrological characters are dynamic and richly developed; those less-favored are given mere cameo appearances. But don't look for fairness from a Libra - look for beauty! And there is much beauty within the pages of The Luminaries. Exquisite prose, gorgeous imagery, lovely moments within its lovely love story; the beautiful mind of its author, yearning to be recognized for its brilliance - and rewarded by the 2013 Man Booker Prize. Libra is represented - perfectly - by Harald Nilssen, a commission merchant.

Scorpio is the Scorpion, and the Eagle as well. It soars above the earth and lives in its holes. This strange sign is the Investigator of the Zodiac and is also its greatest conundrum - secretive to its core, yet suspicious of secrets in others; dark and unyielding; often cold yet deeply sexual. Mysterious, obsessive Scorpio! The Luminaries is intimately connected to the Scorpion, in its basic nature as a Mystery Novel and in its refusal to solve certain mysteries, to keep them shrouded in ambiguity. The Eagle dislikes having to explain itself. Scorpio is represented by Joseph Pritchard, a chemist and a perfectly executed character who is left almost entirely off of the page. Perhaps Catton feared the perverse potential lurking within him and so curtailed her exploration of his depths. I also felt the Scorpio influence upon this novel's villain, the dark, manipulative, unknowable Francis Carver.

Sagittarius the Archer shoots an arrow into the future, his true place; Sagittarius the Centaur gallops quickly, heedless of those too simple and slow to keep his pace. Strong-willed, independent Sagittarius! This sign's influence on The Luminaries is striking: it has no patience for readers of the idiot class. It makes scarce concessions to those longing for explanations or a simple plotline; it will give you the opportunity to come into its world and be surrounded, enveloped... and it will leave you behind if you are unable to keep up. Sagittarius is well-represented by Thomas Balfour, a shipping agent.

Capricorn the Sea-Goat: "still waters run deep" was surely coined for this sign, one whose stable and inhibited surface appearance belies the complicated ambitions within. Patient, resourceful Capricorn! A courageous introvert, a fastidious intellectual, virile yet chilly, dignified and aloof and rich with hidden depths. The novel The Luminaries was born under the sign of Capricorn. The novel's birth sign is represented - perfectly - by Aubert Gascoigne, a justice's clerk.

Aquarius the Water-bearer abhors restrictions and eschews barriers, seeking the enlightenment beyond, traveling the stars without and within, ever in search of wisdom. Inventive, rebellious Aquarius! A shallow reviewer of the novel would find little influence from the Water-bearer as the book is a carefully constructed puzzle rather than an ingenious invention, a mathematically mapped-out pièce de résistance rather than a spontaneous improvisation. But dig deeper and you shall find the sublime Aquarian ruling an eerie and haunting love story, one full of unexplainable visions and brazen leaps of faith. Aquarius is well-represented by Sook Yongsheng, a Chinese hatter and lover of opium.

Pisces the Fish, Pisces the dreamer, the last sign and the oldest. Pisces yearns for escape, in dreams, in drugs, in art, in the dark damp spaces. Elusive Pisces, the sign of self-undoing! I had a Piscean experience when reading this novel. It was my go-to book for a certain period of time, a little bit nearly every morning and every afternoon, for almost 3 months. I escaped into its depths, it was my sweet sweet drug and I fear that I am suffering from withdrawal. This lengthy review was an attempt to live in it again. Alas, now even this review is over. Pisces is represented - rather poorly - by Cowell Devlin, a chaplain.
131 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Luminaries.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

December 20, 2014 – Started Reading
December 20, 2014 – Shelved
March 9, 2015 –
page 848
100.0% "farewell, bus book! you have been a boon companion for several months now, 15 minutes a day, 5 days a week. it was great living in your world. I will miss you!"
March 9, 2015 – Shelved as: into-the-past
March 9, 2015 – Finished Reading
March 19, 2015 – Shelved as: rain-man-reviews
March 19, 2015 – Shelved as: fog-and-gears
March 19, 2015 – Shelved as: these-fragile-lives
April 2, 2015 – Shelved as: unicorn
December 16, 2018 – Shelved as: mnemonic-devices

Comments Showing 1-23 of 23 (23 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by JP (new) - rated it 3 stars

JP Oh lord! I'm so exited to read your review. I haven't read it but I do hope to read it next year.


mark monday so far it is pretty absorbing!


message 3: by JP (new) - rated it 3 stars

JP How far are you in?


mark monday a little over a couple hundred pages. I wish I had more time during the holiday to just sit and read for hours instead of catching a little here, a little there.


message 5: by Sagnick (new)

Sagnick Sarkar Under what genre is this book?


mark monday historical?


aPriL does feral sometimes mathematical. (Great Literature by the numbers)


mark monday as well as astrological!


Em Lost In Books great review Mark!


message 10: by Terry (new)

Terry mark you are an astrologist of the first water (and I love your reviews which are always entertaining!) will you please cast my horoscope?


message 11: by Davytron (new)

Davytron Thanks for identifying the race issues in the novel, Mark. I'm less inclined to read this one now.


Bettie Excellent


message 13: by mark (last edited Mar 20, 2015 11:30AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

mark monday Davytron, it was what stopped me from giving it that 5th star. although i do think they are issues, I don't think this is a racist book by any means. Catton's decisions how to shape her Asian characters' narratives just bothered me on a personal level. overall I think it is a brilliant accomplishment.

thanks Manju and Bettie!

Terry, I will need your sign for that!


message 14: by Terry (new)

Terry Sagittarius baby!


message 15: by mark (new) - rated it 4 stars

mark monday I predict you losing your patience with someone - but because you are older and wiser, you are able to successfully hold your tongue and not be a jerk about it. Good job, Archer! In the future when someone annoys you, try to focus on whatever positive trait(s) they may have; that will help you to avoid dismissing them outright.


message 16: by Moi (new) - rated it 3 stars

Moi I wish I could have enjoyed this story more, I thought I would be hooked because I love historical fiction and the cleverness of the structure seemed bona fide but... I just could not sustain the interest in the story.. usually I am so stubborn that I must find out what happens. I just felt disappointed and abandoned it half way through :(


message 17: by mark (new) - rated it 4 stars

mark monday sad to say, you are not alone in that feeling. alas! ah well


Carol She's So Novel꧁꧂ Glad to see you loved this book the way I so wanted to Mark! I'm with the reviewers, both here & in NZ that believe that Catton will one day write the great NZ Novel - but this isn't it.


message 19: by mark (new) - rated it 4 stars

mark monday I have seen more backlash about this book than any other book in the literary genre this year. I wonder if some of that is due to Man Booker.


Jaidee fabulous review and now I understand :(


message 21: by mark (new) - rated it 4 stars

mark monday fortunately my irritation with that one issue doesn't take away from my excitement at the thought of re-reading this. hopefully in the next year or so. I bet I will find it even more fascinating the second time around, now that I understand all of the moving parts and how they fit together.

and thanks!


message 22: by Rita (new) - rated it 4 stars

Rita Tomás great review, congratulations!


message 23: by mark (new) - rated it 4 stars

mark monday Thanks Rita!


back to top