Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Jibran's Reviews > Chronicle of a Death Foretold

Chronicle of a Death Foretold by Gabriel García Márquez
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
5407952
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: nobel, sui-generis, hispanic

There had never been a death so foretold.

Márquez's oeuvre may be roughly divided into two streams of writing: the magician of One Hundred Years of Solitude and Love in the Time of Cholera and the journalist-adventurer of this novel and News of a Kidnapping. The ominous world of magic realism closes shop when Marquez switches his gears to journalistic storytelling. But may be not quite; because right from the opening scene an eerie premonition trails at the heels of Santiago Nasar and, do what he might, catches him unawares to punish him for a crime he might or might not have committed. In this novella the writer-narrator sets himself up to the task of investigating the events that led to the death so foretold.

You may call it a reportage of an impossible and inexplicable murder that could have been prevented with just a shout. You may call it story of a man who must pay for violating the unwritten code of honour when he is suspected of deflowering Angela Vicario, his best pal's sister, hours before she was to get married to another man. Or you may simply call it a story of an honour killing, but unlike other stories of this kind this is not yet another banal attempt aimed at soliciting public's disgust at the horrific practice, told from the moral high ground of an observer's point of view. It does not portray the entire value system backward and barbaric which stories of this kind are wont to do, but operates from inside the culture to report on the dynamics that lead to and make something like this possible. This objectivity sits at the heart of good writing and this sets Márquez apart from a bevy of writers who have produced stereotypical fictional accounts of a culture at war with itself.

I won't call it "unreliable narration" but rather a deliberate building up of ambiguity with respect to the victim's role: Was Santiago Nasar guilty of dishonouring Angela Vicario, or was there a big misunderstanding all along, made all the more complicated by a surfeit of circumstantial evidence? Here you have Márquez, the master investigative journalist, with the best implements of his trade, testing your powers of observation and turning you into a witness who is being strung along willy-nilly by a powerful voice. It's one of those novels where the process of telling a story is greater than the story itself. In other words, how it's told rather than what's told.

By the honour of Angela Vicario this is a story unequaled in its telling!
174 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Chronicle of a Death Foretold.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Started Reading
January 1, 2014 – Finished Reading
December 29, 2014 – Shelved

Comments Showing 1-24 of 24 (24 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Mala (new)

Mala Do you keep your reviews off the feed?
How come nobody has seen it? This is really good.
Gass has highly praised this one & also The Autum of the Patriarch.


message 2: by Jibran (last edited Apr 09, 2015 07:21AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jibran Mala thank you for stopping by. I thoroughly enjoyed the novella. The Autumn of the Patriarch is on my shelf. Hopefully I can start it soon.

Although I have been registered since 2011, I have become active only recently, for the last 2/3 months, and added all the reviews I had on my blog one after the other. And I had only 3/4 friends on my list. So I'm not surprised no one has seen my reviews.

But now I'm socialising and hope to get feedback from well-read members like you. Thanks again :)


Agnieszka Agree with Mala , this is fine review , Jibran . And double agree about that The Autumn of the Patriarch is really great novel .


message 4: by Dolors (new)

Dolors Superb display of themes and possible interpretations, Jibran. Your elucidations reminded me of how often honor/duty and love/obessession are usually at odds in the greatest works (thinking of Shakespeare right now and Othello in particular). How many review-jewels do you have hidden in your virtual shelves?


message 5: by Jibran (last edited Apr 14, 2015 06:04AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jibran Agnieszka wrote: "Agree with Mala , this is fine review , Jibran . And double agree about that The Autumn of the Patriarch is really great novel ."

Thank you for reading, Agni. I have Autumn... on my TBR for a while. I hope to get to it soon.


message 6: by Praj (new) - added it

Praj The ominous world of magic realism closes shop when Marquez switches his gears to journalistic storytelling.

How aptly said! The metaphoric dreams and the guilt hovering death documented through the apathy of society, the concept of honor and ritualistic mores and ultimately fate, sums the entirety of a world within a world (culturally). Reading GGM, has always felt closer to home. Thanks for this erudite piece.

PS:- Echoing the ladies here, it is a sensory treat with you unearthing gems from your reviewing treasure.


Nishat Such an excellent and thoughtful review!


message 8: by Jibran (last edited Apr 14, 2015 07:00AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jibran Dolors wrote: "Superb display of themes and possible interpretations, Jibran. Your elucidations reminded me of how often honor/duty and love/obessession are usually at odds in the greatest works (thinking of Shak..."

Thank you for the encouragement, Dolors. I'm trying :) I think nothing pits humanity against its own demons like the chasm between desire and duty. And Shakespeare was the ultimate portrayer of this dichotomy. Speaking of which, I'm loving your Shakespearean updates, as I am also reading one of his long poems, Venus and Adonis.


Jibran Praj wrote: "The ominous world of magic realism closes shop when Marquez switches his gears to journalistic storytelling.

How aptly said! The metaphoric dreams and the guilt hovering death documented through t..."


Thank you for adding your magical flavour to the thread, Praj. Reading Marquez feels closer to home, indeed. So true!
And thanks so much for your kind words for my scribbling exercises :)


Jibran Nishat wrote: "Such an excellent and thoughtful review!"

Glad to have you here, Nishat. Thank you! :)


Cheryl Marquez has a peculiar way of making the bizarre real, doesn't he? Really enjoyed the tone of this review, Jibran.


Jibran Cheryl wrote: "Marquez has a peculiar way of making the bizarre real, doesn't he? Really enjoyed the tone of this review, Jibran."

Oh yes indeed. One doesn't even have to suspend disbelief; he makes it so real. He's a consummate master of mimetic persuasion! Thank you for reading Cheryl :)


message 13: by Seemita (new) - added it

Seemita Ah... This novel! And your review! Two, A Tango someone? :) Your hands are one of the safest havens, Gabo's prose can find, Jibran; you hold it soft, assess it minute, lend the perfect magic that is just sufficient to tempt a non-reader to go whole hog without any further ado!

Lovely review and I do remember your reco :)


message 14: by Fionnuala (new)

Fionnuala Nishat wrote: "Such an excellent and thoughtful review!"

Echoing Nishat's perfectly concise comment, Jibran.


Jibran Seemita wrote: "Ah... This novel! And your review! Two, A Tango someone? :) Your hands are one of the safest havens, Gabo's prose can find, Jibran; you hold it soft, assess it minute, lend the perfect magic that i..."

Haha. You excel in making me happy with your lovely comments, Seemita, as always :)


Jibran Fionnuala wrote: "Echoing Nishat's perfectly concise comment, Jibran."

Thank you for reading dear Fio :)


Miquel Reina Totally agree Jibran! ;)


Jibran Miquel Reina wrote: "Totally agree Jibran! ;)"

Miquel, thanks for reading :)


message 19: by [deleted user] (new)

Fabulous review, Jibran, thank you.
Interesting take on the story - Márquez inviting the reader to solve the puzzle he's set. I like that.

And I agree - this is a story unequaled in its telling.
In my review, I called it the "perfect story"!!
Thanks again!


Jibran Anne wrote: "Fabulous review, Jibran, thank you.
Interesting take on the story - Márquez inviting the reader to solve the puzzle he's set. I like that.

And I agree - this is a story unequaled in its telling.
I..."


I'm glad you enjoyed the novella as much as I did, Anne. Thank you for the kind affirmation, and apologies for the late acknowledgment as I've been busy and away from GR for the last month or two.


message 21: by Gaurav (new) - added it

Gaurav Great review, Jibran, written from unbiased point of view. Though I'm a fan of Gabo but hasn't read this book, but really liked the themes and undertones of the narrative well observed by you.


message 22: by flo (new) - rated it 4 stars

flo I read this book twice, in my teens and then at Journalism school, since it is one of the most perfect examples of how to blend journalistic investigation with different narrative techniques - assuming the role of the investigative reporter and still be able to make a book completely unputdownable.
A superb review, Jibran. And it's so nice to be reading it today, on García Márquez's 94th birthday.


message 23: by Jibran (last edited Mar 07, 2021 06:24AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jibran Florencia wrote: "I read this book twice, in my teens and then at Journalism school, since it is one of the most perfect examples of how to blend journalistic investigation with different narrative techniques - assu..."

It's great to get your thoughts on this novella, especially since you must have read it with a trained eye in view of your education in journalism. It indeed is a superb blend of journalistic investigation and masterful literary narration.

Thank you, Florencia, for reminding that it was Gabo's 94th birthday. May his fans always remember him and celebrate his wonderful books!


message 24: by Glenn (new)

Glenn Russell Excellent, Jibran. I'm so excited: I see audible.com has the audio version of this short novel available the end of June. Based on the strength of your review, I can't wait to listen. BTW - I sense GGM works within a profound oral storytelling tradition, thus I want to hear his novel read in addition to reading.


back to top