Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Claire's Reviews > Wolf Winter

Wolf Winter by Cecilia Ekbäck
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
2528841
's review

it was ok
bookshelves: fiction

Set in Swedish Lappland in 1717, Cecilia Ekbäck’s debut novel Wolf Winter follows a family of four, Maija, her husband Paavo and their daughters Frederika and Dorotea from a fishing village in their native Finland to the forested lands surrounding Sweden’s Blackåsen mountain.

They swap houses with Maija’s brother, deciding a life in the interior may be better suited to Paavo, who had developed numerous fears keeping him from earning his living at sea. However, when their daughters stumble across a dead body allegedly killed by wolves, on a route near the mountain, they begin to wonder whether they have left one dark dream for an even blacker nightmare.

Maiji suspects it was a crime and makes it her business to ask questions to an extremely reticent and unappreciative band of local settlers and itinerant Lapps.

Her husband never questions her interference, even when present he plays no role and as soon as the first signs herald the approach of winter, he sets off alone for the coast, leaving the women-folk to survive the harsh physical elements and the even stranger mystical apparitions that some but not all will witness. Without a man to steer them out of trouble, the woman face many risks, not least being perceived as dabbling in witchcraft, as church records show has happened to a few others with similar inclinations who preceded them.

Unfortunately, I couldn't really get into this novel in the way I wanted to, though it wasn't a difficult read. It didn't portray a sense of the era, it felt contemporary even though it did evoke a strong sense of place and it was clear there were no modern comforts. Perhaps it was the attitude and freedom of the protagonist that didn't sit with the era.

The time spent with a number of the characters was so fleeting, it left too little of an impact and rendered them insufficient to develop an interest in. The storyline itself raised so many questions that went unanswered, like why did the husband go off and leave his family in such a vulnerable position when they could have gone with him and been protected.

And why did the wife think she as a newcomer could become an investigator into a crime that clearly the locals were not happy about being questioned, especially when it threatened her safety. Her role was to assist in bringing new life (she was a kind of midwife) and yet at every turn she was endangering those close to her. The younger daughter nearly lost her feet to frostbite after trekking in a blizzard to ask the Lapps questions about the murder. I didn't believe in Maiji’s intentions and relationships and the blurred line between reality and the mystical elements. I wanted to be drawn in by it, but was unable to brush off the scepticism.

So what drew me towards reading this novel in the first place?

Well the snowy winter setting was very appealing, the plot sounded intriguing and the praise of Hilary Mantel and the Library Journal, who had this to say definitely lured me in:

“The novel will appeal to readers who like their historical fiction dark and atmospheric, or mystery fans who are open to mysticism and unconventional sleuths. Readers who enjoyed the winter landscape and magical realism of Eowyn Ivey’s The Snow Child may also want to try this.� Library Journal

“The story creeps up and possesses the imagination; there’s something eerie in the way half-understood and only half-seen events leave their mark. It’s a powerful feat of suggestion, visually acute, skillfully written; it won’t easily erase its tracks in the reader’s mind.� Hilary Mantel

It was an interesting concept and disappointing that it wasn't more engaging, but for those who like a good mystery with an element of hinted at magical realism, this could be just what Hilary Mantel suggests it is.
14 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Wolf Winter.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

January 20, 2015 – Shelved
January 20, 2015 – Shelved as: to-read
January 20, 2015 – Shelved as: fiction
January 21, 2015 – Started Reading
January 21, 2015 –
page 25
6.65%
January 24, 2015 –
page 75
19.95%
January 26, 2015 –
page 180
47.87% "Just survived a blizzard but the snow is piling up outside the door needing to be shovelled away every couple of hours, living in the snow in 1717 was tough. Not for the faint hearted."
January 28, 2015 –
page 230
61.17% "More engaging in the 2nd half, having difficulty believing I am in 1717, it feels more contemporary, no real sense of the era. The absent husband seems strange. And the priest? Hmmm. Not sure about this, a slow burning snowy, superstitious mystery."
February 3, 2015 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-9 of 9 (9 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Claire Didn't highlight any passages, no poetry - when there's no poetry there's usually pace, for me there wasn't that either. There is a plot but it just didn't engage and left too many questions. I think it had potential, just didn't work for me. Tempted by the reference to The Snow Child, one of the best novels I have ever read and this was nowhere near it.


message 2: by Stephanie (new)

Stephanie Swint So it just didn't reach the level of 'The Snow Child.' I can see why you were drawn to it and why you were let down. I'm sorry.


Claire Stephanie wrote: "So it just didn't reach the level of 'The Snow Child.' I can see why you were drawn to it and why you were let down. I'm sorry."

Just not a good match really, I hate when that happens, because I am sure it is a great book for the right readers, its just that those references really raised my expectations, so I'm sad I couldn't do justice to the book.


message 4: by Stephanie (new)

Stephanie Swint I think there is such danger in likening one book to another. It sets expectations. I've had the same experience with different books. It's such a let down and isn't fair to the book.


Louise I've just started this and am really enjoying it so far. I was surprised to see you give it such a negative review as I usually agree with a lot of what you say. I'll reserve my full judgement til the end.


Claire Sorry if I sounded negative, I try not to sound negative about a book but to be honest and specific about how I felt about it and what may have caused that reaction.

Interestingly, I read Aki Ollikainen's White Hunger soon after this, which totally evoked the era it was set in (1867: a year of devastating famine in Finland), however with Wolf Winter, I struggled to be convinced by the authenticity of the era and behaviour/absence of the characters.

White Hunger is a different story, in fact not much of a story, just that really harsh, gut wrenching will to survive laid bare. Almost painful to read, it felt so real.

I'm really happy to hear you are enjoying Wolf Winter, I'd hate to put anyone off it. :)


Louise Sorry negative was perhaps the wrong word to use, I meant I was surprised you hadn't rated it more highly. I think you have been very fair and justified in your comments, I'm just finding it quite readable at the moment but I may change my mind. I'll look out for the other one.


message 8: by Mel (new) - added it

Mel "Perhaps it was the attitude and freedom of the protagonist that didn't sit with the era." Yes, this. Thank you for pinpointing so well what I'm finding difficult with this novel.


message 9: by Catherine (new)

Catherine Take the story for what it was. I found it an incredibly wonderful read. It is Maiji's personality that made her question everything...that comes out at the end.


back to top