Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Sasha's Reviews > Flowers in the Attic

Flowers in the Attic by V.C. Andrews
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3144945
's review

bookshelves: favorite-reviews, 2011, poison, too-many-books, parenting, gothic
Read 2 times. Last read December 22, 2011 to December 29, 2011.

I met a friend for drinks last night. She came up and took one glance at the back cover to this book and her eyes widened. "No," she breathed. "Seriously?" Of course she recognized it from the back. She read it around seventh grade. I read it around seventh grade. You read it around seventh grade. An entire generation has this lurking in our collective adolescence.

So that's why I re-read it. (Okay, that and I thought it was hilarious just to hold it up on the subway.) I wanted to know just how creepy it is. To be honest, I couldn't really remember, nor could most other people I talked to. There's a vague sense of ickiness and illicitness, but that's about it.

Here's your answer: it is very, very creepy. Friends, there's like a whole page where VC Andrews describes a five-year-old's underwear in loving, lavish detail. Andrews is willing to eroticize anything. Here's a whipping:
"My eyes bulged at the site of those pitiful welts on the creamy tender flesh that our father had handled with so much love and gentleness. I floundered in a maelstrom of uncertainty." (91)
Floundered. In a maelstrom. Of uncertainty.

Not that that's what we're here to discuss, though, is it? We're here to discuss brotherfucking. I'm not gonna do a spoiler alert, dude. If you didn't know Flowers in the Attic is about brotherfucking, you wouldn't be reading this. So let's get to it:
"And that is where he took me, and forced in that swollen, rigid male sex part of him that had to be satisfied. It drove into my tight and resisting flesh which tore and bled.

"Long strings of clouds blew across the face of the full moon, so it would duck and hide, then peek out again. And on the roof, on a night that was made for lovers, we cried in each other's arms.

"'Don't hate me, Cathy, please don't hate me. I didn't mean to rape you, I swear to God. There's been many a time when I've been tempted, and I was able to turn it off.'

"'I don't hate you, Chris...it was my fault, too.' Oh yes, my fault too...I shouldn't have worn skimpy little see-through garments around a brother who had all a man's strong physical needs.

"And all we could see in the murky-gray and cold, damp clouds was that single great eye of God - shining up there in the moon."

(357 - 359)
Ladies and gentlemen, this was your puberty. How our generation functions at all, with this in our pasts, is beyond me.

But we do, somehow, and some of you now have kids of your own. And you're worried about them being exposed to too much sex and creepiness on the internet. Listen, parents: your kids are lucky. They won't have to slink through library stacks looking for smut like this; they can just go check out bukkake videos on Youporn. There is nothing on the internet - nothing! - worse than this fuckin' book.

And they'll be spared the godawful writing, too.

I'm not gonna give this book stars. Flowers in the Attic transcends stars.

I hope you're happy, Jayme.
--------------------------
Just because I feel like someone ought to make this list, here are the books Cathy reads:

- Something about King Arthur - unclear which specific book
- Jude the Obscure
- Wuthering Heights
- Lorna Doone: A Romance of Exmoor
- Little Men
- Jane Eyre

--------------------------
UPDATE: I've just been alerted to the existence of VC Andrews' original Awesome.

--------------------------
UPDATE 2:
It's been pointed out by no less august a publication than the New Yorker that Flowers in the Attic is not so much about brotherfucking as it is about (to induce brotherfucking). So basically it's Don Quixote. With brotherfucking. Thanks, alert reader El!
1166 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Flowers in the Attic.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
August 19, 2010 – Shelved
December 22, 2011 – Started Reading
December 29, 2011 – Shelved as: favorite-reviews
December 29, 2011 – Shelved as: 2011
December 29, 2011 – Finished Reading
February 17, 2014 – Shelved as: poison
September 6, 2015 – Shelved as: too-many-books
October 24, 2015 – Shelved as: parenting
October 28, 2020 – Shelved as: gothic

Comments Showing 1-50 of 245 (245 new)


Jayme Yes, yes I am.


message 2: by Marieke (new)

Marieke there is a hysterical review of this somewhere on goodreads...probably near the top. it's genius.


message 3: by Sasha (new) - added it

Sasha Not even sure which one you mean; they're all hilarious...

"Note: sex is actually not so great that you couldn't stop if you're grandma walked in on you mid-act."

"I have this unfortunate penchant for ugly things; I buy ugly jewlery, I go out with slightly unatractive men, and I read books like this."

"im beginning to wonder when and if the hipsters will bring her back, and then it can be fashionable for me to find a 25 cent copy to tote around in my american apparel bag."

I SAY NOW! Who's with me?

(ps: big, general [SIC:].)


message 4: by Marieke (new)

Marieke Ooo I'll have to look later to find the one I mentioned. It was a couple of years ago.

You know, when I get frustrated at work I go on goodreads to find one star reviews. They are always the funniest. This book is an exception because it is a five star book.


message 5: by Tracee (new)

Tracee i'm with you!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Wendy So now I'm totally blushing that not only did I read this book (about a million years ago -- like in jr. high), but I actually had it on my lis of books that I have read and gave it 3 stars. Is this grounds for expulsion from any group attempting to have anything resembling a serious book discussion? Am I now going to be shunned and ostracized (sp?) for copping to having read this book and rating it rather generously?


message 7: by Marieke (new)

Marieke It deserves FIVE stars, Wendy!


Wendy I feel I've officially lost all credibility!!!


Jayme Hey, I gave it three stars and my credibility is better than ever. Not only that but I read the sequels, so...top that.


message 10: by Sasha (new) - added it

Sasha Jayme wins and loses at the same time, and so do the rest of you. For shame / high five? I'll invoke the Cheetara rule, which I just invented: during puberty, free pass.


message 11: by Marieke (new)

Marieke But wait, are you giving it three stars as adults looking back or as seventh graders?


Jayme I actually put more thought than I'd like to admit into that 3 star rating, but in the end decided even my seventh grade self would have given it three stars. I liked it because it was trashy, I knew even then it wasn't amazing. My adult self would have given it one star.


message 13: by Marieke (new)

Marieke My adult self definitely gives it one star, too. My 12-year old self gives it five stars because I was so ashamed to be reading it yet I couldn't put it down. An insanely brilliant book, for all the wrong reasons. Has it ever been banned?


Wendy Yeah, I read the sequal(s) too. I think my rating reflects my 7th grade self. At the time I think I knew it was pretty trashy, but such a guilty pleasure I couldn't put it down. I like Alex's rule on the free pass during puberty. There were quite a few harlequinn romances and one other dreadful bodice ripper I'll never forget called "the rose in winter". I'd like to think that even though the character development was pretty much non-existent it did enhane my vocabulary (I seem to recall becoming acquainted w/ the word sardonic through these readings) and there were certainly an abundance of euphemisms that were quite informative to my jr. high self (center of awakening passionwas an all time favorite). Throw a little Danielle Steele into the mix and you have one very low-brow jr. high reader. I'd like to think I've progressed :-)


message 15: by Sasha (last edited Aug 20, 2010 12:45PM) (new) - added it

Sasha My junior high self would be all "Dude, you promised you'd still be playing with GI Joes when you were grown up. You were gonna have such an awesome set up! And now I find you reading freakin' Paradise Lost? Man, you sold out."


message 16: by Marieke (new)

Marieke My adult self says "good for you to give in to peer pressure in that one instance to read a really trashy disgusting 'novel' and for putting down the odyssey and the Iliad for one moment." I didn't read the sequels or any danielle steel but I did try some sweet valley high, which I did not enjoy, and Stephen king's Christine, which ithought was awesome.


Jayme See, look at all the fun stuff you're learning about us because you admitted to reading this, Alex.


message 18: by Sasha (new) - added it

Sasha All I learned is that you're all morally suspect.


message 19: by Sasha (new) - added it

Sasha "I stared up at the sky. It seemed to me like an inverted deep bowl of navy-blue velvet, sprinkled all over with crystallized snowflakes instead of stars - or were they tears of ice that I was going to cry in the future?" (p. 42)


message 20: by Juniper (new)

Juniper GACK@!$!


message 21: by Juniper (new)

Juniper (that was me throwing up in my mouth a little bit)


message 22: by Marieke (new)

Marieke I just keep picturing Alex with a shiny dark blue bowl on his head. #fairlyridiculous


message 23: by Juniper (new)

Juniper Marieke wrote: "I just keep picturing Alex with a shiny dark blue bowl on his head. #fairlyridiculous"

Hee hee hee. But it's velvet! So, so velvety!


message 24: by Marieke (new)

Marieke Velvet on the inside, right?


message 25: by Juniper (new)

Juniper Marieke wrote: "Velvet on the inside, right?"

Right! :)


Jayme You just made my Christmas. The prose is even more beautiful than my seventh grade self remembers.


message 27: by Juniper (new)

Juniper I have been thinking - and I think we could write a book together, the bunch of us! I mean...how hard could it be?? Hahahahaha!


message 28: by Marieke (new)

Marieke We would be so rich.


Jayme It will be sooo x rated.


message 30: by Juniper (new)

Juniper So, so rich! We could include grunty cave sex!


message 31: by Sasha (new) - added it

Sasha Oh, absolutely.

That's a good point, Jennifer, and I'd forgotten that it's one of the pleasures of reading a book this shitty: it makes you feel much more optimistic about your own writing skills. Even if I never do write that novel, the scraps in my head will always be better than this.


message 32: by Juniper (new)

Juniper Hee hee hee!!!


message 33: by Sasha (new) - added it

Sasha "My eyes bulged at the site of those pitiful welts on the creamy tender flesh that our father had handled with so much love and gentleness. I floundered in a maelstrom of uncertainty." (p. 91)

I'm going to start using "floundering in a maelstrom of uncertainty" in everyday conversation.


Wendy Don't overlook "creamy tender flesh" -- that phrase could come up multiple times over the course of the day. Probably best to avoid it though if you find yourself engaged in conversation with someome from your HR department though.


message 35: by Juniper (new)

Juniper Alex wrote: "I'm going to start using "floundering in a maelstrom of uncertainty" in everyday conversation."

Well of course you are! That seems like a totally excellent phrase to be adopted into use!!! (In fact, I think I spend an inordinate amount of time in that sort of mind-set.)


Jayme You have no idea how giggly rreading this thread makes me. Thank you for making this the best Christmas evar.


Jayme My Mom GAVE me my copy. I was the instigator of the whole grade 7 class reading this masterpiece. Hence all the half falling out pages in my copy.


message 38: by Alasse (new)

Alasse HOW DID I MISS THIS!?


message 39: by Sasha (new) - added it

Sasha I have no idea. I've been hollering about it all over Bookish for like two weeks.

Jayme, I'm so pleased that you were the FitA instigator.

And Anna, you too! Welcome to the club. The weird club.


message 40: by Sasha (new) - added it

Sasha "His lips so beautifully shaped he didn't need to pout to make them sensual, his chin square, strong, clefted, and his chest was beginning to broaden...and there was that hillock of his growing maleness before his strong thighs, beginning to swell. There was something about a man's strong, well-shaped thighs that excited me. I turned away my head, unable to feast my eyes on his beauty without feeling guilty and ashamed." (263)

Hillock.


Jayme So you're getting to the good parts! It's amazing how much of this book is burned into my skull even though I was 11 when I read it.


message 42: by Sasha (new) - added it

Sasha And they're still only skinny dipping!


message 43: by Juniper (new)

Juniper so, so guilty; so, so ashamed!


Jayme I approve of the booklist you're making. We should start a Flowers in the Attic book club.


message 45: by Sasha (new) - added it

Sasha Thank you. I felt like that was something someone ought to do.

And I finally remembered the first book. Jude the Obscure. She was like twelve at the time, jeez.


message 46: by Julie (new)

Julie I have never read this book. And now I know I never will thanks to this wonderful review.
Shut up Jayme.


message 47: by Julie (new)

Julie hahaha....I just noticed what you wrote under "recommended for"


Jayme Ah, don't worry Julie. I don't actually think anyone who's not in grade 7 should read this anyway. I'm really surprised Alex even did, although I totally give him props for doing it. I sure as hell wouldn't reread this. Besides I could pretty much rewrite this boom fom memory anyway. I would kick ass on a FitA quiz I tell you. But basically if you missed out when you were 11 then it's too late for you.


message 49: by Sasha (new) - added it

Sasha I never went to Disney World when I was a kid, which is basically as bad as being locked in an attic, so I went a few years ago. All my life, I'd heard how great and magical it was, and I finally got there, and...really? This is what all the fuss was about? These rides are lame!

Some things, if you don't experience them at the proper time, you shouldn't experience them at all. Better late than never is not always true.

Flowers in the Attic is the Disney World of pubescent rapecest.


message 50: by Sasha (new) - added it

Sasha Money where your mouth is, Jayme: here's the FitA trivia page. I just created the last two questions. (Yeah, those are the first trivia questions I've ever made for this site. For Flowers in the Attic.)


« previous 1 3 4 5
back to top