ŷ

Candi's Reviews > Stoner

Stoner by John  Williams
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3639005
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: contemporary-literary, favorites, classics-shelf

"� a quiet sadness for the common plight was never far beneath any moment of his living."

This novel damn near broke my heart. Come to think of it, it did break my heart. I’ve been picking up the pieces and trying to put them back together for the past eleven days since finishing it. I don’t know what else to say that hasn’t already been said about this exceptional piece of writing. We are William Stoner. Isn’t there a piece of him in every single one of us? We go about our lives with the best intentions. Looking for friendship. Searching for love. Thinking we’ve found it and then not exactly knowing what to do with it. Making mistakes and yet enduring. Sometimes doing battle but mostly resolving ourselves to our individual circumstances.

"The past gathered out of the darkness where it stayed, and the dead raised themselves to live before him; and the past and the dead flowed into the present among the alive, so that he had for an intense instant a vision of denseness into which he was compacted and from which he could not escape, and had no wish to escape."

This is another one of those contemplative novels that leaves me feeling like I’m in the presence of a wise soul. He or she speaks to me quietly but with an underlying urgency I cannot ignore. This soul is not showy but quite pure and simple. It’s achingly honest. I have to wonder though � do we all necessarily damage one another? Do the effects of a hard life trickle down through the generations so endlessly? I hope not. Love, marriage, and parenting � such challenging waters to navigate at times. Our best is never good enough. Perhaps we are the harshest judges of our own actions.

"Dispassionately, reasonably, he contemplated the failure that his life must appear to be."

It can’t get more depressing than that. Yet, there were glimmers of hopefulness and happiness that guided me through to the end of this book. Moments in time that make it all worthwhile. Love for literature and finding love itself. Loving a child. Do we really need an abundance of everything? There were some passages that really took hold of me and wouldn’t let go. I’m still in the clutches of Stoner’s (and John Williams�) words.

"Sometimes, immersed in his books, there would come to him the awareness of all that he did not know, of all that he had not read; and the serenity for which he labored was shattered as he realized the little time he had in life to read so much, to learn what he had to know."

I’ve always been able to relate to that. Sitting surrounded by our massive piles of books, we can all empathize, I’m sure.

"� the person one loves at first is not the person one loves at last, and that love is not an end but a process through which one person attempts to know another."

It kind of makes you want to fall in love all over again, doesn’t it?!

I don’t know why I waited so long to read this novel. I knew I would love it. This was the first book I picked up on the first day of the new year, new decade. I wouldn’t be surprised if it remains my favorite of the year.
388 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Stoner.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

February 15, 2015 – Shelved
February 15, 2015 – Shelved as: to-read
February 15, 2015 – Shelved as: contemporary-literary
January 1, 2020 – Started Reading
January 6, 2020 – Finished Reading
January 17, 2020 – Shelved as: favorites
January 17, 2020 – Shelved as: classics-shelf

Comments Showing 1-50 of 155 (155 new)


Anne Enjoy! Looking forward to your comments


Candi Anne wrote: "Enjoy! Looking forward to your comments"

Thanks, Anne! I'm thrilled to finally be reading this one :)


Karen Yes!!!!


Jeannie I plan to read this one this year. All the reviews of this one are excellent!


Candi Karen wrote: "Yes!!!!"

Hurray!!


Candi Jeannie wrote: "I plan to read this one this year. All the reviews of this one are excellent!"

This one is living up to all of my expectations so far, Jeannie!!


Gabrielle oh, I can't wait to hear what you think! :-D


carlageek I picked it up recently and will likely read it this year as well :D


Candi Gabrielle wrote: "oh, I can't wait to hear what you think! :-D"

I love everyone's enthusiasm for this, Gabrielle! Hoping it lands on my favorites shelf :)


Candi carlageek wrote: "I picked it up recently and will likely read it this year as well :D"

I hope you do, Carla!


Bam cooks the books Wonderful review of a wonderful story, Candi!


message 12: by Sara (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sara With both started the year with this book, Candi. Can't help thinking it bodes well for what 2020 might be.


message 13: by Jenna (new)

Jenna ❤ ❀  ❤ Wow, what a review, Candi! I'll have to put this on my classics list.


message 14: by Ace (new) - added it

Ace Great review Candi. I must get to it myself soon.


Katie With you all the way, Candi. For some reason I always thought this novel might bore me. How wrong I was!


message 16: by Alex (new) - added it

Alex Brilliant review! Adding it to my TBR


Wyndy I knew you’d love this book and do it proud with your own personal stamp. Completely agree that there’s a little piece of William Stoner in us all.


Antoinette Stunning review, Candi! I still haven’t read this book- but it’s on my must read for this year. I get anxious about reading a book that so many people have raved about- but I’m pretty sure this book will meet my expectations.


message 19: by Sue (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sue K H I love you review so much Candi! You captured the essence of this book so well. I'm glad that you loved it as much as I did.


message 20: by Jami (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jami Great Review! I think I need to read this one!


Colleen Browne Based on your review, I am going to buy and read this book. Thanks for recommending a book I would never have found on my own.


Kathleen Well I am depressed now, because I haven't read this yet! Fantastic review, Candi.


Cathrine ☯️ Stoner is now a permanent part of your psyche. I love reading thoughtful reviews of this work and glad you finally got to it Candi.


message 24: by Beata (new)

Beata Grand review, Candi :)) Just like yourself, I've had this book for years .. A mistake! A big mistake! :))


Cecily Ah, Candi, welcome to the Stoner fan club. Your emotional, personal review illustrates just what is so special about this book. Your initial response is close to my own: “Finished. Him and me. Exquisite but exhausted.�

Speaking "quietly but with an underlying urgency I cannot ignore" - yes, yes, yes. And the questions it raises about ourselves. Yes to those too. Wonderful.

(I actually think his Augustus is objectively even "better", but Stoner has my heart.)


Richard (on hiatus) Lovely review Candi ......... loved this novel, it was quietly devastating! Loved your review as well :)


Candi Bam cooks the books ;-) wrote: "Wonderful review of a wonderful story, Candi!"

Thank you, Bam! I'm happy to have finally joined the ranks of Stoner lovers :)


Candi Sara wrote: "With both started the year with this book, Candi. Can't help thinking it bodes well for what 2020 might be."

Sara, I'm thinking it will be a stellar year. I mean, Stoner and now The Little Drummer Girl! The bar is raised high right at the start of the year :)


Candi Jenna wrote: "Wow, what a review, Candi! I'll have to put this on my classics list."

Thanks so much, Jenna! This is a classic not to be missed. I hope that it brings you as much pleasure as it did me :)


Candi Ace wrote: "Great review Candi. I must get to it myself soon."

Thank you, Ace! Don't wait too long! ;)


message 31: by Stephen (new)

Stephen Gibson This is a wonderful review, Candi. I have a copy of ‘Stoner� in stock and will move it up my reading pile on the strength of your review. Thanks. 😀🖖🏼


Laysee I can’t think of a more rewarding book to read at the start of a new year and new decade. What a treat to read your heartfelt and insightful review, Candi. Loved it!


Diane Barnes Lots of people love this book, but only a few can write a review that does it justice. You just joined that club. This is one of my favorite novels ever, and you captured my feelings exactly. I read this before joining GR, but would be intimidated to try a review beside so many excellent ones. But I will definitely re-read it.


message 34: by Melanie (new) - added it

Melanie I love your review of this book Candi. I have it but have not read it. After reading your review I am going to make sure it's one I read in 2020. Thank you 🙂


Candi Katie wrote: "With you all the way, Candi. For some reason I always thought this novel might bore me. How wrong I was!"

Katie, I have to admit that maybe ten years ago, I would not have dreamed of picking up this book. It's one that needs to come at the right time in your life, and that time was now :)


Candi Alex wrote: "Brilliant review! Adding it to my TBR"

Thank you, Alex! I don't think you'll regret reading this, especially if you enjoy a reflective kind of novel.


Candi Wyndy wrote: "I knew you’d love this book and do it proud with your own personal stamp. Completely agree that there’s a little piece of William Stoner in us all."

I really appreciate your kind words, Wyndy. I knew that I would love this based on some friends' experiences, yours being one of them. I can't stop thinking of Stoner.


message 38: by David (new) - added it

David Putnam Nice review. I added it to my list


Carol So agree with your 5 stars Candi! Great review too.


Bianca Beautiful review. I've seen so many glowing reviews of this novel, which prompted me to buy it two, three years ago, but I keep postponing reading it.


Jennifer Tuggey I’m always so happy when other people find this story. It’s been a long time since I read Stoner, but I still think of him with quiet affection. What a simple, beautifully done telling of the complexities and heartbreak of everyday life.


Angela M A beautiful and thoughtful review, Candi . While there is much I appreciate about this novel, I’m in the minority I think because as much as I appreciate the scholarly life that Stoner lived , I felt like he gave up the love of his life and I felt as though he abandoned his daughter . All else was sacred above them . I’m probably missing the point but ....


Karen Beautiful review Candi! I’ve been waiting for it since I saw that you finished it many days ago😊
This is a favorite and I still think about Stoner!


message 44: by Esil (new) - added it

Esil Beautiful review, Candi. I keep meaning to read this one...


Candi Antoinette wrote: "Stunning review, Candi! I still haven’t read this book- but it’s on my must read for this year. I get anxious about reading a book that so many people have raved about- but I’m pretty sure this boo..."

Thank you very much, Antoinette! I know exactly what you mean! But I think you should put your hesitations aside and go for it - I have a really good feeling you will love it too :)


Candi Sue wrote: "I love you review so much Candi! You captured the essence of this book so well. I'm glad that you loved it as much as I did."

Many thanks, Sue! This is a book that will remain lodged firmly in my heart for a long time to come. It's wonderful to share a special book like this :)


Candi Jami wrote: "Great Review! I think I need to read this one!"

Thank you, Jami! It may be the story of an ordinary man, but the storytelling itself is far from ordinary. I hope you love it!


message 48: by Holly (new)

Holly  B (slower pace!) Wonderful review Candi!


Candi Colleen wrote: "Based on your review, I am going to buy and read this book. Thanks for recommending a book I would never have found on my own."

Colleen, one of the best parts about ŷ - finding treasures that you wouldn't necessarily find just walking into your library or bookstore. I hope that you find this book worth every penny you spend on it :)


Candi Kathleen wrote: "Well I am depressed now, because I haven't read this yet! Fantastic review, Candi."

Kathleen, get this book and get yourself out of the blues - doctor's orders! Well, my orders anyway :D I really want to know what you think of it. (Think you'll love it!) Thanks so much :)


« previous 1 3 4
back to top