Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Seemita's Reviews > Letters to a Young Poet

Letters to a Young Poet by Rainer Maria Rilke
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
34622220
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: germany, translated, epislotary, religion, singing_words, philo, novella, for_legacy, me, favorites

Dear Mr. Rilke,

Assuming it to be a frequent phenomenon with you, I partake in pleasure and liberty of appointing you the receiver of yet another letter, from a besotted admirer of your wisdom and expression.

You see I have always felt that the best stories are those that we wish turned true; stories that uplift us with their depths and spring us back to the surface to stay afloat; stories that carry our thoughts in their seams and weave the most warm blankets to protect us in the winters of life; stories that complete the half-drawn picture, packing us to a destination of solace.

But above all, a story works best when the mind inking it knows its reader like a best friend; knowing when to let her be and when to rejig her. When the pen joins dots to create conversations between its one such holder and this distant best friend, the creations turn alive, ringing their elevating bells for years to come.

Although I laid hands on a bunch of letters your wrote to Mr.Kappus, your young poet friend, I was taken aback by the loud resonance that penetrated my soul upon reading them. You came to bless me with your songs on life at a time when I was getting crushed under boulders of fear and anxiety with my arms turning deplorably limp to make even the smallest of difference. These bouts are not uncommon but this time, they were of epic proportions. When the ground beneath one’s ideals is suddenly shaken in virulent jolts, she looks upto the skies in hope of a miraculous intervention. You, were mine. Like a supreme entablature, your sagacity descended upon me, stabilizing my fledgling structure. Your distilled prudence covered every open bevel, every bruised crevice in my existence and all at once, I was steady, sturdy and breathing again.
And your doubts can become a good quality if you school them. They must grow to be knowledgeable, they must learn to be critical. As soon as they begin to spoil something for you ask them why a thing is ugly, demand hard evidence, test them, and you will perhaps find them at a loss and short of an answer, or perhaps mutinous. But do not give in, request arguments, and act with this kind of attentiveness and consistency every single time, and the day will come when instead of being demolishers they will be among your best workers � perhaps the canniest of all those at work on the building of your life.
It might be heartening for you to know that I have been attributing my strength to my doubts as much as to my beliefs. In fact, I have often found myself strolling on numerous evenings, absorbed in an inconsequential mist of doubts and dilemmas. Donning the robe of a forced soloist has never stopped me from performing but has often questioned my embrace of solitude. Is it even worth? All those seconds ticking away without another pair of eyes in the vicinity?
What is needed is this, and this alone: solitude, great inner loneliness. Going into oneself and not meeting anyone for hours � that is what one must arrive at.
You quelled my fear; in the most beautiful way. You didn’t deflect me from my walk. Instead you slipped an inexpressible kind of validation beneath my feet that transformed the weather all at once. Holding your finger, the hard road of complexities and predicaments turned a generous grass-bed of soft, white clouds � engulfing me in a feeling of beauty, tenderness, clarity and alacrity while sending buoyant tremors of spirit into my being.

I know I would continue to run into speed-breakers during this voyage of mine; occasional skidding on account of poor reflexes on dense complexes would also be inevitable. But both in bountiful and sick days, I would survive on your inspiring truths; those that cannot be seized by time or place, those that do not have any negative cape, those that find beauty in much, those that detect a breath in dust.
If there is something ailing in the way you go about things, then remember that sickness is the means by which an organism rids itself of something foreign to it. All one has to do is help it to be ill, to have its whole illness and let it break out, for that is how it mends itself.
.
152 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Letters to a Young Poet.
Sign In »

Quotes Seemita Liked

Rainer Maria Rilke
“Have patience with everything that remains unsolved in your heart.
...live in the question.”
Rainer Maria Rilke, Letters to a Young Poet

Rainer Maria Rilke
“I hold this to be the highest task of a bond between two people: that each should stand guard over the solitude of the other.”
Rainer Maria Rilke, Letters to a Young Poet


Reading Progress

February 25, 2015 – Shelved
December 7, 2015 – Started Reading
December 8, 2015 –
page 40
27.78% "'But then that is one of the severest tests of an artist: he must always remain innocent and unconscious of his greatest virtues if he is to avoid depriving them of their uninhibitedness and purity.'"
December 8, 2015 –
page 82
56.94% "'....to be patient towards all that is unresolved in your heart and to try to love the questions themselves like locked rooms, like books written in a foreign tongue.'"
December 9, 2015 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 53 (53 new)


s.penkevich yay! I love this book


Dolors seconding spenks and awaiting your extended thoughts with bated breath, Simi!


Seemita s.penkevich wrote: "yay! I love this book"

It is indeed exquisite, Steve! I will put up some more thoughts soon.


message 4: by flo (new) - added it

flo *brings popcorn and Diet Coke*


message 5: by Seemita (last edited Dec 09, 2015 11:04AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Seemita Dolors wrote: "seconding spenks and awaiting your extended thoughts with bated breath, Simi!"

Thanks for your enthusiasm, D! Much needed, invigorating read :) Will put up the extended version soon!


Seemita Florencia wrote: "*brings popcorn and Diet Coke*"

*hastens inside the projector room* ;)


message 7: by Lynne (new) - added it

Lynne King Well you've stated in all in one succinct sentence Seemita!


Seemita Lynne wrote: "Well you've stated in all in one succinct sentence Seemita!"

Merci beaucoup, Lynne! :) Too much of depth and a heavenly fall into them; this book is so pure and gorgeous!


message 9: by [deleted user] (new)

with those trailers, you will probably end up making people option of multiple likes on same goodreads review.


Seemita Sidharth wrote: "with those trailers, you will probably end up making people option of multiple likes on same goodreads review."

Lovely compliment to receive, Sidharth! Thank you. That's just how I end up writing after reading; a heady burst, followed by a leisurely walk :)


Seemita Sabah wrote: "Your ability to relay in one sentence, what many of us would fail to in a 100, is a testament to your lyrical fluidity and purity of thought. Thank you Seemita :)"

You are too kind, Sabah! Thanks a bunch :) I can't stop myself from penning in my first thought that comes springing out of me upon finishing a work. Mostly, it happens to be the essence of my understanding of the work. This one was outright inspiring and I am glad the solitary line could convey the message :)


message 12: by Junta (last edited Dec 11, 2015 03:03PM) (new) - added it

Junta Beautiful review Seemita! The books that speak to our soul are the most precious, and your depiction of the review waltz with Mr. Rilke is a delight to read.


Dolors Dearest Seemita,

This is a phenomenal example of words offering solace without actually dispelling the dark clouds of our doubtful (and limited!) condition as impressionable human beings. But to fully accept solitude in exchange of grabbing at fleeting beauty, if only for a second, is to acknowledge our transience, and that requires a great deal of mental strength and humility. There is plenty of both in this letter, plus an inexhaustible flow of poetic vigor that pours from the wellspring of your being, Seemita. Let the rivers break loose in the oceans locked within you and shower us with your cleansing waters... It's raining poetry today! :)


message 14: by flo (new) - added it

flo Oh, this is not a popcorn-and-coke review, this is a review to enjoy with the finest wine or something; but I don't like those drinks :P so I'll just pretend I have a refined beverage rather than this unpoetic apple juice, and will allow your words to take me to the core of Rilke's exquisite poetry. This is a letter that speaks softly, soothingly, about everything that is essential to a reader's life. A letter that whispers in my ear about how the right book helps a reader to overcome the toughest of times. So much emotion contained in this sweet whisper that loudly reflects the beauty of your reflections. Mr. Rilke smiles...
Beautiful review, my friend! I've read only one book by him. This should be the next one.


message 15: by Pradnya (new) - added it

Pradnya Breathtaking review Seemita! It's a book you praise n it's your words I marvel at. Keep them coming.. That was a novel way too.


Seemita Fatty wrote: "Un-liked this just so I could re-like it. Such a beautiful, eloquent review! You even outdid the quotes you selected. A pleasure to read; thank you!"

Now, that's a unique style! :) Thank you for reading and leaving such a lovely note of appreciation, Fatty.


Seemita Junta wrote: "Beautiful review Seemita! The books that speak to our soul are the most precious, and your depiction of the review waltz with Mr. Rilke is a delight to read."

If this waltz of a review made you sway, the entire orchestra of the book will transport you to another world, Junta! Rilke writes with such acute clarity and passion that to think of him being all of 26 at the time of penning these verses, is mind-boggling! I am excited to see this in your TBR pile. May your meeting condense ages :)


Seemita Dolors wrote: "Dearest Seemita,

This is a phenomenal example of words offering solace without actually dispelling the dark clouds of our doubtful (and limited!) condition as impressionable human beings. But to f..."


Your words are nothing short of a sparkling water-spring on the parched deserts of my heart, dearest! Every time they emerge, they wash me anew with a scintillating beauty, that remains long after they have vanished; much like how reading Rilke felt. The letters are dipped in a certain uncorrupt percipience that can elevate us from all the petty, trivial vices of the world and exhort us towards something more meaningful, more potent, even more difficult, but more gratifying. You know it all well, Dolors and thus, I thank you doubly for finding merit in my review. The words would flow from here as long as they continue reaching your shore :)


Seemita Florencia wrote: "Oh, this is not a popcorn-and-coke review, this is a review to enjoy with the finest wine or something; but I don't like those drinks :P so I'll just pretend I have a refined beverage rather than t..."

You humble me with your heart-warming articulation, Florencia! This book is indeed a friend for those cold, dark nights; like a lever, it can pull us out of the abyss and render us steady, to once again look at life with renewed determination and hope. He talks about solitude, friendship, love, despair, failure and hope in healing, salubrious tones that go a long way in clearing the haze clogging our minds and render clarity of thought and discovery. I am thrilled to see it on your TBR... I hope you get to it soon! Many thanks for that vivacious endorsement, my friend; always treasured :)

P.S. Sorry about leaving you without a proper beverage to read this review with; I will make it up someday! :D


Seemita Pradnya wrote: "Breathtaking review Seemita! It's a book you praise n it's your words I marvel at. Keep them coming.. That was a novel way too."

Glad this review resonated with you, Pradnya! This book is much greater than what my meagre words have made it out to be. You must read him and experience the magic for yourself.


message 21: by Ian (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ian "Marvin" Graye Wonderful review, Seemita. May ease always follow dis-ease!


message 22: by Fionnuala (new) - added it

Fionnuala I see you also found it impossible to resist the impulse of writing back to Rilke, Seemita!
I was struck by the amount of words related to burdens and heavy objects in your letter - it does seem to have been written out of a troubled place so I'm glad that Rilke's letters to another young poet assailed by doubts were a comfort to you - though you seem to have figured by yourself that your own doubts are not necessarily a handicap. I'd imagine Rilke might have been a lot more patient in his response to your letter than he was to poor Mr Kappus ;-)


Seemita Ian wrote: "Wonderful review, Seemita. May ease always follow dis-ease!"

Masterfully put, Ian! Amen to that! And thank you for giving your nod to my musings :)


Seemita Fionnuala wrote: "I see you also found it impossible to resist the impulse of writing back to Rilke, Seemita!
I was struck by the amount of words related to burdens and heavy objects in your letter - it does seem to..."


That was a delightful coincidence, Fio! :) I posted my review and off I went to check out my friends' review and voila! found the pattern recur in yours :) Indeed, Rilke's words came my way as immensely wise and particularly therapeutic and I found myself reset to a tranquil mindset. And a little birdie within tells me that had Rilke been dealing with me, he would have summoned me for once and for all, dispatching me and my bag of doubts to an eternal search with a fully-charged torch of his words - 'Go! And Hunt' !! ;)


Violet wells I've got such fond memories of reading this book.


Rakhi Dalal I echo Fionnuala's thoughts here,Seemita. I am glad that Rilke's words soothed your soul and made your solitude more joyous :) Your review expresses your experience so well.Lovely.


Helle This is wonderful, Seemita. I enjoyed the juxtapositions you give voice to here of fear and hope, doubts and beliefs. We are surely more whole as human beings (if not necessarily happier), if we have the ability to encompass both these ends of the emotional scale. Thank you for clarifying and underlining why this must go into my to-read pile!


Seemita Violet wrote: "I've got such fond memories of reading this book."

I am sure you have, Violet; this book is such a treasure-trove of melodious wisdom after all!


Seemita Rakhi wrote: "I echo Fionnuala's thoughts here,Seemita. I am glad that Rilke's words soothed your soul and made your solitude more joyous :) Your review expresses your experience so well.Lovely."

Thank you so much, Rakhi! Rilke's words, indeed, came as a huge calming wave over me and I was just happy to be standing at a place to receive it. Guess it was a certain, ethereal kinda experience... I can see you had it too :)


Seemita Helle wrote: "This is wonderful, Seemita. I enjoyed the juxtapositions you give voice to here of fear and hope, doubts and beliefs. We are surely more whole as human beings (if not necessarily happier), if we ha..."

You put it so eloquently, Helle! Yes, perhaps we are the sum total of the good and not-so-good elements within us and all we must strive throughout our lives is to preserve the former and work on the latter. Let me be presumptuous and state that you would like what Rilke relays should you choose to sit in his class someday. I would be more than glad to hear your experience :) Many thanks for your encouragement, my friend.


message 31: by Lily (new)

Lily I love how you've written this review. :)

But above all, a story works best when the mind inking it knows its reader like a best friend; knowing when to let her be and when to rejig her.

Very very true, and it's magical to discover an author who already knows one so well. :)


Seemita Lily wrote: "I love how you've written this review. :)

But above all, a story works best when the mind inking it knows its reader like a best friend; knowing when to let her be and when to rejig her.

Very ve..."


Thank you so much for the affirmation, Lily! You are right; Rilke knows us dangerously well; our predicaments and the accompanying horror in not being able to work things out in time. It was a pleasure to read this benevolent teacher :)


message 33: by Deea (last edited Dec 13, 2015 02:02AM) (new)

Deea But both in bountiful and sick days, I would survive on your inspiring truths; those that cannot be seized by time or place, those that do not have any negative cape, those that find beauty in much, those that detect a breath in dust.

This is the nicest declaration to a writer that I have read. This review is very characteristic of your style: ingenious, poetic, charged with meanings and feelings,loaded with gems. Really nice!


message 34: by Cheryl (last edited Dec 13, 2015 09:35AM) (new)

Cheryl Seemita, this is my favorite review from you so far. Poignant, astute, and adroit prose. Oh and that second paragraph (wow!) pokes at the craft of writing itself. This is one book I'm ashamed to say I've only read in portions, with just the right excerpts needed to share Rilke's wisdom with a group. I've promised myself I'd read it soon and your evocative review has prompted me to do so. Perhaps his words will also be my numbing prescription for the anxiety, frustration, and pain one sometimes has to endure through difficult phases in life. Thanks for the beautiful writing, dear Seemi:)


Seemita Deea wrote: "
But both in bountiful and sick days, I would survive on your inspiring truths; those that cannot be seized by time or place, those that do not have any negative cape, those that find beauty in m..."


My declaration is not even wee bit exaggeration; Rilke does it all so simply yet so profoundly that one is healed, no matter how wounded. Thrilled to see you adding this to your TBR pile; may he leave you equally enthralled :) For your ever-flowing generous praise, many thanks, dear Deea!


Seemita Cheryl wrote: "Seemita, this is my favorite review from you so far. Poignant, astute, and adroit prose. Oh and that second paragraph (wow!) pokes at the craft of writing itself. This is one book I'm ashamed to sa..."

Ah! Such a lovely compliment from you to double up as a sweet goodnight wish, dear Cheryl! :) Yes, this happens to be a book which reached me at the right time; a time not so sunny and a time that was trying my resolve and resilience. It was a perfect example of a piece of literature working as that missing piece to complete an incomplete puzzle of life, if only of a short chapter. I am glad you have a flavor of Rilke's writing; and you have nothing to be ashamed of since you have been scaling new heights in your experimental sampling and incisive understanding of numerous worthwhile books. You, our adorable little manic bibliophile :) May your tryst with Rilke enrich your already fecund treasures.


message 37: by Ilse (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ilse Seemita, what a brave and stirring letter you wrote. Your creativity seems boundless, first you posted the stunning poem on Marquez, now this astonishing epistolary tour de force...my reservoir of superlatives is short falling your admirable writing skills, dear Seemita. It is such a joy to see a review from you popping up � and then holding myself from reading it, till I find a right and proper moment to taste and reread it. Like wonderful stories in their own right, your postings resemble the softest of blankets in which we can enwrap ourselves, in our own private winters of life. Tnank you.


Seemita Ilse wrote: "Seemita, what a brave and stirring letter you wrote. Your creativity seems boundless, first you posted the stunning poem on Marquez, now this astonishing epistolary tour de force...my reservoir of ..."

Oh Ilse! Thank you so very much for sending my way such a sparkling, beautiful message, replete with warmth and invigoration! My acute awareness of the many flaws and slips in my writing is solely neutralized by the generous dose of appreciation and motivation, flowing consistently from dear friends like you. So, please accept my gratitude, for being so patient and receptive of my reviews, for imparting them an undeservedly high place and never ceasing to send me a shout. I hope you always have the warm blanket of words to embalm you with uplifting emotions, keeping you striding on the journey of life.


message 39: by Vessey (new) - added it

Vessey "When the ground beneath one’s ideals is suddenly shaken in virulent jolts, she looks upto the skies in hope of a miraculous intervention. You, were mine"

Seemita, your mind is infinite. This may sound odd, but I often worry that my capabilities are quite limited. That there are only so many times I can express something worthy and that at one point it will turn out that I have said and done everything I could and despite my brightest ambitions, I would have nothing new to share and every time I need to feel confident in my intelligence, I would have to cling on the old days. But you never seem to run out of things to say and they are always incredible. You bear a boundless sea within you and this gives me hope for myself. You are my Rainer Rilke, my miraculous intervention. Thank you.


Seemita Vessy wrote: ""When the ground beneath one’s ideals is suddenly shaken in virulent jolts, she looks upto the skies in hope of a miraculous intervention. You, were mine"

Seemita, your mind is infinite. This may ..."


I am immensely humbled by the faith you have bestowed me with, Vessy. You have awarded me one of the best gifts ever that I have gathered over my short but eventful life. But my dear, you have no reason to discount your own abilities which I have had the good fortune of witnessing not once, but many times over. While the sea can be defined by its boundlessness, it can also be measured by its depth. And its when every time, you reach the deep recesses of human psyche and come up with pearls that just don't adorn your mantle but also spread their shines to the emotional lawns of your friends, you do a worthwhile deed. I am glad to have befriended you and I take heart in the fact that you have found some solace in my words. If you ever read Rilke, I am certain you would cover vast wisdom in multiple leaps. I would await that day. Thank you, once again, for showering such warm albeit undeserved praise on me. Truly treasured.


Seemita Sabah wrote: "I'm so grateful to Vessy for commenting upon this review. I had read your first thoughts upon your initial read and now I am conversant with the wealth of meaning, of which I only had a brief glimp..."

Thank you for gracing my review thread with your illuminating thoughts, Sabah. Despairs and disappointments are indeed the limp backgrounds over which the bright colours of our joys and successes resound and make a pretty picture. In the absence of the former, the significance of the latter may well be lost. But that transition! Ah! Its in that transitional phase that we require a mentor, a guide, a teacher, who somewhere, is also our friend. I was fortunate to find Rilke at a such a junction and perhaps that's why, he spoke that much more louder to my soul. But if my timid words possessed the capability to leap to your heart, Rilke's would, most certainly, transform you, in a good way. While I wish eternal spring in your life, may there always be a Rilke to assuage your anxieties should winter make a guest appearance.


message 42: by Vessey (new) - added it

Vessey Seemita wrote: "Vessy wrote: ""When the ground beneath one’s ideals is suddenly shaken in virulent jolts, she looks upto the skies in hope of a miraculous intervention. You, were mine"

Seemita, your mind is infin..."


Seemita, I treasure the gift of your friendship and your always warm and sparkling words of encouragement. Thank you, my friend. I believe you deserved every word.


Seemita Sabah wrote: "Omg! Seemita your review is far from timid, even your comments are words of art! :)."

You are too kind, Sabah! My heart-felt thanks :)


Seemita Vessy wrote: "Seemita, I treasure the gift of your friendship and your always warm and sparkling words of encouragement. Thank you, my friend. I believe you deserved every word."

The admiration is mutual, Vessy! Thank you very much :)


message 45: by Margaret (new)

Margaret That you for this beautiful and eloquent letter to Rilke. Would that he could write back to you. And I believe you correct; we do wish true those very best stories (and poems). They walk with us and make our troubles feel lighter.


Seemita Margaret wrote: "That you for this beautiful and eloquent letter to Rilke. Would that he could write back to you. And I believe you correct; we do wish true those very best stories (and poems). They walk with us an..."

Thank you so much for the nod, Margaret! Rilke writes with a ruminated pen that seems to draw its ink straight from his heart. I don't know if you have read him but if you haven't, I would most heartily recommend his musings. Irrespective of a sunny or balmy day, his thoughts would come as the perfect piece to complete the puzzle :)

And let me take this opportunity to wish you a Merry Christmas and a wonderful 2016!


message 47: by Margaret (new)

Margaret And a very Happy New Year to you as well. Yes, some years back I read Rilke: this book a and volume of poems. I remember his deeply Romantic insistence that the inner depths of the solitary soul are the deepest only) sources of true poetry. And also his advice to young would-be poets that unless they MUST write, they should not. I remember writing down those points on 3x5 cards and keeping them. (Of course, I have since decluttered decades worth of paper, and they are gone. No worry, the Internet has all.)


Garima I don't know till when but it will be some time before I will pick these letters again to read. For now, Seemita's letter will be my solace, my bestest season's greeting. Lovely thoughts there, my friend.


Seemita Garima wrote: "I don't know till when but it will be some time before I will pick these letters again to read. For now, Seemita's letter will be my solace, my bestest season's greeting. Lovely thoughts there, my ..."

Oh Garima! Having you drop in with a comment is akin to experiencing a sprightly morning breeze that was on a sabbatical. And receiving your warm affirmation through it, is indeed an added bonus :) So glad to see you, dear; please accept my best wishes for a wonderful 2016.


Himanshu I can't imagine an ode more poignant and full of breath than this one, Seemita. I find myself accompanying you on that lonely walk with similar doubts and dilemmas and as if the words of Rilke have somehow touched me tangentially. Your words soothe me just like Rilke's has soothed you. Supremely glad that I didn't miss this review. Wow!


« previous 1
back to top