ŷ

Dolors's Reviews > Cannery Row

Cannery Row by John Steinbeck
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
18383778
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: read-in-2015
Reading for the 3rd time. Most recently started July 30, 2022.

Why does Steinbeck's narrative voice entice me so, I've been asking myself over the past few days.
In my second reading of this novella, which has become a favorite of mine, I realized that it's his unshakeable belief in mankind.
Steinbeck reinvents the concept of family and expands its boundaries with his blatant love for humanity. Nobody is homeless in Cannery Row, not even imps or prostitutes, destitute painters or big-hearted biologists, mentally impaired kids or immigrant shopkeepers. Even mongrels and frogs are treated with decorum in this picturesque portrait of comradeship in Monterrey, California.

Interweaving a wide array of anecdotes with symbolic connotations, Steinbeck paints decent lives for the dispossessed that endure the sentence of social marginalization. Unexpected dignity comes in the form of reciprocal support, selfless loyalty and the humbling acceptance of the foibles of human condition and, as if by some sort of magic, the unappealing milieu of rattling caravans, crumbling shacks and noisy honky-tonks constitute an enchanting place where people live for themselves and need very little to reach serenity of mind.
The spell of Steinbeck’s soothing prose settles in and Mack and the boys, troublesome rascals, become the Beauties, the Graces and the Virtues of this vibrant community. Doc, whose faith in the goodness of mankind is as fervent as his devotion to the mysteries of marine biology, is the converging point that brings out the best in his fellowmen, modeled after his creator. His compassion is genuine and carries not a hint of condescendence, and so when he listens to his friends� predicaments or to one of his albums of Gregorian music at the hour of the pearl, he is equally overcome by the joy of extending unconditional friendship or by his not unwelcome loneliness.

But watch out. Don’t allow yourself to be misled.
Steinbeck, like Doc, doesn’t offer a glorified, syrupy version of the hardships of life while sermonizing on the benefits of collective insurgency; his clear-cut vision synthesizes the healing compassion that human beings are capable of and inspires us to find poetry in the most prosaic, even the most repulsive of things.
There is an irresistible modesty in Steinbeck’s minimalistic yet deeply charged prose. The half-deprecating, half-dramatic tone in which he paints these stories gives a tragicomic intensity to the clumsy, reprovable characters and tinges their daily tribulations with an authentic tenderness that pierces right through the thickest skins.

Cannery Road is a toast to ordinariness, an unabashed portrayal of men at his worst shinning with the best of human condition, an ode to the invisible treasures of life.
I dare you who read to look at the world through Steinbeck’s eyes.
And you will see a cocktail prepared with drink leftovers and cheap whisky become a delicatessen, if shared in good company.
A disastrous birthday party; the much-desired present that restores lost innocence.
The high tides and waves splashing on the rocks under the piers; the perfect moonlight sonata at the time after the light has come and before the sun has risen.
And Black Marigolds that wither with the evanescence of life; an eternal blessing.
Even now. Even here. Even for us.



173 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Cannery Row.
Sign In »

Quotes Dolors Liked

John Steinbeck
“It is the hour of pearl—the interval between day and night when time stops and examines itself.”
John Steinbeck, Cannery Row


Reading Progress

Finished Reading
February 25, 2015 – Shelved
February 28, 2015 –
page 113
62.43% ""Cannery Row in Monterey in California is a poem, a stink, a grating noise, a quality of light, a tone, a habit, a nostalgia, a dream.""
September 2, 2015 – Started Reading
September 2, 2015 – Finished Reading
July 30, 2022 – Started Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 81 (81 new)


message 1: by · (new) - rated it 5 stars

· Oh, Dolors, you have caught my heart all over again with this paean to humanity washed up on the Western shore. It is a marvel, is it not? That acuity of vision, the tough lack of sentimentality, and the warmth that is stitched through the fabric.

And the gopher!


message 2: by 7jane (new)

7jane Beautiful review :) <3


message 3: by Billy (new)

Billy O'Callaghan Ah, what a wonderful review. Steinbeck was the writer who made me fall in love with reading, and who inspired me, in time, to write. Such an empathetic voice. I haven't read Cannery Row in probably twenty years, but you've brought it all back in the most beautiful fashion. Now I want to pick it up again! Thank you for these words.


message 4: by Fionnuala (new)

Fionnuala Dolors, you've convinced me that I need to sit down soon, perhaps at the hour of the pearl, with a cocktail in my glass and some Gregorian chant in the background, and reread this favourite Steinbeck :-)


message 5: by Ray (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ray Agree that this is a lovely book - vibrant and full of joy in the characters - they come across as real people, flawed as we all are

have you read any other steinbeck? i pick his books up on occasion when browsing second hand bookshops and have enjoyed them very much


Deea The fact that you love Steinbeck's style transpires through your words. It's more than obvious. I really enjoyed reading this review of yours Dolors and I am convinced...will add this too on my pile of TBR. Thank you so much!


Dolors ·· wrote: "Oh, Dolors, you have caught my heart all over again with this paean to humanity washed up on the Western shore. It is a marvel, is it not? That acuity of vision, the tough lack of sentimentality, a..."

Oh yes, the gopher…and the ambivalent message of those deadly traps coupled to that “successful� party! Doc’s burrow in Cannery Row might not be the best one to find him a suitable partner, and yet there is so much to savor in life in spite of the rats and the rattlesnakes trapped in their cages in the wrecked lab! Tough, yet so marvelous�. Indeed, Karen.


Dolors 7jane wrote: "Beautiful review :) <3"

Thanks for reading 7jane! :))


message 9: by Dolors (last edited Sep 04, 2015 12:39PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dolors Billy wrote: "Ah, what a wonderful review. Steinbeck was the writer who made me fall in love with reading, and who inspired me, in time, to write. Such an empathetic voice. I haven't read Cannery Row in probably..."

Thanks so much, Billy. This novella contains one of the most breathtaking openings I have ever read� "Cannery Row in Monterey in California is a poem, a stink, a grating noise, a quality of light, a tone, a habit, a nostalgia, a dream.�
The invoking tone of that first sentence is irresistible, isn’t it? But not all of us have the gift to canalize the sweeping inspiration provoked by extraneous talent to create something of our own. I bet that you do, but I will have to find out for sure one of these days!


message 10: by Dolors (last edited Sep 04, 2015 12:40PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dolors Fionnuala wrote: "Dolors, you've convinced me that I need to sit down soon, perhaps at the hour of the pearl, with a cocktail in my glass and some Gregorian chant in the background, and reread this favourite Steinbe..."

First loves will always remain memorable, won’t they Fionnuala? The chants emanating from Doc’s tattered gramophone blended with the sound of the waves lapping against the logs is the closest to the divine one might probably get. I hope you savor your “remember-when� party…and that dubious cocktail! :)


message 11: by Dolors (last edited Sep 04, 2015 01:58PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dolors Travelin wrote: "Really excellent book. I've read a reference to the fact that Steinbeck's writing lost something (humour? humanity? carmelizer?) after the man Doc was based on died."

Thanks for that tidbit, Travelin, I didn’t know that. But the fact that Doc was based on a real person, gives more credibility to Steinbeck’s vision of humanity. The Pearl is the only work I have read that was published after “Cannery Row� and it’s a much darker, cautionary tale, the gentle humor is certainly gone in that fable. Something to have in mind when I finally tackle East of Eden.


message 12: by Dolors (last edited Sep 04, 2015 12:45PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dolors Ray wrote: "Agree that this is a lovely book - vibrant and full of joy in the characters - they come across as real people, flawed as we all are

have you read any other steinbeck? i pick his books up on occas..."


The characters have caricaturesque qualities but they are not overblown, and so they are easy to relate to because we can invariably identify traits of our own personalities in them. I read The Grapes of Wrath and a couple other of his novellas last year and I still have to be disappointed. If you aim for a short work, I would recommend Of Mice and Men if you still haven’t read it. Thanks for your comment, Ray.


message 13: by Dolors (last edited Sep 04, 2015 12:46PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dolors Deea wrote: "The fact that you love Steinbeck's style transpires through your words. It's more than obvious. I really enjoyed reading this review of yours Dolors and I am convinced...will add this too on my pil..."

Many, many thanks for reading, Deea! Heh, yes I admit I am half in love with this man, and I am not kidding! ;P Steinbeck is on my list of authors I want to read and re-read many times in the future for years to come. I will be waiting for your reaction if you decide to take the plunge into his humanistic vision of the world with bated breath, Deea.


message 14: by Samadrita (new) - added it

Samadrita I know what my next Steinbeck will be. Thank you for convincing me with this spirited homage of a review, D.


Dolors Samadrita wrote: "I know what my next Steinbeck will be. Thank you for convincing me with this spirited homage of a review, D."

Super glad to hear that Sama, for I know your keen eyes will bring out some essential aspects of Steinbeck's writing I surely missed in my particular "love feast"...


message 16: by Kim (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kim How beautifully you have expressed the essence of Steinbeck and of this work, Dolors. I am so happy that you love his writing as much as I do.


message 17: by Kim (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kim BTW, Doc was based on Steinbeck's closest friend, Ed Ricketts. There are characters based on Ricketts in a number of Steinbeck's novels. (Jim Casey is one). He died as a result of a motor vehicle accident. Steinbeck was living in NYC at the time and Ricketts had died by the time Steinbeck arrived in Monterey. He was deeply depressed after Ricketts died and never completely got over his death.


Henry Avila Majestic review, Dolors, the human heart does continue even in the most depraved situations, hope is eternal, hope is life.


message 19: by Cheryl (new)

Cheryl Well, any author who believes in the goodness of humanity, is worth reading. I usually enjoy your Steinbeck preciosities, Dolors.


message 20: by Joe (new) - rated it 5 stars

Joe Cheryl wrote: "Well, any author who believes in the goodness of humanity, is worth reading. I usually enjoy your Steinbeck preciosities, Dolors."

Cheryl is a powerful clarivoyant and she read my mind on this one, Dolors. All I can add is a question: When are you going to write a novel?


message 21: by Pramod (new)

Pramod Nair Excellent review, Dolors...


message 22: by Corinne (new) - added it

Corinne Thanks for this inspiring review, Dolors. I have not read this book so far. I feel that Steinbeck managed to capture the realities of life through his books. As you said 'nobody is homeless', it is true that his characters always feel part of the life, Steinbeck masters the details and include all the surrounding life with the fauna and flora. He then managed to create the 'life' including the human beings, the fauna and tb flora. And his characters don't give in to despair; they struggle on, hold on to their dignity till the end, even if that means being beaten down by the system. His characters and their stories inspire us, give us hope.


message 23: by Dolors (last edited Sep 05, 2015 02:10AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dolors I was unaware that Doc was based on a real person until Travelin mentioned it in the post above, but I had no idea that other characters of Steinbeck’s books were inspired by the same person. Ed Ricketts must have been a magnificent individual if Steinbeck shaped characters like Doc and Jim after him, for their sympathy and compassion glowed and warmed the rest of the characters in his books, like I suppose Ed's friendship did for Steinbeck.
I intend to continue reading him and I consider myself lucky because I still have several of his works to discover. He has become an author that I know won’t ever disappoint. Thanks for the enlightening comment and for your kind words, Kim.


Dolors Henry wrote: "Majestic review, Dolors, the human heart does continue even in the most depraved situations, hope is eternal, hope is life."

That’s the spirit that makes my heart leap. Sweet Thursday is queued up to read soon, btw. Thank YOU for this inspiring comment, Henry.


Dolors Cheryl wrote: "Well, any author who believes in the goodness of humanity, is worth reading. I usually enjoy your Steinbeck preciosities, Dolors."

Many thanks, Cheryl. Steinbeck’s works are fine examples of art as a vehicle to demand social justice without sacrificing its authenticity. That to me is precious, indeed.


Dolors Joe wrote: "Cheryl wrote: "Well, any author who believes in the goodness of humanity, is worth reading. I usually enjoy your Steinbeck preciosities, Dolors."

Cheryl is a powerful clarivoyant and she read my m..."


Totally agree with your first statement. As to your question…heh, I think I am more a reader than a writer, but who knows what is written in the stars! Honored by your generous spurring, Joe. Thank you.


Dolors Pramod wrote: "Excellent review, Dolors..."

Thanks for your validating comment, Pramod!


message 28: by Henry (last edited Sep 05, 2015 02:15AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Henry Avila You will finally get to San Diego...


Dolors Corinne wrote: "Thanks for this inspiring review, Dolors. I have not read this book so far. I feel that Steinbeck managed to capture the realities of life through his books. As you said 'nobody is homeless', it i..."

How timely that you mention the important presence of the fauna and flora in Steinbeck’s books, Corinne. In this book, there are short parables involving animals (frogs, rattlesnakes, gophers, dog puppies, stray cats) that add further meaning to the dismaying state of affair of the characters, who find their home in the ties that bond them together in spite of the miserable life they are trapped in. Steinbeck’s bigger achievement to me is that his vision of the world is compassionate but not moralizing and that regardless of the pastoral quality of his prose, it is crudely realistic. Thanks for reading and for sharing your insightful thoughts on this thread, Corinne. I hope you enjoy your future readings by Steinbeck.


Dolors Henry wrote: "You will finally get to San Diego..."

You bet! :)


Cristina M'ha encantat l'observació sobre la creença en la goodness of the humankind. Diga-li ingenuïtat, si vols, però molt necessària per viure. L'afegeixo a la llista to read!


Agnieszka Absolutely beautiful piece of writing , Dolors ! It gladdens me , it saddens me and then again brightens . Adding this one without hesitation . Thanks .


Dolors Cristina wrote: "M'ha encantat l'observació sobre la creença en la goodness of the humankind. Diga-li ingenuïtat, si vols, però molt necessària per viure. L'afegeixo a la llista to read!"

Necessària especialment davant de la brutalitat de la vida i de la pròpia essència de les persones. I que algú aconsegueixi inspirar tot i parlar de les misèries que l'envolten a diari sense moralitat o sensibleria barata es mereix tot el meu respecte. Crec que l'Steinbeck és un d'aquells escriptors que va fer servir les paraules a favor dels seus ideals de justícia social sense sacrificar la vessant artística de les seves obres. Espero que t'agradi, a mi, òbviament, m'encantaaa! Bon dissabte nena, merci per llegir.


message 34: by Dolors (last edited Sep 05, 2015 03:34AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dolors Agnieszka wrote: "Absolutely beautiful piece of writing , Dolors ! It gladdens me , it saddens me and then again brightens . Adding this one without hesitation . Thanks ."

Thrilled to see you have added this one to your pending reads, Agna. Steinbeck's compassionate perspective might be a good contrast to the bleak nostalgia of the Nordic writers you have been reading of late. Hope he does make your heart leap as your comment did mine. Thanks for stopping by and for your inspirational words! :)


message 35: by Carol (new) - added it

Carol There is an irresistible modesty in Steinbeck’s minimalistic yet deeply charged prose.
I love your review and your description of this author's writing style, Dolors. I'm adding this one to my queue.


message 36: by Raph (new) - added it

Raph Splendid review! It let me feel a drop of warmness, (which was enough to have a good night's sleep!) of what I might find in this book. Thank you.


message 37: by Traveller (new) - added it

Traveller Sounds charming! Beautiful, warm review, indeed. I love that you always manage to see the good in everything, Dolors. :)
Strangely GR is not updating me on you, but I found you anyway, and I'm glad.


message 38: by [deleted user] (last edited Sep 05, 2015 02:16PM) (new)

Wow, I am awed by your shimmering ode to humanity, Dolors. I became caught up in Steinbeck's vision of the celebration of humanity through its brokenness and ordinariness. Dignity can be constructed from the fellowship of suffering and from appreciation of the common. I know that you are reviewing your impressions of Steinbeck, but it is really like you are revealing yourself and what inspires you. In each review, you perform your own Gregorian chant that quickly achieves polyphony. Instead of Deum Verum (God is true), I hear you sing "Sunt Vera" (people are true).I want to share this cocktail of cheap whisky and remnants of old bottles and drink in the company of fellow believers in the possibility of goodness in human beings. Your review inspires me to listen to the music, taste the liquor, and join voice in the chorus of praise for the marvelous gift of life and fidelity to humanity. Your review constructs a tapestry of beauty out of the ordinary.


message 39: by Deanna (new)

Deanna Wonderful review, Dolors :)


Dolors Carol wrote: "There is an irresistible modesty in Steinbeck’s minimalistic yet deeply charged prose.
I love your review and your description of this author's writing style, Dolors. I'm adding this one to my queue."


Thanks for reading and for your lovely, lovely words, Carol. Steinbeck’s prose is lucid and gentle, plus one can’t avoid ending up caring for the characters and having a very vivid image of the places they inhabit and the common bonds that unite them. Hope you like it if you decide to tackle any of his works at some point.


Dolors Raph wrote: "Splendid review! It let me feel a drop of warmness, (which was enough to have a good night's sleep!) of what I might find in this book. Thank you."

Thanks to YOU for putting it so beautifully, Ralph! Indeed. Steinbeck’s writing is warm and tender but he doesn’t avoid addressing the hardships or the unfairness in life. Thanks again for such a delightful and adequate comment.


Dolors Traveller wrote: "Sounds charming! Beautiful, warm review, indeed. I love that you always manage to see the good in everything, Dolors. :)
Strangely GR is not updating me on you, but I found you anyway, and I'm g..."



Hi Trav! I see you have managed to escaped the labyrinthine maze of a certain ensnaring author... how GREAT to hear from you. Heh, I think you solved my own enigma. I love Steinbeck because he tried to stress out "the good in everything�!
Grateful, pleased and beaming here because you decided to wink from afar and spread your kind words around�


message 43: by Dolors (last edited Sep 06, 2015 01:13AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dolors Marita wrote: "Lovely review, Dolors. I agree with Traveller: you see the good and find beauty everywhere."

Thanks Marita! Some people might call that trait as “ingenuity�, which might apply to me, but not in Steinbeck’s case because he paired that “goodness� with a piercing, yet subtle, denouncement of social injustice. That makes him a very capable writer to my eyes.


Dolors Steve wrote: "Wow, I am awed by your shimmering ode to humanity, Dolors. I became caught up in Steinbeck's vision of the celebration of humanity through its brokenness and ordinariness. Dignity can be constructe..."

And your comment leaves me without suitable words to reply as per usual, Steve. I have come to realize that whenever I write my impressions on a novel, I need to establish a common point of reference with either characters or narrative voice or the storyline. With some authors, that requires a bigger effort from my part, but with others (like Steinbeck), I have the full cannon of voices tugging at my heartstrings at once. His vision of the world, his ideology and his compassionate stance towards mankind appeal to me, as does his carefully crafted prose.
I guess I was in need of some “light� after having lived in the shadows of Japanese lit and O’Connor’s dismaying reality for a while. Steinbeck was a perfect hit for that. I raise that glass of leftovers and toast to the silent music, buried beauty and ordinary but precious life that consumes us. Thanks for making me sing at the tune of your silvery-toned words, my friend.


message 45: by Dolors (last edited Sep 06, 2015 01:15AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dolors Deanna wrote: "Wonderful review, Dolors :)"


Thanks Deanna, I appreciate you stopping by to post some such kind words.


message 46: by Jaidee (new)

Jaidee A lovely poetic review. I have not read Steinbeck but have enjoyed theatre productions based on his work. Thank you for pushing me towards him.


message 47: by Seemita (new)

Seemita That moment of utter joy to see a Steinbeck in your hands!! Yes, that infallible belief in mankind and that indomitable spirit to live life despite odds make his books life-givers in the storm of worldly vices. And what sublime cloud of soothing dews descended upon me on reading this celebration of family and togetherness, yet again in your inspiring homage to the master , Dolors! For that last para, a big, long, tight hug to you dear :)


Dolors Jaidee wrote: "A lovely poetic review. I have not read Steinbeck but have enjoyed theatre productions based on his work. Thank you for pushing me towards him."

Would love to see any of Steinbeck’s works performed on stage. I think “Of Mice and Man� is the most theatrical I’ve read by him so far. Thanks for checking in with your kind comment, Jaidee.


message 49: by Dolors (last edited Sep 06, 2015 08:00AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dolors Seemita wrote: "That moment of utter joy to see a Steinbeck in your hands!! Yes, that infallible belief in mankind and that indomitable spirit to live life despite odds make his books life-givers in the storm of w..."

Thanks so much for easing up my Sunday night blues with your glowing words, Seemita. I have a list of spotted authors that are like “comfort food� for me and Steinbeck is one of my new additions to that list. I will wait for the day you lay your skillful hands on him and wait to be blinded by Steinbeck's essence refracted in your delectable prose, as you have proved repeatedly to be the case over and over in your reviews. Bear, elephantine hug traveling back! :))


message 50: by flo (new)

flo ...an ode to the invisible treasures of life. Florencia reads while holding her cup of coffee, smiling at such a remarkable concept that has the power to change lives; nothing more, nothing less. A concept conveyed with simple words, a tender melody that fills ŷ with beauty, admiration and a big sense of "I get you, I see the same things you see, I long for the same things you long for". Just like Steinbeck's prose has been described in previous passages: a minimalistic yet deeply charged prose.

You are poetry, my friend! Lovely, lovely review, Dolors.


« previous 1
back to top