Sign in with Facebook
emma's Reviews > The Girl on the Train
The Girl on the Train
by
by
emma's review
bookshelves: nope, unpopular-opinion, 1-star, non-ya, reviewed, mystery-thriller-horror-etc, project-review-everything
Apr 04, 2015
bookshelves: nope, unpopular-opinion, 1-star, non-ya, reviewed, mystery-thriller-horror-etc, project-review-everything
this. book. suuuuuuuucks.
i can't believe it was an international sensation. i can't believe it was adapted into a moviestarring actual queen emily blunt. i can't believe it SOLD A SINGLE COPY. (i didn't buy this one. my mom did. so there.)
this is just...a straight up bad book on every level. the characters are so insanely unlikable it's cartoonish. it'd be funny if it didn't make EVERY SECOND OF THIS BOOK, EVERY PAGE, EVERY WORD, A FRESH HELL TO FIGHT THROUGH IN ORDER TO GET TO THE NEXT ONE, WHICH IS, GUESS WHAT, ALSO HELL.
this would be maybe O.K. or at least survivable if this book was scary or thrilling or spooky or intriguing at all, but guess what, IT ISN'T. just some lady getting blasted on vodka and riding a train. looking out some windows. sometimes sneaking a peek at a house.
the entertainment potential is almost overwhelming.
honestly all i really want from a thriller = some thrills. that really does not seem like too much to ask for, considering IT'S THE F*CKING NAME OF THE WHOLE ENTIRE GENRE. and the reveal of this makes it even worse.
bottom line: straight up one of the worst books i've ever read. are there people who like this book? if so, HOW????
(this is part of a project i'm doing where i write mini-reviews of books i read a long time ago. this parenthetical insert is a constant snoozefest)
i can't believe it was an international sensation. i can't believe it was adapted into a movie
this is just...a straight up bad book on every level. the characters are so insanely unlikable it's cartoonish. it'd be funny if it didn't make EVERY SECOND OF THIS BOOK, EVERY PAGE, EVERY WORD, A FRESH HELL TO FIGHT THROUGH IN ORDER TO GET TO THE NEXT ONE, WHICH IS, GUESS WHAT, ALSO HELL.
this would be maybe O.K. or at least survivable if this book was scary or thrilling or spooky or intriguing at all, but guess what, IT ISN'T. just some lady getting blasted on vodka and riding a train. looking out some windows. sometimes sneaking a peek at a house.
the entertainment potential is almost overwhelming.
honestly all i really want from a thriller = some thrills. that really does not seem like too much to ask for, considering IT'S THE F*CKING NAME OF THE WHOLE ENTIRE GENRE. and the reveal of this makes it even worse.
bottom line: straight up one of the worst books i've ever read. are there people who like this book? if so, HOW????
(this is part of a project i'm doing where i write mini-reviews of books i read a long time ago. this parenthetical insert is a constant snoozefest)
1131 likes · Like
�
flag
Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read
The Girl on the Train.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
April 4, 2015
– Shelved
July 5, 2015
–
Started Reading
July 5, 2015
–
41.96%
"i hate all these characters so much. reading from rachel's perspective makes me legitimately sick to my stomach. i don't know if i've ever been so disgusted with a character. if this book doesn't make a U-turn soon i'm going to have to DNF."
page
141
July 6, 2015
–
43.75%
"oh my god, i've never hated a character like this. i've never hated a character to the point where it is physically difficult for me to read a book."
page
147
July 6, 2015
–
64.29%
"OH MY GOD rachel! why are you the worst?! obviously everyone around you sucks too but COME ON grow up"
page
216
July 6, 2015
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-50 of 183 (183 new)
message 1:
by
Rosemarie
(new)
-
rated it 2 stars
Oct 16, 2017 08:23PM
I agree with you. I can't see what all the fuss was about either. Fortunately, I read a library copy.
reply
|
flag
Just how I felt! :PHated it! To think of it, it was a GR choice award winner too :P
Rosemarie wrote: "I agree with you. I can't see what all the fuss was about either. Fortunately, I read a library copy."i wish i had too!!!!
Hannah ◇Reader in the Rough� wrote: "SOMEBODY GETS ME"THANK GOD
Anish wrote: "Just how I felt! :PHated it! To think of it, it was a GR choice award winner too :P"
UNBELIEVABLE!!!!!
emma wrote: "Anish wrote: "Just how I felt! :PHated it! To think of it, it was a GR choice award winner too :P"
UNBELIEVABLE!!!!!"
I am glad someone feels me! :D
I couldn't agree more! 👏👏👏
Omg yes!!!!!!! I hated the characters and could not get into it at all.
emmaaaaaa I’m making you a suspense rec list1) Allegedly - this book is fucking terrifying like I don’t even,, categorize this it’s all realistic fic but it scared the crap out of me
2) Female of the Species - a Fucking Masterpiece!! also real fic but it rocked
3) And the Trees Crept In - just,, a straight up thriller
4) Murder on the Orient Express
5) Big Little Lies - more slowburn but also kind of the most emotionally cathartic thing I’ve ever read
6) Jane Unlimited by Kristin Cashire,, listen this book scared me so much at points it’s weird and speculative fictiony
7) Slasher Girls and Monster Boys - my all-time fav short story collection maybe
8) the book I’m reading right now (Sacred Lies Of Minnow Bly) it’s so fucking good I’m going to binge it
Completely agree. It felt like an unsuccessful Gone Girl knockoff.
Ugh, there is so much I honestly couldn't stand about this book, I seriously do not know what all the hype is about. I think people read the wrong book XD
Could not agree more. It was terrible!
lowkey love you now because EVERYONE seems to love this shit excuse of a thriller and i’m like how?? the only characters i hate more than the ones in this book are john green ones lmao
This review is on point! Great stuff!
Is it weird that reading your reviews makes me change my opinion??? 👀😂😂😂 I see everything in a new light
I have to agree I don't understand why it became this huge but I don't think it was a bad read.
Hope the next one is better!
Skipped the book, saw the movie and though, Nah....
Swaye wrote: "I couldn't agree more! 👏👏👏"IT'S SO BAD
Nicole wrote: "Omg yes!!!!!!! I hated the characters and could not get into it at all."RELATABLE
Elise wrote: "emmaaaaaa I’m making you a suspense rec list1) Allegedly - this book is fucking terrifying like I don’t even,, categorize this it’s all realistic fic but it scared the crap out of me
2) Female o..."
i love you so??? much??? for this??? you're amazing what a dear
Nenia *The Flagrant Liberal* wrote: "Completely agree. It felt like an unsuccessful Gone Girl knockoff."YES
Megan wrote: "Ugh, there is so much I honestly couldn't stand about this book, I seriously do not know what all the hype is about. I think people read the wrong book XD"that is the only possible explanation
Caitlin wrote: "Could not agree more. It was terrible!"right????
Clara wrote: "lowkey love you now because EVERYONE seems to love this shit excuse of a thriller and i’m like how?? the only characters i hate more than the ones in this book are john green ones lmao"ok i do not lowkey love u, i highkey love u. SAME TO JOHN GREEN
Matthew wrote: "This review is on point! Great stuff!"THANK YOU means so much
Naima wrote: "Is it weird that reading your reviews makes me change my opinion??? 👀😂😂😂 I see everything in a new light"this makes my ego BALLOON i love it
April wrote: "Skipped the book, saw the movie and though, Nah...."the movie i will pass on forever
Well, my mom loved it😂maybe it's a mom thing
this book was so bad everytime i think about it i fall asleep
omg I hated this, so boring and not thrilling?? 😂
I’d like to explain where 2 of the stars come from, according to the perspective of a person who lives in the western United States, we don’t have trains...the few trains do that do exist, you can’t drink. Western Americans were so shocked by drinking on trains that we Day dreamed through most of the plot, mildly paying attention as she did shit and was a shitty person. It should be called drinking on a train...we would have give 3 extra stars
Funniest review I've read in ages.This is on my Tbr shelf,but instead of wasting my time reading it,I will give it to someone I don't like.Thanks Emma!
Haha great review Emma! I, ahem, have this sat on my shelf at home ready to read....should i??😂
Charlie wrote: "Well, my mom loved it😂maybe it's a mom thing"lol it really might be
maybelline� wrote: "this book was so bad everytime i think about it i fall asleep"éâٲè
sana wrote: "omg I hated this, so boring and not thrilling?? 😂"SO TRUE WORST EVER
Andrew wrote: "I’d like to explain where 2 of the stars come from, according to the perspective of a person who lives in the western United States, we don’t have trains...the few trains do that do exist, you can�..."hahahaaaa best reasoning i've read yet
John of Canada wrote: "Funniest review I've read in ages.This is on my Tbr shelf,but instead of wasting my time reading it,I will give it to someone I don't like.Thanks Emma!"
good call john! it's a fantastic prank gift
Craig wrote: "Haha great review Emma! I, ahem, have this sat on my shelf at home ready to read....should i??😂"if you're asking "should i toss it out the window?" the answer is yes
emma wrote: "Craig wrote: "Haha great review Emma! I, ahem, have this sat on my shelf at home ready to read....should i??😂"
if you're asking "should i toss it out the window?" the answer is yes"
Ahahaha....nooo, should i "endure" it, ahem, read it, just for the giggles??😂
if you're asking "should i toss it out the window?" the answer is yes"
Ahahaha....nooo, should i "endure" it, ahem, read it, just for the giggles??😂
Actually, I am a mom of a daughter in her 30s and we both didn't like it. As some one said, none of the characters were likeable.
Rosemarie wrote: "Actually, I am a mom of a daughter in her 30s and we both didn't like it. As some one said, none of the characters were likeable."agreed!!
Craig wrote: "emma wrote: "Craig wrote: "Haha great review Emma! I, ahem, have this sat on my shelf at home ready to read....should i??😂"if you're asking "should i toss it out the window?" the answer is yes"
..."
there will be no giggles if you read this book, only suffering
emma wrote: "there will be no giggles if you read this book, only suffering "BRAVO!
Your reviews are seriously the best -- I enjoy every one! :)
Haha you actually have me intrigued now....hmm😉
omg i'm obsessed with you and your reviews and this one is just as amazing and hilarious 😂
Matthew wrote: "emma wrote: "there will be no giggles if you read this book, only suffering "BRAVO!
"
i wish every comment i made got bravos and neil patrick harris in response
