ŷ

Dear Faye's Reviews > Dumplin'

Dumplin' by Julie   Murphy
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
7650833
Once upon a time, I was fat.

I would have liked to use the nicer term "overweight", but who am I kidding? Almost weighing 70 kilos in my 5 feet 3 inches frame, I was fat and unhappy. I had big fucking boobs, big bulging sides, big buttcheeks, big arms, thighs that met together in at least one tangent, and the fact that my cheeks were already chubby without the added fat? Unhappiness galore. I tried to convince myself that even though I looked this way, I should still exude confidence because my physical appearance didn't and shouldn't decide my worth as a person, but after countless, "Oh, dear! Look at how you've grown!" from uncles and aunts who drop by every 2 months, after having to look for pants two to three sizes larger because I gained more weight again, after having seen your friends get hit on and try out sexy-as-fuck clothes and look so effortlessly fabulous, and you were stuck with pants and loose shirts, it started getting old, and fast.



It came to that point where whenever I heard the term mataba (fat) or malaki (big), I'd get so insecure and anxious. I'd want to get out of the scene and then hide until everyone was gone. I'd start thinking how inadequate I was, how much I was missing out on just because I wasn't as sexy or as fabulous as other girls. I'd start crying to myself why the fuck I was this way. Why did my mom had to come from a family of big people? Who didn't my dad come from a family that was tall and glamorous? I struggled so hard during this phase, and it became that motivation for me to shed down the weight, because I didn't want these wordsto keep haunting me like a ghost that just won't go away. It was mentally, emotionally, and psychologically traumatizing for me.

I've lost weight then. I've become confident. I feel better now in my own skin and body.

But I do wish this book had already existed during that time of my life, because maybe I wouldn't have hated myself that much then. Willowdean is fat, and she doesn't care. I mean, she does feel insecure about herself sometimes (like everybody else does), but she is fairly confident in her own body, although she does struggle with the judging and teasing of her peers when it comes to body types that are not deemed "beautiful" by society. Willow sets out to change that, by joining a beauty pageant, and inspiring deemed "fat/queer" girls to join her as well.

I loved Will's character and attitude. She was a mix of the ME I was back then, and the ME that I wish I was back then. Her insecurities were the things that I was anxious about on a daily basis, the only difference is that Willow decided to do something about it, and to prove to others wrong that someone's being fat is not a cause for them to not do the things they want to do. That just become someone is queer doesn't mean they can't win a fucking beauty pageant. That just become someone has a buckteeth doesn't mean they can't feel and be beautiful. This was a light-hearted book that talked about heavy issues and made them inspiring, enlightening, and so, so positive.

I used to be fat, and I used to be ashamed of it. Willow made me realize just how wrong I was for feeling so, for letting people's opinions weigh me down and decide how worthy I was. Fat is just an adjective, but that doesn't make up the whole of me.

Aside from the strong messages that was in this book, I was in awe of the female friendships and family dynamics that were portrayed here, and how much Will has grown so much as a character through these unexpected bonds. There were so many complex themes that played out between each and every one of them - the relationship between a fat daughter and a mother who was still stuck in her glorious days as a beauty pageant winner; between two best friends who come from two opposite sides of the spectrum; between a girl and a boy whose worlds are far apart; among four females who were shunned as outcasts because of how they looked. I loved each and every one of them, and how positive this book made them out be. Yes, there were drama, but it wasn't the exhausting kind where you'd want to haul the book into the trash can. They were the kind that tingled and pulled your heart a little bit, then warmed you all over.

Plus, there's a ship that unexpectedly made me want to clutch my heart. A romance rarely does that to me.

Dumplin' is something to behold. It speaks to every one of us who have felt insecure and frustrated with ourselves - by the way we look, or the way we act, or simply because by the way we simply ,all insecurities brought about by social pressure and norms. It speaks to that side of us who looked for reasons to feel confident in ourselves. This book gives that to you and lets you realize that at the end of the day, we're not made up by the labels society imposes upon us. I am me because of the experiences, values, and things that make up me; and you are you for the same reasons, too. Fat, or short, or queer, or straight, or thin, or healthy - who the fuck cares? Let's not make these things define us. Life is so much more than that.

This book makes you want to scream, "Yeah, I used to be fat! Maybe in the future I'll get fat again! But you know what? FUCK THAT SHIT CAUSE EITHER WAY I'M BEAUTIFUL!"
218 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Dumplin'.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

April 10, 2015 – Shelved
Started Reading
September 2, 2015 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-23 of 23 (23 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Morgan (new) - added it

Morgan E Wow! Your review blew me away! Well said and much love honey!


Dear Faye Thanks, Morgan!!! <3 I wish the me that was 3 years ago was more confident :( So much time wasted away hating myself and the way I looked. This book needs to be read by everyone out there!


Kelly (and the Book Boar) What an excellent review!


message 4: by TL (new) - added it

TL beautiful, gorgeous review hun *big hugs*


message 5: by raf (new) - added it

raf amazing review.thanks for sharing your story ^^


Val. This is an awesome review! I have struggled with my weight all my life and have always been the "fat kid". I totally get where you are coming from! Thanks for sharing a piece of your story!


Dear Faye Thank you so much, guys! And yes, Valerie, I so get what you mean. It's always the words that hurt so much. People may say to just ignore them, but it's never that easy :(


message 8: by Nuzaifa (new) - added it

Nuzaifa Love this review, Faye! *tackle hugs*


Dear Faye Thank you, Nuzaifa!! <3


message 10: by ˛T (new) - rated it 4 stars

˛T Brave of you to share your struggles with your weight, Faye. <3

And I agree on all points of your terrific review.


Binibining `E (of The Ugly Writers) "Once upon a time, I was fat"

Ugghh!! I so feel you. At that time hearing people say fat or big was so frustrating.. HAHA! Now I just don't care about them. HAHA. Great Review! Now I have to read this!


Dear Faye @Tash - thanks, Tash! I cried a bit while writing that because it was the first time I actually accepted and talked about it "publicly".

@Elaine - Right?! Every time an uncle or an aunt would say any of those terms, my mind would just shut down. I wouldn't think clearly anymore and I'd just hide somewhere >_<


message 13: by Brigid (last edited Sep 03, 2015 03:47PM) (new)

Brigid Hey we're the same height! Also as someone who used be fat, can we talk about how fucking uncomfortable those rashes are? LETS JUST GET BLUNT ABOUT THIS PEOPLE. I admire people who are confident with their bodies as are. But, I also think fat people can be heathy. That's one stereotype I would like to see change. I want to read this so badly.

I loooove your review Faye. SO MUCH. I love how you just open up with us. Those are my favorite reviews, btw. That picture of you is gorgeous. You are pretty in whatever life choices you decide. As someone who lost weight and had people snark at me for losing it, I'm not going to tell you the things those people threw at me. I am happy you are happy no matter how you look.

GIRL FIST BUMP.


Dear Faye GIRL FIST BUMP!!!! As someone who was on the heavier side, I knew I was healthy. I didn't have any health problems that were urgent or anything, but the fact that people kept emphasizing how BIG I was or FATTER I've gotten just made me hate it so much.

And thank you so much girl <3


La La I could not put this down last night!


message 16: by Izzy (new) - added it

Izzy Even though I haven't read the book your review is amazingly honest and you are very admirable for overcoming all those judgments and just being who you are.
Thanks <3


message 17: by Brigid (new)

Brigid Faye is a beautiful person. Everybody should follow her reviews imo.


message 18: by Theresa (new) - added it

Theresa That was such a beautiful review, thank you for sharing your experiences! I literally can't wait to read this book. Clearly you need to be writing professional (Aka. New Yorker) reviews!!!


Dear Faye @Izzy - thank you so much! <3 <3 I think the best way to represent yourself is to be honest and transparent, so here we are.

@Birigd - YOU MAKE ME BLUSH, YO!

@Theresa - Aw, thank you, dear! And I don't think I'm in the calibre of writing professional reviews yet haha


Sandy Salazar Loved your review!!! ❤️


message 21: by e (new) - rated it 2 stars

e While I agree with you for the most part, I just wish that e author's way of showing body positivity didn't involve putting others down like when Will refers to Callie as a "twiggy b*tch" because she was skinny and pretty, and how Will was okay with her body but put others' down


ella grace I love this review!! thanks for sharing your story :)


katherine Girl this is coming from a very honest 12 year old. Both the girls in that picture are so gorgous, and Im guessing one of them was you. So sis, if your one of them your so amazingly beautifull. And that review was amazing. ANd that was a long time ago. Cant imagine how beautifull you are now! <3


back to top