ŷ

Jessica's Reviews > I Am Number Four

I Am Number Four by Pittacus Lore
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3283298
's review

it was ok
bookshelves: 24-ebooks

The Mogadorian caught Number One in Malaysia,
Number Two in England,
And Number Three in Kenya.
I am Number Four.
I am next.


Catchy, isn’t it?



Unfortunately, the story itself isn’t quite as catchy. I was rather underwhelmed, to be honest.

The plot was ok but somehow it only managed to hold my attention for a period of about 10 minutes. After that, I found myself getting bored and my thoughts kept drifting off to random topics like "what’s for dinner" or "shit, I really need to iron that white blouse of mine".

While some parts of the story were quite entertaining, other parts were just so cliché that I almost gave up on the book entirely. I found myself slapping my forehead more often than is healthy and several times I surprised myself (and random people around me) by shouting out loud "Oh come on! Seriously?"

The scenario in a nutshell:

Alien hides out in small town, alien falls in love with human girl, alien goes to party with human girl, party escalates, house starts burning, alien saves human girl from flames (said alien is resistant to fire), alien tells human girl about true identity, human girl has no trouble at all accepting this, alien and human girl lie to police about rescue that should have been impossible, nasty reporter dude gets suspicious of alien and fishy rescue story, chapter ends with reporter dude yelling after alien "I will find the truth! I always do!"

Now tell me, is this worn out or is this worn out?

And this was just one of the scenes that made me want to bang my head on the table. There were more...

The characters also felt kind of flat to me. John aka #4 was nice enough (imagining him as Alex Pettyfer actually helped a lot), I also liked Sam, Henri and even Mark but just like John’s and Sarah’s relationship, the girl herself was dull and just plain boring. I didn’t feel the love, there was absolutely no tension, no tingling, no butterflies, nada, zip, zero, zilch. Just nothing at all that could have triggered any kind of emotion on my part.

I think the characters I liked best were Six (she really kicked ass) and the dog. o_O

Overall this was a solid two stars read for me, seeing as the story did entertain me at times (especially towards the end) and I made it through the book, but it was definitely nothing memorable for me.

I’m really looking forward to the movie, though. I think this might be one of those rare cases where the movie is actually better than the book. We’ll see...
97 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read I Am Number Four.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

October 15, 2010 – Shelved
February 20, 2011 – Started Reading
February 20, 2011 –
page 17
3.86%
February 20, 2011 –
page 40
9.09% "Hmm...not bad but also nothing special so far...The story reminds me very much of "Roswell High""
February 20, 2011 –
40.0%
February 21, 2011 –
60.0% "I think I'm bored. :-/"
February 22, 2011 –
100.0%
February 22, 2011 – Shelved as: 24-ebooks
February 22, 2011 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-28 of 28 (28 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Sense361 (new) - added it

Sense361 Hi. Waiting for your review on this one. I started but was put off by the man perspective. Now I wander if I should return to the book.


Jessica I know what you mean, I tend to prefer female POVs, too. What I like even better, though, is when I get the male and the female POV.

So far I think it’s quite entertaining, but right before this one I read Neal Shusterman’s "Unwind" and "I am #4" pales in comparison. :-/

Anyways, I'll let you know soon! :) I should be done by tomorrow.


message 3: by Sense361 (new) - added it

Sense361 Thank you. I will read Spy glass, while waiting for your verdict:)


Michele (Reading Lark/CanadianTwiMom) I think you'll like the movie much better Jessica. Although I do understand the book being a bit underwhelming. I felt the same about the romance factor and the relationship between John & Sarah. The action sequences (fight scenes) and special effects were really well done! No. Six was also really cool in the movie!


message 5: by Kim (new)

Kim Lubs the review. Still not reading this piece of you-know-what.


Jessica @Michele: I think so, too, and it has Alex, after all, so I'm pretty sure I'll like it ;-)

@Kim: Thanks babe :) That's the right decision. I don't think you would like this.


message 7: by Kim (new)

Kim I would trash it.


Jessica Probably ^^


Kristy I actually enjoyed this one, but all of your points are spot on... I hardley ever read this type of book though, so I'm not too picky! Looking foward to the movie as well :)


Jessica I don't know, lately I feel like the more I read, the pickier I get. I'd rather go back to enjoying nearly everything I read ;)


Kristy I am going through that too... you just have more to compare the books to I guess!!
It's been about a month (I think) since I read this one... and now I can't even remember why I liked it?? That's probably not a good sign, huh?!?!?


Jessica Yeah, that's the thing. Stuff that didn't bother me in the past is bothering me now, because I've read so many great books and a lot of the stuff I'm reading now just can't compete with those.

Hehe, probably not. ^^


~Tina~ Aww, sorry this one didn't make it babe.


Kristy Ditto and agreed!


Jessica Thanks Tina! :) Well, like you said, you can't love them all :)


message 16: by Sense361 (new) - added it

Sense361 God, I became green just reading the summery. I'll let the book go with no regrets whasoever. Thank you!


Arlene Sorry you didn't care for this one. :( enjoy the movie!!


Michele (Reading Lark/CanadianTwiMom) Jessica... oh yes... Alex is why I read the book!! And I also agree that the more you read... the more pickier we get! Certain books set the bar really high. :)


message 20: by Nomes (new)

Nomes you made it to the end! wahoo!

loved your review!


Jessica Thank you, Nomes :)


message 22: by Nomes (new)

Nomes and i agree ~ i think the movie will be way better than the book ~ the writing was terribly clunky and the characters so dull but it was easy to imagine it having some life pumped into it for the big screen.

I agree it sounds catchy ~ i was hooked on the tag-line/premise thing.


message 23: by Lexi (new) - rated it 3 stars

Lexi I see that you, like many other reviewers, found this novel to be cliché and worn out. I like how you put your reaction while reading, "...several times I surprised myself by shouting out loud 'oh com on! Seriously?'" It sups up how I felt while reading about the dull and predictable relationships between the characters. For example, John and Sarah's relationship was boring; there was no tension, butterflies or any sort of emotion. I didn't make me, the reader, feel any emotion whatsoever. Although the alien theme was quite compelling, the author was unable to develop his idea in to a quality novel.


message 24: by Colton (new)

Colton Burroughs That picture sums up what i thought of your opinion you fucky fuck.


Jaroslav Tuček > I think the characters I liked best were Six

Funny, I thought Six was the biggest retard of them all. Like she's looking for Four so they can start fighting back, has good knowledge of the Mogadorians, even knows they have an outpost 3 miles away...

By the logic of the silly charm, she is invincible until 4 and 5 are taken care of. She can walk right over any Mogadorian she finds. Does she hunt them down? Does she at least wipe out their outpost? Of course not. She has to find 4 and break the charm so that they all have to be on the run again...


message 26: by Someone (new)

Someone Found one braindead idiot/troll who decides to rage. If the troll sees this, trolling others only makes you dumber.


message 27: by Someone (new)

Someone For a review criticizing the book, there are almost no idiots.


message 28: by Husna (new) - rated it 1 star

Husna I agree. If I could give it anything less than one star I would have


back to top