ŷ

Seemita's Reviews > The Waste Land and Other Poems

The Waste Land and Other Poems by T.S. Eliot
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
34622220
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: poetry, nobel-laureates

Thomas Stearns Eliot. A lot is hidden between those three words. A whole world perhaps. A depth measured by many oceans, a mystery viewed from bewitching lenses, a song marrying numerous notes, a candle thriving on inexhaustible wax.

During his writing season, that spanned over three decades, T S Eliot penned many evocative and luscious poems, with his pen always leaving a signature cryptic mark over his dotted sheets. Often a source of delusion to an enthusiastic poetic heart, his labyrinthine lyricism was like a lashing downpour on a parched heartland: one surrendered to the torrent at the risk of bearing undecipherable strokes on one’s soul. I belong to this clan.

In this volume, his celebrated and most popular poems rub shoulders with their relatively lesser known but still dense cousins. And while my soul may curse my mind for being picky about Eliot’s poems, I might go asunder for a while and share with you three gems, whose themes, narratives, cadence and wholeness can be adorned by adjectives from the ‘superlative� family alone.

THE WASTE LAND

In his most celebrated poem, his thoughts, meandering through five reverberating alleys of melancholy and despair, purport to create an image that oscillates between our meretricious values and late realizations. It begins with The Burial of the Dead where a collage of pictures bearing subdued trees, stony lands, dried showers and insipid sun leaves a young girl with a heavy heart who is further introduced to the throbbing futility of it all.
And I will show you something different from either
Your shadow at morning striding behind you
Or your shadow at evening rising to meet you;
I will show you fear in a handful of dust.
Leading us to the next alleys, Eliot plays A Game of Chess, issues A Fire Sermon, condemns us to a Death by Water and lets us hear What The Thunder Said. All through this trail, we are trembling; more with remorse or excitement, is something we can’t guess without ambiguity. Touching the themes of vengeance, repentance, nostalgia, penance and decay, he halts at ”Datta, Dayadhvan and Damyata� as the final rousing call. This mantra in Sanskrit translates to “Give, Sacrifice and Control� respectively. This trinity, capable of resurrecting our being in a more dignified and buoyant fabric, is left for the reader to comprehend and validate.
Datta: what have we given?
My friend, blood shaking my heart
The awful daring of a moment’s surrender
Which an age of prudence can never retract
By this, and this only, we have existed
Which is not to be found in our obituaries
Or in memories draped by the beneficent spider
Or under seals broken by the lean solicitor
In our empty rooms
------------

GERONTION
Thou hast nor youth nor age
But as it were an after dinner sleep
Dreaming of both.
Thus starts this splendid poem, which is a mighty paean to a person’s journey from youth to mellow. And as always detected by a fatigued eye, this journey is laden with discolored beliefs and stung steps.
After such knowledge, what forgiveness? Think now
History has many cunning passages, contrived corridors
And issues, deceives with whispering ambitions,
Guides us by vanities. Think now
She gives when our attention is distracted
And what she gives, gives with such supple confusions
That the giving famishes the craving. Gives too late
What’s not believed in, or is still believed,
In memory only, reconsidered passion.
-----------

ASH WEDNESDAY

We are always in a vicious circle of creation and destruction. This engaging activity provides momentum to our lives and reinforces our core strength.
I rejoice that things are as they are and
I renounce the blessed face
And renounce the voice
Because I cannot hope to turn again
Consequently I rejoice, having to construct something
Upon which to rejoice.
A pity, then, that we can’t always control this rigmarole. What if, dotting the circle, we reach a point from where a deviation threatens to derail our movement, propelling our faith engine to go kaput? The tumultuous fall, then becomes impossible to confine in words, for it pervades everything: our skin, our bones, our heart. Should we be foolish enough to expect a hand to pull us out of this ditch, at this hour, when all we have done till now, in our sturdy capacity, is overlook meek yet expectant eyes? Is hope of such benevolence, an absurdity? Well, there is someone, indeed, to whom we can always look upto.
Will the veiled sister pray
For children at the gate
Who will not go away and cannot pray:
Pray for those who chose and oppose.
----------

"Shantih Shantih Shantih - The Peace that passeth understanding."

These poems are like pearls; the metaphorical oyster may pose a formidable guard but caress it with patience and stimulate it aloud and it will open up to a mesmerizing world of mellifluous prose and inspiring gist.
40 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Waste Land and Other Poems.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

June 3, 2015 – Started Reading
June 5, 2015 – Shelved
June 5, 2015 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-25 of 25 (25 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Kalliope (new)

Kalliope Seemita, I am reading this soon... Please let me come back to this later....


Seemita Kalliope wrote: "Seemita, I am reading this soon... Please let me come back to this later...."

Sure, Kall! :)


message 3: by Sue (new) - rated it 4 stars

Sue Simply magnificent review. I have been re-reading this slowly this year and am enjoying the voyage. What I am finding is that it takes time and attention...no rushing through Eliot.


message 4: by Praj (new)

Praj Seemi, this is unquestionably a super review. I like how your reviewing style is attuned to the genre you read. Thanks.


message 5: by Stephen (new)

Stephen P(who no longer can participate due to illness) I never read Elliot. This Seemita is an exquisite introduction. Your turns of phrase are such a pleasure to read and each furthers the point and meaning you are getting across. Absolutely amazing!


Seemita Sue wrote: "Simply magnificent review. I have been re-reading this slowly this year and am enjoying the voyage. What I am finding is that it takes time and attention...no rushing through Eliot."

Thank you, Sue. Indeed, Eliot needs us to close the doors, open the windows, take a cup of coffee and enjoy a date with one's self. One gotta sip both, the coffee and the poetry, in the same way: slowly. I hope your reunion with him is turning out great :)


Seemita Praj wrote: "Seemi, this is unquestionably a super review. I like how your reviewing style is attuned to the genre you read. Thanks."

Much thanks, Praj! About the reviewing style, ah.. I try! Glad I had you appreciating it :)


Seemita Stephen wrote: "I never read Elliot. This Seemita is an exquisite introduction. Your turns of phrase are such a pleasure to read and each furthers the point and meaning you are getting across. Absolutely amazing!"

I read Eliot for the first time, Stephen. And had to read the poems over and over again. He isn't an easy weather; one has to observe keenly to gauge the clouded stars, the direction of his windy thought and his sunny demeanor through a storm of overlapping metaphorical skies. I wish you give him a try someday; I am sure you will like his companionship!

Thanks for your encouraging comment, Stephen! Starts my day good :)


Samadrita I have always resented Eliot because reading him is like an academic exercise. One needs to be armed with mountains of annotations to understand. But your review simplified his themes so masterfully. Lovely writing, Seemita.


Seemita Samadrita wrote: "I have always resented Eliot because reading him is like an academic exercise. One needs to be armed with mountains of annotations to understand. But your review simplified his themes so masterfull..."

He is fairly cryptic, I have to second. I had my share of trouble getting inducted into his world. But a little perseverance pays handsomely here. I see your rating and let slip a smile :)

Thanks for your wonderful comment, Samadrita! A pleasure :)


message 11: by Dolors (new)

Dolors "Consequently I rejoice, having to construct something
Upon which to rejoice."

Isn't there a bit of the Japanese "wabi-sabi" doctrine there? Even a touch of The Tao philosophy? Beauty implies imperfection and transience, and what T.S. Elliot does with his poems is to transform that vicious circle of creation and destruction into a virtuous one, accepting the bleakness of future as part of something bigger. Your delightful commentary interwoven with the poet's verses is a treat to behold Seemita, and once again you inspire me to grab my copy of T.S. Elliot's collection of poems from my shelves and submerge into this expansive world where poetry conquers it all.


Seemita Dolors wrote: ""Consequently I rejoice, having to construct something
Upon which to rejoice."
Isn't there a bit of the Japanese "wabi-sabi" doctrine there? Even a touch of The Tao philosophy? Beauty implies imper..."


Ah Dolors! You got me thinking! This is my first ever exposure to Eliot's thoughts and it would be premature for me to draw a generic frame around his musings. So what I remark is strictly keeping this book in view. One can detect seams from the Wabi-Sabi doctrine in some of the poems for sure. In the transience and barrenness witnessed in the 'The Waste Land' and in the austere blanket embracing 'Gerontion', the chief principles of the philosophy come alive. But I was unable to feel much vibrations of the Tao way of life in this reading. But going by the enigmatic juxtaposition of words and their hidden meanings so rampant in Eliot's works, I may not surprised if I stumbled upon something new, a philosophy or a secret, if lingered on it for long! :) In fact, elements of Hindu philosophies find a direct mention in 'The Waste Land' and hence, you may just be on the right path!

For always coming up with a unique observation and warmth-filled words, thank you dearie :))


message 13: by Deea (new)

Deea Poetry is not my thing. I can read it and sometimes I really like what I read, but I am not craving to read it like with prose. Your review about this world created by Eliott in his poems is so wonderfully written that I however crave to read everything you write.

"A pity, then, that we can’t always control this rigmarole. What if, dotting the circle, we reach a point from where a deviation threatens to derail our movement, propelling our faith engine to go kaput? The tumultuous fall, then becomes impossible to confine in words, for it pervades everything: our skin, our bones, our heart..." This fragment is simply mindblowing. I am so glad I discovered you here. Reading what you write is so mentally enriching that I feel unable to confine its attrobutes in words.


Seemita Deea wrote: "Poetry is not my thing. I can read it and sometimes I really like what I read, but I am not craving to read it like with prose. Your review about this world created by Eliott in his poems is so wo..."

You are too kind, Deea. And such kindness is the fruit of a beautiful heart; one that is replete with goodness, hope and sunshine with an enviable art to spread it to every other heart it touches. I am no exception and so, I want you to know that I am equally glad to have your wondrous companionship. Although I rue the geographical distance occasionally, I am thankful for the emotional proximity we nurture.

Thanks a bunch for your heartfelt comment, Deea. Eliot's poetry is a bit like coconut (pardon my puerile simile); it will take time to get to the cream but once you do, it becomes a sumptuous meal for the mind and soul. Give him the gift of your discerning eye someday :)


message 15: by Jibran (new)

Jibran A richly poetic tribute to a writer who deserves it so. Loved the way you bring out the may themes and motifs of T.S. Eliot in your review with characteristic deftness and wit - a thing of beauty which is a pleasure to behold!


message 16: by Kim (new)

Kim Excellent review, Seemita. I enjoyed Eliot's poetry when I was at school and university. However, I have more trouble with him these days because of his anti-Semitism, something that has been written about and discussed more widely in recent years.


Seemita Jibran wrote: "A richly poetic tribute to a writer who deserves it so. Loved the way you bring out the may themes and motifs of T.S. Eliot in your review with characteristic deftness and wit - a thing of beauty w..."

Eliot is the owner of many brushes and his dexterity propels him to use them all at the same time! So, what we get is a collage of artistic musings, often a tad intimidating but mostly, a carnival for the sensory being. Yes, he has a reputation that is truly deserving. Thanks Jibran :)


Seemita Kim wrote: "Excellent review, Seemita. I enjoyed Eliot's poetry when I was at school and university. However, I have more trouble with him these days because of his anti-Semitism, something that has been writt..."

Thank you, Kim. I cannot overlook the controversy that dogged Eliot's alleged antisemitism. But I am not in a position to assert without ambiguity as to where did Eliot's loyalties exactly lie. There is a mention of Jews in 'Gerontion' which I didn't catch in my first reading. Only in the second reading, having acquainted myself with a bit of his life and this disputed angle of his literary takes, did I notice a verse that just might be a simmering point of contention. I have to read a little more of him to make an accurate assertion. On purely poetic rendition though, he scored for me.


message 19: by Lynne (new)

Lynne King An excellent review Seemita.


Seemita Lynne wrote: "An excellent review Seemita."

Thank you, Lynne! :)


message 21: by flo (new) - added it

flo There is not a review where you don't leave me thinking, Seemita. Such beautiful and evocative lines, portraying a T.S. Eliot whose work reflects on almost every aspect of human nature. I've been wanting to read this book for a long time; but in the sea of books where I usually find myself, there is always something else before, and I just can't find the time. Shame on me! I must have time for this mesmerizing poetry that you kindly shared with us.


Seemita Florencia wrote: "There is not a review where you don't leave me thinking, Seemita. Such beautiful and evocative lines, portraying a T.S. Eliot whose work reflects on almost every aspect of human nature. I've been w..."

You won't believe it, Florencia but I had thought of you after penning down this review; that how much meaning your discerning and enthusiastic poetic eyes may draw from Eliot's artistry. I am glad I found you applauding Eliot's diverse canvas and his equally compelling verses. And I so hope you get to him soon, for that would be a dazzling combination of a creator and his reader!

For being here with your sparkling comment, thank you dearie :)


message 23: by Himanshu (new)

Himanshu What a review, Seemita! I haven't gotten introduced to Eliot yet simply for the fact that I think he is way out of my league. Your review shows a new light to this perception. Great piece of writing!


Seemita Himanshu wrote: "What a review, Seemita! I haven't gotten introduced to Eliot yet simply for the fact that I think he is way out of my league. Your review shows a new light to this perception. Great piece of writing!"

Out of your league? Going by the adroitness you display in catching and comprehending the written and unwritten words of several masterpieces, I am sure, wandering into Eliot's land and spotting and living his creations would be quite your thing, Himanshu! I would be glad to see you come up with some butterflies I missed :)

Thanks for the warmth of your lovely words, as always.


Seemita Marita wrote: "A beautiful review, Seemita!"

Thanks for reading and leaving your encouraging comment, Marita :)


back to top