ŷ

Glenn Russell's Reviews > The Man in the High Castle

The Man in the High Castle by Philip K. Dick
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
23385697
's review

it was amazing



Fans of Philip K. Dick and science fiction might be underwhelmed by The Man in the High Castle since, other than passing mention of cross continental rocket ship travel and a German exploration of Mars, there really isn’t any science fiction or signature PKD craziness or large-scale action; rather, Dick’s 1962 book is alternative history, the aftermath in the United States after Germany and Japan win World War II and a novel of ideas.

There are a number of crisscrossing plots, colorful main characters, applications of the ancient Chinese I Ching; however, by my reading, the heartbeat of the novel is the author’s historical, political, social commentary, reflections on cross-cultural miscommunication and observations on racial and ethnic prejudice � all laced with a healthy dose of black humor.

Ah, black humor, as in this snatch of dialogue when judo instructor Juliana Frink talks with a fellow American, Joe the truck drive in a Colorado small-town: ““Did you hear the Bob Hope show the other night?� she called. “He told this really funny joke, the one where this German major is interviewing some Martians. The Martians can’t provide racial documentation about their grandparents being Aryan, you know. So the German major reports back to Berlin that Mars is populated by Jews.”� Meanwhile, the German Reichs Consul in San Francisco, Freiherr Hugo Reiss, doesn’t fine Bob Hope one bit funny; in point of fact, he thinks the Aryan super-race might indeed find Jews on Mars since those loathsome Jewish vermin are everywhere else.

PKD 1960s-style self-referential postmodern metafiction, anyone? Novel within a novel: The Grasshopper Lies Heavy by Hawthorne Abendsen is about what the present day world would look like if Germany and Japan lost the war. Abendsen’s novel is all the rage, an honest-to-goodness American literary fad (the book is banned back in Germany and in lands such as the Eastern United States controlled by Germany).

Curiously, rumors have it the author of the outrageous Grasshopper bestseller is a paranoid living in isolation on a Wyoming mountain in a fortress-like house surrounded by barbed wire and heavy artillery, calling himself The Man in the High Castle. Perhaps the author’s armed, isolated fortress isn’t such a bad idea since Freiherr Hugo Reiss has a predictable Nazi reaction when reading the book: “Maybe this Abendsen is a Jew. They’re still at it trying to poison us. . . . Actual name probably Abendstein. . . . If Abendstein should be found dangling from the ceiling some fine morning, it would be a sobering notice to anyone who might be influenced by this book. We would have had the last word. Written the postscript.�

And such a paranoid racist mindset is hardly confined to the German Nazis. Here are the thoughts of Robert Childan, a good old American boy from San Francisco, after his less than satisfying business dealings with someone who is Jewish: “We live in a society of law and order, where Jews can’t pull their subtleties on the innocent. We’re protected. I don’t know why I didn’t recognize the racial characteristics when I saw him. Evidently I’m easily deceived. . . . Without law, I’d be at their mercy. He could have convinced me of anything. It’s a form of hypnosis. They can control an entire society.�

With its scathing satire on culture and society and novel within a novel, in many ways The Man in the High Castle reminded me more of JR by William Gaddis than PKD’s other novels. Similar to Gaddis, all the men and women are more than happy to spout their opinions and observations about the arts and books and literature; and more than happy to make strident pronouncements about culture, history and race, not only on the Jews but, among others, Blacks, Italians, Japanese, Germans, Swedes, White Americans, Puerto Ricans, Irish. Turns out, the author of The Grasshopper Lies Heavy claims his nightmarish novel is about the state of the world as it currently exists. Perhaps PKD is telling us indirectly he is making a similar claim in his The Man in the High Castle.

265 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Man in the High Castle.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
June 7, 2015 – Shelved

Comments Showing 1-21 of 21 (21 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Donna (new)

Donna Another epic review Glenn.


Glenn Russell D. wrote: "Another epic review Glenn."

Thanks so much, D! Really appreciate you taking time to read.


Hanneke Sounds pretty far off in space sort of book, Glenn!


Glenn Russell Hanneke wrote: "Sounds pretty far off in space sort of book, Glenn!"

Well, it isn't Charles Dickens but for Philip K. Dick it is a straight-forward, easy-to-follow narrative, although there are several crisscrossing plots. Much more tame than the craziness of many of his other novels with their mutants, life forms from other planets, hallucinogenic drugs, people inside the bodies of other people, etc. etc.


Hanneke Sounds like I would enjoy that book!


Rick Patterson It's a classic. I also strongly recommend it. It does have the PKD motif of "Is this the real world or not?" happening.


message 7: by Glenn (last edited Jun 07, 2015 07:02PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Glenn Russell Rick wrote: "It's a classic. I also strongly recommend it. It does have the PKD motif of "Is this the real world or not?" happening."

Thanks, Rick. I plan on rereading with that question in mind.

I should post a few other PKD reviews over the summer. I'm looking forward to his books - my first real plunge with sci fi by any author.


message 8: by M. (new)

M. Sarki I still haven't read the first PKD book, but I own a couple. I feel as if I am still preparing my mind for him. Thanks for the very fine review. I might cheat first and watch the amazon prime film with the same title.


Glenn Russell M. wrote: "I still haven't read the first PKD book, but I own a couple. I feel as if I am still preparing my mind for him. Thanks for the very fine review. I might cheat first and watch the amazon prime film ..."

I've never been a big sci fi fan. I enjoy the ideas in PKD as well as his clear writing style.


Yasin Spot on analysis about the ending. Just heard they made a television show and I wonder how similar it will be.


Glenn Russell Yasin wrote: "Spot on analysis about the ending. Just heard they made a television show and I wonder how similar it will be."

Thanks, Yasin. Wow, I wonder how much of PKD will be retained. I usually do not watch tv but I wouldn't mind checking this out. Do you know the title of that TV show?


Yasin It has the same title, "The Man in the High Castle". It should be coming out on Amazon's streaming service soon with a few changes.


Glenn Russell Yasin wrote: "It has the same title, "The Man in the High Castle". It should be coming out on Amazon's streaming service soon with a few changes."

Thanks!


Thomas Salerno Great review! I really enjoyed Man In the High Castle. It is, so far, the only PKD book I've read, but I definitely plan on reading more of his novels and stories.


Glenn Russell Thomas wrote: "Great review! I really enjoyed Man In the High Castle. It is, so far, the only PKD book I've read, but I definitely plan on reading more of his novels and stories."

Thanks, Thomas! Hope you really enjoy some other PKD novels. Take a look at VALIS - my favorite of his. I wrote a review you might want to check out.


message 16: by Sylvie (new)

Sylvie Well, Glenn, had I not read the book, I would have been really attracted to it by your review. You make such a glowing case for it. Maybe you picked the best bits, or brought out the satire at its most revealing, or maybe you saw something that eluded me!


Glenn Russell Sylvie wrote: "Well, Glenn, had I not read the book, I would have been really attracted to it by your review. You make such a glowing case for it. Maybe you picked the best bits, or brought out the satire at its ..."

Thanks, Sylvie. If you like PKD's style and are after an alternate history rather than straight sci fi, this is your book!


message 18: by William (last edited Sep 20, 2018 03:33AM) (new) - added it

William Thank you for the review, Glenn. Don't know how I missed this before.

Did you ever check out the Amazon tv series?


message 19: by Glenn (last edited Sep 20, 2018 09:18AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Glenn Russell William wrote: "Thank you for the review, Glenn. Don't know how I missed this before.

Did you ever check out the Amazon tv series?"


Thanks, William. This certainly counts as one of PKD's most philosophical novels.

I recall seeing a preview for the series on Amazon - looked quite good, although I have not seen the actual episodes myself.


message 20: by Maricarmen (new) - added it

Maricarmen Estrada M Fantastic review!


Glenn Russell Maricarmen wrote: "Fantastic review!"

Thanks so much!! I wrote this review back when I first encountered PKD and felt my mind expanding with every chapter.


back to top