Bianca's Reviews > Giovanni’s Room
Giovanni’s Room
by
by

A few months ago, I was blown away by the documentary I Am Not Your Negro, which featured James Baldwin. I only heard of Baldwin a few years prior, via other GR friends' reviews of his books. I had his books on my TBR list, but they were there with six hundred other books ...
Anyway, that documentary pushed me to seek some of his books.
It didn't occur to me when watching the documentary that Baldwin was gay. The poor man, being black and gay, during a very reprehensible period in US history. Not only he had to fight against the white people, against the system because of his race, he had to hide and fight his own community's homophobia. No wonder he escaped to France for a while.
Anyway, I had to remind myself that Giovanni's Room is not autobiographical, although it must have drawn inspiration from his personal experiences. I plan to read a bit more about Balwin and this novel.
As I was reading Giovanni's Room I had to remind myself several times that the main character, David, an American in Paris, was a white man. David is in the closet and is ashamed by his one time encounter with a male friend. As the only child of a nice man, he feels it's his duty to be the "right" way. It's not only that, it's the 1950s and earlier, homosexuality is illegal. Paris though is more relaxed. While the cat was away, in this case, Hetta, David's fiancee, he has a dalliance with Giovanni, a beautiful and passionate Italian bartender, whom he met in a gay bar. The two have a passionate affair for a little while, even sharing Giovanni's small room. Giovanni's small, cluttered, dirty room is a metaphor of sorts for David's complex feelings, especially when he knows the time is approaching when he has to make a decision - to have a respectable life that includes a wife and kids or to give in to his preferences?
It's important to remember that this was published in 1959. That's quite a feat in itself. The fact that it was written by a black man, way before the Civil movement, makes this novel even more significant.
Baldwin's writing is beautifully lyrical and packaged tightly. You can sense the doubt and dread, the fear, the self-loathing.
None of the male characters is likeable, that includes David himself.
This is a very sad novel, albeit one beautifully written.
Anyway, that documentary pushed me to seek some of his books.
It didn't occur to me when watching the documentary that Baldwin was gay. The poor man, being black and gay, during a very reprehensible period in US history. Not only he had to fight against the white people, against the system because of his race, he had to hide and fight his own community's homophobia. No wonder he escaped to France for a while.
Anyway, I had to remind myself that Giovanni's Room is not autobiographical, although it must have drawn inspiration from his personal experiences. I plan to read a bit more about Balwin and this novel.
As I was reading Giovanni's Room I had to remind myself several times that the main character, David, an American in Paris, was a white man. David is in the closet and is ashamed by his one time encounter with a male friend. As the only child of a nice man, he feels it's his duty to be the "right" way. It's not only that, it's the 1950s and earlier, homosexuality is illegal. Paris though is more relaxed. While the cat was away, in this case, Hetta, David's fiancee, he has a dalliance with Giovanni, a beautiful and passionate Italian bartender, whom he met in a gay bar. The two have a passionate affair for a little while, even sharing Giovanni's small room. Giovanni's small, cluttered, dirty room is a metaphor of sorts for David's complex feelings, especially when he knows the time is approaching when he has to make a decision - to have a respectable life that includes a wife and kids or to give in to his preferences?
It's important to remember that this was published in 1959. That's quite a feat in itself. The fact that it was written by a black man, way before the Civil movement, makes this novel even more significant.
Baldwin's writing is beautifully lyrical and packaged tightly. You can sense the doubt and dread, the fear, the self-loathing.
None of the male characters is likeable, that includes David himself.
This is a very sad novel, albeit one beautifully written.
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
Giovanni’s Room.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
June 20, 2015
– Shelved as:
to-read
June 20, 2015
– Shelved
February 28, 2018
–
Started Reading
March 3, 2018
– Shelved as:
lgbtiq
March 3, 2018
– Shelved as:
literary-fiction
March 3, 2018
– Shelved as:
male-author
March 3, 2018
– Shelved as:
us-author
March 3, 2018
–
Finished Reading
August 23, 2018
– Shelved as:
2018
Comments Showing 1-46 of 46 (46 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Robin
(last edited Mar 03, 2018 05:35AM)
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Mar 03, 2018 05:35AM

reply
|
flag

Robin, watch the documentary. I confess I fell a little bit in love with Baldwin. There are some YouTube videos of some of his speeches. I had goosebumps.




I am surprised to discover how relatively unknown he is even to Americas. I'm sure the documentary will reignite people's interest in him and his writing. I've been raving about the doco to everyone. Now I can do that about this novel as well. :-)

It's a tremendous little book. I wholeheartedly recommend the documentary.

Thanks, Cheri. I'm looking forward to hearing your thoughts on it.

Thanks, Glenn. It's a powerful little book. Given his race and poverty, it's even more incredulous to discover he was not univerity educated. Obviously, he was gifted. I'm looking forward to reading more by him.

Angela M wrote: "Fabulous review, Bianca."
Thanks, Tammy and Angela.

Thanks, Karen. I hope you enjoy it.

Thanks, Deanna. I'm glad I finally got to read Baldwin. He was one of a kind.

Thanks, Wen. This is darker than Invisible Furies, but it's so worth reading. It's an important book, considering when it was written.


Some of the youtube interviews appear in the documentary, but it's much more than that. It's on SBS on demand.

Superb review, Bianca!

Superb review, Bianca!"
Thanks, Kevin. I'll have to read a bit more about it, indeed, it's incredible it got published in an era where there was so much censorship and black people were treated so badly.

Thanks, Katie. It's well worth it.

Thank you so much. It's a very well written little book.
outstanding review, bianca! very nice indeed.

Thanks, Debbie. I hope you'll enjoy it.

Thanks, Nat. I'm certainly happy to have read it.


Thank you, Marialyce. I only heard of him a year or two ago via other people's reviews of his books. Seeing I'm Not Your Negro propelled me to finally read one of his books. I'm hoping to read more, as I enjoyed his writing. I had no idea you studied him in school (was is in a more progressive State?)


Haha ... it's interesting how few of us appreciate the classics or other texts when we're pushed to read them in school. I was a voracious reader but I rarely read what was expected in class.

It sure was - I'm glad you enjoyed it.