Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Michael's Reviews > Y: The Last Man, Vol. 1: Unmanned

Y by Brian K. Vaughan
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
1036930
's review

liked it
bookshelves: graphic-novels, most-popular-reviews

In typical comic book male-centric fashion, this series wonders what life would be like if all men died spontaneously...except for one.

I suppose if we're trying to put ourselves in the head of an early-nineties comic book reading teen, this might feel innovative. Unfortunately, I find that innovative in the world of comics is pretty much Iron Age for the rest of literature. How does Vaughan manage to make a series with gender issues at its center so bizarrely sexist?

Example: In a world where all men are dead except for one, and the death of that one man will mean the end of humanity, VIOLENT CULTS OF FEMINISTS SPRING UP TO TRY AND HUNT DOWN MEN AND MALE SYMPATHIZERS. What is the motive here? There sure isn't one written into the plot, other than the one speech about social inequality between the sexes--and how the only way to escape this inequality is to KILL ALL MEN.

Characterwise, I was exceptionally not impressed. Even the main character has vague motivations. As for the women, pretty much none of them function as anything but placeholders: the token love interest, the sister who has gone astray, the protective mother. IN A WORLD WHERE ONLY ONE MAN SURVIVED...apparently the world still revolves around that man.

And here's where the cultural rant starts...

This is a symptom of thinking that is still prevalent in most of popular culture, although not to as great an extent in literature. F'rinstance, lets talk about movies: movies are a great medium for making political statements. Statements about social injustices, such as the way that women are objectified, sexualized, expected to live up to some bleached, shaved, makeup-smeared, surgically modified yet waifishly thin ideal that has been developed over centuries of patriarchal society...and how this objectification upon women is psychologically damaging--to men.

description

This poor guy above has been so mentally warped by Hollywood and advertising that he's incapable of developing a physical attraction to any of the normal girls he knows in real life. Let's take a moment to pitty him.



Okay, we done? Good. Fortunately, a blonde porn star moves in next door, and immediately falls for him, even though he's intensely dorky, because, you know, it's what's on the inside that counts. But, I'm not just cherry-picking films here. I could point to this one:

description

Another example of an attractive woman with a *cough cough* career who ends up with a loser whose only redeeming trait is that he's willing to "raise" the baby...if sleazy frat boys without jobs can be said to raise babies.

But surely this is a phenomenon in teen comedies?

Well, look at "romances."

description

Here's a fairly recent romantic comedy where a successful, relatively well-balanced woman who is portrayed as HORRIBLY DESPARATE for being interested in a neighbor....meanwhile, the character played by Gerard Butler mudwrestles with models on television, and has no interest in anything but one-night stands, yet this is understandable because of his childhood. This is a ROMANCE.

End rant.

Okay, BUT, regardless of how inadequately this comic deals with gender issues, it at least TRIES to grapple with them, and it does a better job than any of the movies mentioned above. Perhaps by the end of the series, the author's portrayals of gender issues will become more interesting and sophisticated. This was an entertaining comic, and I plan on continuing it for at least a little longer...but I'll admit that I'm highly confused by the acclaim it has gotten.
325 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Y.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
November 28, 2010 – Shelved
November 28, 2010 – Shelved as: graphic-novels
June 30, 2014 – Shelved as: most-popular-reviews

Comments Showing 1-50 of 96 (96 new)


Joel i have a female nerd friend who loves this series and i have no idea why. the second volume is all about the daughters of amazon and is even worse. i kind of hated it.


The Crimson Fucker i hated this series!!! but not for the same reasons y'all do... i ain't care about the sexism and all that crap! all i care is that i thought this book was going to be full with lesbian doing the nasty! but no!!! 0 girl on girl action!! and in the one book where is supposed to go down... they cut it out!!! garbage! pure garbage!!! one more case of false advertisement to go along with The Never Ending Story and that book that claims there are no cats in it!!


Michael IKNOWRIGHT? And NOBODY gets their arms cut off in A Farewell to Arms! And in Of Mice and Men, not one goddamned mouse!


The Crimson Fucker ha! you just gave me an idea for a new shelf!


Joel there are no arrows in Time's Arrow. bite me, amis.


message 6: by [deleted user] (new)

Joel wrote: "i have a female nerd friend who loves this series and i have no idea why. the second volume is all about the daughters of amazon and is even worse. i kind of hated it."

I did not read book two, because of my irritation with this one, but my husband did. Big mistake.

The Amazons were stupid for many reasons, but the one that really killed me is that they cut off the wrong breast. It's the right, not the left. Does no one have a sense of craft anymore? Bah. Off my lawn.


Michael What's funny is, I've talked to a grand total of three people who had read this, and ALL of them noticed the breast mistake. Talk about a big oops...I wonder how many thousands of letters the author has gotten correcting him on the breast thing.

The Amazons just rubbed me the wrong way all over, like a perverse uncle in a dark movie theater. The second volume came in at the library today, so I'll be reading it soon...if the amazons are even more prevalent, he might be getting a one or two-star rating. I feel like my three was on the border with two.


message 8: by Eh?Eh! (new)

Eh?Eh! Was the breast on a designated side or didn't it depend on how she shot her arrows, to remove an obstruction from drawing the bow?


Michael Well, Ceridwen might know better than I, but I believe it was always on the one side BECAUSE it removed an obstruction from shooting a bow and throwing javalins. But, I don't know what the southpaw Amazons did.


Michael Ah, Elizabeth beat me to the punch...


message 11: by Paul (new)

Paul Bryant Great rant, more please.


Michael Oh, I have much more to rant about...


message 13: by JD (new)

JD Waggy I love that you're almost more feminist than I am, even though several of my friends lovingly group me with the occasional low-level feminazi. Keep it up, Michael!


message 14: by mark (new)

mark monday except Knocked Up was awesome. fat loser fucks rock! Y: Last Man was equally awesome. vaughan is great! Ex Machina especially.


Michael I enjoyed Knocked Up, too, and it was only looking back that I had some issues with it. I'm still undecided about how awesome Y is, but I'm gonna keep going, and we'll see....I'm pretty new to graphic novels as a genre, and still kinda getting my feet wet. I haven't heard of Ex Machina before.

I love that you're almost more feminist than I am

I think it all stems from my dislike of stupidity. Thinking a woman won't do as good a job as a man because she's a woman is stupid. Thinking that gay people can't drop bombs on foreign civilians just as well as straight guys is also stupid. I'm feminist, and pro-equality in just about every way, but that all stems from my strong anti-stupid stance.


Jakob "Unfortunately, I find that innovative in the world of comics is pretty much Iron Age for the rest of literature."

Well, that's not really fair. There are a few graphic novels out there that break the mold. The Sandman series by Neil Gaiman are my favorite and Maus is a pretty famous example of the possibilities of the graphic novel.


message 17: by [deleted user] (new)

...which are now both 20 years old. Though I agree, those examples rock.


message 18: by Joel (new) - rated it 3 stars

Joel i need to read sandman one of these days. i am cool on gaiman's fiction but i really liked coraline and i want to like him more.


Jakob Ceridwen wrote: "...which are now both 20 years old. Though I agree, those examples rock."

hehe :) To be honest I stopped reading comics about 9-10 years ago when I felt I had depleted all the most interesting comics. I should probably see if there are some good new ones that have come out.


message 20: by [deleted user] (new)

The first one or two are uneven, but by 3, Sandman is awesome.


message 21: by [deleted user] (new)


Scott Clearly you are one of the women who would cut off their breasts and terrorize the roads in this alternate world.


Michael The joke's on you, Scott: I'm a MAN! I'm one of the MEN who would cut off their breasts and terrorize the roads!


message 24: by [deleted user] (last edited Dec 11, 2011 08:54PM) (new)

Scott wrote: "Clearly you are one of the women who would cut off their breasts and terrorize the roads in this alternate world."

...but it would be the right one.


Scott My mind has just been blown. I thought maybe you were a super feminist and pronounced your name similar to michelle.


message 26: by mark (new)

mark monday Scott wrote: "My mind has just been blown.

and it was so easy! you must not get blown too often. don't worry, it happens to the best of us.


Michael I thought maybe you were a super feminist and pronounced your name similar to michelle.

Nope, I just like to call bullshit when I see it, regardless of whether it's socially-accepted bullshit or not. But let's talk about you, Scott. Since you gave Y a five-star review, I must ask, Y? Did you notice that it wasn't very good?

Do you find the whole idea of violent hordes of feminists to be supported by anything from reality?


message 28: by Mir (new)

Mir the only way to escape this inequality is to KILL ALL MEN.

Well, that would end gender inequality, wouldn't it? I mean, if that is one's concern...


message 29: by mark (new)

mark monday there's too many of these guys crowding the planet anyway. i'm not sure i support killing "all" men, that sounds a little extreme and quite a lot of work. so let's say maybe a third, or a half if we're ambitious. i'm confident that together we can solve this problem!


message 30: by [deleted user] (new)

Miriam wrote: "the only way to escape this inequality is to KILL ALL MEN.

Well, that would end gender inequality, wouldn't it? I mean, if that is one's concern..."


It certainly would. Although, in the context of this book, all the dudes are dead to begin with. The Amazons would have their first meeting, dust off their hands, and congratulate the sub-committee before disbanding.


Scott Michael wrote: "I thought maybe you were a super feminist and pronounced your name similar to michelle.

Nope, I just like to call bullshit when I see it, regardless of whether it's socially-accepted bullshit or n..."


I honestly didn't realize any anti-women themes. Maybe it's because I'm not the type of person to notice it, or maybe I'm such a male chauvinist that I'm blind to this.. perceived degradation of women.

I gave it 5 stars because the full color drawings were good, and because it's funny and bizarre.

Were you blind to the powerful confident.. and very sane female leads?


Michael Were you blind to the powerful confident.. and very sane female leads?

No, I wasn't blind to them. A couple of them were nearly as developed as the lead character... I didn't find ANY of the characters very interesting or believable, including the male lead, but that has nothing to do with gender issues, and more with the limitations of writing a comic book: it's hard to get the depth of character you get with a novel.

But the fact that a couple female characters have personality doesn't negate the specific aspect of the story that I was taking issue with in this review: I specifically found the guerrilla feminists offensive and badly researched, and I think feminists get a horrible rap for no clear reason. That whole aspect of the plot--which is HUGE in this collection; in fact, it's the climax--might be the most badly examined plot I've come across in comic books, period. Since the most interesting part of this book was the humor, there wasn't enough substance to overcome the problems I had with this story.

That said, I DID enjoy collections two and three a lot better, when the plot moves away from the militant feminists. I stand by this review, though, because volume one was a really crappy beginning to what would go on to be an okay, readable series.


message 33: by Kat Kennedy (new)

Kat Kennedy The Ugly Truth was a truly horrible movie - thank you for mentioning it.

As for this graphic novel, I appreciate your review. It addresses a lot of issues I agree with and have noticed in other stories with similar concepts.


Michael Thanks, Kat! Yeah, that movie officially made me hate Gerard Butler. Well, that and Gamer, both of which I saw within a couple weeks of one another. God, what a stupid pair of movies.


message 35: by Stefan (new)

Stefan Bhagwandin I like how most of this review isn't about the book.


message 36: by Paul (new)

Paul Bryant that's quite a common feature of this site


Michael I like how most of this review isn't about the book.

That's how I roll.


Briar Rose Thank you so much for this review. I was beginning to think I was the only person in the world who had noticed that this series was sexist. And also that it was pretty average, not brilliant as everyone claims.


message 39: by Hektor (new)

Hektor Robertson This review can bugger off.


Michael Not a highly developed argument, but you're entitled to your opinion.


message 41: by Jason (new)

Jason Trolls are getting lazy.


message 42: by JD (new)

JD Waggy At least it's British slang; perhaps a bit of class, that.


Michael I enjoy the fact that it was review-directed, not reviewer-directed. That's a sign of a classy troll as well.


message 44: by [deleted user] (new)

That is refreshing.


abbax I have the same feelings about the amazons and the general way women are treated in this series. Also, I do get why everyone finds it annoying that they cut off the wrong breast in this but keep in mind that the actual amazons (yes they existed) DID NOT CUT OFF ANYTHING. Why would they? Have you seen any women archers in the olympics with only one breast?
But I digress. Off to a crappy start. I give it another volume to make up for its crappiness although I suspect I will be further disappointed.


Michael I went a bit farther with this--I think it was through the first three collections--and I definitely warmed to it a bit more. Then again, I didn't warm to it enough to finish the series....


message 47: by [deleted user] (new)

abbax wrote: "I have the same feelings about the amazons and the general way women are treated in this series. Also, I do get why everyone finds it annoying that they cut off the wrong breast in this but keep in..."

Wonder Woman had both her boobs, for example.


Scott No, I wasn't blind to them. A couple of them were nearly as developed as the lead character... I didn't find ANY of the char..."

It's been a year, how have you been?

Anyway.. you are missing the point. In this universe all men have died, except for the protagonist. Therefore.. the absurd violent enemies in this story could only be women.

Write this story where all the women have died save one, and it's men roaming the Earth, would you take offense if in such a story there was a group of masculine-supremacists who walked around with weapons acting crazy?


message 49: by [deleted user] (new)

I'm not taking offense that this story is full of stupid, badly written feminist caricatures, I'm just dismissing it as not very good.


abbax Ceridwen wrote: Wonder Woman had both her boobs, for example. "

Was that an attempt at humour?


« previous 1
back to top