Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Stephen's Reviews > The Buntline Special

The Buntline Special by Mike Resnick
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
1413439
My expectations were erect and fully engorged going into this story. A steampunky Tombstone meets Terminator, complete with android sex machines, magic, zombies, and even a vampire…my inner nerd was swooning.


And then...well...Shit!!

Like getting doused with ice water, my happy quickly shrunk and went limp, which is a tough thing to adknowledge, espcially since Mike Resnick is one of my favorite storytellers. Yet, despite having all of the ingredients for a fun-loaded page turner, the book never really got me going. The promise of the premise quickly petered out and the whole thing stalled somewhere short of likeable.

Don’t get me wrong, this isn't a bad read. Resnick’s prose is very, very readable, and the pacing was brisk enough that I read all 300 pages in a single sitting. That says something good about the story. I’d say it’s between okay and good (hence my 2.5 star rating).

It’s just that my nerdlinger hopes were dashed and I was left disappointed, which probably left me judging the book a bit more harshly than it really deserves.

I can’t help it…I just feel let down.


PLOT SUMMARY:

The novel, book 1 of a proposed series, takes place in an alternative 19th century America, where the United States never expanded beyond the Mississippi River. The westward expansion was halted by tribes of Native Americans. The most power of these tribes are led by Geronimo, whose “medicine men� possess magic formidable enough to create a stale-mate with the U.S. Territories like Tombstone, Arizona, while located within the Native American sphere of influence are pretty much left alone so long as they do not interfere with the tribes.

Well, along comes Thomas Edison and Ned Buntline, whose invention of electricity and electric trains have transformed Tombstone into a thriving city, while the development of brass has provided buildings, trains, and people with protection against the weapons of the Native Americans. Throw in the recently developed “gatling� machine pistol being used by the United States and the Native American’s are growing nervous.

The central plot surrounds Edison’s latest project, an attempt to neutralize the magic of the Native Americans so that expansion of the U.S. can continue to the Pacific Ocean. Several powerful groups are trying to kill Edison before he completes his work, and the Earp brothers (Wyatt, Virgil and Morgan), Doc Holliday, and Bat Masterson, have been hired to protect Edison, while also trying to uncover who’s trying to murder him.

This all leads to an alternate version of the story of the O.K. Corral.

THOUGHTS:

Decent…that’s the best I can do, which is a shame because it could have been something terrific. Instead, it turned out to be the literary equivalent of a bag of potato chips. A decent, diverting read, but nothing you are going to remember when you’re finished.

On a positive note, the end of the novel left me with some hope that future novels may develop several interesting threads involving the ongoing struggle between the U.S. and Native American tribes. That was the most interesting aspect of this book, and if subsequent novels more fully explore this, good things may happen.

As for this one�


Turns out...quite a lot.

2.5 stars.
84 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read The Buntline Special.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

December 2, 2010 – Shelved
February 12, 2011 – Started Reading
February 12, 2011 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-29 of 29 (29 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Randy (new)

Randy I've read a western by this title, but not familiar with this one.


message 2: by Dan (new)

Dan Schwent I've been curious about this one for a long time. Most of Resnick's books are in the 2.5 to 3 zone for me.


Stephen Then you might rate this one even lower as it is certainly not his best. I really like his Africa themed stories likeKirinyaga: A Fable of Utopia, Ivory: A Legend of Past and Future and Paradise: A Chronicle of a Distant World and think that it is in these stories that he is at his best. I also thought that Santiago: A Myth of the Far Future was a fun read.


message 4: by Dan (new)

Dan Schwent Kirinyaga and Ivory were good. I really liked the two Santiago ones and the Widowmaker books. The thing I really liked about Resnick's books set in the Birthright universe is that every event he mentions in the story is depicted in full in another book.


Stephen I agree. Did you read Birthright: The Book of Man? I thought that was a really good collection of stories depicted Resnick's universe. Also, if you haven't read the short story Seven Views of Olduvai Gorge, you might want to check it out as I think it is one of his best stories.


message 6: by Dan (new)

Dan Schwent Birthright was good. I went on a Resnick binge a few years ago and read 25 of his books in a few months. Have you read the ones with Lucifer Jones? Those are some that I missed.


message 7: by Dan (new)

Dan Schwent I've never even heard of the Seven Views of Olduvai Gorge. I think the only Resnick's I've read that weren't in the Birthright universe were The Branch and Kirinyaga.


Stephen If you look at Resnick's chronology of the Birthright universe, Seven Views of Olduvai Gorge is the last story set in the universe and so is a really good bookend to the timeline. I am not sure what short story collection it is part of but I bought the audio version on if you ever listen to audio books.

I haven't yet read the Lucifer Jones books but I have the first couple and hope to check them out soon.


Nathan Henrion Great review...loved the pics and gif


message 10: by Tamahome (new) - added it

Tamahome His prose is too 'bare bones' for me. I admire elegance, but I need more stimulation than this.


message 11: by Richard (new)

Richard Derus Hate it when a bookgasm fails to launch. ::sadface::


message 12: by Ronyell (new)

Ronyell Awesome review Stephen! Is that Kenan Thompson in the first image?


Stephen Thanks, Ronyell. I don't know if that is Kenan. I will have to look it up.


Stephen Richard wrote: "Hate it when a bookgasm fails to launch. ::sadface::"

It is the worst...I was left with blue brains.


message 15: by Anne (Booklady) (new)

Anne  (Booklady) Molinarolo Stephen, this is the first book I've ever stopped reading...couldn't get past page 37.


Stephen I didn't dislike it quite that much, but that may be because I'm such a big Resnick fan. I gave him a lot of rope on this one...and he hung me with it.


message 17: by Trudi (new)

Trudi Stephen wrote: "...I was left with blue brains."

You so silly -


message 19: by Richard (new)

Richard Derus

owwwww


message 20: by Hend (new)

Hend


message 21: by Lady Heather (new)

Lady Heather Great Review Stephen! I too hate when my 'inner nerd' is crushed :(


message 22: by Carol (new)

Carol Sounds like a good plot. Too bad it was only decent. The review sounds better than the book.


Jeffrey Keeten The disappointment still leaves a bad taste in my mouth. I was so excited, shadow boxing in anticipation, and that meant just a longer fall to the carpet for the KO. Great Review of a bantam weight book.


Stephen Thanks, Jeffrey. This one really hurt.


Stephen Carol wrote: "Sounds like a good plot. Too bad it was only decent. The review sounds better than the book."

Thanks, Carol. I had high hopes for this one.


Stephen Lady Heather wrote: "Great Review Stephen! I too hate when my 'inner nerd' is crushed :("

Thanks, Heather. My inner nerd is resilient and will recover.


message 27: by E.M. (new)

E.M. Powell Nice one, Stephen. I hate it when a book promises so much (and this one should have been terrific), then fails to deliver. makes me wonder is it an editorial gap as well. Often a novel jumps up a whole lot of levels when there's been a great editor involved.


Brian Oberle Wow, evidently we didn't read the same book. I couldn't put it, or any of its successors down. Resnick really nailed Doc's character, or as much of it as I can get from several biographies. I really like how he weaves many different historical figures into the story. Oh well different strokes ;)


Vigneshh Nice review


back to top