Sara's Reviews > Nicholas Nickleby
Nicholas Nickleby
by
by

Sara's review
bookshelves: classics, gutenberg-download
Nov 26, 2017
bookshelves: classics, gutenberg-download
Read 2 times. Last read October 8, 2024 to December 16, 2024.
2024 Update:
Why on earth would I have said that Charles Dickens is predictable? My 2017 self was obviously having a moment of delusion. I don’t think I have ever completely predicted what Dickens was going to do next, and his characters are, in general, nothing if not unique. Other than that shocking opening, I’m not unhappy with my first review of Nicholas Nickleby.
The first read I did alone, this read was with the Dickensians group, and I cannot ever resist saying how much reading with this group enhances the enjoyment and understanding of Dickens� work. These novels were written as serials and reading them that way and discussing both the book and the times in which it was written is an experience always worth having. If there are libraries in Heaven, Jean is going to be appointed head librarian and teacher extraordinaire.
Of course, having now read Nicholas with the group, I must update my 4-star rating to 5-stars. Whenever I am tempted to give a Dickens� novel less than 5-stars, it is probably a failing in me and not in Charles.
2017 Review:
I’m really not sure why I like Dickens so much. He is predictable, there will be coincidences that could never happen in the real world, and in the end everyone will get their just deserts except for the poor, sad creature who is destined to see heaven ahead of his time. Ah, but he does it with so much style and panache. He creates characters you are seldom ambivalent about, dastardly villains you can feel no compassion for, and good people who restore your faith in humanity.
In Nicholas Nickleby, as in all his novels, Dickens has a full grasp of the class system of his time and the conditions of the poor. He never fails to illustrate that money brings its own unhappiness for some, and that true value is found in character and dignity, devotion and love. When a Dickens character is at the mercy of the world, you can bet he will see the worst and best sides of humanity rearing their heads.
Nicholas Nickleby has its share of Dickens humor as well. Mrs. Nickleby is a bit of a buffoon, who is saved from herself by the good sense of her children. I will admit that there are times when she is almost too much. There is Newman Noggs, who is sure to remain a favorite for me because he is good without any obligation to be so. He gives from a position in which there is very little to be given and made me chuckle more than once when snipping at the horrible Uncle Ralph. I dare say, most of us would hoard our coins and protect our position in Nogg’s situation, and yet he puts his neck and meager fortune on the line for friendship.
We should all like to think that somewhere in our world there are people like Charles and Ned Cheeryble. They live up to their names, for no two cheerier people could there be in this world and they certainly spread the cheer everywhere. They seem to be proof that goodness is its own reward.
Another thing I love about Dickens, his ability to touch upon the thin divide between our world and that of the departed. ”It is an exquisite and beautiful thing in our nature, that when the heart is touched and softened by some tranquil happiness or affectionate feeling, the memory of the dead comes over it most powerfully and irresistibly. I t would almost seem as though our better thoughts and sympathies were charms, in virtue of which the soul is enable to hold some vague and mysterious intercourse with the spirits of those whom we dearly loved in life.� I found this observation remarkably accurate.
I have discovered that reading Dickens slowly brings out the best in his writing. I languished over his descriptions of people and places and took my time over his hilarious conversations. If you pay close attention, you can see 1840s London through his eyes. The lessons of his time are the lesson of today, where so many seem to think money and possessions outweigh personal connections and love of humanity. It is good for the soul to read Dickens.
Up next, some Christmas stories and the annual reading of A Christmas Carol. Next year I am planning to fit in three more Dickens novels: Hard Times, Little Dorrit and Pickwick Papers. It is going slowly, but that is fine, since it means there will be Dickens� yet to come for a long, long time.
Why on earth would I have said that Charles Dickens is predictable? My 2017 self was obviously having a moment of delusion. I don’t think I have ever completely predicted what Dickens was going to do next, and his characters are, in general, nothing if not unique. Other than that shocking opening, I’m not unhappy with my first review of Nicholas Nickleby.
The first read I did alone, this read was with the Dickensians group, and I cannot ever resist saying how much reading with this group enhances the enjoyment and understanding of Dickens� work. These novels were written as serials and reading them that way and discussing both the book and the times in which it was written is an experience always worth having. If there are libraries in Heaven, Jean is going to be appointed head librarian and teacher extraordinaire.
Of course, having now read Nicholas with the group, I must update my 4-star rating to 5-stars. Whenever I am tempted to give a Dickens� novel less than 5-stars, it is probably a failing in me and not in Charles.
2017 Review:
I’m really not sure why I like Dickens so much. He is predictable, there will be coincidences that could never happen in the real world, and in the end everyone will get their just deserts except for the poor, sad creature who is destined to see heaven ahead of his time. Ah, but he does it with so much style and panache. He creates characters you are seldom ambivalent about, dastardly villains you can feel no compassion for, and good people who restore your faith in humanity.
In Nicholas Nickleby, as in all his novels, Dickens has a full grasp of the class system of his time and the conditions of the poor. He never fails to illustrate that money brings its own unhappiness for some, and that true value is found in character and dignity, devotion and love. When a Dickens character is at the mercy of the world, you can bet he will see the worst and best sides of humanity rearing their heads.
Nicholas Nickleby has its share of Dickens humor as well. Mrs. Nickleby is a bit of a buffoon, who is saved from herself by the good sense of her children. I will admit that there are times when she is almost too much. There is Newman Noggs, who is sure to remain a favorite for me because he is good without any obligation to be so. He gives from a position in which there is very little to be given and made me chuckle more than once when snipping at the horrible Uncle Ralph. I dare say, most of us would hoard our coins and protect our position in Nogg’s situation, and yet he puts his neck and meager fortune on the line for friendship.
We should all like to think that somewhere in our world there are people like Charles and Ned Cheeryble. They live up to their names, for no two cheerier people could there be in this world and they certainly spread the cheer everywhere. They seem to be proof that goodness is its own reward.
Another thing I love about Dickens, his ability to touch upon the thin divide between our world and that of the departed. ”It is an exquisite and beautiful thing in our nature, that when the heart is touched and softened by some tranquil happiness or affectionate feeling, the memory of the dead comes over it most powerfully and irresistibly. I t would almost seem as though our better thoughts and sympathies were charms, in virtue of which the soul is enable to hold some vague and mysterious intercourse with the spirits of those whom we dearly loved in life.� I found this observation remarkably accurate.
I have discovered that reading Dickens slowly brings out the best in his writing. I languished over his descriptions of people and places and took my time over his hilarious conversations. If you pay close attention, you can see 1840s London through his eyes. The lessons of his time are the lesson of today, where so many seem to think money and possessions outweigh personal connections and love of humanity. It is good for the soul to read Dickens.
Up next, some Christmas stories and the annual reading of A Christmas Carol. Next year I am planning to fit in three more Dickens novels: Hard Times, Little Dorrit and Pickwick Papers. It is going slowly, but that is fine, since it means there will be Dickens� yet to come for a long, long time.
Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read
Nicholas Nickleby.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
July 14, 2015
– Shelved
July 14, 2015
– Shelved as:
to-read
September 28, 2017
–
Started Reading
October 5, 2017
–
5.75%
"First three chapters, which just lay the foundation for Nicholas' life. I will be reading this over several months and not rushing."
page
47
October 16, 2017
–
7.83%
"I don't think I have come across a more naive character than NN in a long time. Wonder when he will see that his uncle does not have his best interests at heart."
page
64
October 29, 2017
–
14.81%
"Nicholas has arrived at the "Hall" with Squeers. I can see he is in for a very cruel and difficult time, but nothing compared with what the boys will suffer."
page
121
November 8, 2017
–
22.64%
"Ralph Nickleby is a horrid person--Dickens does this type so well.
Noggs is one Dickens kind, humble characters. I like him ever so much."
page
185
Noggs is one Dickens kind, humble characters. I like him ever so much."
November 20, 2017
–
49.69%
"Can't help thinking Dickens really lived in a very bleak world."
page
406
November 23, 2017
–
72.95%
"Dickens is a master at creating two kinds of characters: the heartless, horrible, villainous cad and the goodhearted, kind, and deserving friend...and here we have them, Ralph Nickleby and Newman Noggs."
page
596
November 23, 2017
–
48.0%
""In short, the poor Nickelby's were social and happy, while the rich Nickleby was alone and miserable.""
November 24, 2017
–
60.0%
""You and Nicholas are left to me, we are together once again, and what regard can I have for a few trifling things of which we never feel the want? When I have seen all the misery and desolation that death can bring, and known the lonesome feeling of being solitary and alone in crowds...can you wonder that I look upon this as a place of delicious quiet and rest..."
Gratitude is everything."
Gratitude is everything."
November 26, 2017
– Shelved as:
classics
November 26, 2017
– Shelved as:
gutenberg-download
November 26, 2017
–
Finished Reading
October 8, 2024
–
Started Reading
October 16, 2024
–
3.0%
"I am on Chapter 14 and trying desperately to catch-up with the group read. Always enjoy Dickens. Don't want to miss any of the comments, so going faster is not an option."
October 17, 2024
–
20.0%
November 2, 2024
–
75.52%
"Enjoying reading this with Dickensians. I had only a slight memory of it, but it has seemed like a new read altogether and it is almost certainly going to get a star upgrade from me when I have finished."
page
617
November 6, 2024
–
63.28%
"Among men who have any sound and sterling qualities, there is nothing so contagious as pure openness of heart."
page
517
November 19, 2024
–
74.0%
November 23, 2024
–
79.0%
December 16, 2024
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-38 of 38 (38 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Sue
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Oct 12, 2017 07:31PM

reply
|
flag





Thanks, Kathleen. I find him uplifting, for sure.

I also took a college course and we read the same books there that I had read in high school. They are certainly worth all the time you can give them, but I missed all his other works and found I had read a half dozen more than once. My favorite is (and I suspect always will be) Great Expectations, but David Copperfield is a great one as well.

You are exactly where I was, Diane. I am whittling away at them and enjoying it very much. I hope I get to the entire canon, but if I do not I will enjoy the journey anyway.







Thank you. I am re-reading this one right now, Savita. I have only one more to go and will have read them all. I won't do another until sometime next year.

Of course they do.

How many writers would have the chutzpah to try doing that?!


Anytime you make a Buddy Read of a Dickens ' novel , Sara , I'll definitely join in 😊 . Anyway , I'm adding Nicholas Nickleby to my TBR.

I am lagging behind and not commenting at all, Antoinette. I had hoped to catch up, but so far I am just enjoying the comments of others when I finally reach the chapters. I find reading with the group makes me see so much I missed the first time around.

Thank you, Chris. I think he deserves his place at the top of the heap!



