ŷ

Candi's Reviews > My Brilliant Friend

My Brilliant Friend by Elena Ferrante
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3639005
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: historical-fiction, book-i-own

"It was as if, because of an evil spell, the joy or sorrow of one required the sorrow or joy of the other; even our physical aspect, it seemed to me, shared in that swing."

Elena and Lila, a friendship born of necessity � the need to find another human soul that understands us, our longings and sorrows - someone to emulate, someone that drives each of us to become our very best self. These two girls, born into poverty in 1950s Naples, forge a relationship that is both captivating and completely authentic. There is something about a novel told from the point of view of an adult looking back at his or her childhood that thoroughly captures my attention and feels so convincing. Even if I cannot relate to the circumstances or the surroundings, the emotions are so very real and bring back such sharp memories of my own inexperience and innocent yearnings.

With keen insight and skillful writing, Elena Ferrante has crafted a vivid account of two young lives struggling to rise above the usual fate of those born into such harsh conditions. The impoverishment and violence of the neighborhood are part of the daily fabric of Elena and Lila’s lives, but they dream of a life elevated above those around them. The key to achieving this dream � education. "In that last year of elementary school, wealth became our obsession. We talked about it the way characters in novels talk about searching for treasure� Then, I don’t know why, things changed and we began to link school to wealth. We thought that if we studied hard we would be able to write books and that the books would make us rich. Wealth was still the glitter of gold coins stored in countless chests, but to get there all you had to do was go to school and write a book." Oh yes, there was a time when I believed diligent studying would achieve similar results! What little girl doesn’t dream of becoming rich or famous?! Both girls work hard, but it is quite evident that Lila is the dominant one in the relationship � academics come easy to her and Elena finds herself wanting to reach those same heights. She often feels inferior to Lila and it becomes her goal to keep up with her, but believing she can never surpass the brilliance of her friend.

Of course, the competition between two coming-of-age girls doesn’t just end at schoolwork. The fragility of such a relationship is further tested by the attraction they hold for the boys of the neighborhood. In this arena, Elena perhaps feels she has an advantage over Lila: "In general I was the pretty one, while she was skinny, like a salted anchovy, she gave off an odor of wildness, she had a long face, narrow at the temples, framed by two bands of smooth black hair." However, true to the nature of girlhood, feelings of inadequacy settle in and Elena feels second-string once again. "But Lila now had retaken the upper hand, satisfaction had magnified her beauty, while I, overwhelmed by schoolwork, exhausted by my frustrated love for Nino, was growing ugly again. My healthy color faded, the acne returned. And suddenly one morning the specter of glasses appeared."

I couldn’t help but wish that Elena would stand up for herself, value herself as an individual separate from her attachment to Lila. Lila, the leader and Elena, the follower � certainly a familiar dynamic in a friendship. I wonder who benefits most from these friendships. Perhaps Elena needed the competition to drive her own ambition and rise above her circumstances. But Lila too needed someone to ground her, give her some sense of stability in her own life. I think perhaps such relationships are fluid � giving and receiving on both ends at different times, always changing along with the trials and tribulations each experiences. Ferrante does an exceptional job of examining the complexities of friendships and this is what I found to be the most fascinating aspect of this novel. The ending leaves one with a question and the desire to grab the second book in the series. Without a doubt, I will do exactly that. I am eager to follow not just Elena and Lila’s friendship but also to learn more about the fate of the large cast of characters � especially Nino, Stefano, Rino, Pasquale, Antonio, and even the city of Naples itself.
154 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read My Brilliant Friend.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

August 28, 2015 – Shelved
August 28, 2015 – Shelved as: to-read
August 28, 2015 – Shelved as: historical-fiction
September 24, 2016 – Shelved as: book-i-own
November 20, 2016 – Started Reading
November 30, 2016 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 55 (55 new)


Diane I'm thinking I should get this from the library.


Candi Diane wrote: "I'm thinking I should get this from the library."

Yes, Diane! If you have the time to get it and read it, I think you would like it. I am planning to continue with the series.


Diane Thanks. And i would also be interested in the series if I read the first one.


Doug Bradshaw For some reason, this series really resonated for me. So personal and honest. Glad you liked it.


Candi Doug wrote: "For some reason, this series really resonated for me. So personal and honest. Glad you liked it."

That's great, Doug! I've heard that the series gets even better after the first, so I'm hoping to continue before too much time passes by!


Renata You are in for a very special and unique reading experience w this series. I found the book compulsively readable and when I wasn't reading them I was thinking of all the characters, their choices, their interactions, their struggles and hardships. Ferrante breathes such credible life into each and every character and that is part of what makes the series better and better as you read on.


Candi Renata wrote: "You are in for a very special and unique reading experience w this series. I found the book compulsively readable and when I wasn't reading them I was thinking of all the characters, their choices,..."

Renata, I am so looking forward to continuing with these. I felt I understood the characters so well, and they are ones that won't be quickly forgotten. I can imagine myself getting really hooked on this series!


Karen Hi Candi
The first one in this quartet just starts to get good at the ending. I promise you will love books two., three and four.-)


Candi Karen wrote: "Hi Candi
The first one in this quartet just starts to get good at the ending. I promise you will love books two., three and four.-)"


Oh goody, Karen! I am looking forward to them!


Candi Deanna wrote: "sounds like a good start to a new series :) I am looking forward to your review :)"

It is a very good start, Deanna! I was never really much of a series reader, but it looks like that is changing recently!


Cathrine ☯️ I love reading such a well done review on a book I did not care for. Great perspective Candi.


Candi Cathrine � wrote: "I love reading such a well done review on a book I did not care for. Great perspective Candi."

Cathrine, I'm sorry this one didn't work well for you, but I'm glad that you read and appreciated my review! That's what makes this such a wonderful site. I too like to read the various points of view - and those that are opposite of my own are just as enriching as those that support my own! Happy New Year, Cathrine :)


Karen Wonderful, Candi. I loved the entire series :)


message 14: by Vessey (new) - added it

Vessey Candi, this is one of your best reviews. I loved it! :) I have this one on my list. I listed it after reading The Days of Abandonment. It is hers too. Have you read it? :)


Candi Inês wrote: "I've had this book in my Kindle FOREVER, but never tried reading it. I might give it ago after reading your beautiful review."

Thanks so much, Ines. I recommend giving it a try! I have heard that the series gets even better after this first one :)


Candi Karen wrote: "Wonderful, Candi. I loved the entire series :)"

Thank you, Karen! I am looking forward to continuing this very soon!


Candi Vessey wrote: "Candi, this is one of your best reviews. I loved it! :) I have this one on my list. I listed it after reading The Days of Abandonment. It is hers too. Have you read it? :)"

I appreciate the generous compliment, Vessey! Thank you :) This is my first Ferrante novel - I am going to add The Days of Abandonment now, if it's not already on my TBR!


message 18: by Vessey (new) - added it

Vessey Candi wrote: "Vessey wrote: "Candi, this is one of your best reviews. I loved it! :) I have this one on my list. I listed it after reading The Days of Abandonment. It is hers too. Have you read it? :)"

I apprec..."


I hope you like it and write a review for it! :)


Candi Deanna wrote: "Wonderful review, Candi!!

Happy New Year and all the best to you and your family <3"


Thank you, Deanna! Wishing you and yours a fantastic year ahead!


message 20: by Mary Beth (new)

Mary Beth Excellent review Candi! Happy New Year!


Candi Mary wrote: "Excellent review Candi! Happy New Year!"

Thank you, Mary! I hope you have a wonderful New Year too!


Candi Marita wrote: "An excellent review of a favourite series, Candi! The series improves, so I look forward to seeing how you get along with Elena & Lila."

Thank you, Marita! I've heard it improves, so I'm really excited to continue. Am planning the next one for March :)


Sharon What a great review Candi. I just finished Book 1, and now I'm hooked! I too wondered who benefitted more from this complicated and fascinating friendship!


Candi Thanks so much, Sharon! Book 2 is a terrific read too - I hope you continue with the series. I am planning to read the third one next month :)


message 25: by Jola (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jola I'm a huge fan of Elena Ferrante's series, so your superb review was a double pleasure for me!
I've already read all volumes. I totally share your point of view, Candi: 'I couldn’t help but wish that Elena would stand up for herself, value herself as an individual separate from her attachment to Lila.' At times I felt like screaming that to Elena. :)


Candi Jola wrote: "I'm a huge fan of Elena Ferrante's series, so your superb review was a double pleasure for me!
I've already read all volumes. I totally share your point of view, Candi: 'I couldn’t help but wish t..."


Thank you very much, Jola! I appreciate your sweet comment! I'm glad to hear that you are a fan of the series. It's so easy to get wrapped up in the lives of Ferrante's characters.


Jaline Beautifully done, Candi! I have also read the series and agree 100% with your assessments. I loved this series, yet this first one will always have an element of something extra for me.

I, too, wanted to say, 'Stand up for yourself!' - but I also felt that their friendship seemed to need that dynamic. It was also about the time and place where they were growing up, and that Elena was not "that person" - which led me to really want to find out more about all the qualities she actually contained and straight into the second volume. Enjoy! :)


Candi Jaline wrote: "Beautifully done, Candi! I have also read the series and agree 100% with your assessments. I loved this series, yet this first one will always have an element of something extra for me.

I, too, wa..."


Thank you for your lovely comment, Jaline! I must say it's nice to meet more of the Ferrante fan club here! I like your point about the friendship needing that dynamic - I think you are quite right. I enjoyed delving even further into the relationship in the second book and am looking forward to the third one :)


Jaline Candi wrote: "Thank you for your lovely comment, Jaline! I must say it's nice to meet more of the Ferrante fan club here! I like your point about the friendship needing that dynamic - I think you are quite right. I enjoyed delving even further into the relationship in the second book and am looking forward to the third one :)

I am looking forward to your review of the next one so much, Candi! This is all bringing back wonderful memories! :)


message 30: by Mariah Roze (new)

Mariah Roze Our Diversity in All Forms Book Club is reading this for July. We’d love to have you join the discussion on it. :) /topic/show/...


Anne Hi. I read this novel after watching the tv series just found it marked as unread. I read your superb overview and review this a.m.


message 32: by Candi (last edited Mar 19, 2020 07:32AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Candi Anne wrote: "Hi. I read this novel after watching the tv series just found it marked as unread. I read your superb overview and review this a.m."

Hi Anne! I apologize for missing your comment last month - am just seeing it now. Thanks for your lovely comment! I just saw a commercial for the series the other day and really hope I can find a way to watch it. Did you think the tv series was well done?


Anne Candi wrote: "Anne wrote: "Hi. I read this novel after watching the tv series just found it marked as unread. I read your superb overview and review this a.m."

Hi Anne! I apologize for missing your comment last..."


Hi Candi. No worries. You get so many comments on your reviews I can imagine that you might miss a comment now and again. I know that your intention is only good because you very graciously write a personal reply to all comments.

I miss comments too but not for the same reason. For a long time GR wasn't sending me notifications re: comments. I would find them days, weeks, or months later and feel horrible that I hadn't replied to the comment in a timely fashion.


Candi You are very sweet, Anne! Yes, I do feel bad if I miss a comment. My thoughts are that if someone took the time to read and then make a comment, it's the least I can do to leave a little reply in return :) Plus, I love to chat!

Yes, GR notifications can be a bit unpredictable from time to time!


Anne Candi wrote: "You are very sweet, Anne! Yes, I do feel bad if I miss a comment. My thoughts are that if someone took the time to read and then make a comment, it's the least I can do to leave a little reply in r..."

No, you're sweet! :)). It's so funny because I love reading your reviews and I like chatting about books or just letting you know how much I enjoyed your review so I leave a message but, I kind of feel bad at the same time, knowing that you will feel obliged to respond to the million people who also commented. The cost of popularity, my friend.


Candi Thanks for the much-needed cheer today, Anne! So funny! I don't feel obliged so much as I really just enjoy doing it and connecting with friends even more. If I have lots of comments to respond to, I use it as an excuse to not do chores ;D


Anne Glad to bring cheer to your life. We all need a dose of that as often as possible these days.

So glad to know that you enjoy responding to comments with the bonus that you get to procrastinate chores. Phew. One less thing for me to feel guilty about. :))


message 38: by Christine (new)

Christine Superb review, Candi! Trying to decide about this series.


Candi Christine wrote: "Superb review, Candi! Trying to decide about this series."

Thanks very much, Christine! Gosh, I loved the experience of the entire series, but it's a tough one for me to say without doubt to any one person, "Oh, you will love this!" I would say, however, that if you're at all interested, then give this first one a try. The writing is dense and it's very character heavy, but I found it to be 'brilliant'! ;)


Lorna A beautiful review, Candi. I loved this series as well.


Candi Lorna wrote: "A beautiful review, Candi. I loved this series as well."

Thank you very much, Lorna! It was a great series to sink your teeth into!


message 42: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa It was so nice to see this review pop up to help me revisit this wonderful book.


Candi Lisa wrote: "It was so nice to see this review pop up to help me revisit this wonderful book."

I'm glad you bumped into it then today, Lisa! I like to think about this series every now and then :)


message 44: by Cecily (last edited Nov 22, 2022 11:44AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Cecily What an excellent review. Like you, I couldn't relate to the specific circumstances or surroundings, but the emotions are utterly relatable, and your opening analysis of Lila and Elena's friendship is true of them and of many others known to me, perhaps including me.
"I wonder who benefits most from these friendships."
I think the balance waxed and waned, sometimes switching suddenly. That seemed more realistic, and certainly more interesting, than having one girl always dominant. It's an aspect I'm looking forward to exploring in subsequent volumes.


Candi Cecily wrote: "What an excellent review. Like you, I couldn't relate to the specific circumstances or surroundings, but the emotions are utterly relatable, and you opening analysis of Lila and Elena's friendship ..."

Thank you very much, Cecily. The whole thing is truly an epic reading experience. I love examining complex relationships, and Ferrante really delivers on that level. Everything about this felt so authentic. I'm looking forward to following your thoughts on the rest of the series!


Margaret M - (having a challenging time and on GR as much as I can) Fabulous review again Candi 💖


Candi Margaret M - (semi hiatus - wrote: "Fabulous review again Candi 💖"

Thanks so much, Margaret! :)


Left Coast Justin Another review that seems to get to the heart and soul of the book -- and for what it's worth, salted anchovies are delicious!


Jaidee Ha ! You just want of those horrible little crinoline dresses in lime green in your size 😸


Candi Left Coast Justin wrote: "Another review that seems to get to the heart and soul of the book -- and for what it's worth, salted anchovies are delicious!"

Justin, I can hardly believe that seven years have passed since I read this book - and yet, it remains so vivid in my mind. It's a dense novel, but I enjoyed watching these two friends grow. Anchovies are the bomb!! :P


« previous 1
back to top