欧宝娱乐

Bill Kerwin's Reviews > City

City by Clifford D. Simak
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
83582
's review

liked it
bookshelves: fiction, science-fiction


Remember when you鈥攖he na茂ve philosopher鈥攕truck by the similarities of molecule and solar system, imagined your body to be composed of billions of nano-planets and stars? I do. I was twelve years old at the time, working at my parent's grocery, and I was suddenly forced to lean upon my push-broom to keep from falling headlong in a dizzy marvel of surprise.

Reading City (1952) is like that. Although now it may look na茂ve, simplistic, perhaps even shallow, at the time it must have seemed so imaginatively brave, so wide in scope, that it made you dizzy to contemplate it.

Simak's book is certainly ambitious. Originally a series of eight short stories published from '44 tp '51, it stretches more than ten thousand years in the future, from the days when men abandoned the large industrial cities in fear of the atomic bomb, through the growing isolation and disappearance the human species, unable to come to grips with its own violence or feel comfortable in its own skin, to the new order established on earth by the talking dogs and their robot helpers, who now face the threat of a rising insect civilization.

Unfortunately, City, though broad in scope, lacks depth. The writing style is merely serviceable, and the characters are often thin, their motivations uncomplicated. Worse, the world itself lacks credibility, evolving according to a child-like version of lamarckian inheritance: for example, some genius sets a glass dome over an anthill so the little dudes won't have to hibernate, and soon they are building little factories and pushing things around in tiny carts).

Such deficiences, however, are almost counterbalanced by the ingenious, self-referential framework of the novel. Simak connects his eight stories with a series of introductory scholarly notes that summarize the opinions of Doggish critics through the centuries (with names like Rover, Tighe, and Towser), who analyze the significance of these fabulous ancient folktales and conjecture that humankind itself may be nothing but a canine myth.

Which is 鈥渨ild,鈥� man, it could 鈥渂low your top,鈥� make you 鈥渇lip your lid鈥濃€攁s my twelve year old self might say. And if the twelve-year-old philosopher lives in you鈥攁s he still lives in me鈥攜ou may find something to enjoy in Simak's City.
173 likes ·  鈭� flag

Sign into 欧宝娱乐 to see if any of your friends have read City.
Sign In 禄

Reading Progress

May 23, 2007 – Shelved
January 21, 2016 – Started Reading
January 21, 2016 – Shelved as: fiction
January 21, 2016 – Shelved as: science-fiction
January 21, 2016 –
page 430
100%
January 21, 2016 –
page 43
17.77%
January 22, 2016 –
page 60
24.79%
January 22, 2016 –
page 60
24.79%
January 23, 2016 –
page 94
38.84%
January 23, 2016 –
page 115
47.52%
January 24, 2016 –
page 187
77.27%
January 26, 2016 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-8 of 8 (8 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Glenn (last edited Jun 03, 2016 06:57AM) (new)

Glenn Russell Thanks, Bill. This is a very fine review. I can picture you running the scenes through your 12-year old mind as you helped out at your family grocery store. That's the thing about sci-fi, particularly for kids and teenagers - it really can fire the imagination. Sure, the characters and plot can be thin but the ideas and images can be the fuel to make your spaceship soar (tacky metaphor but this is what actually happens).


Bill Kerwin Glenn wrote: "Thanks, Bill. This is a very fine review. I can picture you running the scenes through your 12-year old mind as you helped out at your family grocery store... the ideas and images [of science fiction] can be the fuel to make your spaceship soar (tacky metaphor but this is what actually happens)."

Glad you liked the review, especially the part about twelve-year old me. It's my favorite part of the review, and I am happy the you noticed it.

I liked your "spaceship" metaphor too. It is appropriate, and apt.


message 3: by Christine (new)

Christine Zibas Love your review and that you've managed to hold on to something of that young self.


message 4: by William (new)

William Thank you for the review, Bill.


message 5: by Berkley (new) - added it

Berkley Read this just recently myself and experienced a similar reaction: enjoyed it very much, but couldn't help wishing I'd encountered it back in my younger days, when I was first discovering and exploring SF.


message 6: by Dennis (new)

Dennis Wow! Great review. I was on the fence regarding City by Clifford Simak. Now, I am eager to buy and read this book.


Rodzilla Agreed with the review. Spot on. I would add that "Hiding Place" (the 2nd short story in this related collection) is the best of the lot and stands alone as a short story. I first encountered it in "The Science Fiction Hall of Fame, vol. I".

I will add that this collection plus vol IIA and vol IIB are phenomenal and worth buying as a set of three. They were put together to honor some of the gems published before the Nebula and Hugo awards were put into place. In them you can find HG Wells' "The Time Machine" and "Who Goes There," the novella that led to John Carpenter's film, "The Thing," which remains tied with Alien as the best monster Sci Fi out there. But lots of cerebral or mind-expanding stories packed in these books. Many are dated, but it is fun to hop in the Wabac Machine and try to put oneself in the shoes of writers at the time.


Jeff Alan Anything less than 4 1/2 stars really does not do this book proper service


back to top