ŷ

Candi's Reviews > Inés of My Soul

Inés of My Soul by Isabel Allende
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3639005
's review

liked it
bookshelves: book-i-own, historical-fiction, south-america

"In the Americas every man was his own master; he never had to bow to anyone, he could begin anew, be a different person, live a different life. There no one bore his dishonor for years, and even the humblest could rise in the world."

Many years ago, I read several of Isabel Allende’s books and fell in love with them. Novels like The House of Spirits, Daughter of Fortune and Of Love and Shadows put Allende on my list of favorite authors at the time. Whenever I saw any of her books at a library book sale, I would eagerly snatch them up. Then a couple of years ago I read one of her more recent pieces, The Japanese Lover, and was somewhat lukewarm about it. As a result, those books I had been so keen to buy just sat on my bookshelf for some time. Until now. The result? Well, let’s just say I found it interesting, but I feel less than enthused to tell you all about it. Bottom line, this means that there was an emotional connection lacking here for me.

"With Pedro de Valdivia I lived a life of legend, and with him I conquered a kingdom."

Written in the first person, Inés of my Soul recounts the settling of the country of Chile by the Spanish conquistadors during the sixteenth century. Inés Suarez was instrumental in the founding of the city of Santiago and Chile alongside Pedro de Valdivia. In fact, I imagine she was quite a remarkable woman and ages ahead of her time. She exhibited great courage and was incredibly resourceful. I daresay she could have been a leader herself, and often demonstrated those skills when Valdivia was away on various missions and battles. She provided guidance to her lover, and he took her advice quite seriously much of the time. "A man does what he can; a woman does what a man cannot." Inés is now a woman in her seventies and she has set out to write a memoir of her life. Occasionally, her story is interrupted by brief remarks directed to Isabel, her adopted daughter. This became a tad irritating and disrupted the flow of the narrative. Perhaps it was just me.

"Faults committed in the name of Spain and the church were not sins."

How often have we heard similar excuses when one group of individuals attempts to conquer another? In this case, it was the native Chileans, the Mapuche, that the Spanish aimed to subdue. Naturally, there followed much bloodshed on both sides with some very violent and grisly battle scenes depicted throughout. Punishments were harsh and sometimes quite vicious; beheadings were not uncommon. The Yanaconas, those Native Americans who had served the Inca Empire, were now enslaved to the Spaniards. Without their assistance, I have to wonder if Spain would have succeeded in claiming these lands for themselves. The Yanacona were a tireless and able-bodied people that also suffered from grave injustices. "We want to found cities and prosper, live with decency and comfort, while they aspire only to be free."

Overall, I would have to admit that this book was quite fascinating from a historical standpoint. I’ve never read about the conquest of Chile prior to reading this, so I now feel more educated in that sense. I have no doubt that Allende did thorough research in writing this novel, as she herself was born in Peru, raised in Chile, and had ties to political leaders. In her author’s note, she indicated that she spent four years conducting her research. I typically adore a book with an intelligent and strong heroine, and Inés Suarez certainly fit that to a T. But there was something in the writing that was a bit lacking for me. Perhaps it was missing the beautiful lines I so crave. And, as I stated before, I was not particularly connected to Inés, despite my admiration of her tenacity and adventurous spirit. Still, this is a worthwhile read, and you can certainly judge for yourself if it would suit you or not. I’ll still give it a go with those other unread Allende’s on my shelf.

"In a hot, swampy, voracious world infested with reptiles and poisonous insects, things decay very quickly, especially the soul. The jungle transforms men into rogues and murderers."
116 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Inés of My Soul.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

October 26, 2015 – Shelved
October 26, 2015 – Shelved as: to-read
October 26, 2015 – Shelved as: book-i-own
October 26, 2015 – Shelved as: historical-fiction
January 31, 2019 – Shelved as: south-america
February 19, 2019 – Started Reading
February 26, 2019 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-38 of 38 (38 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Sara I felt the same. I find that she is an author I loved in the beginning and have gone off of over the years. I was hovering between 3 & 4 stars and I gave her the extra for the historical content. I did learn some history that was 100% foreign to me before I read the book. I have two more books by her on my physical bookshelf and I keep reaching around them.

I do remember loving Daughter of Fortune. Sometimes I think authors have a limited number of stories within them and once expended even a good writer can become just mediocre.


message 2: by Julie (new)

Julie G Well, Candi, I wrote a comment here and it Disapparated. (Sorry, just finished Harry Potter #4).
Let's just say. . . I totally understand what you've written here, in this review. I loved The House of Spirits but then I read her Aphrodite: A Memoir of the Senses and I was like. . . is this the same author?


message 3: by Diane (new)

Diane Wallace Fair review, Candi


message 4: by Felicia (new)

Felicia "A man does what he can; a woman does what man cannot." Best. Quote. Ever.
Fantastic review, Candi 💖


Candi Sara wrote: "I felt the same. I find that she is an author I loved in the beginning and have gone off of over the years. I was hovering between 3 & 4 stars and I gave her the extra for the historical content. I..."

I agree, Sara. Her later work does seem much different from what I recall of her earlier books. I have one of her older books that I believe lies more heavily in the realm of magical realism, and I'm curious to see if that appeals to me more. I can be very picky about the genre, but Allende perhaps excels there.


Candi Julie wrote: "Well, Candi, I wrote a comment here and it Disapparated. (Sorry, just finished Harry Potter #4).
Let's just say. . . I totally understand what you've written here, in this review. I loved The Hous..."


Strange things can happen on Pi day, Julie! (We are math nerds celebrating in our house today ;)

Your comment "is this the same author?" expresses what I felt in reading this one. Then I wondered if I just had a faulty memory of how I felt reading her earlier books. But I think Sara is perhaps quite right when she said "even a good writer can become just mediocre." That may be the case here.


Candi Diane wrote: "Fair review, Candi"

Thank you, Diane :)


Candi Felicia wrote: ""A man does what he can; a woman does what man cannot." Best. Quote. Ever.
Fantastic review, Candi 💖"


Ha ha! Thank you, Felicia! I thought my women friends might appreciate that quote! :)


message 9: by Wyndy (new)

Wyndy I’m haven’t read one of hers in many years either. I do plan to give ‘Island Beneath The Sea� a chance. We’ll see ;-)


message 10: by Diane S � (new)

Diane S ☔ Awesome review, Candi.


message 11: by Maureen (new)

Maureen Wonderful review Candi 💕


Barbara Lovely review, Candi. I love Allende and want to include more of her books in 2019.


Candi Wyndy wrote: "I’m haven’t read one of hers in many years either. I do plan to give ‘Island Beneath The Sea� a chance. We’ll see ;-)"

I have that one sitting on my bookshelf, too, Wyndy. I hope we both end up liking it! :)


Candi Diane S � wrote: "Awesome review, Candi."

Thank you, Diane! :)


Candi Maureen wrote: "Wonderful review Candi 💕"

Many thanks, Maureen! :)


message 16: by Paula (new)

Paula K Lovely review, Candi. I read her The Japanese Lover and didn’t think to highly of the book.


Candi Barbara wrote: "Lovely review, Candi. I love Allende and want to include more of her books in 2019."

Thank you, Barbara! I hope you can squeeze in a couple of good ones this year :)


Candi Paula wrote: "Lovely review, Candi. I read her The Japanese Lover and didn’t think to highly of the book."

Thanks, Paula! I remember having such high hopes for that one. It was fine, but wasn't really what I had expected from Allende after reading her previous books.


Melissa ♥ Dog/Wolf Lover ♥ Martin Excellent review dear Candi 😊💕🌸❌⭕�


message 20: by JanB (new)

JanB Great review Candi! I’ve not read this author before. I don’t know what it is but when I pick one up at the library or bookstore I end up putting it back down. If I ever feel inspired to try her I’ll be sure to not start with this one!


Candi Melissa � Dog/Wolf Lover � wrote: "Excellent review dear Candi 😊💕🌸❌⭕�"

Thank you, sweet Mel!! XO


Candi JanB wrote: "Great review Candi! I’ve not read this author before. I don’t know what it is but when I pick one up at the library or bookstore I end up putting it back down. If I ever feel inspired to try her I�..."

Thank you, Jan! Yes, I would suggest picking up one of the earlier ones I mentioned if you're ever in the mood :)


message 23: by Cheri (new) - added it

Cheri I have yet to read Allende, but have several of her books on my shelf to read, so am happy to know to avoid this one. Excellent, balanced review, Candi!


Candi Thank you, Cheri! I'm a sucker for beautiful language in a book and this one was just lacking for me in that department :) I hope you enjoy one of her other novels when you get a chance to give her a try :)


message 25: by Marialyce (new)

Marialyce I have pretty much had a hard time with this author. It's always been hard for me to maintain focus on her stories. Wonderful review, Candi!


Candi Marialyce wrote: "I have pretty much had a hard time with this author. It's always been hard for me to maintain focus on her stories. Wonderful review, Candi!"

Thank you, Marialyce! I'm beginning to wonder if maybe I've just 'grown out' of her. I'll try one more, in case it was just this particular novel, but I'm not in a big hurry to do so!


message 27: by Jaline (new)

Jaline Wonderful review, Candi, and thank you for the heads up. I don't know why, but I have never felt a 'pull' toward this author's books, although I have seen them many times and read many other reader's reviews of them. Maybe some day . . . :)


Candi Jaline wrote: "Wonderful review, Candi, and thank you for the heads up. I don't know why, but I have never felt a 'pull' toward this author's books, although I have seen them many times and read many other reader..."

Thank you, Jaline! Well, if Allende is not calling your name, I'm certain that you won't be lacking in other reading material. There are plenty of others just screaming to be read!


message 29: by Rafael (new)

Rafael Garcia Just point out that the yanaconas were the slaves of the Incan empire before the arrival of the spaniards. They were enrolled in the spanish armies and some authors believe that they showed incredible cruelty against their former masters. However, they remained in semi-slavery despite the spanish laws of the XVI century that theoretically gave the natives the status of subjects of the emperor and therfore equals to the invaders.


Candi Rafael wrote: "Just point out that the yanaconas were the slaves of the Incan empire before the arrival of the spaniards. They were enrolled in the spanish armies and some authors believe that they showed incredi..."

Thanks for the additional background on a topic I know very little about, Rafael!


message 31: by Amelie (new)

Amelie Cox Good review!


Maureen I felt the same Candi


Candi Amelie wrote: "Good review!"

Thanks, Amelie!!


Candi Maureen wrote: "I felt the same Candi"

Glad I wasn't alone, Maureen! :)


Ms.pegasus It was hard to adopt the mindset of the 16th century conquistadors as you mention in your review. Like you, mixed reaction.


Candi Mixed reaction is exactly how I remember it, Ms. pegasus! I haven't read another Allende since this one, unfortunately.


Ms.pegasus The only other one I've read is A LONG PETAL BY THE SEA. I'm not an Isabel Allende fan but thought that book was better than this one. I mention it because the poet Pablo Neruda is a character in the book and news has recently been published that he was in fact poisoned, something many had long suspected.


Candi Ms.pegasus wrote: "The only other one I've read is A LONG PETAL BY THE SEA. I'm not an Isabel Allende fan but thought that book was better than this one. I mention it because the poet Pablo Neruda is a character in t..."

I appreciate that tip, Ms.pegasus, as I do have that Allende on my list and was a bit hesitant to read it. I might give it a try one day now, thanks to you!


back to top