ŷ

Sam Quixote's Reviews > JLA: Earth 2

JLA by Grant Morrison
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
5759543
's review

it was amazing

The DC Universe is largely responsible for superhero comics� reputation as a baffling and utterly inscrutable place. Case in point: JLA: Earth 2. In Grant Morrison and Frank Quitely’s late �90s book, Earth 2 is actually our Earth - Earth-Prime - dubbed so by Alexander Luthor (from the mirror world). However to the “real� Justice League of America and the audience, our Earth is Earth-Prime and Earth 2 is the home of the Crime Syndicate, the “evil� Justice League headed up by Ultraman, Owlman, and Superwoman.

BUT to more recent comics readers who joined DC when they rolled out their infamous New 52 line and who read the event books Trinity War and Forever Evil, the Crime Syndicate is from Earth 3. Also, looking at Morrison’s latest DC book, The Multiversity, the Guidebook confirms Earth 3 as home to the Crime Syndicate.

So what are we to make of JLA: Earth 2? Here’s my advice to new readers of superhero comics and anyone else for that matter: ignore all the extraneous crap and focus on the story and characters instead. Don’t try to understand the continuity and all the trivial nonsense, you’ll never get it; it’s way too convoluted and pointless, especially as DC reboot their universe(s) whenever their sales hit lower than usual points and they get desperate - “Quick, slap a CRISIS on that book or we’re all going to the poorhouse!�. Just enjoy the books themselves without looking too hard at the context.

That said, a large amount of DC books (and Marvel for that matter) are total shit so it’s a real pleasure when something superb like JLA: Earth 2 comes around - but then it’s Morrison and Quitely so it was never going to suck!

Earth 2 Alexander Luthor travels to Earth-Prime where he discovers the Justice League are good. He tells them about the Crime Syndicate and they return to Earth 2 to help make Lex’s world a better place. But, like what goes up must come down, the Multiverse must be balanced (or something) and as the heroes of our Earth head to Earth 2, their villainous counterparts are sent to our Earth - oh noooo!

This might be my favourite Justice League book which isn’t saying much as I’ve pretty much disliked every one I’ve read! I love how Morrison doesn’t feel like he has to use every member of the League every time (take note Geoff Johns!). The opening scene sees Superman, Martian Manhunter, Wonder Woman, Green Lantern and Flash saving a falling plane full of dead people (they were pre-dead - the game is afoot!) without Aquaman or Batman in sight - and it’s awesome (even if it’s kinda undermined by a better scene years later in Bryan Singer’s Superman Returns where Superman saves a downed plane full of living humans all by himself)!

Something similar happens once the League head to Earth 2 without all its members feeling the need to go and a couple stay behind to protect the Earth if things go awry (as they are wont to do). That’s great! Use the ones who’ll be most effective - think tactically, not in terms of numbers.

Besides the action, it’s just interesting seeing how strangely Earth 2 looks with corruption and evil everywhere, familiar characters turned upside down, etc. Also because it’s a relatively short book at under 100 pages, Morrison gets right into it: we’re at Earth 2 in no time, the League get stuck in, the Crime Syndicate are pushed with their backs to the wall, and things barrel along quickly with some twists and turns thrown in. Brilliant, gripping stuff!

It helps that Frank Quitely - in my mind the greatest superhero comics artist working today - draws the hell out of this book. Some of my favourite scenes: Owlman operating in his Gotham City, the Crime Syndicate’s Watchtower hovering over the city, the opening plane sequence, and Green Lantern’s prison for the Crime Syndicate. There’s not a page in this book that’s not perfect. Frank Quitely’s art is just awesomeness personified and makes me very, very happy to see it!

To readers who are familiar with Morrison’s writing style and might be a little gunshy: Earth 2 is one of his “sober� comics. It’s not weird and zany and it doesn’t go all round the insane asylum - it’s straightforward superhero storytelling at its finest. Totally accessible.

JLA: Earth 2 is arguably the best adventure the Justice League have ever had and is yet another masterpiece from one of the medium’s greatest creative teams, Morrison and Quitely. It’s enough to forgive DC’s bullshit tinkerings with their universe!
36 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read JLA.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Started Reading
October 30, 2015 – Finished Reading
October 31, 2015 – Shelved

Comments Showing 1-12 of 12 (12 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Anne Happy Halloween, Spooky. :)


Donovan So this was like a mini series back in the day? Sounds a lot like Crisis on Infinite Earths, which I just started. Seriously, my head explodes trying to figure out DCU continuity.


message 5: by Sam (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sam Quixote I think it was a story arc from Morrison's JLA run in the late 90s - a great one too! How many pages are you into Crisis? The furthest I made it before giving up was just before p.100.


message 6: by Donovan (last edited Oct 31, 2015 02:44PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Donovan Well I'm actually reading it in its original comic form, borrowed from a friend, of which I think there are...12? I just finished the first issue. It's pretty insane already just 30 something pages in. But. I must say that the science-fiction and multiverse shit is very interesting if head exploding. Multiverse. Antimatter. I don't know if physicists even theorized that stuff forty years ago...?


message 7: by XenofoneX (last edited Nov 01, 2015 02:35AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

XenofoneX Awesome review, and I love this book; this is Quitely at his peak, and I wish he'd go back to inking his own art (with actual ink, in his classic style; the Gary Gianni-type shit he used for Batman & Robin -- NEIN!)... or getting John Stokes to do it... or better yet, doing a fully painted book. He hasn't done much since Shimura and Missionary Man for 2000 A.D., but his painted covers are spectacular, and his one fully painted story for Sandman: Endless Nights is completely fucking amazing (knowing Quitely, a books' worth of painted art could take years).

JLA: Earth 2 was first released in 2000 as an original hardcover, which was kind of rare for DC at the time, but there were others. I think it was a line of HC graphic novels featuring DC characters that were self-contained... 'DC Originals', maybe? The one that stands out is Green Lantern: Willworld, by JM Dematteis and Seth Fisher (RIP); it's the only Green Lantern book I've liked, largely due to Seth Fisher's Quitely and Geof Darrow-styled hyper-detailed art, though the story is great as well, requiring no knowledge of the GL back-story.


message 8: by Sam (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sam Quixote Gordon Rennie's MISSIONARY MAN: Bad Moon Rising was a book whose art I loved years before I knew Frank Quitely's name. And Shimura! That's a deep cut bro, I read those stories when they appeared in 2000AD but completely forgot which character they featured until you just mentioned it - I'm gonna go look for a collected edition now!

Ditto Endless Nights which I haven't read in a while - Quitely provided a painted story for that one? Time for a re-read!


message 9: by XenofoneX (last edited Nov 01, 2015 04:44AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

XenofoneX Yeah, I hunted those 2000AD collections down a few years ago, and they were harder to find. I know new editions are available.

I've been a Quitely fan for years; Flex Mentallo blew my eyeballs out, more than any book since Hardboiled by Geof Darrow. I loved Darrows art enough to buy Big Damn Hardboiled and King-Sized Big Guy & Rusty the Boy Robot way back around 1999, when I was still a broke student. They were massive over-sized B&W showcases sans speech bubbles and captions, about 12"W x 16"H, the old-school equivalent the IDW Artists Editions. Something like that for all of Quitely's early work and the best of the new would be great.

And yeah, Quitely does a simple, 8-page story for Destiny that is full-painted comic-art perfection. It's subtle, and very beautiful. Miguelanxa Prado and Milo Manara are fucking super-stars, but... IMO, Quitely Quietly Qilled It.


message 10: by Sam (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sam Quixote awesome, just ordered a copy of hondo-city justice - can't wait to re-read it after all this time!


XenofoneX Nice! It's beautiful stuff. I've got the older Shimura collection (from when DC was publishing TPB collections of 2000AD material); it has about 40 painted pages by Quitely, and art from other 2000AD vets like Andy Clarke. I'm kind of assuming Hondo City has the same material.


message 12: by Drew (new) - rated it 3 stars

Drew Canole Thanks for the heads up. I didn't know about this one. I love Quitely.


back to top