ŷ

Sara's Reviews > The Siege

The Siege by Helen Dunmore
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
5512657
I didn't understand until now. My eyes fill with tears, and I don't know why. But I know that it's by these things, and nothing else, that we survive. Poetry doesn't exist to make life beautiful. Poetry is life itself.

The Siege is the story of a Russian family trapped in Leningrad in the long siege by Nazi troops that took place between September 8, 1941 and January 27, 1944. The book covers the first year of the siege, including the first relentless winter. I knew, of course, that the Germans had attacked Russia and that German soldiers paid a huge price for that error, but I had no idea that it lasted for over two years and had truly given no thought to what it was like for those being blockaded behind the line.

The story revolves around Anna, a young woman in her early twenties, who is already raising her younger brother because her mother has died giving him life. Her father is a writer, who is out of favor in Stalin’s Russia. An actress, also out-of-favor, a tough red-head who becomes Anna’s friend, and a young doctor named Andrei round out the cast of characters. The details we are given regarding the effects of the winter and the absence of food make the suffering palpable.

It is hard, indeed, to imagine how anyone endures the hardships and keeps their sanity.

Anna doesn't like going past the park anymore. There are people sitting on benches, swathed in snow, planted like bulbs to wait for spring. They stay there day after day. No one comes to take them away.

One of the things history does is inform us. The past can be a warning to the future, for it has that uncanny way of repeating itself if you dare to forget the lesson it has offered you. The moment you say, “this cannot happen to us�, it might.

Pre-Covid, this might have just read like a World War II history, but post-Covid, when I got to the section where Dunmore began to talk about the city, the danger, the complacency of the people, who had always been supplied and believed they could not be completely without, I shivered with a sense that history was talking to me, directly.

Suddenly and sharply, it's obvious that cities only exist because everyone agrees to let them exist. It's crazy, when you think of it, for millions of mouths to pack themselves into a couple of hundred square kilometers, without a pig or a potato patch between them.

I fear cities are even less self-sufficient these days.

For city people it is hard to grasp that the supply chain is broken. It’s kept them going all their lives, even though the system sometimes dissolves into chaos, and prices go up and down like an undertaker's hat.

I think about how crazy people went when they thought there was going to be a shortage of toilet paper. Imagine being rationed to two pieces of bread a day—total.

This book is as tactile as a book can get. I smelled the stale breath, felt the cold, tasted the jars of jam and wedges of honey they so carefully hoarded, heard the cries of the hungry babies, and saw the hanging flesh and gaunt faces. It is a story of hardship, but it is also a story of sacrifice and survival and transcendent love.

What a remarkable way to begin a new year of reading.

62 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Siege.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

November 6, 2015 – Shelved as: to-read
November 6, 2015 – Shelved
November 23, 2018 – Shelved as: waiting-in-line
November 10, 2019 – Shelved as: waiting-physical
January 1, 2022 – Started Reading
January 1, 2022 –
page 34
11.56% "love her writing:

"The sun is hot now, and under the canopy of irs the air is warm, resinous and sleepy. You could lie down her, with your head on a cushion of pine-needles, where the tree' roots arch above the forest floor like arthritic fingers playing the piano."

How beautifully descriptive!

Life in Stalin's Russia is all fear."
January 1, 2022 –
page 34
11.56% "Everyone Anna has ever drawn has been nervous at first. Perhaps they are afraid that she will prise out hidden things, and put them down on paper for everyone to see. But Anna would say that the portraits don't work like that. They're not about exposure, they're about recognition."
January 2, 2022 –
page 35
11.9% "If only she'd known at the time how important every detail of that evening was going to become, Kolya boasting that the trout he'd caught had been this one, the fatter of the two. Her father, sunburnt and relaxed after his day at the lake. The taste of the trout."
January 2, 2022 –
page 53
18.03% "There are two realities now. There are summer trees, flights of startled birds, the smell of honeysuckle in the depths of the night. This is the old reality, as smooth as the handle of a favorite cup in your hand. And then there's the new reality which consists of hour after hour of digging, and seconds of terror as sharp as the zig-zag of lightning. Lightning that's looking for you, seeking out warm flesh..."
January 2, 2022 –
page 68
23.13% "She could not separate out her feelings for Marina Petrovna, or decide which to trust. Was Marina generous, or self-interested? Was she manipulating Anna, or trying to help her? But you couldn't listen to her voice and disbelieve her. That came from her training perhaps. She was an actress."
January 3, 2022 –
page 82
27.89% "What he loved most was the sound of the wind, moving softly over the face of the earth, stirring the grasses and delicate fronds of summer moss. ... There's nothing like that in Leningrad, here the wind is funnelled down avenues of stone. It blows dust into your eyes, and the air tastes as if it's been breathed before, hundred of times, by hundreds of people."
January 3, 2022 –
page 82
27.89% "I have taken as immediate a liking to Alexei as Anna has."
January 4, 2022 –
page 126
42.86% "Yes, but I can go away. Real Leningraders can't. Wherever they are, no matter how beautiful it is, no matter how happy they are, they're always pining to be back. They can't live without a cold in their head, and someone's boot on their neck."
January 4, 2022 –
page 130
44.22% ""We'll be fine," she says. "You'll see Misha, it'll all be all right, as long as you don't ever believe that your're going to be beaten.""
January 4, 2022 –
page 132
44.9% "But in a strange way a state of perpetual shortages can make you feel secure. You believe that because things are bad enough, they won't get any worse."
January 4, 2022 –
page 143
48.64% "I had not thought about the plight of the zoo animals when a city is being bombed.

"I didn't understand until now. My eyes fill with tears, and I don't know why. But I know that it's by these things, and nothing else, that we survive. Poetry doesn't exist to make life beautiful. Poetry is life itself.""
January 4, 2022 –
page 145
49.32% "For city people it is hard to grasp that the supply chain is broken. Its kept them going all their lives, even though the system sometimes dissolves into chaos, and prices go up and down like an undertaker's hat."
January 4, 2022 –
page 146
49.66% "Suddenly and sharply, it's obvious that cities only exist because everyone agrees to let them exist. It's crazy, when you think of it, for millions of mouths to pack themselves into a couple of hundred square kilometres, without a pig or a potato patch between them."
January 4, 2022 –
page 225
76.53% "Anna doesn't like going past the park anymore. There are people sitting on benches, swathed in snow, planted like bulbs to wait for spring. They stay there day after day. No one comes to take them away."
January 4, 2022 – Shelved as: death
January 4, 2022 – Shelved as: historical-fiction
January 4, 2022 – Shelved as: literary-fiction
January 4, 2022 – Shelved as: more-than-5-stars
January 4, 2022 – Shelved as: russia
January 4, 2022 – Shelved as: war
January 4, 2022 – Shelved as: women-writers
January 4, 2022 – Shelved as: world-war-2
January 4, 2022 – Finished Reading
January 13, 2022 – Shelved as: 2022-aty-challenge

Comments Showing 1-33 of 33 (33 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Tricia (new)

Tricia Great review- I read The Siege and The Betrayal ages ago and recall how powerful they were.


Sara I have put The Betrayal in line for next month, Tricia. This one was exactly that--Powerful!


Connie  G I'm so glad you suggested this book for a Classics buddy read, Sara. I loved Helen Dunmore's writing!


message 4: by Sara (last edited Jan 04, 2022 08:51PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sara Thanks, Connie, so did I. I have had this sitting on my physical bookshelf for almost five years. This is the year I read all these books I was so anxious to read that I went out and bought them!

So grateful to all of you for reading it with me.


message 5: by Diane (new) - added it

Diane Barnes One of my (tentative) reading resolutions was to concentrate on the books on my physical shelves this year. I have you to thank for breaking that early on. I have to add this.


message 6: by Zoeytron (new)

Zoeytron I've just read two 5-star reviews of this and couldn't wait to add it to my list. Some of the parallels you draw are truly chilling, and sadly, right on point. Exceptional review, Sara.


Sara Diane wrote: "One of my (tentative) reading resolutions was to concentrate on the books on my physical shelves this year. I have you to thank for breaking that early on. I have to add this."

I have resigned myself to it, Diane. I can stop reading reviews and stop adding books, or I can keep reading reviews and finding books I cannot afford to miss. Resolutions are made to be broken. :0)


Sara Zoeytron wrote: "I've just read two 5-star reviews of this and couldn't wait to add it to my list. Some of the parallels you draw are truly chilling, and sadly, right on point. Exceptional review, Sara."

Great book and more timely than I had expected. Thanks, Zoey.


message 9: by Chris (new)

Chris Terrific review!


message 10: by Sara (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sara Chris wrote: "Terrific review!"

Thank you so much, Chris. I hope the rest of my 2022 reads can live up to the standard this one has set.


message 11: by Antoinette (new) - added it

Antoinette Magnificent review, Sara. Only way I can describe it. I really wanted to join the buddy read and my library does not have it. May have to sneak it on kindle if it’s available. I have been banned from buying books after all the books I acquired in London and Bath in December. 🤣


message 12: by Sara (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sara Thank you so much! I do hope you are able to get a copy. It is worth the effort. I am green because I would love to have books acquired in London and Bath!


message 13: by Sue (new) - added it

Sue K H Beautiful review, Sara. The quote you shared about cities is chilling and too familiar. I hate that I had to miss this one. Maybe someday my library will get it or there will be a Kindle version. I may brake down and buy a hard copy at some point if I can bring myself to purge my overstuffed shelves!


message 14: by Sara (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sara I'm sorry you weren't able to get a copy, Sue. Frustrating! Do read it when the opportunity presents itself. I found myself thinking about this in a much different way than I had expected.


Kathleen What a superb review, Sara. Palpable--yes! I love the quotes you chose, particularly that first one. And your thoughts on our current situation are so pertinent. Much to consider in this gripping read, and I'm glad you got so much out of it.


message 16: by Mike (new)

Mike Wonderfully reviewed, Sara!!


message 17: by Sara (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sara Kathleen wrote: "What a superb review, Sara. Palpable--yes! I love the quotes you chose, particularly that first one. And your thoughts on our current situation are so pertinent. Much to consider in this gripping r..."

Thanks so much, Kathleen.


message 18: by Sara (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sara Mike wrote: "Wonderfully reviewed, Sara!!"

Thanks, Mike.


message 19: by Anna (new)

Anna Such a thoughtful review Sara. It seems to me that this could be one of those books that induces thoughts and impressions far beyond its scope.
You are so right in that ”One of the things history does is inform us. The past can be a warning to the future, for it has that uncanny way of repeating itself if you dare to forget the lesson it has offered.� That thought has occurred to me too, but I have an impression that its lessons are only too often dismissed as implausible because the circumstances of the past events do not exactly mirror the present.
It is as if to say that we never have to worry about food shortages again, unless the Germans were to siege Leningrad again�
But history never repeats itself exactly, and this is not the way that lessons are learned, and as you say, Covid is a small but chilling remainder of that.
Great review Sara!


message 20: by Sara (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sara Thank you, Anna, for such a measured response. It is as if to say that we never have to worry about food shortages again, unless the Germans were to siege Leningrad again�. Ah, that is it in a nutshell. We are so short-sighted.

Another thing I feel (and wonder about) is whether we have softened ourselves to the point that we cannot survive as well. Are we less mentally and physically tough? Do our ancestors just seem a lot stronger because we are seeing them facing difficulties we have never been asked to endure? Will we prove to be just as strong if calamity visits us?

I love a book, like this one, that invites me to think about something very important long after the read is over.


message 21: by Kevin (new)

Kevin Ansbro You are so right about cities being less self-sufficient these days, Sara.
Anything that stops the movement of freight seems to stop people's ability to fend for themselves in the meantime! : )
Excellent review!


message 22: by Laysee (new)

Laysee What a remarkable review, Sara! You evoked the hardship of the seige the Russians experienced in such a visceral fashion I was moved. Loved your comparisons of life then and life now. Much food for thought. Thank you!


message 23: by Sara (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sara Kevin wrote: "You are so right about cities being less self-sufficient these days, Sara.
Anything that stops the movement of freight seems to stop people's ability to fend for themselves in the meantime! : )
Ex..."


It is frightening how little self-sufficiency we have now. We are dependent upon an entire global apparatus. Almost makes you long for the days of Davy Crockett...well, almost.


message 24: by Sara (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sara Laysee wrote: "What a remarkable review, Sara! You evoked the hardship of the seige the Russians experienced in such a visceral fashion I was moved. Loved your comparisons of life then and life now. Much food for..."

Thanks so much, Laysee. I was amazed how often I thought "this could be us" while reading this historical account, and no war required to get us there.


message 25: by Anna (new)

Anna Sara wrote: "Thank you, Anna, for such a measured response. It is as if to say that we never have to worry about food shortages again, unless the Germans were to siege Leningrad again�. Ah, that is it in a nuts..."

That’s a good question Sara, I guess to an extent you don’t have to be strong, unless you have to� so whoever knows? Let’s hope we will not have to find out. But in the times when we specialize more and more and move further and further away from self-sufficiency, if things would change and we would have to survive without the chain of others that deliver to us what we need to survive, my feeling is that our chances are slim� even if we do have the will and strength - which is a whole other question�


Anne Sara, I had to hunt down your review. It never showed up on my feed. Glad you told me that you'd written a review, and what a thoughtful review it is. So glad you loved it. Unfortunately, the Russians were more practiced at deprivation than are we, spoiled 21st C. Americans.


message 27: by Sara (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sara Anna wrote: "Sara wrote: "Thank you, Anna, for such a measured response. It is as if to say that we never have to worry about food shortages again, unless the Germans were to siege Leningrad again�. Ah, that is..."

The box we have backed ourselves into is smaller than theirs, I think.


message 28: by Sara (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sara Anne (On semi-hiatus) wrote: "Sara, I had to hunt down your review. It never showed up on my feed. Glad you told me that you'd written a review, and what a thoughtful review it is. So glad you loved it. Unfortunately, the Russi..."

So glad you took the time to find it, Anne. Thank you. I can certainly see that we have lost a lot of the knowledge that we would need for survival. My parents were much better equipped mentally to handle a survival situation, I think, and would have had a much better idea of what needed to be done and how to do it.

I enjoy reading good dystopia, but this was in many ways more frightening because it was face-to-face with reality and I knew I would come up short.


Lori  Keeton Wonderful and accurate review, Sara. I grew up learning how to can our garden’s bounty and make preserves and all. But I don’t have the skill to do it now. You’re speculations about city dwellers is sadly true.


Terry Great review, Sara! I was also taken by the quote about cities and how they are structured on dependency. And then, hunger is still a problem throughout the world, right now in Afghanistan where the entire country faces famine and a cold winter. This book was a very powerful story that I am so glad we read!


Graeme Waymark I have read many a novel and even more reviews. I have never copied a review until I read yours. I didn’t change a word…I simply copied and pasted. Sara, your review was amazing!


Graeme Waymark What I find unsettling about today, May 2022 is that Putin is subjecting Ukrainian people to similar deprivation and siege conditions as was done to his parents by an ‘enemy� of Russia at the time. The Ukrainian citizen has always been closer to the Russian people than most others and yet like WWII, it is not the people who are evil. It is the leader: Hitler and Putin both, “natzified� the conflict that they caused! The irony hurts all civilized persons and threatens any advancement in civilization over the last century.


message 33: by Jim (new) - added it

Jim Puskas Wow!
What a great review!
I must go and look for this book. I think I'm ready to read it now.


back to top