ŷ

Jeff 's Reviews > Batman: Arkham Asylum - A Serious House on Serious Earth

Batman by Grant Morrison
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
12618229
's review

it was ok
bookshelves: comix

The Caped Crusader with footnotes!?!

or Art for Art’s Sake.

or Holy Histrionics, Batman, I’d rather have listened to an opera�

Grant Morrison gets “serious� � it’s even mentioned in the title twice in case you need a reminder � and if Carrot Top wants to star in a remake of Death of a Salesman or Billy Joel wants to write a concerto for flugelhorn and triangle, I don’t want to hear about it.



Wait, Jeff, did you say footnotes?

Yes, Goodreader, this is why I love you, because nothing ever gets by you. Nothing.

This is the 25th anniversary edition of the publishing of this pretentious pile of crap, so we get Morrison’s script tacked onto the actual comic. The script includes footnotes because Mr. Morrison wants to share each and every pop culture allusion and Easter egg that he’s cleverly included for us.

The script actually came in handy, because I could actually read what The Joker was trying to say, but shuffling back and forth between the comic and an addendum quickly wore thin.



A plot summary: The inmates at Arkham take control of the asylum because it’s Tuesday and demand that Batman pay them a visit, because they love him so so much and want to cuddle and spoon and eat Toll House cookie dough real fast, which is a good thing because this isn’t take-control-of-the-situation-with-a-few-well-placed-bat-flash-gernades-and-a-couple-of-kidney-punches-and-or-batarang-or-two-to-the-dome Batman, this is Emo-boy-Mr.-Feels-Kyle-Raynor-is-my-psychic-twin Batman, so let’s brood, shall we?

Therapy seems to work wonders for a few of the rogues � yes, Two-Face flip a coin pick a card to see if you can scratch your ass.



The rest:

Mad Hatter:



Stop spouting drivel and take a tranquilizer!

Clayface:



He’s seen better days.

Idea: Bats, shove him into a kiln and present him to Alfred as a big ashtray or something. You can put him between the dinosaur and the big penny.

Did I mention that the asylum is haunted because the Arkham’s were a bunch of loons or the Arkham’s were a bunch of loons because the original house was haunted?

No? Sorry.



Bottom line: The art is purty, but then so was Where’s Waldo? And with Where’s Waldo you didn’t have to work as hard to find the player(s).



Another word association? Ready?

This book…………………�.Crap.
89 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Batman.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

December 7, 2015 – Shelved
December 10, 2015 – Started Reading
December 11, 2015 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-40 of 40 (40 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Paul I cannot wait to see how much you hate this one... :-)


Jeff This one's too easy...


message 3: by Anne (new) - rated it 1 star

Anne Told ja. This suuuuuuuucks!
Fantastic review!


message 4: by Paul (last edited Dec 11, 2015 06:26AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Paul Oh, how I loathe self-congratulatory footnotes. We get it, already! I'm glad I don't have this edition.


Jeff Anne wrote: "Told ja. This suuuuuuuucks!
Fantastic review!"


You wuz right, Anne! Awful!

Thanks, buddy!


Jeff Paul wrote: "Oh, how I loathe self-congratulatory footnotes. We get it, already! I'm glad I don't have this edition."

The footnotes literally took up two thirds of this volume.

Here's your cookie, Morrison, go away.


Lono Time for a re-read. I do remember being especially into the art. Really don't remember much about the story actually.


message 8: by Anne (new) - rated it 1 star

Anne Lono wrote: "Time for a re-read. I do remember being especially into the art. Really don't remember much about the story actually."

Because there was NONE.


message 9: by carol. (new)

carol. did you say footnotes???




Jeff Sundry Batfootnotes per page. Morrison footnotes everything and sucked any fun or interest right out of this sucker. Nobody but yer Mum cares that Maxi Zeus's line is an extrapolation from Guard #2's bit in Timon of Athens or that you were listening to "Pictures of Matchstick Men" a thousand times while you wrote this. Again except maybe your Mum.


Sandee is Reading I just finished this, after reading it a few months ago... Damn. It started out interesting for me. The thing that bothered me, wasn't really the story, it's more of how they told the story. If it was just the script I read, I would have liked it more. The weirdly placed panels and unbearably annoying transitions from past to present put me off... I just... it gave me a headache in to summarize it. I'm still trying to find the right words to put my review up for this...


Jeff BlueLilyxLilyBlue wrote: "I just finished this, after reading it a few months ago... Damn. It started out interesting for me. The thing that bothered me, wasn't really the story, it's more of how they told the story. If it ..."

I don't mind the "artsy-fartsy" approach at times, but this one left me with a headache as well. Morrison's head was way up his behind here.


message 13: by Anne (new) - rated it 1 star

Anne God. I had a headache too. Too trippy.


Jeff Trippy with footnotes...


message 15: by Anne (new) - rated it 1 star

Anne Yes. Because that's what we all LOOOOVE about comics. The footnotes. :/


message 16: by Trish (new)

Trish The art doesn't look too bad but apparently that couldn't save it. So sorry.


message 17: by Paul (new) - rated it 5 stars

Paul 'Doesn't look too bad'? It's Dave McKean!

I'm sorry, Mr. McKean, sir; I shall burn these heretics at the stake immediately.


message 18: by Trish (new)

Trish Bwahahahahaha. So that's why it looked familiar. ;)

I've read Gaiman's Black Orchid where he did the art as well as Black Dog and The Graveyard Book. So yeah, I know the guy (sort of) and obviously like his art.


message 19: by Anne (new) - rated it 1 star

Anne Hahahaha! Ick.


message 20: by Trish (new)

Trish "Ick"???


jenn *mother of a dragon* The pictures in this review gave me the heebee-jeebees.


message 22: by Anne (new) - rated it 1 star

Anne Trish wrote: ""Ick"???"

Ick. Hate the headache inducing art.
*runs from Paul*


message 23: by Trish (new)

Trish Anne wrote: "Trish wrote: ""Ick"???"

Ick. Hate the headache inducing art.
*runs from Paul*"


Bwahahahaha. I actually like it. Not as much as in Black Dog but I still like it.
*helps Anne to hide*


message 24: by Paul (new) - rated it 5 stars

Paul Well, this was very early work. He's had lots of years to practice between Arkham and Black Dog.


message 25: by Paul (last edited Mar 15, 2017 10:38AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Paul Not that I think the boring-DC-house-style-lovers would prefer his newer stuff. >runs from Anne<


message 26: by Trish (new)

Trish *whispers to Paul*
She loves Aquaman. #enoughsaid


message 27: by Paul (new) - rated it 5 stars

Paul Damnit, Trish! You had to mention the fish guy! Now I'm gonna have to go back into witness protection again!


message 28: by Trish (new)

Trish BWAHAHAHAHAHAHA!


It really does pay off to be a villain.


message 29: by Kuroi (new)

Kuroi See Morrison, this is why we have the Harvard style of referencing, because it interrupts your comic books less when there are parentheses in the speech bubbles.
Footnotes my foot.


Sud666 Krishna- my regards for knowing, and aptly applying, the Harvard reference style :)


Jeff Krishna *is a savvy evil overlord* wrote: "See Morrison, this is why we have the Harvard style of referencing, because it interrupts your comic books less when there are parentheses in the speech bubbles.
Footnotes my foot."


Harvard! Ooo-la-la! Way to go all scholarly in this thread.


message 32: by Trish (new)

Trish Well, SOMEONE had to give it a bit of an intelligent touch, and it sure as hell wasn't you, Anne or me. ;P


message 33: by Anne (new) - rated it 1 star

Anne Are you actually attracting intelligent-talk to your threads, Jeff? Oh, how the mighty have fallen...

#leaveaquamanalone #psychoshowerscene
#mydronescantargetyou #fisharepeopletoo


Jeff You forgot a couple...

#neednewfreezerbutwentlookingforpornoncraigslistinstead
#smellygothdrummergirlsrus
#dreamingofandrewmccarthy
#beardkidsforfreecomix


message 35: by Trish (new)

Trish Anne wrote: "#mydronescantargetyou"

Oh please! You programmed them! Between that and your eyesight (though your irises are so PRETTY), I wouldn't be worried at all if I were Jeff.


message 36: by Kuroi (new)

Kuroi Sud666 wrote: "Krishna- my regards for knowing, and aptly applying, the Harvard reference style :)"

Haha, I live to serve.

Anne, they won't know what hit them.

#sendsharkstoeattheaquahaters
#fishequality


message 37: by Gary (new) - added it

Gary M I just finished reading this 25th Anniversary one. I thought I had a nice thick Batman book to read until I was about half way through and I noticed the page colours in the second half were white. So I had a look. No way was I going to read any of that. The book itself was ok.


Jeff Yep. It had some interesting elements.

As per the expanded-ness of this edition: Did readers really want to get that far into the head of Grant Morrison?


Andres Wholly disagree.


Sarah this is my first read, i just started, and the artwork is interesting, but it is most certainly not my cup of tea.


back to top