Lizzy's Reviews > The Lover
The Lover
by
by

Lizzy's review
bookshelves: classics-literay-fiction, read-years-ago, favorites-of-all-times, stars-5
Dec 17, 2015
bookshelves: classics-literay-fiction, read-years-ago, favorites-of-all-times, stars-5
Read 2 times. Last read September 19, 2016.
I opened the first page of Marguerite Duras� The Lover, and there she was, the girl with no name with all her ancient reminiscences. I heard her voice as if it were inside my head, Very early in my life it was too late. It was already too late when I was eighteen. How did you get there, my friend? Or should I call you my sister, since from the beginning I discovered we shared anguishes and most certainly a great multitude of passions and dreams?
We both were introduced to this world by tortured mothers, who experienced this deep despondency about living. Sometimes it lasted, sometimes it would vanish with the dark. But their desperation was thoroughly heartfelt, for what can a daughter do when facing a mother desperate with a despair so unalloyed that sometimes even life’s happiness, at its most poignant, couldn’t make them forget it. We daughters recognize them effortlessly as the awkward way she holds herself, the way she doesn’t smile. That image of our mothers certainly stayed with both of us for life, my friend. But what can we do, but go on living? I glance outside, and the wind is speeding like my heart is beating, faster and faster, bum, bum, bum, as I get to know you.
But suddenly my mind gets back inside. Yes, I was also there when you met the nameless man while crossing the river going back to Saigon with a storm blowing inside the water. I will never forget how you looked at our first meeting, my friend, wearing a dress of real silk, the famous pair of gold lame high heels and a man’s flat-brimmed hat, a brownish-pink fedora with a broad black ribbon. I have to agree with you, The crucial ambiguity of the image lies in the hat. You were only fifteen and a half, but wearing powder to camouflage the freckles and your mother’s lipstick. He was elegant, not a white man but wearing European clothes. Again I remember myself, walking hand in hand with a 26-year-old man when I was just sixteen. Our experiences seem to mimic each other, don’t you think? But while I had two fine sisters, you had two wild brothers that would never do anything.
Going back to your nameless young man, as you told me he got out of the limousine and is smoking an English cigarette. He looks at you in the man’s fedora and the gold shoes. He slowly comes over to you. He doesn’t smile to begin with. He’s obviously nervous. Was it so easy to get into this man’s car, dear friend? I don’t know if I would have had the courage or the temerity. That’s a clue that even though sisters, we are inherently different. And he presented himself, I was thin and soft and naïve, even though I had just returned from two years in Paris. I was still a boy, at 28. I’m sure I would have continued as a boy, unless I met you. And you simply got into his car. The door shuts. A barely discernible distress suddenly seized you, weariness, the light over the river dims, but only slightly. Everywhere, too, there’s a very slight dearness, or fog.
Further memories of those times we shared during one of our meetings, comes running back to me. It is as if I was there with you, peeping into your afternoons. At first he looks at you as though he expects you to speak, but you don’t. He says he loves you madly, says it very softly. Then is silent. You don’t answer. You could say you don’t love him. You say nothing. But you did not stop at that, no, you said, I’d rather you didn’t love me. But if you do, I’d like you to do as you usually do with women. He looked at you in horror, asked, Is that what you want? You said it is. He says he knows already you’ll never love him. Then you let him say it. You were a cool one, weren't you?
I look out the window, and now it’s raining like if it was going to drown us, hiding the sun shining at me. It's dark inside, for nothing could be harder than remembering those times. We who are now almost old ladies, at least well into our mature years. On top of my supposed wisdom, I wonder what is it so mysterious about being a woman. As a matter of fact, I often asked myself that before meeting my first lover at sixteen. Yes, I was some months older than you. Not that it would have made any difference if I could envision what and where that would lead me to. As you said some women just wait, they dress just for the sake of dressing. They look at themselves, dream of romance. long days of waiting. Some of them go mad. Some are ditched. You can hear the word hit them, hear the sound of the blow. Some kill themselves. But that was never us; please tell me so. But why could we expect to be different? Did you ever think you might have known, but forgot to tell me? Suddenly inspiration hits me, and I know how we saved ourselves despite our mothers. Do you still remember what you said, some time ago? I think you might have forgotten, let me remind you: it’s so simple, it was the writing that saved us! You told me how it all started,
I want to write. I’ve already told my mother. That’s what I want to do–write. No answer the first time. Then she asks, Write what? I say, Books, novels. She says grimly, when you’ve got your math degree you can write if you like, it won’t be anything to do with me then. She’s against it, it’s not worthy, it’s not real work, it’s nonsense. Later she said, A childish idea.
I answered that what I wanted more than anything else in the world was to write, nothing else but that, nothing. Jealous. She’s jealous. No answer, just a quick glance immediately averted, a slight shrug, unforgettable. I’ll be the first to leave.
I also write, although nobody knows, I am not famous after all. But it saved me nonetheless. But you tried to hide it from me. It’s ok; I forgive you, my friend. But I remember so well what you said once, I’ve never written, though I thought I wrote, never loved, though I thought I loved, never done anything but wait outside the closed door.
So many years have passed us by, leaving their ignoble scars; but we still reminisce all that went when we were almost children. Yes, you told me I can still see his face, and I do remember the name. The name you forgot to tell me. Indeed, it’s a place of distress, shipwrecked. And your mother, that went on living even after you left her. Let’s leave your brothers and my sisters for another talk, please. Or what you told me happened in Paris. Or my years in London and New York. Let’s leave the rest for another time, for I know with a certainty that goes deep into my bones, that we will meet again. Until then!
__
Notes
1. All quotes are in italics;
2. I took the liberty to change some pronouns to fit the flow of the writing in some quotes; so sometimes it will read 'you' where it was 'her.'
We both were introduced to this world by tortured mothers, who experienced this deep despondency about living. Sometimes it lasted, sometimes it would vanish with the dark. But their desperation was thoroughly heartfelt, for what can a daughter do when facing a mother desperate with a despair so unalloyed that sometimes even life’s happiness, at its most poignant, couldn’t make them forget it. We daughters recognize them effortlessly as the awkward way she holds herself, the way she doesn’t smile. That image of our mothers certainly stayed with both of us for life, my friend. But what can we do, but go on living? I glance outside, and the wind is speeding like my heart is beating, faster and faster, bum, bum, bum, as I get to know you.
But suddenly my mind gets back inside. Yes, I was also there when you met the nameless man while crossing the river going back to Saigon with a storm blowing inside the water. I will never forget how you looked at our first meeting, my friend, wearing a dress of real silk, the famous pair of gold lame high heels and a man’s flat-brimmed hat, a brownish-pink fedora with a broad black ribbon. I have to agree with you, The crucial ambiguity of the image lies in the hat. You were only fifteen and a half, but wearing powder to camouflage the freckles and your mother’s lipstick. He was elegant, not a white man but wearing European clothes. Again I remember myself, walking hand in hand with a 26-year-old man when I was just sixteen. Our experiences seem to mimic each other, don’t you think? But while I had two fine sisters, you had two wild brothers that would never do anything.
Going back to your nameless young man, as you told me he got out of the limousine and is smoking an English cigarette. He looks at you in the man’s fedora and the gold shoes. He slowly comes over to you. He doesn’t smile to begin with. He’s obviously nervous. Was it so easy to get into this man’s car, dear friend? I don’t know if I would have had the courage or the temerity. That’s a clue that even though sisters, we are inherently different. And he presented himself, I was thin and soft and naïve, even though I had just returned from two years in Paris. I was still a boy, at 28. I’m sure I would have continued as a boy, unless I met you. And you simply got into his car. The door shuts. A barely discernible distress suddenly seized you, weariness, the light over the river dims, but only slightly. Everywhere, too, there’s a very slight dearness, or fog.
Further memories of those times we shared during one of our meetings, comes running back to me. It is as if I was there with you, peeping into your afternoons. At first he looks at you as though he expects you to speak, but you don’t. He says he loves you madly, says it very softly. Then is silent. You don’t answer. You could say you don’t love him. You say nothing. But you did not stop at that, no, you said, I’d rather you didn’t love me. But if you do, I’d like you to do as you usually do with women. He looked at you in horror, asked, Is that what you want? You said it is. He says he knows already you’ll never love him. Then you let him say it. You were a cool one, weren't you?
I look out the window, and now it’s raining like if it was going to drown us, hiding the sun shining at me. It's dark inside, for nothing could be harder than remembering those times. We who are now almost old ladies, at least well into our mature years. On top of my supposed wisdom, I wonder what is it so mysterious about being a woman. As a matter of fact, I often asked myself that before meeting my first lover at sixteen. Yes, I was some months older than you. Not that it would have made any difference if I could envision what and where that would lead me to. As you said some women just wait, they dress just for the sake of dressing. They look at themselves, dream of romance. long days of waiting. Some of them go mad. Some are ditched. You can hear the word hit them, hear the sound of the blow. Some kill themselves. But that was never us; please tell me so. But why could we expect to be different? Did you ever think you might have known, but forgot to tell me? Suddenly inspiration hits me, and I know how we saved ourselves despite our mothers. Do you still remember what you said, some time ago? I think you might have forgotten, let me remind you: it’s so simple, it was the writing that saved us! You told me how it all started,
I want to write. I’ve already told my mother. That’s what I want to do–write. No answer the first time. Then she asks, Write what? I say, Books, novels. She says grimly, when you’ve got your math degree you can write if you like, it won’t be anything to do with me then. She’s against it, it’s not worthy, it’s not real work, it’s nonsense. Later she said, A childish idea.
I answered that what I wanted more than anything else in the world was to write, nothing else but that, nothing. Jealous. She’s jealous. No answer, just a quick glance immediately averted, a slight shrug, unforgettable. I’ll be the first to leave.
I also write, although nobody knows, I am not famous after all. But it saved me nonetheless. But you tried to hide it from me. It’s ok; I forgive you, my friend. But I remember so well what you said once, I’ve never written, though I thought I wrote, never loved, though I thought I loved, never done anything but wait outside the closed door.
So many years have passed us by, leaving their ignoble scars; but we still reminisce all that went when we were almost children. Yes, you told me I can still see his face, and I do remember the name. The name you forgot to tell me. Indeed, it’s a place of distress, shipwrecked. And your mother, that went on living even after you left her. Let’s leave your brothers and my sisters for another talk, please. Or what you told me happened in Paris. Or my years in London and New York. Let’s leave the rest for another time, for I know with a certainty that goes deep into my bones, that we will meet again. Until then!
__
Notes
1. All quotes are in italics;
2. I took the liberty to change some pronouns to fit the flow of the writing in some quotes; so sometimes it will read 'you' where it was 'her.'
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
The Lover.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
Finished Reading
December 17, 2015
– Shelved
December 17, 2015
– Shelved as:
classics-literay-fiction
Started Reading
September 19, 2016
– Shelved as:
read-years-ago
September 19, 2016
–
Finished Reading
October 5, 2016
– Shelved as:
favorites-of-all-times
October 5, 2016
– Shelved as:
stars-5
Comments Showing 1-50 of 58 (58 new)
message 1:
by
Dolors
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Sep 19, 2016 08:46AM

reply
|
flag

I hope you have patience, Dolors, I have a backlog of recently read to review! But I will let you know when I do.


I'm still figuring it out, Jeffrey! Beautiful but sad. It's not easy to have lived so much at such an early age. She might have lost part of her innocence, but seems to have gained enough to break up with a difficult family life. However, we can't forget she wrote it so later in her life. And her mother... As I said, I'm still reviewing it in my head.
Thanks for the tip on the movie, I didn't see it yet. Maybe later. By the way, I loved your review. As always wonderful and insightful, Jeffrey!

Please take your time though."
While I'm readingThe Portrait of a Lady, I let my feelings on The Lover sink in, and my ideas start to emerge. But I'm still not there... Thanks. L.


Very nice to read your words first thing in the morning, Bianca. Thanks. Never watched the movie, now I really want to. L.

David wrote: "Whew, great, wonderful."
@Adina & @David: Thanks, dear friends. I am glad you liked my exchanges with this no-name girl. I thoroughly enjoyed writing it. L.

V..."
I remember it was considered quite scandalous, 24 years ago.

The thing I learned was...I could get away with it and most everybody liked it. When you write as many reviews as I do a year you have to do some things differently from time to time.
You are a courageous woman certainly more courageous than I've ever been with a review. There you are peeking between the lines of every paragraph. Your uncertainty. Your fragileness lends emotional weight to every aspect of this review. I bet you were something something at 16. :-) Just like you are something something now!
The hardest part of review writing is writing a review that people can't help but read. I struggle with a preponderance of information, or obscure references that made me chuckle with recognition, but means absolutely nothing to most other people. You've written a compelling review that people can't help, but read. The thoughts must be followed. We look for the bare feet, the bare ankles, maybe a flash of knee, the wind blown hair or a glimpse of that space between the ear and the neck where the very essence of a person resides. There she is...there's the reviewer. Thank you Lizzy, simply marvelous. Kudos to bringing something real to GR.

I suddenly have the need of a cigarette, and I don't even smoke!
A fabulous, personalised review, Lizzy; the restrained passion in your writing precisely mirrors the electric mood of the 'car scene' from the movie version.
I've yet to see the movie, but the excerpt was widely broadcast. The curbed sexual tension between the debonair, linen-suited Chinese (older) man and the precociously beautiful young lady was way more erotic than something that could have been more distastefully conspicuous.
It merely shows them sitting coyly in the back of a classic car trying to ignore their respective gulfs in culture and age.
Polite conversation masks their true feelings and a bumpety-bump ride over a rickety bridge and the timidity of their hands touching speaks volumes.
I understand that the amour in the book is much more understated, but the depth of feeling where one's first love is concerned is almost impossible to cast aside.
A bighearted and stirring review, Lizzy. Bravo!

Oh, you're very good for my ego, dear Jeffrey!
I have to tell you that I did not choose to write it this way; it just grabbed me and did not let me go until I was there together with her. We were one in our pasts, even being so disparate. And I fully enjoyed being there with my new friend. Maybe the fact that I am currently reading Virginia Woolf's To the Lighthouse also helped to inspire me.
I loved how you revealed the reviewer one piece at a time, from feet to the bare ankles and knees, to reach between the ears and neck where her essence resides... It amazes to witness how you have an alluring way with words. It's always a pleasure to read, and I always learn something new with you.
I hope you are right and people cannot help themselves but read my ramblings. The best thing for a writer, even an amateur at that, is to be read.
My most heartfelt thanks. :-) L.

I suddenly have the need of a cigarette, and I don't even smoke!
A fabulous, personalised review, Lizzy; the restrained passion in your writing precisely mirrors the electric mood of the 'ca..."
I hope you don't start smoking just from reading one of my reviews, dear Kevin. But your reaction is rewarding. You probably know how good it is to see your writing so appreciated by someone whose opinion you value.
Like you, I haven't watched the movie yet. But I am curious and hope to do it soon.
Thanks again for your nice words, Kevin. L.

We both were introduced to this world by tortured mothers, who experienced this deep despondency about living
That line reminds me of a book we talked about last week, Lizzy - Hot Milk. I felt at the time you might get more out of it than I did and now I'm certain - my own mother didn't fit that description at all.


What I wrote, Fionnuala, came directly from inside my heart. Duras touched me. You are so right, she always writes looking back at her fifteen year self. I think that's because that time for her was simply arresting and defined what she would be as an adult.
Thanks for reminding me of Hot Milk, you convinced me and I will be adding it to my tbr-list. Above all, thanks for your feedback and your praise. I appreciate it. L.

Such nice words you gift me with, dear Dolors, that I feel recompensated for all the emotion I put in this special review. I do not know even how to thank you. But I do it from my innermost self, it was all worth it. To expose me as I know I did, to feel so much and think of how I could throw it all out there with the insecurity of how it would be received. Thank you, thank you, my dear friend. L.

Thanks so much, dear Vessey! I am very happy you liked it, you know that how much I value your opinion. L.


I was immersed in Duras' recollections as if they were my own, Junta, it really touched me. You put it so well, I felt like I was inside talking to this girl with no name, and listened as she talked to me. Thanks for your nice words, my friend. I appreciate it. Read it and let me know what you think. L.

Oh, dear Sidharth, that is very bad for my ego... Thanks for your very nice words. I really appreciate it. L.

It's very nice when your friends enjoy your reviews, Cheryl! Thanks. L.



Thanks for your nice words, Praj! It certainly deserves a revisit. L.


You made my day with such high praise, my dear Seemita. You are so right, we live many lives through our readings. However I don't know if I was in fact courageous, or I simply wrote what needed to be told. But the most important thing is that I enjoyed writing it. Thanks, L.


You are most welcome and thanks for your kind words, David. You are right, this is a review very close to my heart. I identified so much with Duras in The Lover, that in many passages I felt she was talking about me.... She inspired me. L.

Which in American means I agree with you. :)

Thanks, BlackOxford! I'm glad you enjoyed this review, for it is special to me. L.

thank you for sharing.

thank you for sharing."
I'm glad you liked it. It seems we share our appreciation of this great novel. Thanks. L.