Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Amanda's Reviews > A Discovery of Witches

A Discovery of Witches by Deborah Harkness
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
1219253
's review

did not like it
bookshelves: untumbled-turds, crap, blog, bloodsuckers

In A Discovery of Witches, we clueless humans have no idea that we share our world with witches, vampires and daemons (creatures whose manic bursts of creativity result in some of the world's greatest artistic works). Isn't that exciting? One would certainly think so. So, what kind of shenanigans does this preternatural lot get up to while we live our ordinary lives?

Well . . .

Behold the books that shall be read! Thrill to the revelation that trips to the library will be made time and time again! Gasp as cups of warm tea are made and consumed! Swoon as vampires are repeatedly described as smelling of baked goods! And grip the edge of your seat for the most bizarre yoga-scene in the history of the written word!

That's right, folks. Vampires, witches, and daemons aren't like you and me--in fact, our lives are infinitely more interesting than theirs.

Seriously, what the hell is this? The best I can tell is that it's Twilight for grown-ups. And I can't believe I'm going to say this, but here it goes: Twilight is better. Suddenly vampires playing baseball during thunderstorms seems down right genius compared to vampires attending a supernatural yoga class. You want to drain all the sex appeal right out of your vampiric leading man? Just mention him doing some peculiar yoga move where he seems to be holding himself up vertically from the floor by nothing but his ear.

And then prattle on about how he's cold. And always has his hands stuffed in his charcoal trousers. And gets ridiculously enraged every time someone mentions blood because . . . he . . . might . . . not . . . be . . . able . . . to . . . control . . . himself (despite living a relatively normal life around humans for 1,500 years and seeming to need little in the way of sanguine sustenance). And how he maintains control of himself by always grasping the talisman he wears beneath his some-shade-of-grey sweater. And then have him ply the witch he is inexplicably drawn to with hundreds of bottles of wine and query her as to what every single one tastes like.

Oh, ho! And the witch! Now there's a live wire! Diana Bishop spends her days running, rowing, yoga-ing (?), and reading. Oh, and never using her magic because she wants to be just like us. Well, actually, she does use her magic every now and then, but only when it's really important. Like fixing her washing machine or getting a book off of a really high shelf. But other than that, it's all ixnay on the magic-ay.

At 200 pages in, I decided I couldn't stomach it any more. After all, up to that point, I had already been treated to a baker's dozen of the same basic scene:

--Diana goes to the library

--creatures are there; they pretend to read so they can watch her read all day, but they do so in a really creeptastic and menacing way, man

--Matthew, the vampire, goes to the library and pretends to read so he can watch them watching her watch a book and protect her in case one decides to, oh, I don't know, nick her with a really nasty papercut or something

--Diana and Matthew later go and consume a meal and beverages and talk ad nauseum about food to the point where an epicurean would offer them both a hot cuppa shut the fuck up

--Matthew will get angry with Diana, she'll apologize, and he'll settle his ass down

Round and round they go, where do they stop? Nobody knows! Oh, wait. I do! At the library! It's like freaking Groundhog Day without Bill Murray. And Groundhog Day ain't shit without Bill Murray. And neither is A Discovery of Witches.

When I decided I had a life to live, Matthew was fervently explaining how daemons, witches, and vampires might be going extinct!

To which I can only ask, so what's the problem?

Cross posted at
358 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read A Discovery of Witches.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

February 16, 2011 – Shelved
January 25, 2014 – Started Reading
January 26, 2014 –
page 24
4.05%
January 27, 2014 –
page 89
15.03%
January 29, 2014 –
page 180
30.41%
January 29, 2014 – Finished Reading
January 30, 2014 – Shelved as: untumbled-turds
January 30, 2014 – Shelved as: crap
February 4, 2014 – Shelved as: blog
February 4, 2014 – Shelved as: bloodsuckers

Comments Showing 1-50 of 60 (60 new)


carol. Hey! The only thing I ever recommended about this book is reading the yoga scene for giggles. But I look forward to your thoughts!!!


Amanda Ha! Well, I did consider your "recommendation" as more of a "dare."


message 3: by Trudi (new)

Trudi I love it when you hate a book! It's always such an entertaining treat :)


message 4: by Elizabeth (new)

Elizabeth I guess this one goes on the Do Not Want pile. I tried the first chapter a while back and couldn't take it... but thought I was being wussy. :)


Anne Great review...terribly boring book.


message 6: by Aric (new)

Aric Cushing Great review, and in depth. Not to mention seriously funny.


Amanda Trudi wrote: "I love it when you hate a book! It's always such an entertaining treat :)"

It's been a while since I've been whipped into such a rage, but when this narrative began to act like an idiot dog chasing its tail something in me snapped.


Amanda Louisa wrote: "OMG. Hilarious!!! "

Glad you got a giggle!


Amanda Elizabeth wrote: "I guess this one goes on the Do Not Want pile. I tried the first chapter a while back and couldn't take it... but thought I was being wussy. :)"

Nope, it wasn't just you--I wussed out and couldn't take any more! I should have heeded the multiple negative reviews I saw from my friends. Unfortunately, I had already purchased the book so thought I'd still give it a shot. Really wish I had saved that $20.


Amanda Anne wrote: "Great review...terribly boring book."

Ridiculously boring book. It was almost as if it set out to be the most boring book on the shelf. And in that it certainly succeeded.


Amanda Aric wrote: "Great review, and in depth. Not to mention seriously funny."

Thanks! I hope it was at least more entertaining than I found the book itself.


message 12: by Aric (new)

Aric Cushing I have a feeling it is..


message 13: by Anne (new) - rated it 2 stars

Anne Amanda wrote: "Anne wrote: "Great review...terribly boring book."

Ridiculously boring book. It was almost as if it set out to be the most boring book on the shelf. And in that it certainly succeeded."


Wine and tea, wine and tea...I'll never forget the wine and tea.


message 14: by Jeff (last edited Feb 03, 2014 05:05AM) (new)

Jeff Amanda, you are the gold standard when it comes to hating a book. I still laugh when I think of your review for "The Last of the Mohicans". Epic stuff.


message 15: by Kemper (new)

Kemper It's like freaking Groundhog Day without Bill Murray. And Groundhog Day ain't shit without Bill Murray. And neither is A Discovery of Witches.

I'm gonna be laughing all day over that one.


message 16: by Jonathan (new)

Jonathan Peto Now I know why vampires live so long: yoga. Duh.

Does it at least tell you what the witch was reading?


message 17: by Robert (new)

Robert Really wish I had saved that $20.

You could have gone to town at the taco stand...or the local donut shop.


message 18: by Robert (new)

Robert And I can't believe I'm going to say this, but here it goes: Twilight is better.

I think I might cry.

You really know how to offer up a good smackdown...


message 19: by Kelly (and the Book Boar) (last edited Jan 31, 2014 08:28AM) (new) - rated it 1 star

Kelly (and the Book Boar) I'm so glad someone else didn't like this either!

Oh, and BRILLIANT review : )


message 20: by Terry (new)

Terry Ah, a one-star Amanda review! It's been too long.


message 21: by D.G. (last edited Feb 01, 2014 03:57AM) (new)

D.G. Amanda! Thanks for writing a book review that made me take this book out of my TBR. :)


Amanda Anne wrote: Wine and tea, wine and tea...I'll never forget the wine and tea."

I would have required more wine than my budget can afford to finish it.


Amanda Jeff wrote: "Amanda, you are the gold standard when it comes to hating a book. I still laugh when I think or your review for "The Last of the Mohicans". Epic stuff."

Why, thank you. I like to think that I have well-springs of hate not yet tapped, so I'm sure there shall be more hatin' in my future.


Amanda Kemper wrote: "I'm gonna be laughing all day over that one."

Not even Bill Murray could have saved this one.


Amanda Jonathan wrote: "Now I know why vampires live so long: yoga. Duh.

Does it at least tell you what the witch was reading?"


It does, actually! She reads many different texts, all focusing on alchemy, but the whole narrative revolves around her discovering a spellbound book called Ashmole 782 (the most unfortunate name for a book ever, especially since it's repeated so often).

So what does Diana do when she uncovers this magical book in the Bodleian Library? Why sends it back to the stacks, of course. Because it's magic. And Diana has that whole "Get thee behind me, magic!" thing going on.


message 26: by Amanda (last edited Jan 31, 2014 09:35PM) (new) - rated it 1 star

Amanda Robert wrote: "And I can't believe I'm going to say this, but here it goes: Twilight is better.

I think I might cry.

You really know how to offer up a good smackdown..."


It killed my soul a little to offer Twilight even a dram of praise, but it was unfortunately true. $20 worth of tacos, however, would be a better choice than either of them.


Amanda Kelly (Draco Malfoy is my homeboy) wrote: "I'm so glad someone else didn't like this either!

Oh, and BRILLIANT review : )"


Thank you--you are certainly not alone!


Amanda Terry wrote: "Ah, a one-star Amanda review! It's been too long."

It's been a while since a book whipped up such a torrent of rage within me. I've read some bad books, sure, but mostly I just pitied them. This one hit too many pet peeves to be ignored. Someone somewhere in the publishing process should have said, "Hey, how's about we cut out all but one tea swilling, biscuit crunching scene? We get it--people eat. Move on." And since they didn't do that, I was stuck reading all of them. For that, I shall never forgive!


Amanda D.G. wrote: "Amanda! Thanks for writing a book that made me take this book out of my TBR. :)"

Trust me, I had barely scratched the surface of what I disliked so much. Glad I saved you from falling victim to this snooze-fest!


message 30: by Jonathan (new)

Jonathan Peto Amanda wrote: "So what does Diana do when she uncovers this magical book in the Bodleian Library? Why sends it back to the stacks, of course. Because it's magic. And Diana has that whole "Get thee behind me, magic!" thing going on. "

An unexpected twist, I suppose.


message 31: by Mandy (new)

Mandy Perfect review! I took this out of the library a while ago, thinking it looked interesting. I couldn't get through more than the first chapter or so before realising that life is too short to read crap. It's just AWFUL. Which makes me shudder for the state of publishing that a trilogy like this could get published.


message 32: by Jason (new) - added it

Jason Koivu "Groundhog Day ain't shit without Bill Murray."

Yer so gangstah.


Amanda Mandy wrote: "It's just AWFUL. Which makes me shudder for the state of publishing that a trilogy like this could get published."

Amen to that. It was a wise move to call it quits so early--I struggled through 200 pages before cutting this clunker lose. To think of all the time I wasted . . .


Amanda Jason wrote: ""Groundhog Day ain't shit without Bill Murray."

Yer so gangstah."


You should see my grillz.


message 35: by Jason (new) - added it

Jason Koivu Amanda wrote: "Jason wrote: ""Groundhog Day ain't shit without Bill Murray."

Yer so gangstah."

You should see my grillz."


Do you have Foreman's grill? <-- I am not gangstah :'(


message 36: by Michael (new)

Michael Thanks for saving me from this read, and in such an entertaining fashion. "Practical Magic" might be my limit, though I am curious about potential fun in Maguire's "Wicked".


message 37: by Hitandmiss (new)

Hitandmiss This sounds like a must read,

I cant wait till we get to the vampire who was turned so he can solve all of the worlds jigsaw puzzles.

How about the Wolfman who spends all his time brushing his coat, Like ever 5mins.

Or the witch who just wants to build a gingerbread house, but can't create a gingerbread structurally sound enough to put up with the stressed of a load bearing wall?

- Side note, Should I go into fan fic? or am I just crazy in thinking those ideas sound like winners.


carol. Awesome. "Dare" challenge exceeded.


Amanda Jason wrote: "Do you have Foreman's grill?"

You know it--hardcore gangstah's love a panini.


Amanda Michael wrote: "Thanks for saving me from this read, and in such an entertaining fashion. "Practical Magic" might be my limit, though I am curious about potential fun in Maguire's "Wicked"."

I did enjoy Practical Magic, but I read it back when it first came out and was drawn to the novelty of it. Now it seems like this genre is everywhere and I'm kind of burnt out on it (although burn out had nothing to do with my dislike with this book--it really is that tiresome).

Like you, I'd like to read Wicked one day. I saw the musical and really enjoyed it.


Amanda Hitandmiss wrote: "This sounds like a must read,

I cant wait till we get to the vampire who was turned so he can solve all of the worlds jigsaw puzzles.

How about the Wolfman who spends all his time brushing his co..."


Or the succubus who always had a "headache" and just can't be bothered! Or the ghost who spends 20 pages trying to pick up a fork before accepting his disconnect from the tangible world! Or the Creature from the Black Lagoon who opens up a roadside stand where he sells handmade sea grass baskets!

The sad thing is, I think we could combine all of these ideas and end up on the bestseller list for at least 4 months. And we could stretch it out into a trilogy. So, yes, fan fic is an option that should be considered!


Amanda Carol. [All cynic, all the time] wrote: "Awesome. "Dare" challenge exceeded."

Thank you. You were right--so very, very bad.


message 43: by mark (new) - rated it 1 star

mark monday agree, agree, agree! I also couldn't finish this one.

love this part, so true:

That's right, folks. Vampires, witches, and daemons aren't like you and me--in fact, our lives are infinitely more interesting than theirs.


message 44: by Amanda (last edited Feb 03, 2014 04:12PM) (new) - rated it 1 star

Amanda mark wrote: "agree, agree, agree! I also couldn't finish this one.

love this part, so true:

That's right, folks. Vampires, witches, and daemons aren't like you and me--in fact, our lives are infinitely more i..."


I wish I had read your review and Carol's before this ill-advised purchase! If two people I respect hated it that much, then it's a safe bet that I would (and did), too.


carol. On the positive side, the community sincerely appreciates a well-deserved Amanda rant.


message 46: by Jason (new) - added it

Jason Koivu Carol. [All cynic, all the time] wrote: "On the positive side, the community sincerely appreciates a well-deserved Amanda rant."

Hear! Hear! In fact, I think I'll intentionally start raving about how good certain shitty books are in hopes of tricking Amanda into reading them!


message 47: by Mara (new)

Mara Swoon as vampires are repeatedly described as smelling of baked goods! And grip the edge of your seat for the most bizarre yoga-scene in the history of the written word!

Just laughed so hard at this. I'm with Jason and Carol, if shitty books yield your rants, then I'm sure I've got copies of my Don't Bother shelf around here somewhere!


Amanda Jason wrote: "Hear! Hear! In fact, I think I'll intentionally start raving about how good certain shitty books are in hopes of tricking Amanda into reading them!"

It doesn't take dash cunning to get me to read one. Carol and Kemper have both suckered me in by basically pitching it to me thus, "Yeah, if literature took a shit, it would be this book. You should read it!"


Amanda Mara wrote: "Just laughed so hard at this. I'm with Jason and Carol, if shitty books yield your rants, then I'm sure I've got copies of my Don't Bother shelf around here somewhere!"

A "Don't Bother" shelf you say? I may just have to "Bother" . . .


Tammie I couldn't agree more! And that yoga scene, oh my, I've never read anything like it since. I really couldn't believe what I was reading.


« previous 1
back to top