Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Laysee's Reviews > Plainsong

Plainsong by Kent Haruf
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
4863523
's review

really liked it

Published in 1999, Plainsong is Kent Haruf's most famous work. It won the Mountains & Plains Booksellers award and was a finalist for the National Book Award, the Los Angeles Times book prize, and the New Yorker book award.

The novel is set in the small fictional town of Holt, Colorado. It captures life in a small community. In alternating fashion, it relates the story of the key characters: Guthrie (a teacher estranged from his wife), his sons, Ike (age 10) and Bobby (age 9), Victoria (a homeless pregnant teen); Ms Maggie Jones (Victoria's teacher), and the McPheron brothers (a pair of bachelors in their 50s).

The language is spare and simple but effective. We are rarely told how the characters feel but we know from the straightforward description how things are. E.g., Ike and Bobby go round to collect payment for their paper routes and are subjected to questions about their home situation but their humiliation and discomfort are plainly communicated.

It is also remarkable how the prose in drawing attention to dusty pickups, dirt-blowing winter wind, yellowish street lamps or a leafless Chinese elm tree convey a mood, such as a sense of desolation. In this scene, one feels Victoria's hollow panic when she is trying in vain to contact her boyfriend from a pay phone on the highway outside of town. Even the natural environs are captured in their raw, unflattering state: "The flower spikes of the soap-weed stuck up like splintered sticks, the seed pods dry and dark-looking against the winter grass." Yet, the landscape stripped of all romanticism reflects how life is for the ordinary folks living unremarkable lives.

The story holds up stark contrasts between cruelty and kindness. Victoria's mother and the Beckman family embody callousness and meanness. They are the foil that sets in tender relief the thoughtful solicitude of the kindly old doctor, the supportive teacher Maggie Jones, the young boys who love and miss their mother, and the McPheron brothers. Acts of kindness are told with grace.

I warm most of all to the McPheron brothers who have led reclusive lives from their orphaned youth and are rough, gruff, and socially very awkward. Precisely because of this, it is touching to see how they strive against their latent reticence to make conversation with Victoria (even if it is about cattle on their farm) and to be family to her.

It takes someone like Maggie to build bridges between people. It makes me think how much we can really know about what others have undergone in their lives when all we see is simply the exterior facade. At the same time, we also cannot underestimate the goodness that lies behind seemingly unapproachable folks and the extent of compassion even scarred individuals are capable of extending to each other.

The novel ends quietly on a note of realism. Crises are not fully resolved. I am left thinking about the vulnerable young brothers whose mother is never coming home. I cannot help but wonder if they will grow up to become like the McPheron brothers. Yet, I also get a sense that they, like Victoria, will find their way in life.

Like a chant, "Plainsong" reverberates in my mind and heart after the last page is turned.
22 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Plainsong.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

December 24, 2015 – Started Reading
December 30, 2015 – Shelved
December 30, 2015 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-18 of 18 (18 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by [deleted user] (new)

Laysee, I thank you so much for this marvelous review which helps to say goodbye to 2015. I was particularly moved by the truth of your observation: "It makes me think how much we can really know about what others have undergone in their lives when all we see is simply the exterior facade. At the same time, we also cannot underestimate the goodness that lies behind seemingly unapproachable folks and the extent of compassion even scarred individuals are capable of extending to each other. I think that this reading life helps us to be more sensitive to the interior life of others that exists beneath the tapestry of exterior scars.


Laysee Thank you, Steve, for your thoughtful and encouraging comment. The interior life is all important because it is, according to Buechner, "the real news".


message 3: by Cecily (last edited Dec 31, 2015 12:12PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Cecily Ah, Laysee, I'm not at all surprised that this resonated with you and that you've really captured the appeal of Haruf's apparently simple prose.

Having enjoyed this one, Laysee, I commend Eventide to you: it's the second half of the same story, and the perfect compliment and conclusion to it, still with the "stark contrasts between cruelty and kindness".


message 4: by Fionnuala (new)

Fionnuala The language is spare and simple but effective. We are rarely told how the characters feel but we know from the straightforward description how things are.

I've had my eye on this book for a while - ever since reading Steve's and Cecily's reviews in fact. Now your description of the writing has confirmed that this book should suit me. Thanks!


Laysee Cecily wrote: "Ah, Laysee, I'm not at all surprised that this resonated with you and that you've really captured the appeal of Haruf's apparently simple prose.

Having enjoyed this one, Laysee, I commend [book:E..."


Hi Cecily, "Plainsong" is my first Haruf book. I expected to like it when I read your review and I did. I'm amazed that clean, spare prose can speak beautifully. Yes, I will be reading "Eventide". Thank you for introducing me to Kent Haruf. Happy new year, Cecily!


Laysee Fionnuala wrote: "The language is spare and simple but effective. We are rarely told how the characters feel but we know from the straightforward description how things are.

I've had my eye on this book for a while..."


Hi Fionnuala, thank you for stopping by to leave a comment. Don't you love how GR allows us to spread the word about books that like-minded readers may enjoy? I hope you will enjoy "Plainsong" and I look forward to reading your review.


Cheri This was the first of Haruf's that I read, and I fell in love with his simple, spare prose, which was all the more powerful because of its simplicity. Lovely review, Laysee, I'm so pleased that you appreciated Haruf's lovely insights into these lives.


Laysee Cheri wrote: "This was the first of Haruf's that I read, and I fell in love with his simple, spare prose, which was all the more powerful because of its simplicity. Lovely review, Laysee, I'm so pleased that you..."

Oh Cheri. I just saw your comment two months after it was posted. So sorry I missed it. Am pleased we both love Haruf's simple, spare but powerful prose.


Jeannie Awesome review, Laysee!


Diane Barnes This IS an awesome review Laysee. "Acts of kindness told with grace" is a perfect description of Haruf's writing.


Laysee Elyse wrote: ""Like a chant"............Yes.........it is! Lovely review -- I loved this book! xoxo"

Thank you, Elyse. Glad you loved this book, too. Haruf writes simply and beautifully. I am saving one last book of his to read like I am hoarding a precious last piece of candy.


Laysee Jeannie wrote: "Awesome review, Laysee!"

Thank you, Jeannie. That you read it twice and loved it both times testify to Haruf's genius.


Mark  Porton Great review of one of my favourite books/series/authors Laysee. Your last 2 lines really nails it for me. These books stay with you. Magic!


Laysee Diane wrote: "This IS an awesome review Laysee. "Acts of kindness told with grace" is a perfect description of Haruf's writing."

Thank you, Diane. There's something about Haruf's books that brings grace to my mind.


Laysee Mark wrote: "Great review of one of my favourite books/series/authors Laysee. Your last 2 lines really nails it for me. These books stay with you. Magic!"

Thank you, Mark. The Plainsong Trilogy is a magical series and Haruf's gift to us. One day, I will re-read them.


message 16: by Vishakha (new) - added it

Vishakha Your review always captures the essence of the book in question. This is a wonderful review, Laysee.


Laysee Vishakha wrote: "Your review always captures the essence of the book in question. This is a wonderful review, Laysee."

Thank you, Vishakha. :-)


message 18: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa What an exquisite review!

I laughed when the McPheron brothers were teaching Victoria about the market. I so appreciated Haruf allowing her to understand where they were coming from and to reciprocate with asking questions and trying to understand. These people are so genuine that I feel like they're my friends.

I'm so happy to have finally read Plainsong, and I understand all the love around this novel.


back to top