ŷ

Julie's Reviews > Star Wars: The Force Awakens

Star Wars by Alan Dean Foster
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
1143969
's review

it was ok
bookshelves: i-am-a-masochist, star-wars, tie-ins, because-of-the-movie-or-show

Ughhhhh, what to make of this book.

I really grudgingly dragged my heels through this, and it felt like it took forever to read. Mostly I'm irritated at what an utter waste it is, because I loved The Force Awakens SO MUCH (saw it three times in theatres in the course of like two weeks, y'all), and the characters are so great and the imagery so gripping and plot so FUN... and this book, mostly through its stiff, tepid prose, pretty much sucks all that joy out of it.

And it's not that I'm judgmental of cheesy tie-in writing! Because the thing is, this isn't even cheesy fun! I have written gushing 5-star reviews for freakin' novelisations of the non-canonical Alien comic books, with the campiest prose. Whereas the writing in this book makes me want to punt it into the nearest star, because Alan Dean Foster has a tendency to make his sentences really garbled and convoluted in an attempt to a) use lofty words rather than their simpler counterparts, and b) jump through every hoop possible to avoid ending his sentences with prepositions. Seriously, it's fucking painful and stilted to read. Apart from a couple key scenes, usually with Han or Han/Leia, I just didn't feel the emotion of the story; it read more like a flat plot summary than a rollicking tale.

His characterisations of the new characters, apart from Poe and fleeting moments with Finn, also pretty much suck. He didn't capture Rey's scrappy spirit (there was just something lacking even in the scenes which bowled me over on-screen); Kylo Ren just sounds super pompous; scenes that were hilarious in the movie come across forced here.

So. 2 stars mainly because it has a plot that I love (which... is more indebted to the movie, and my vicarious feels still buzzing along from the movie), his characterisation of Han is actually pretty good, and the rathtar sequence, which was the most exciting in the whole book.

Mostly I picked this up because I have a Star Wars problem, and I was hoping to glean the tiniest pieces of extra world-building -- which naturally wasn't really here, because PLOT SECRETS remain secrets.

In short, go read Before the Awakening instead.

Favourite quotes below, and by "favourite" I mean "some things I highlighted because I did like the prose, mainly to do with Han and Han/Leia and STORMPILOT" and "some other things I highlighted because the writing was so tremendously fucking bad that I wanted to share it with you":

(view spoiler)

Cont'd in comments...
2 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Star Wars.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

December 30, 2015 – Shelved
December 30, 2015 – Shelved as: to-read
January 11, 2016 – Started Reading
January 11, 2016 – Shelved as: i-am-a-masochist
January 11, 2016 – Shelved as: star-wars
January 11, 2016 – Shelved as: tie-ins
January 11, 2016 – Shelved as: because-of-the-movie-or-show
February 10, 2016 –
30.0% "Love the plot (obvy, as evidenced by the 3 times I went to see TFA in theatres), still hate Alan Dean Foster's writing style. Gnashes teeth."
February 11, 2016 –
66.0% ""Alone in the room, Kylo Ren--saturnine of aspect, lithe of build, tortured of mien, and troubled of eye--gazed at the silent recipient of his confession." I well and truly cannot emphasise how much I hate the writing in this book."
February 15, 2016 –
90.0% "oh thank god I'm probably going to finish this tonight"
February 15, 2016 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-6 of 6 (6 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Julie Part two of the quotes!

(view spoiler)


Julie Camilla wrote: "Wow the change to "Be nice to me" is so interesting and feelsy. Idk what I prefer but wow."

YEAH. I didn't commentate any further on it because I honestly can't decide which one I like more -- I like both, for different reasons? Like, "Anything!" is fun and surly and exactly what old marrieds would gripe at each other. Whereas "Be nice to me" is a bit more serious, a bit more revealing of how it hurts to revisit that compassion between them, idk.

JUST, ALL MY HAN/LEIA FEELS <3


message 3: by Ginger (new)

Ginger I think I may be glad I skipped this. Foster was a hack when he was writing Star Wars tie-ins before Empire came out. I think he wrote the original novelization too. It's a tradition.


Julie Ginger wrote: "I think I may be glad I skipped this. Foster was a hack when he was writing Star Wars tie-ins before Empire came out. I think he wrote the original novelization too. It's a tradition."

Yeaaaah, I can't recommend it at all, even though it has a few good moments (which is what spared it from being 1-star). HIS WRITING IS TERRIBLE. I saw a few people being like "it's so appropriate for him to write this one because he ghostwrote the original novelisation, it's all come full-circle, huzzah!", but it just read like the worst of old-school 70s prose. I so wish someone else had been handed the reins for this one.


message 5: by Kendall (new)

Kendall Moore Thank you Julie. This review perfectly sums up the way I feel about the movie as well.


message 6: by Nick (new)

Nick It's so long that I hard to read it.


back to top