Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Doug Bradshaw's Reviews > The Story of the Lost Child

The Story of the Lost Child by Elena Ferrante
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
808994
's review

it was amazing

I want to thank Elena Ferrante aka Lenu, for writing such an excellent and complete story of the lives of herself and her soulmate-crazy and brilliant best friend, Lila. The four books are chronological and start when the two girls are about 8 years old and continue into their sixties. I don't want to tell the story here but here are some of my observations about reading such a poignant, emotionally honest and complete story:

1. Life is hard and then you die. There is nothing easy about relationships, marriages, having and raising families, living on tight budgets, deciding what career path to take, dealing with family members on drugs, raising kids who are young and becoming sexual, and in this particular environment in Naples, Italy in the 50's, friends and families with a lot of influence who are basically mobsters. Elena takes us through all of these type of issues along with her high strung, highly opinionated and beautiful friend, Lila, who is the opposite of Lenu, never a compromiser, always aggressive and pushy, highly opinionated and willing to put her life at stake to stand up for herself and Lenu. Some of the situations are hilarious and amazing, others are depressing and life threatening.

2. I think the author has been willing to admit many personal thoughts and reactions to various ultra personal situations that are eye openers as to how relationships actually work. The submissive girl can so easily yield to the thoughts and opinions of the dominate girl, that her whole life is changed not necessarily for the better. The one with low self esteem or less confidence can become overly ready to do almost anything for love or approval. It's so true and yet so painful to watch. And yet the friendship endures and each is successful in working their way through a world, especially in this era, so dominated by the desires and customs of parents and the men that they end up having relationships with.

3. There is interesting history of the politics of Italy of the era, facists, communists, the fight for labor unions and equality, the opinions of the liberal professors in the universities of the era, the disdain each group has for the other and the two girls, each in totally different settings, becoming part of this whole politically morphing time. Some of each of their friends become very involved in the mess, which includes murder, friends dragged off into the chaos in real danger.

4. There is a lot of realistic and sometimes difficult to handle marriage and relationship situations, adultery, abandonment, way too much forgiveness of one particular womanizing fellow who affects the life of each of the girls who are becoming women. However, it is written in a way that almost makes some of their stupid and immature decisions totally understandable, while each of them try to help the other get through horrible and sometimes almost funny and pathetic situations occur. There is one sexual description of what one of the girls walks in on that nailed me, so real and yet a ridiculous eye opener, almost as if I had to see it to understand what a dope this guy really was. This was another example of how Elena was able to make us walk in her shoes. I'm guessing she had to be chuckling as she finished writing this particular scene, maybe too much for some readers.

5. And then there is the never ending worry and difficult time raising the 5 kids that the two of them had, both stepping in to help the other from time to time. Not wanting to tell the story, there is an event involving one of the kids that almost devastates one of the mothers.

In the end, we have watched in great detail the full lives of two ordinary and yet both extraordinary women, and I will miss them both, always hoping that maybe, a fifth book will show up.
57 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read The Story of the Lost Child.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

January 2, 2016 – Started Reading
January 2, 2016 – Shelved
January 12, 2016 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-32 of 32 (32 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Jeannie I loved these books! I can't find anything worth reading now.
I hope for book 5 also. Excellent review.


Doug Bradshaw I know, Jeannie. I doubt it will happen though. I may read another book or two of hers.


message 3: by LeeAnne (last edited Jan 19, 2016 01:38PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

LeeAnne Great review Doug! These books are so incredibly personal and real. I'm still not convinced that they are just characters. We need to travel to Italy so we can see all of the places talked about in the book!


Doug Bradshaw I've driven through, past Vesuvius, but now I'd like to spend some time in Naples looking down at the stradone like they always did. More than anything, I'd like to spend an evening with lenu, Lila and or the author. Wouldn't that be fun? Loving Cozumel although sprinkling a little right this second. Great little island.


LeeAnne What I wouldn't give to be in Cozumel right now!
It's FREEZING (20°) here and windy (feels like 15°)
Monster snow storm coming Friday with 18-20 inches of snow. (sobs!)


Renata I'm about Two through Lost Child and needing to stop - breathe - and process all the sorrow, the love, the pain, and the small mercies of this series. I love the way you organized your thoughts and expressed the so eloquently.
I visited Naples as a teenager in the 1960's and recall poverty, densely crowded living, and a million tv antennas sprouting from rooftops. In the evenings when we climbed back up the hill to our pensione the lights from the small TV sets illuminated the rapt faces of families clustered around them like moths to a flame. And in the background Vesuvius and Pompeii.
I'm glad I was oblivious to the violence of that city for a few more years. I loved instead the expressive gusto of her Italians.


Doug Bradshaw Makes these stories all the more meaningful to have been there, I'm sure. Yes the story kind of wears you out sometimes. But well worth it.


Renata It was absolutely worth reading. I loved the ending - it just felt right. It felt like a requiem to their friendship, their lives. I re-listened to the ending a few times (My drive to work is about fifteen minutes and I could barely get out of the car). I'll be interested in what you think
Of her other books when you have a chance to read them.


message 9: by Sarah (new)

Sarah Loved these books - I'm having a break before reading the last one - don't want them to be over. Going to savour it.


message 10: by Doug (new) - rated it 5 stars

Doug Bradshaw Sarah, good to hear from you. I'll look for your review in the future. What other of her books have you enjoyed, Renata?


Renata A few months ago I started listening to My Brilliant Friend because I was intrigued by how often these titles came up on GR by people whose opinions I had come to value and enjoy. I was completely enthralled with the characters and the telling - there was an authenticity and depth that transcended most realistic fiction. Other than the Neapolitan series I have read no other of her books - I'm actually afraid to at this time. I think I
Might compare them and find them wanting. Maybe after a year I will be more open to different characters. Ferrante is both intellectually rigorous and challenging and intensely personal. I am
curious how her writing evolved over time, though. I just read an interview with Anne Tyler in which she said she would like to disavow her first four books :-)


message 12: by Doug (new) - rated it 5 stars

Doug Bradshaw Renata, I know exactly what you mean. You go first, please. And if you like them, I'll give them a shot. Lol


Renata Hmmm...a double date sounds about right!
Think I'll climb a tree and read Corrag!


Renata Good grief - meant double dare :-)


message 15: by Doug (new) - rated it 5 stars

Doug Bradshaw LOL, are you flirting with me, Renata?


Catherine  B. Hello Doug,
I started this saga only a month ago with a paperback of the first book which I found on a park bench (true !). In France, the third book is released now (I am French) . I have read the rest of this life-long friendship which fascinated me as it was a brilliant support to share so many thoughts over a long period of time. The time as living beings and the time of history - political, sociological, economical - with a sense of being trapped whatever the box is your own. It was interesting to read the critics in the French press. They were excellent in praise for the third book but they were short-coming by a long chalk as compared with I read from you. I wanted to let you know that I appreciated very much what you wrote. I will certainly read again these books and apart from the addiction of learning more about these two amazing main characters, the narrative is extremely rich with an honesty, crudity and bareness. I have a word for it : the floated-wood language. In cooking, a complete reduction of all flavours and ingredients. Could not be more far apart from "politically-correct language", "zen atttitude" in a world - ours - dominated by communication codes which prevent open discussions. I was personnally very surprised and hooked by the narrative which was so honest and outspoken about one's interiority - inheritance of any kind and most of the time subterranean, thoughts, beliefs, dreams, doubts, emotions, survival, thriving in everyday life - all intertwined in one's life. Thanks for your rreview !


message 17: by Doug (new) - rated it 5 stars

Doug Bradshaw Catherine wrote: "Hello Doug,
I started this saga only a month ago with a paperback of the first book which I found on a park bench (true !). In France, the third book is released now (I am French) . I have read the..."


Catherine, thanks for taking time to write such a great note regarding my review and this excellent series. You have a real way with words and the things you say about the stories really distills these books into the most important ingredients. It really is as if we lived as close friends to these two great characters. I hope to hear more from you. It looks like you just barely joined Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ. I think you'll enjoy it. Welcome to this great community.


Catherine  B. You react and read fake to me. No comment.


message 19: by Doug (new) - rated it 5 stars

Doug Bradshaw What? Lol. Not fake. I enjoyed what you said and your writing and hope you enjoy Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ.


Catherine  B. I wonder if you are not planted. Generally wise these books have found a female readership, Your communication is too "clean" . I wonder if you are not an utter commercial fake. (publishing house, in--house communication ( never you !), etc.)


message 21: by Doug (last edited Jan 14, 2017 04:15PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Doug Bradshaw Nope. Just a normal male who reads a lot of different types of literature. If you look at my profile you'll see I have reviewed a few hundred books. Some of my reviews are better than others. I spend more time if I love a book. I admit I do sound like an Elena advertisement here. But I do want friends here who love a lot of the same books I do to give this series a shot.


Catherine  B. Thanks for your so instant reply - you have a life of your own ? - I am sure your book reviews are ... interesting. The one I read today is. Which makes me sad, most of the press critics are lesser in their qualitity. It makes me question how book promotion works out now. I am not getting out of my mind that you are a fraud , a publisher's ghost.
Hence, hence, hence...
Catherine


message 23: by Doug (new) - rated it 5 stars

Doug Bradshaw Lol. I'm flattered. Love it. Maybe I should be. I don't always love my job. I'm in commercial real estate finance. I would love to make money reading and commenting on books. I sent you a friend request on Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ. What do you do? Are you in the book business?


Catherine  B. I am not in the book business - I cannot help you. I am a reader. In my reading, I may be contemplating our past and present and wonder about our future. I am a fleck, I hope I am a human being and I am still wondering what it is. The books I love are all about that in forms would not have imagined myself. And I am so grateful .
Euh ? Make friend with you ? Be aware that I will not be of any hel with you. I am not connected with the edition word.
What do you say ? Love frankness.


message 25: by Doug (new) - rated it 5 stars

Doug Bradshaw More than anything I would enjoy hearing about your recent favorite books. Your five star reads.


message 26: by Doug (new) - rated it 5 stars

Doug Bradshaw I loved two recently. "A Gentleman in Moscow" and "Corrag."


Catherine  B. Thanks, Doug, for sharing and not turning your back on me. I am aware that I was quite offensive. My sincere apologies. Your review was just too good ! I feel now just happy that it was that good! I have won a "reading friend" and I appreciate it.

I do not know the books you are mentioning and having finished a few days ago the Naples saga, I will gladly open up to these unknown writers. Glad to have new leads to follow in my reading errands.

In 2016, I changed my reading habits as I was myself changed by the experience of unemployment. I read a lot of “thrillers� from Scandinavia � a genre I did not really know apart from a few Simenon books which for me * I confess - were reminiscent of being stuck to bed with the flu. Very ungrateful of me, Simenon is good as well as the Nordic thriller gang, a whiff of European countries I never set foot in. Authors : Henning Mankell, Jo Nesbo, Arnaldour Indridason. A gripping book, also which unusually treats of death conviction � a conviction repelled in France � was

2016 was the discovery for me of Martha Gellhorn, an American journalist who covered most wars in the 20th century. She is amazing and this compilation of long articles from the 1930ies to the 70ies are extremely interesting and it helped me a lot putting in perspective the making of Europe and naturally that of the western world, in this time of uncertainty . The title is very appropriate: “View from the Ground�. A very humanistic and direct view unusual …now.

It was also the discovery of Aminatta Forna . I read “The Hired Man� Looks like an easy read � small book and yes easy to read . A trap ! This is extremely clever of this writer. The real subject is tackled with so much subtlety that it made me think more than any news reel . It reads easily but once you are over with the book , many thoughts assailed me and I found that stunning � maybe because I am European and it deals with a recent European history at its worse. At the time, I tried to understand a thing and I did not. It shows how news reel, accessible to anyone cnnot be matched by the lesson of time which makes history. The trouble is assessing what can be a historical disaster and how inadequate one can be with his/her own times. I then read on her other books but I would recommend that book to start with. However, it takes a particular sensitivity that I had when I read it to appreciate it. I don’t know. I have not shared my views and feelings on that book.

Amricanah, by Chimamanda Ngozi Adishie.

Sweet Caress : the Many Lives of Amory Clay by William Boyd.

Wild Idea : Buffalo and Family, by Dan O’Bryen (a very appreciated author in France), just as Jim Harrison who left us a year ago, and whom I read with great relish.

I need to renew my “vein� of authors and I do not trust anymore the critics I read from French newspapers, TV � this small edition world is now too connected with the media and the critics are very much driven by how much it sells as if it meant it all. Readers forums have indeed a place. This is why I welcome suggestions and I thank you in advance.
Cheers from Paris.

PS If I had to do a list of my 5-star books, my "island books", it would be different. This is my 2016 cropping ! Sorry for language mistakes.


Catherine  B. Frendship offered and withdrawn ? I am told on the site that I have no friends. Are we not friends ? New on the site, did I do something wrong or missed doing something right ?
Had a good read with "A Gentleman in Moscow". I do not think that in the so many books on offer I would have picked this book in particular. I do see the interest of browsing and sharing on our most appreciated reads - c'est enrichissant.

" By their very nature, human beings are so capricious, so complex, so delightfully contradictory, that they deserve not only our consideration, but our reconsideration--and our unwavering determination to withhold our opinion until we have engaged with them in every possible setting at every possible hour.�
A well spread quotation from the book, and well deserved.


message 29: by Doug (new) - rated it 5 stars

Doug Bradshaw Catherine wrote: "Frendship offered and withdrawn ? I am told on the site that I have no friends. Are we not friends ? New on the site, did I do something wrong or missed doing something right ?
Had a good read with..."


Yes, a great quote. I sent you a friend request. When you log in to goodreads, you'll see the friend icon in the upper right hand corner of the site. You then need to accept my friend request. I'm glad you tried the book. Did you read it in English? I'll send you another friend request.


message 30: by Doug (new) - rated it 5 stars

Doug Bradshaw OK, I cancelled the old friend request and sent you a fresh one. You'll have to double click on the icon and accept my request. Then we'll be official friends! LOL


message 31: by Cheri (new) - added it

Cheri Wonderful review, Doug, I hope to get to this series eventually!!


message 32: by Doug (new) - rated it 5 stars

Doug Bradshaw It's one of those series that pulls you in like its part of your life. Looking forward to your thoughts Cheri.


back to top