Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

carol. 's Reviews > Darkfever

Darkfever by Karen Marie Moning
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3978225
's review

it was ok
bookshelves: urban-fantasy, paranormal-romance

I enjoy a fun read as much as the next person, but the Fever series will not be taking that role in my life. Overall, not particularly impressed.

To start with, the language is most likely about a 10th grade reading level: "Now we turned down a long dim hallway that ended in an immense, square black door belted by bands of steel." Its very chick-lit as well, taking time to describe her outfits and nail polish: "What I had on was a luscious gauzy skirt of nearly every pastel hue on the color wheel that hugged my hips and kicked frothily at my ankles, a form-fitting rose sweater with silk trimmed cap sleeves and a plunging silk-edged neckline that made much of my bust, and dainty pink high heels that laced around my ankles." That's right; Moning took more time to describe the heroine's outfit than the approach to meeting her first vampire.

Not many reviews have mentioned it, but there's definitely not-so-concealed racism, describing the "primitive mix" of races in Barrons, and the background of one of the "Black Irish" bad guys. She blah blahs all the time how her home has nicer, kinder, more thoughtful people and comes across like a narrow-minded American prig. Perhaps that's Moning's point, that this is the growing-up period for our heroine, but frankly, I don't see any change during this book.

There isn't romantic interest so much as flat out sexualized scenes. Now that I think of it, I wonder if current authors are reacting against the over-explicitness of the Anita Blake generation, and are trying to find ways of more unique encounters. In the initial one, Mac basically has a self-sufficient encounter, and in the second one, after arousing her, the fae disappears, leaving her half-naked in front of a museum full of people. There wasn't really romantic tension between her and Barrons, her teacher, just an exchange of insults and orders. Perhaps that too is for another book.

Regardless, not sure I care. My TBR pile is so large I don't know how much time I want to waste.
There wasn't a specific moment that drove me batty; it was an accumulation of the writing emphasis and the shallow focus. Zala has a review that has a number of quotes and gives a much better sense of how it can wear on one: Zala's review
92 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Darkfever.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

February 20, 2011 – Shelved
May 1, 2011 – Started Reading
May 1, 2011 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-22 of 22 (22 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Kristina (last edited Jun 10, 2011 09:45AM) (new)

Kristina Your third paragraph is perfect. "Primitive mix" is so offensive I can't even find words.


Carly Oh good! I've been looking through reviews and no one else mentioned the racism. I was beginning to think it was just me. And you're spot-on with the reading level and the issues with the sexual scenes.
Wonderful review!


carol. Carly--thanks. I look forward to your usual high-quality thoughtful analysis, especially as this was written in my early reviewing days.

I understand a number of fans say "Mac gets better/changes/matures/becomes a unicorn" but I don't care enough to continue. Bad writing, a character I wouldn't lend a pen to and porn standing in for erotica.


Carly Yeah, I feel like I shouldn't need to read a whole series to evaluate the first book. I'm somewhat weirded out by the disturbing undercurrents of racism and antifeminism that are left unchallenged. Maybe she deals with them later, but stopping at the first book shouldn't feel like a DNF.

...are porn and erotica different? I actually am quite unfamiliar with the genre(s).


message 5: by carol. (last edited Sep 17, 2013 07:55AM) (new) - rated it 2 stars

carol. Carly wrote: "..are porn and erotica different? I actually am quite unfamiliar with the genre(s)"

I'd say as a gross generalization that it's an issue of desire/intimacy versus um (censored) the act and factoring in control. The sex scenes in this book are more about humiliation standing in for romance (that I remember, particularly the panties she didn't remember taking off) and yet it's supposed to be oh-so-titillating during Mac's public humiliation (versus Mac enjoying being the object of voyeurism). I


message 6: by Carly (last edited Sep 17, 2013 06:22PM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Carly Huh. I thought they were interchangeable. So erotica implies some level of agency and porn doesn't? Well, I learned something new today. I guess that probably shouldn't be my word of the day, though.
My utter inability to comprehend romantic scenes is a bit of a killer for this type of book. I wasn't able to determine the intent of those scenes--whether they were intended to be horrifying or titillating.


message 7: by Elena (last edited Nov 26, 2017 02:40AM) (new)

Elena Not many reviews have mentioned it, but there's definitely not-so-concealed racism, describing the "primitive mix" of races in Barrons, and the background of one of the "Black Irish" bad guys. OMG YES! Thank you!!! I thought I was seeing things or something, no other reviews I came across mentioned it!

Also - and that's pretty beside the point, but still: Barron's "primitive pairing of genes" would be...Basque and Celt?! What does Moning imagine a Basque looks like, exactly? Beside "primitive", that is.


carol. Not beside the point at all! I'm told that it is all about the shallowness of the character and that she 'evolves,' but yeah. Any time you use 'primitive' in description--and not talking about archeology--and are writing after 1960 in America, you're pretty much a fail. This was such a bad book for me on so many levels.


Alexandra I agree, this one left me underwhelmed.


carol. Glad I'm not the only one. I know Moning has many committed fans of this series.


message 11: by Alexandra (last edited Nov 26, 2017 09:00AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Alexandra Carol. wrote: "Glad I'm not the only one. I know Moning has many committed fans of this series."

You're not alone. Perhaps this is an unfair generalization, but I suspect fans of this sub-genre of UF are more Romance fans than Fantasy fans. They're far too "Romancy" for *this* Fantasy fan, anyway.

Which might be fine (for me), if it were interesting and compelling, but for me it was "meh".

I like the "Fantasy set in an Urban setting" type UF, but not this Romancy monster hunter type.


carol. Alexandra wrote: "I like the "Fantasy set in an Urban setting" type UF, but not this Romancy monster hunter type. "

Yes. It's a fine line, for me. Which is probably why I often gravitate towards the male heroes--because there is much less emphasis on a man's emotional/romantic connections than on the conflict.


Alexandra Carol. wrote: "Alexandra wrote: "I like the "Fantasy set in an Urban setting" type UF, but not this Romancy monster hunter type. "

Yes. It's a fine line, for me. Which is probably why I often gravitate towards t..."


I hear ya. I enjoy bad ass female MCs, but finding a story with that, that isn't really-a-Romance can be a challenge :)


message 14: by Elena (new)

Elena Carol. wrote: "I'm told that it is all about the shallowness of the character and that she 'evolves,'": yes, I've heard the same thing. But I fear this is Moning's view of the world seeping through rather than a masterful depiction of a provincial 20-something girl. I'll give #2 a go, since this is a buddy read and all - I guess I'll see if the it's-all-Mac's-fault-but-then-she-evolves theory stands ;)


carol. I will look forward to your insight :D


Adina (notifications back, log out, clear cache) I totally understand why you didn’t like it. All your points are valid but damn, I don’t care about them. I still love this series. :)) and I don’t read too many romance books or porn or erotica or whatever.


carol. Hey, that's totally cool that you enjoy it. I heard Mac improves a lot as a main, but I just am not enough into it to allow for that time. We've all got a series or two that we know isn't great and we love anyway... Anne Bishop's Other series is my candy. It's turned to absolute trash, but I read it anyway.


message 18: by Carmen (new) - added it

Carmen Great review.


carol. Thanks, Carmen.


carol. Jennifer, your mileage may vary, as it certainly has its fans. However, if you are ambivalent, it's not the direction I'd push you. :)


carol. Jennifer, just my little way of not irritating my friends who disagree :)
Annoying about the app.


message 22: by Dawn (new) - rated it 2 stars

Dawn Taylor-Hudson I picked up on racism early and found it very off putting. I will read the next book to see if the characters matures/evolves, but it didn’t go unnoticed.


back to top