Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Terry (Ter05 TwiMoms/ MundieMoms)'s Reviews > A Discovery of Witches

A Discovery of Witches by Deborah Harkness
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3043482
Edit 5/25/18 I intended to just skim through this re-reading while I was reading The World of All Souls but once I started I could not do anything but look even closer at the story thinking about the history I was getting from the companion book and about all the knowledge and research Deborah went into to write it. This trilogy becomes more amazing every time I read it. AMAZING!

Edit 5/18/18 I am also reading the new The World of All Souls and just had to pick this up and start it for maybe the fourth or fifth reading. The new companion book just makes this trilogy all the more fascinating. The real history of people who actually existed, places that exist and have for centuries - when I read the author was a historian, I had no idea how deep she was into history long before she wrote this novel!

Edit#2 Re-reading for second time

Edit: Listening to on audiobook when I drive and LOVE the audio. I only read the book a little over a month ago but it's good enough to re-read and sure to listen to! finished the audio and it is wonderful.

Wow! This is the best book I have read this year (2011) other than the final book of a favorite series and that doesn't count! This is what I would call an epic novel. It was recommended to me on an Outlander thread and I was a little unsure why fans of a great epic historical novel series would be interested in a book about witches. Now I understand. It's not a quick read which is part of what I loved about it as I wanted to absorb every little detail of the history, the science, the romance, the characters who simply came alive the longer I "knew" them. It's a book I did not want to finish because I wanted to remain in this story, and it left me thinking about it.

The two main characters in this book are Matthew Clairmont who is a M.D. although not practicing medicine, a famous geneticist, and esteemed scholar. He is also a 1500 year old vampire. It is through Matthew's life experiences that we see back into history that he lived and the famous people he knew including Darwin. Matthew was there during the Knights Templar, a physician in WWI and that is only the tip of the iceberg of course. Through Matthew this is a historical novel and a study of his vampire family. Most of the book is written in the first person by Diana Bishop who is also a scientist and has a position at Oxford University. There are some parts where Diana is not present that are told in the third person, but I didn't even notice the transition. Diana comes from a famous old family of witches going back to and before Salem, but she has renounced her powers and believes that she only uses them a few times a year for simple things- like stopping her washing machine from leaking. Both of her parents were murdered in Africa when she was seven and she has been raised by her Aunt Sarah and her companion, Em. Through both Matthew and Diana we are introduced to fascinating families, Matthew's vampire mother in France, Diana's witch aunt in America, and the wonderful house that Diana grew up in. In this house, populated not only by Sarah and Em, but by the ghosts of many of their ancestors, the house is "alive" and does things like adding a room when someone is coming to visit, hiding things and producing them later. In this world there are also deamons who are often gifted artists, musicians, scholars, and somewhat eccentric. Then of course there are humans.

Matthew is definitely a vampire. He is domineering, has a temper, passionately protective of those he cares about (and a passionate vampire with a temper is not a safe "person" to be around). He is also loyal with experience gained in not just living 1500 years but using his time to study and research. Diana is a strong woman, secure in one way but very insecure in others. She has been diagnosed as suffering from too much adrenalin and to counter that she runs, rows, and does yoga. In actuality it is her magic hidden deep within her with a binding spell that causes her problems. Diana's reluctance to accept some of Matthew's traits makes interesting reading and her realization that falling in love with a vampire is not going to be the same as interacting with a human man is part of the story too.

I don't want to do spoilers but wanted to give an example of the writing that I particularly liked.
I skipped a bit and just my favorite parts from a page or two below.

"Contemplating the sleek black car and the elegant vampire, I felt unaccountable cross....." 'You think a subcompact would be better subterfuge?' he asked... ""Not really, no'. Standing in the fall twilight, he positively screamed vampire, yet the rising tide of undergraduates and dons passed him without a second glance. If they couldn't sense what he was --- see what he was, standing in the open air--the car was immaterial."

Later in the book:

"'So you're the vampire,' Nathaniel said, giving Matthew an appraising look. 'My mother warned me about you.' 'You should listen to her,' Matthew suggested, his voice dangerously soft."

"'Are you certain of him, Diana?'he asked. Em wiped her hands on her apron and left the room, giving me a sad look. 'Yes' I met his eyes, trying to make my confidence in Matthew clear. Hamish nodded, unsurprised. 'I did wonder if you would take him on, once you knew who he was -- who he still is. It would seem you're not afraid to have a tiger by the tail.'"

I have discovered that the author is a historian and in so many ways this is indeed a historical novel covering many centuries through the experiences of the vampire who lived them. It is a different kind of romance and this part of the story is sensual but nothing in it that a teen should not be reading. The only reason it is an adult book and not a YA is that it is deeper and more detailed than a teen book and the main characters are in their thirties. I would definitely recommend it for older teens.

This is the first book of a series. So how does it end? Beautifully. The last chapters bring together the characters we have come to know and some very interesting new ones who are united in what is obviously going to be a war of some kind. Matthew and Diana have broken long standing laws by being together, but it is more than that. The two of them are going on a quest that you need to read the book to understand, but the ending is one of hope and optimism. The last line of the book is, "'It's time.' Together we lifted our feet and stepped into the unknown."

I already know I will love the next book and will read this one again before then. I need to slow down and look closer at the details I probably missed in reading to find out what would happen.
10 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read A Discovery of Witches.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
February 27, 2011 – Shelved
July 18, 2011 – Started Reading
July 20, 2011 –
page 209
35.3% "A lot more interesting than I expected. And since I had not read any reviews but just bought it on a recommendation, I really didn't have a clue what it was about. Very intriguing."
July 22, 2011 –
page 412
69.59% "Really don't want to have this end - really really interesting book. I don't know what I expected but this is not it and I let it sit on my shelf far to long. I am not really into reading about witches but so much history in this story."
July 25, 2011 – Finished Reading
July 26, 2011 – Shelved as: favorites
September 10, 2011 – Shelved as: could-not-put-it-down-books
October 23, 2011 – Shelved as: love-the-audio
October 23, 2011 – Shelved as: read-more-than-once
May 18, 2018 – Started Reading
May 18, 2018 – Shelved as: a-big-box-of-stars
May 18, 2018 – Shelved as: epic-series
May 18, 2018 – Shelved as: favorite-author
May 18, 2018 – Shelved as: favorite-series
May 18, 2018 – Shelved as: historical
May 18, 2018 – Shelved as: magic
May 18, 2018 – Shelved as: paranormal
May 18, 2018 – Shelved as: romance
May 18, 2018 – Shelved as: supernatural
May 18, 2018 – Shelved as: trilogy
May 18, 2018 – Shelved as: vampires
May 18, 2018 – Shelved as: witches
May 25, 2018 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-17 of 17 (17 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Michele (Reading Lark/CanadianTwiMom) Great review Terry! I think I will like it! Hopefully, I'll get to it soon!! :)


message 2: by [deleted user] (new)

WOW! thanks ever so much


Constinteen Your reviews are always so thorough! I've had a similar opinion with most things we've both read. Which is making me think I should give this another try. The first half of the book I LOVED. Something about the second half annoyed me though. I'll definitely being reading the sequels though. (Don't you hate starting a series before the next book is out?!! Especially with that ending!) Hey thanks again for the Juliet Marrilier suggestions. I'm obsessed!


Terry (Ter05 TwiMoms/ MundieMoms) Thanks. I actually loved every minute of this book and the audiobook is just awesome. Actually this book being part of a series didn't bother me as I was content with the way it ended. It was like a chapter in their life together had been written and I don't mind waiting for the next chapter. The total fact that they had a real solid love that could survive anything was established so now we just need to have the adventure they are going to share. And glad you love Juliet Marillier! My daughter in law is reading them now and loving them too. She has read all the Sevenwaters books and the Bridei Chronicles and now reading Wolfskin. Those are books I will read again and again.


Gina (My Precious Blog) So, I'm nearly 70% through with the first book. I'm enjoying this read, its got a lot to offer. My only problem is I feel like the romance lives in the foreground of this book. I would like it to be more in the background... does it remain the main focus as the series progresses?


Terry (Ter05 TwiMoms/ MundieMoms) Hmmmm. I never thought about that. Thinking about the second book, it is less in the foreground for sure. I think the first book is establishing their relationship. The second book is very much historical and they are in a different setting and Matthew is different. Which I know is kind of confusing considering where you are in the book. I think she had to establish just how much Diana loves him because he is not human and she has to love him totally to endure what is to come. Not to make that ominous. I loved the first book, really liked the second but when I re-read it I loved it more (I should have gone to Wiki and looked up some history as it went along which I did the second time- it was a place and period I was not familiar with) The third book just blew me away. I've read some really great books this year and it was my favorite. There are some really great characters in the second two books that are not brought out or are not in the first one. One in particular I would really like to see a spinoff for.


Gina (My Precious Blog) Terry (Ter05 TwiMoms/ MundieMoms) wrote: "Hmmmm. I never thought about that. Thinking about the second book, it is less in the foreground for sure. I think the first book is establishing their relationship. The second book is very much..."

Nice, I think I'm going to like the series more moving forward. I've heard many people comparing this to Twilight saying this is the adult version. I've not read Twilight, so this is all brand new to me. I enjoy the detailed history, the alchemy and especially the vampire and witch lore. I'm so intrigued by the Ashmole book and its contents. I have some many things I'm curious about. I'm looking forward to continuing the series, I have #2 available at the library (digital). The only problem is the LENGTH. Its taking me a while to get through this one!


Terry (Ter05 TwiMoms/ MundieMoms) I've read Twilight countless times and this series does not remind me of Twilight in the slightest. The only thing they have in common is that the guy is a Vampire as are his family. But in Twilight he is 17 and not even 100 years old - not exactly a vampire like Matthew! This series is history if only for the reason that Matthew is what, 1500 years old. He knew Darwin for heavens sake. No witches in Twilight. I guess it irritates me when people say things like that because it gives so many people preconceived ideas. I loved Twilight but on a whole different level than these books. If they remind me of anything just as a read and not by content, it is the Outlander series. And that just because neither of them remind me of anything else I have ever read but these two series have history, a love story that is no cheesy romance, incredible grown up characters and subject matter...and they are long detailed deep books.


Gina (My Precious Blog) Terry (Ter05 TwiMoms/ MundieMoms) wrote: "I've read Twilight countless times and this series does not remind me of Twilight in the slightest. The only thing they have in common is that the guy is a Vampire as are his family. But in Twili..."
Great explanation of the poor comparison between Twilight and DoW. I feel the same as you do. For example, people are really missing out on Holly Black's latest MG novel, The Iron Trial because they say its too much like Harry Potter. I loved the book and didn't see any real similarities.

I've always steered clear of Outlander because I thought it was a cheesy romance story. I'm just not a big fan of lots of romance in the books I read. If its anything like Discovery of Witches I may have to give it a try. Since even though romance is in this one, its very subtle and gentle in descriptions. What I appreciate in my most loved books are detailed, deep books, but I do struggle with length. That being said, some of my most FAVORITED books/series are extra long. BTW have you read Michael J. Sullivan's Riyria Revelations Series? It might be something you'd really like?


Terry (Ter05 TwiMoms/ MundieMoms) I have not read tjpse amd will check them out. I have a ridiculous number of books here to read. If I find something I want to read and it seems like book in series I have been reading have come out like craay this fall I tend to just buy it. I am afraid I will forget about them if I don't. And there is nothing cheesy about Outlander. There is a lot of sex in it and I tend to skim that. It's gritty and real and details about 18th century Scotland are graphic. My brother and my son have read all the books and both feel it is probably the most realistic portrayal of history they have read. It is not "prettied up". It is an amazing love story - I would not cal it a
romance" because that tends to sound cheesy. It's a love story because it is not about two youngsters who fall in love and ride off into the sunset. In the most recent book in the series Claire is 62 and Jamie is five years younger - and theirs is still a love story. Of course they are long too - and detailed. I love books/movies about Scotland anyway. I struggle with length too but perhaps my favorite book ever is Atlas Shrugged and it is over 1000 pages and I didn't want it to end. But I don't usually read books that long!


Gina (My Precious Blog) OMG you read Atlas Shrugged, 1000+ pages! Wow! I commend you. I wouldn't probably even have the courage to try. I'm glad you loved it, otherwise it may have been torturous! The "there is a lot of sex" in Outlander is the part that tends to scare me off. I just don't like reading about sex, not sure why. I'm still going to check into it because Game of Thrones is like that, but its a series I LOVE!


Terry (Ter05 TwiMoms/ MundieMoms) I wouod rather do without specific sex scenes too, but I can skim. The big difference between Outlander and GoT is that all the sex is between two people who are married and who deeply love each other. Big difference than Game of Thrones!

Atlas Shrugged has romance in it and definitely a mystery. It is the characters that make it incredible. The romance is secondary but part of the amazine story. I actually found myself looking at my right hand to see how much book I had left and sad when it started dwindling. It's an incredible story - and so amazing that it was written in the late fifties and so timely. I really do not seek out long books!! I've given up on a number of them. I read Game of Thrones to the wedding scene, threw the book up against the wall and sold the rest of them back to the bookstore. Just too much treachery for me. I figured Rob would be killed....but not like that.


Gina (My Precious Blog) Terry (Ter05 TwiMoms/ MundieMoms) wrote: "I wouod rather do without specific sex scenes too, but I can skim. The big difference between Outlander and GoT is that all the sex is between two people who are married and who deeply love each o..."
I'm mainly watching the HBO series and I'm still on Season 1. I really like the dwarf and the dragon lady. I never can get the names straight so many characters. I don't know if I'd ever have the courage to read Atlas Shrugged. Its very intimidating. I may have a better chance reading the Outlander Series for sure. Its also nice to know others don't like reading the specific sex scenes. I thought I was for sure in the minority.


Terry (Ter05 TwiMoms/ MundieMoms) LOL I think we are in the minority on the sex scenes. I can handle them as written in Outlander but detest the smutty ones. I tend to be more forgiving if it is historical or fantasy than if it is contemporary. Probably my favorite fantasy series is CL Wilson's Tairen Soul series and the sex in it is so beautifully written that I was not even tempted to skim. That is the exception though. I do read a lot of YA to avoid the raunchy stuff.
Sorry if I did a spoiler on Game of Thrones. I thought you had read them. If you think the TV series is hard to keep track of names - the books are just awful that way. I quit reading the second one part way through and then decided I would just ignore all the names except the very main characters and did fine after that. There really isn't as much sex in the books as there is in the series - or maybe it's because seeing it is more shocking.


Crazy4more Hope to have this audiobook for my roadtrip from FL to IL!


Terry (Ter05 TwiMoms/ MundieMoms) It should be a good one for a long trip. I liked the narrator a lot.


Crazy4more Can't wait for the book. Heard great things about it.

Thanks!


back to top