ŷ

Lisa's Reviews > Tschernobyl: Eine Chronik der Zukunft

Tschernobyl by Svetlana Alexievich
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
32532774
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: nobels, unforgettable, so-good-it-hurts

Very touching voices, chronicling the Chernobyl experience and comparing life before and after the moment that changed everything.

Svetlana Alexievich captures the suffering of ordinary people of all walks of life, as well as that of professional staff sent to Chernobyl to deal with the crisis immediately after it happened. She creates a social panorama of the society that was affected in its totality by the nuclear disaster.

I will never forget my feelings in 1986, living in West Germany and attending a small town primary school. All of a sudden, global politics became a tangible reality and a threat. Chernobyl was the first man-made disaster that I experienced and understood. After Chernobyl, nothing was ever as innocent as before again. A wake-up call for my social conscience, you could say. But I never grasped what it was like for the people who were there, who saw it happen, who had to make decisions on their future based on that catastrophe. Reading Alexievich gave me inside knowledge of the nightmare I remember from my childhood. While we were just kept away from certain foods, and weren't allowed to play in the sandbox or go on field trips, people in proximity to Chernobyl fought - often hopelessly - for their lives.

I had to put down the book several times and take a break, as the stories are painful to read, particularly those which tell of ordinary issues and problems, and of ordinary people. The individuals telling their stories are not heroes, and they don't have the privilege of being seen and heard and worshipped for their suffering, like religious martyrs or soldiers. They just happened to be singled out by the shared experience of the disaster:

"We're often silent. We don't yell and we don't complain. We're patient, as always. Because we don't have the words yet. We're afraid to talk about it. We don't know how. It's not an ordinary experience, and the questions it raises are not ordinary. The world has been split in two: there's us, the Chernobylites, and then there's you, the others. Have you noticed? No one here points out that they're Russian or Belarussian or Ukrainian. We all call ourselves Chernobylites. "We're from Chernobyl." "I'm a Chernobylite." As if this is a separate people. A new nation."

It is the author's strength to put those silent voices on loudspeaker, to let them have their say, to let them show "the others" what it was really like to live through a nuclear accident. Alexievich gives literature a democratic touch, not putting her creativity in focus, but rather her empathy for the different people she encounters. Her literary skills lies in the careful collection and arrangement of the disparate voices to a reading experience of unique character.

Intense reading! I strongly recommend it to the world of today. Read and think.
109 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Tschernobyl.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Started Reading
January 16, 2016 – Shelved
January 16, 2016 – Shelved as: nobels
January 16, 2016 – Finished Reading
October 28, 2017 – Shelved as: unforgettable
October 28, 2017 – Shelved as: so-good-it-hurts

Comments Showing 1-21 of 21 (21 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by [deleted user] (new)

My experience from 1986 was that I suddenly started getting Lugol’s iodine at school to block the possible radiation... The world we live in... *sigh*


message 2: by Czarny (new)

Czarny Pies Congratulations for a fine review. I particularly like the way you integrate your personal experiences into the review.


Lisa T for Tongue-tied wrote: "My experience from 1986 was that I suddenly started getting Lugol’s iodine at school to block the possible radiation... The world we live in... *sigh*"

Yes, I remember those as well!!


Lisa Czarny wrote: "Congratulations for a fine review. I particularly like the way you integrate your personal experiences into the review."

Thank you kindly, Czarny! I think most people are shaped by the events they remember from childhood. And Chernobyl was such a moment for me! Later, the fall of the Berlin Wall played a similarly defining role.


Lisa Jean-Paul wrote: "Thank you for conveying the the silent voices to us, Lisa!"

Thank you, Jean-Paul! They deserve to be heard!


message 6: by Dolors (new) - added it

Dolors A powerful review, Lisa... Voices that shouldn't fall into oblivion...


Lisa Dolors wrote: "A powerful review, Lisa... Voices that shouldn't fall into oblivion..."

Thank you, Dolors! That is the message of her book: don't forget those silent people.


message 8: by Dimitri (new) - added it

Dimitri Tsjernobil diary. We love Tsjernobil. Tsjernobil: a chronicle of the future. Each translation has a very divergent title; what is the meaning of the original Russian?


Lisa Dimitri wrote: "Tsjernobil diary. We love Tsjernobil. Tsjernobil: a chronicle of the future. Each translation has a very divergent title; what is the meaning of the original Russian?"

I don't know, Dimitri! That is an interesting question. Often I find Enflish translations to have far-fetched titles - presumably to draw attention to the book. I read it in German, which features the "chronicle of the future" subtitle.


message 10: by Haaze (new) - added it

Haaze Wikipedia has the original title listed as "Chernobyl Prayer"

Чернобыльская молитва (Chernobylskaya molitva, Chernobyl Prayer)


message 11: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Haaze wrote: "Wikipedia has the original title listed as "Chernobyl Prayer"

Чернобыльская молитва (Chernobylskaya molitva, Chernobyl Prayer)"


Thanks, Haaze!!


Steven Godin I hope one day I can bring myself to read this. It's not going to pleasant, but feel it's a must.


message 13: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Steven wrote: "I hope one day I can bring myself to read this. It's not going to pleasant, but feel it's a must."

Yes, that is a perfectly accurate estimation of the reading that is waiting for you, Steven. And as I believe we are approximately of the same generation, you will probably have similar childhood memories of that catastrophe breaking into "innocent" life?


message 14: by Julie (new)

Julie Once again, you've touched a nerve, Lisa. It seems almost indecent to "like" your review on such an emotional topic -- but what else can one do? Flash a peace sign, to say "I hear you". ??? Sigh.


message 15: by Isidora (new) - added it

Isidora I remember the spring 1986 as a spring when we didn't eat lettuce. Could I possibly understand then what it was like for Chernobyl people? I"ll do as you recommend: read and think.


message 16: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Julie wrote: "Once again, you've touched a nerve, Lisa. It seems almost indecent to "like" your review on such an emotional topic -- but what else can one do? Flash a peace sign, to say "I hear you". ??? Sigh."

I like the idea of flashing peace signs, Julie! Maybe they would eventually outnumber the ugly flags people are waving to show exclusive rights?


message 17: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Isidora wrote: "I remember the spring 1986 as a spring when we didn't eat lettuce. Could I possibly understand then what it was like for Chernobyl people? I"ll do as you recommend: read and think."

Yes, I remember that as well: no lettuce, no milk, Geiger-counters in the garden...


message 18: by Cecily (new)

Cecily Very powerful, Lisa. Even in England there were small effects (domestic lamb was not allowed to be sold and eater for a while). But unless you were a sheep farmer, that was trivial. Your memories, let alone those of the people in the book... what can one say? But we need to remember.


message 19: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Cecily wrote: "Very powerful, Lisa. Even in England there were small effects (domestic lamb was not allowed to be sold and eater for a while). But unless you were a sheep farmer, that was trivial. Your memories, ..."

Yes, we do indeed need to remember! I think this book does humanity a great favour, despite the bitter feeling. It shows concrete - not abstract - consequences of nuclear disaster.


message 20: by Fiona (new)

Fiona On holiday in Guernsey, Channel Islands, a few years ago, we were having lunch on a hotel patio when a group of around 15 young teens appeared and launched themselves into the pool. They were speaking what sounded to us like Russian or an Eastern European language so we asked the waiter about them. Every year, the hotel owner sponsors a group of kids from Chernobyl, bringing them over to stay for a week’s holiday. The kids were having a great time and we were very moved that they weren’t being forgotten, at least not here.


message 21: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Fiona wrote: "On holiday in Guernsey, Channel Islands, a few years ago, we were having lunch on a hotel patio when a group of around 15 young teens appeared and launched themselves into the pool. They were speak..."

That is a glimpse of hope for sure! Thank you for sharing, Fiona!


back to top