ŷ

Brina's Reviews > And Then There Were None

And Then There Were None by Agatha Christie
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
2933855
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: agatha-christie, mystery

This year I have decided to take part in a women's century challenge in the group catching up on classics where the participants read a book written in ten consecutive decades. I chose to focus on the 20th century and my 1930s selection is And Then There Were None by Agatha Christie. Although I had previously read some of her Hercule Poirot cases, this is my first stand alone mystery of Christie's that I have read. A suspenseful premise for a case, And Then There Were None left me on edge for the duration of the book.

Ten individuals who committed murder at one point in their lives have been invited to Soldier Island for a supposed holiday. Upon arrival, the participants note the quaintness of the island and the home which they are staying in. Yet, on top of the mantel in each bedroom is the poem "ten little Indians". In the communal dining room are ten salt shakers each representing a person and the same poem. As the group gathers for cocktail hour, a gramophone recording announces the crime each individual is guilty of committing. Shocked at first, each person comes to terms with the accusation and reveals what really happened to the group.

Christie's participants represent a cross section of society including a judge, doctor, Scotland Yard police officer, retired general, mercenary, governess, and spinster. None of these primary participants believes themselves guilty of the crime because after all they were acquitted. Yet one of their party believes them all to be guilty, or they would not have been invited to Soldier Island. One by one the group is murdered, the island is searched, and the dwindling group realizes that there is a murderer in their midst. The death mirrors the poem on the wall, and as each person is killed, another salt shaker breaks. It is up to the remaining people to identify the murder.

Unlike Hercule Poirot cases where Christie allows the reader to crack the case early on only to have Poirot peal back layers and layers to the case, in And Then There Were None, Dame Christie does not clue us as to who the murderer is. Even someone as myself who reads a fair number of mysteries was left captivated as to whodunit, allowing me to read quickly until the end of the book. The participants were also held in suspense, accusing each other of being the murderer. This lead to a revealing denouement, one that had me guessing until the last page.

I have read many mysteries written by women, including many cases starring female private eyes and police detectives. Many of these mystery writers have Dame Agatha Christie to thank for paving their way as early as the 1920s. And Then There Were None first appeared in serial form, leaving its readers in suspense until the next installment appeared. A captivating mystery, I am open to reading more of Christie's stand alone cases, and rate this mystery 4 stars.
250 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read And Then There Were None.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

January 29, 2016 – Shelved
January 29, 2016 – Shelved as: to-read
April 1, 2016 – Shelved as: mystery
April 1, 2016 – Shelved as: agatha-christie
January 2, 2017 –
page 51
20.65%
January 3, 2017 – Started Reading
January 4, 2017 –
page 137
55.47%
January 5, 2017 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-22 of 22 (22 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

PorshaJo Yeah! This is a great Christie book. Hope you like Brina.


Kristy Miller In my opinion this is the best mystery ever written. I've probably read it five times, and it still makes me keep the light on at night. Last year there was a 3 part miniseries adaptation done by Acorn, and it is phenomenal!


Brina I am still partial to Poirot. I don't know if I could watch this but it would be interesting to say the least.


Kristy Miller Charles Dance, Toby Stephens, Burn Gorman, Aidan Turner, Miranda Richardson, Sam Neill, and Anna Martin-Maxwell. It's worth it. :)
I need to read some Poirot. They're doing Murder on the Orient Express this year. That cast is also amazing.


Brina I love Murder on the Orient Express. That is my all time favorite. That is an amazing cast. I would watch just for Richardson, and I'm going to check to see if the library has.


message 6: by Mike (new)

Mike Fantastic review, Brina. Probably my favorite book that my English teachers forced me to read and remember caring about.


Brina Thanks much, Mike. I have been rereading the books I had to read for school. You are lucky that you got to read Christie because most of the books I read in school were so-so.


éèԱ I had forgotten this one; good to remeber it through your review.


Brina Thank you, Helene. I prefer Poirot but this was a riveting case.


❶Ĵܱ Great review, Brina! I could not sleep after reading this!


message 11: by Jann (new)

Jann This was also made into a play in 1943 which was very well received at the time. Great review Brina. I may now go back to read this again, myself! I had once set myself a goal of reading all the Christie mysteries but eventually stopped because I realized that many were just the same old plot, but with other characters substituted. This book obviously does not conform to the pattern which may be why it has been an enduring classic, both in print and in dramatised versions. I wish I had seen the miniseries Kristy refers to. It seems there were a lot of super actors in it and Aidan Turner alone would make me want to see it!


message 12: by Monnie (new)

Monnie Haven't read any of her books in, well, never mind how many years. But I loved them. Excellent review!


Kristy Miller Jann wrote: "This was also made into a play in 1943 which was very well received at the time. Great review Brina. I may now go back to read this again, myself! I had once set myself a goal of reading all the Ch..."

Jann, he is definitely, *DEFINITELY* worth it. Acorn has their own streaming platform now, and I think you can try it free for 30 days. I don't know if you can rent it from Amazon.


message 14: by Jann (new)

Jann Thanks Kristy, I will have a look.


Brina Julie, Monnie, Jann thanks for the insights. Sorry I don't have time to give this normal attention. It the stomach bug has hit my house. Kids under the weather so at least I can stay in and read.


message 16: by Jann (new)

Jann Brina wrote: "Julie, Monnie, Jann thanks for the insights. Sorry I don't have time to give this normal attention. It the stomach bug has hit my house. Kids under the weather so at least I can stay in and read."
So sorry to hear that, Brina. I hope your kids get better soon and that you don't catch it yourself. :-) I'm glad you are taking advantage of the bright side of this.


Brina I work at their school so either I'll catch it or I'll get lucky. Thanks, Jann. I'm looking forward to 48 hours of reading time.


message 18: by Cindy (new)

Cindy Marsch I love the idea of creating a structured reading challenge like this - fun!


Brina Cindy it's in the group catching up on classics but easy to do on your own-- pick a century and read a book in each decade. This challenge was for women authors but easy enough to come up with one of your own.


message 20: by Cindy (new)

Cindy Marsch Brina wrote: "Cindy it's in the group catching up on classics but easy to do on your own-- pick a century and read a book in each decade. This challenge was for women authors but easy enough to come up with one ..."

Thanks!


Aprilleigh How funny! I'm using it for exactly the same challenge in the same group for this year!


Brina I hope you enjoy it Aprilleigh :)


back to top