ŷ

Seemita's Reviews > Embers

Embers by Sándor Márai
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
34622220
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: fiction, hungary, translated, sharp_sword, singing_words, favorites, monologue, nostalgia, for_legacy, me

My fingers were interlocked around my Baba’s arm and my head was resting on his shoulders. I was stealing a glimpse of his face every now and then, convinced that the lines of exhaustion were going to creep upto his tongue any moment, tendering me an apology to relieve him of our evening chatter for the day. However, my apprehensions were misplaced. The exhaustion stood defeated in the face of the radiance that slowly, ever so gradually, filled his visage, displacing the fatigue like a magic potion, as he reached for the cassette player and put one of his most favorite songs in loop. He also fondly went on to explain me its meaning. , originally composed in Oriya language, is an ode to ‘m𳾴ǰ�; in Oriya, the two words literally translate to ‘Memory, You�. The translated lyrics go like this:

Memory, You are the indiscernible breeze of a spring evening;
Memory, You are the seething ember beneath the ash;
Memory, You are the dancer’s teasing frill at a temple’s entrance;
Memory, You are the glimpse of tender moon from the mane of Casuarina trees;
Memory, You are the passionate note left behind in a traveller’s lodge;
Memory, You are the departed lover’s village�
Memory, You are the red stain on the stone guarding shoreline;
Memory, You are the dusk’s glow that lights up a dull widow’s countenance;
Memory, You are the paper boat on the river that won’t reappear;
Memory, are you not my treasured Beloved?

As I read Embers, this song hung heavily on my psyche due to its similar metaphorical luminosity:
With age, memory enlarges every detail and presents it in the sharpest outline.
When the rhapsody of those evening lyrics dissolved into the heartbeat of these present words, I heard a tremor that wasn’t a simulacrum of a faint earthquake but the obstreperous throbbing of a vein - a matter of delicate urgency where an inflammation not arrested in time leaves a spot defunct; worse, violated. Such violated lumps of memory hover around a life like the spirit - unseen, unlit, frequently uncouth but always undone.

In Embers, two boys forge the best kind of friendship, two young men test the toughest kind of friendship and two old men relive the only kind of friendship.
Their friendship was deep and wordless, as are all the emotions that will last a lifetime. And like all great emotions, this one contained within itself both shame and a sense of guilt, for no one may isolate one of his fellows from the rest of humanity with impunity.
Over a period of seventy-five years, the birth, maturity and death of every emotion is held between the tender palms of decision and indecision, truth and cowardice, fate and loss, and is flannelled against life filters. A single deed, thus crushed and sieved, comes to haunt one for forty-one years, enmeshing him in the web his exploring fingers had unsuspectingly sewn around his own house. Did the deed trickle down in the same abnegating, granular texture beneath the pillow of the other too, robbing his sleep for those very forty-one years? Márai invites us to find out over a course of a cold, dark night; lit exquisitely by one’s questions, suspended excruciatingly by another’s abstinence and held inadvertently by a few embers, standing witness to a debilitating relationship, slowly meeting her fate.

In an all-encompassing, surreal, lyrical, almost devastating monologue, Márai trounces everything supercilious, including answers, for a man at his twilight doesn’t require answers; he seeks peace. Words become mere instruments of wrapping time into bearable currents, getting their echoes despatched to silent death in the confines of a mind engaged in altering memories, if not erasing them. When a sigh can expel the biggest burden off the chest and impart purpose to one’s living, hypothesis await no longer the stamp of verification. Endurance of a life-time denudes all justifications and arguments, leaving a residue that intends to simply burn and become smoke.

Smoke they did become, the memories. But the vestiges persisted, like the embers; silent, hidden, simmering and expectant of revelation on yet another cold night, subjugating the breeze of words and emerging triumphant.

[Note: My apologies for any mistakes I might have committed in translating the Oriya song. My memories of it are a decade old and I might have faltered at few places in comprehension or recollection.]
99 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Embers.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

February 3, 2016 – Shelved
February 22, 2016 – Started Reading
February 22, 2016 –
page 10
4.67% "'Many years ago—he thought only in decades, anything more exact upset him, as if he might be reminded of things he would rather forget—he had had the wall between the two rooms torn down.'"
February 22, 2016 –
page 16
7.48% "'After reaching ninety, one ages differently from the way one aged at fifty or sixty: one ages without bitterness. Nini’s face was rose pink and crumpled—such is the way noble fabrics age, and centuries-old silks that hold woven in their threads the assembled skills and dreams of an entire family.'"
February 23, 2016 –
page 30
14.02% "'One day we lose the person we love. Anyone who is unable to sustain that loss fails as a human being and does not deserve our sympathy.'"
February 23, 2016 –
page 63
29.44% "'When he listened to music, he listened with his whole body, as longingly as a condemned man in his cell aches for the sound of distant feet perhaps bringing news of his release.'"
February 24, 2016 –
page 87
40.65% "'Memory has a wonderful way of separating the wheat from the chaff. There can be some great event, and ten, twenty years later one realizes that it had no effect on one whatsoever. And then one day, one remembers a hunt or a passage in a book or this room.'"
February 24, 2016 –
page 102
47.66% "'Isn’t it our duty to accept the faithless friend as we do the faithful one who sacrifices himself? Is disinterest not the essence of every human relationship? That the more we give, the less we expect?'"
February 25, 2016 –
page 120
56.07% "'By the end, everything has happened and the sum total is clear. And yet, sometimes facts are no more than pitiful consequences, because guilt does not reside in our acts but in the intentions that give rise to our acts.'"
February 26, 2016 –
page 160
74.77% "'And like everyone whom the gods spoil without reason, I feel a kind of anxiety buried at the heart of my happiness. It is all too beautiful, too flawless, too complete. Such unbroken happiness always arouses fear.'"
February 27, 2016 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 69 (69 new)


Dolors Wow... flabbergasting review coming soon...


Seemita Dolors wrote: "Wow... flabbergasting review coming soon..."

Still grappling for words... Such exquisite brilliance!


Stephen P(who no longer can participate due to illness) I absolutely loved this book. Looking forward to your take on it Seemita.


Dolors Seemita wrote: "Dolors wrote: "Wow... flabbergasting review coming soon..."

Still grappling for words... Such exquisite brilliance!"


Okay, I get the cue. I need to read Sándor Márai. Directly to my wishlist!


message 5: by flo (new) - added it

flo Ah, I saw this one today at the bookstore. It has been on my TBR pile since like two years but I wasn't sure. I'm ecstatic to see your five stars! I'm definitely going to buy it next time.


Seemita Stephen wrote: "I absolutely loved this book. Looking forward to your take on it Seemita."

I can see those sparkling 5 stars next to your name, Stephen and only I know what it is taking on my part to withhold jumping to your review thread right away and reading your thoughts! I hope to pen something soon although I am certain of not meting out justice to Márai's craft.


Seemita Dolors wrote: "Okay, I get the cue. I need to read Sándor Márai. Directly to my wishlist!"

Yay!! My work is already half done :))


Seemita Florencia wrote: "Ah, I saw this one today at the bookstore. It has been on my TBR pile since like two years but I wasn't sure. I'm ecstatic to see your five stars! I'm definitely going to buy it next time."

Thrilled to know of your intention, Flor! I hope I haven't magnified your hopes too much although the euphoria is not without reason either :)


Ilse Seemita, I am so delighted with your 5* rating - Márai. is one of my absolute favorites, and I am sure your review-to-come will induce a next true Márai wave amongst your friends! I read Embers 3 times, and I just know your will write a stellar review on it!


Agnieszka So glad , Seemita , that you found that little novel to your taste ! Will be waiting for your thoughts on it . I , by myself , was trying to gather my thoughts , but as for now words still escape me .


message 11: by Violet (new) - added it

Violet wells Beautiful seductive review, Seemita.


Seemita Ilse wrote: "Seemita, I am so delighted with your 5* rating - Márai. is one of my absolute favorites, and I am sure your review-to-come will induce a next true Márai wave amongst your friends! I read Embers 3 t..."

Oh I am totally with you here, Ilse! Márai has a bewitching charm, which when laden with insight, becomes a fatal combination. I have put up my humble thoughts which, although pale under his prowess, is my way of thanking him for penning this beauty.

P.S. I, too, must read this again sometime :)


Seemita Agnieszka wrote: "So glad , Seemita , that you found that little novel to your taste ! Will be waiting for your thoughts on it . I , by myself , was trying to gather my thoughts , but as for now words still escape me ."

Glad to find you too in the warm net of Márai's magic, Agna! Like you, words kept escaping me too. But I was also increasingly being caught by a fear of not being able to write anything lest I allowed postponement any further. So, here I am. Hope you continue to be generous and give your nod to the ramblings :)


message 14: by Srividya (new) - added it

Srividya Vijapure Beautiful and sublime review! I loved the song in the beginning. I can imagine how beautiful it must have been to experience it in the original language. Lovely memories of your father as well. Loved it all. :)


Kalliope I jumped when I saw you were reviewing this, Seemita. A great favourite of mine, and your approach through the Oriya song, introducing it for the rest of us, is a treat.

A dramatised version of this was produced with Jeremy Irons acting on it.. Shame I could not attend to it.


Dolors Dear Simi, in this vivid exploration of the nature of memory and the inexorable passage of time you achieve the impossible: that the distant past writhes with life. What is the present but a still, immobile moment, an artifact that projects our past memories and discounts what the future might hold in store for us?
The personal tone of your opening paragraph sparkles with whatever genius Marais's prose might possess, and in the tune of that nostalgic song, pregnant with life-altering meanings, I envision springtime ahead, with the sunbeams warming our glowing faces...
I have "Portraits of a Marriage" waiting on my shelves, thanks for making sure that I pick it soon, very soon...


message 17: by Ilse (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ilse Such a joy to read your sublime, exquisite reflections on Embers, Seemita. If there would be only ten books one could read in a lifetime, shouldn't Embers be one of them ? Your images on the substance of memory are poignant and the lyrics of the song you translated from the Oriya language mesmerises the senses. Thank you for honoring this novel which is very dear to me with your radiant prose!


Kalliope Jean-Paul wrote: "A simply sublime review Seemita. The lyrics to the song are breath-taking; I loved: Memory, You are the seething ember beneath the ash. Sándor Márai is one of my favourite authors; "Embers" one of ..."

jean-Paul, I also loved Portraits of a Marriage, and saw an excellent dramatised version too. Marai is one of my favourite writers - shame I have to read him in translation.


message 19: by Vessey (last edited Feb 29, 2016 11:08AM) (new) - added it

Vessey Seemita, the unrelenting graceful beauty of your reviews reminds me of Virginia Woolf and what she calls a writer’s integrity. I believe you have that in abundance. In “A Room of One’s Own� she claims that one’s writing needs to be devoid of “all desire to protest, to preach, to proclaim an injury, to pay off a score, to make the world the witness of some hardship or grievance�. And I can wholeheartedly say that your writing is exactly such one. It is imbued with tenderness, grace, beauty and calm, steady determination. It is like a narrow, but strong and relentless stream that flows tirelessly and in harmony with everything around it. You are a beautiful and graceful lady with an enormous talent and your style strongly resembles her own. I believe she lives in you..


Helle Beautiful, Seemita. You have long since branched off into your own genre here on GR: no matter what you read, your reviews are poems, ballads and odes which the rest of us read in awe. This book sounds tempting, but I wonder if it's for me...


Kalliope Jean-Paul wrote: "Kalliope wrote: "Jean-Paul wrote: "A simply sublime review Seemita. The lyrics to the song are breath-taking; I loved: Memory, You are the seething ember beneath the ash. Sándor Márai is one of my ..."

Jean-Paul, this one I saw was a dramatisation on the theatre... it was very cleverly done... the way it had to adapt the tripartite structure - it became a triptych on the stage.

But I know what you mean about filmed adaptations of books.. even though I am also seeing the film versions like a sort of 'review'... a creative exercise in its own right..


message 22: by Sumati (new)

Sumati Amazing review Seemita! That was such a warm beginning.


rahul :)


Seemita Violet wrote: "Beautiful seductive review, Seemita."

Thank you, Violet!


Seemita Srividya wrote: "Beautiful and sublime review! I loved the song in the beginning. I can imagine how beautiful it must have been to experience it in the original language. Lovely memories of your father as well. Lov..."

Thanks a ton for your warm words, Sri! Yes, this book brought back that memory like a gust; and that tender perspicacity of the song. It is indeed an ethereal feeling to hear it in Oriya; I did steal a few moments of blissful reminiscence of my father :)


Seemita Sabah wrote: "Seemita, your exquisite prose floods and ignites my synaptic senses, to stir to life the power of memories not dimmed or faded to sepia by time. Their impressions may be altered and heightened to a..."

Oh Sabah, the vibrancy of your gushing flow of thoughts is hard to match and hence, I am simply sending you a heartfelt thanks :) Our memories are indeed an extended part of us, never to die, never to cease; perhaps they assume different garbs from time to time but they undauntingly stand companion in our journeys. I am glad you share a similar perception and have been kind enough to share it in your beautifully crafted comment.


Seemita Kalliope wrote: "I jumped when I saw you were reviewing this, Seemita. A great favourite of mine, and your approach through the Oriya song, introducing it for the rest of us, is a treat.

A dramatised version of th..."


Pleasure is all mine, Kall! I jumped at your rating too! This is such an amazing little gem; so precious. I was reminded very strongly of that Oriya song during my reading and sort of felt compelled to include it in the review. Glad it resonated with you :) As far as the dramatic adaptation is concerned, I have, sadly, now come across any enactment in locations accessible to me. But I wish you get lucky soon!


Seemita Jean-Paul wrote: "A simply sublime review Seemita. The lyrics to the song are breath-taking; I loved: Memory, You are the seething ember beneath the ash. Sándor Márai is one of my favourite authors; "Embers" one of ..."

Thank you very much for your lovely words, JP. I suppose the book invokes such reaction; one is held captive, almost like the narrator, in the castle of memories and retrospection from where even the passing breeze cannot escape untouched. I am pleased to share your enthusiasm for this book as well as the lyrics I awkwardly translated :) And I do have PoaM with me and it will take me in sometime, soon.


Seemita Dolors wrote: "Dear Simi, in this vivid exploration of the nature of memory and the inexorable passage of time you achieve the impossible: that the distant past writhes with life. What is the present but a still,..."

Your craft of distilling the beauty of a work, irrespective of its dazzle, distance and density, is an enviable trait I wish to emulate, dear D! You completely make Márai's essence your own when you tenderly place the mirror of present to reflect the past in all its glory and vanity. Márai's narrator is not a preacher, nor is he a victim; he is simply a conduit of life events that integrate to attest a certain neutrality which life imparts as it touches the finishing line. I am so glad you sent a little tremor down your TBR pile to up Márai's place; your review of his music would be an otherworldly experience :) Here's to warm springs and glowing faces!


message 30: by Junta (new) - added it

Junta Nice incorporation of the song lyrics! Sounds like a fascinating story (monologue) to read - I'll be watching out for this book.


message 31: by Seemita (last edited Mar 01, 2016 04:38AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Seemita Ilse wrote: "Such a joy to read your sublime, exquisite reflections on Embers, Seemita. If there would be only ten books one could read in a lifetime, shouldn't Embers be one of them ? Your images on the substa..."

The honour is all mine, Ilse. To be able to read such exquisite literary pieces is why we indeed come to literature; to ask, to explore, to infer, to learn, to unlearn, to relearn, to live our lives in a tad clearer air. Oh I also revisited a lovely time in past which makes this book all the more special to me :) So, I am thrilled to join you in Márai's club, jumping and buoyant at being totally enchanted!


Seemita Vessey wrote: "Seemita, the unrelenting graceful beauty of your reviews reminds me of Virginia Woolf and what she calls a writer’s integrity. I believe you have that in abundance. In “A Room of One’s Own� she cla..."

Oh dear Vessey, what can I possibly offer in return of such a heartfelt, beautiful compliment? That you were reminded of an author whom I consider in great reverence, for the incessant germination of life-altering observations that she effortlessly shaped into scintillating sentences and incredible arrangement of words, is the best kind of validation my writing sojourns can receive. And to have it coming from someone like you who has written glowing reviews herself, testimonial of a seeking, positive, rhythmic mind is the icing on the cake! So, thanks yet again, Vessey... you make my day :)


Seemita Helle wrote: "Beautiful, Seemita. You have long since branched off into your own genre here on GR: no matter what you read, your reviews are poems, ballads and odes which the rest of us read in awe. This book so..."

Hehe... Thanks, dear Helle! Yup, I do have my own world and things are a ...err... bit customized there ;) But I ask you to give this author one chance. This is just over 200 pages. And its narrative and texture would give you a good idea about his writing without demanding much of your time. A win-win, won't you say? :)

P.S. Bukowski is, anyway, waiting for us! :P


Seemita Sumati wrote: "Amazing review Seemita! That was such a warm beginning."

Many thanks, Sumati :)


Seemita rahul wrote: ":)"

Merci beacoup, Monsier :))


Seemita Junta wrote: "Nice incorporation of the song lyrics! Sounds like a fascinating story (monologue) to read - I'll be watching out for this book."

Thanks, Junta! It sure reads like is a whirlpool of thoughts, holding captive one's senses with an acute hypnotic charm. I would watch out for your tryst with Márai with bated breath :)


message 37: by Warwick (new)

Warwick Heady stuff!


message 38: by Fionnuala (new)

Fionnuala Thanks for the Smruti Tome link and the translation, Seemita. It was fascinating to listen to a little of the Oriya language - and something about the tone of the singer's voice made me immediately think of memories even if you hadn't told us that Smruti Tome means 'memory of you'. All so beautiful.


Seemita Warwick wrote: "Heady stuff!"

Haha... Thanks, Warwick!


Seemita Fionnuala wrote: "Thanks for the Smruti Tome link and the translation, Seemita. It was fascinating to listen to a little of the Oriya language - and something about the tone of the singer's voice made me immediately..."

I love how you sample anything new with enthusiasm, Fio! Thanks for making the link-sharing worthwhile. And it is fascinating for me to hear what a non-Oriya speaker makes of the syllables, tonality, rhythm and nuances of the language and which in your case, was a pleasure to discover :)


Seemita Jean-Paul wrote: "I'm very happy you intend to read PoaM Seemita. We live in anticipation of the hypnotic and mesmerising prose you will compose for this monumental psychological triptych. ."

I hope to be indeed swept away by another Márai-wave, JP! Thanks for your zeal.


Helle Seemita wrote: "Helle wrote: "Beautiful, Seemita. You have long since branched off into your own genre here on GR: no matter what you read, your reviews are poems, ballads and odes which the rest of us read in awe..."

Aarrghh, you tempt me into adding this, Seemita. I just took a closer look at the blurb and the cover, and I'm sold! Plus it'll give me a chance to read something by a Hungarian author and broaden my geographical scope.
And yes, Bukowski is indeed waiting for us - with bated breath, I'm sure :-)


Seemita Helle wrote: "Aarrghh, you tempt me into adding this, Seemita. I just took a closer look at the blurb and the cover, and I'm sold! Plus it'll give me a chance to read ..."

Awesome! If Hungarian lit is what you are on the lookout for, you could also sample works of László Krasznahorkai . Although I have read only one of his works, he kept me utterly hooked.
And lemme ping you for a Post Office date :D


message 44: by Glenn (new)

Glenn Russell Excellent review!

Words become mere instruments of wrapping time into bearable currents, getting their echoes despatched to silent death in the confines of a mind engaged in altering memories, if not erasing them. --------- Very true. There are more times for silence than we in our modern world generally heed.


Seemita Glenn wrote: "Excellent review!

Words become mere instruments of wrapping time into bearable currents, getting their echoes despatched to silent death in the confines of a mind engaged in altering memories, if ..."


Thanks a ton, Glenn! Yes, you are right; the underrated eloquence of silence is often the loss of the observer and not the bearer.


Seemita Marita wrote: "A beautiful, lyrical review Seemita."

Thanks a lot, Marita! Glad you liked it :)


message 47: by [deleted user] (new)

Once again a beautiful review, Seemita. I'm sure if there was a collection of your reviews, it could make it to that 'singing words' shelf.


message 48: by Jibran (last edited Mar 03, 2016 10:34AM) (new) - added it

Jibran Stunning writing, Seemita! Your lyrical reviews bring to life all images so vividly that we, the ordinary ones, feel like part of the scenes that run in our consciousness. The context of the novel is lent a sharpness of feeling with the Oriya song. I don't have access to speakers right now, but I have made a note to play it later, and savour it anew.


message 49: by Cheryl (new) - added it

Cheryl Embers and memory, oh how apropos. What beautiful memories you share also, Seemita. I've had this book marked to read for some time, so it's good to get a snippet of it from your view. Lovely review as usual.


Seemita Sidharth wrote: "Once again a beautiful review, Seemita. I'm sure if there was a collection of your reviews, it could make it to that 'singing words' shelf."

Thanks much for your lovely comment, Sidharth! Well, the residents of the singing_words shelf are stalwarts who could perhaps keep me as one of their many gate-keepers :)


« previous 1
back to top