ŷ

Stephanie *Eff your feelings*'s Reviews > The Life-Changing Magic of Tidying Up: The Japanese Art of Decluttering and Organizing

The Life-Changing Magic of Tidying Up by Marie Kondō
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
1085121
's review

liked it
bookshelves: 2016, why

Edit: Apparently thntn is very upset and thinks it’s racist of this white woman not to like this book (I like Kondo as a person just fine) because the author isn’t white. Well, that’s bullshit, obviously. If thntn doesn’t like a book by an author that is of a different race than her’s... I guess that makes thntn a racist herself. It appears that I have to make a correction. I’m told that Ms. Kondo never said to get rid of hangers. I apologize. It must have been the word ‘tidy� echoing in my brain on a loud enough level that I missed it.

Forgive me.

Terrible. Ridiculous. Repetitive.

If you took the words, tidy, tided, and tidying, out of this book you would be left with a pamphlet. I have this thing called misophonia and I made the crucial error of listening to this book on audio. Repetitive stuff can really get under my skin and there were a few instances when listening to this book that I had to stop myself from throwing my phone out of my moving vehicle. “Say tidy one more time! Do it!� Crunch.

This isn’t the type of book I would normally pick up and I think I did because of something a friend mentioned. I’ve been thinking of go through all my stuff and simplifying. So much crap accumulates around a house over the years and it starts to make one feel a little anxious. I thought that maybe this book might have some helpful tips to get it done.

Nope.

This is the book broken down once all the ‘tidy� words have been removed.

1. The whole damn house must be done in one go. (Hahahaha)
2. You have to touch each item you own and ask yourself if it brings you joy. (Riiiight)
3. If the item does not bring you joy, thank the item for it’s service (I’m not kidding) and discard it.
4. Don’t ball up your socks or tie your hose together (who does that?) because it hurts their feelings (I’m still not kidding), your supposed to put them together and roll them up like sushi and stand them in shoe boxes.
5. Fold all your clothing, no hangers of any kind EVER! Because it’s very important to touch everything you own as often as possible�.but I have to touch my clothes to hang them, right?
6. Store things vertically. This means, don’t lay your shirts down flat in the drawer, but file them (I guess) like you would files in a file drawer�.?.....
7. Women, always choose pretty clothing to wear even while lounging around the house or going bed. (Um, no)

Seriously, how much time does this woman have? There was more ridiculousness I’m sure, but I think I blocked it out, or I missed things whilst yelling ‘no no no no� to block out the ‘tidies�. As a experiment, I started going through my stuff. I didn’t ask the stuff any questions. I worked diligently, though I took breaks here and there, and after two days of sorting, purging, loading up the car and running the stuff to be donated, I got trough�.drum roll please�.. One. Closet.

Don’t bother with this book unless you love the words, tidy, tidied, and tidying and you need a good laugh.
129 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Life-Changing Magic of Tidying Up.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

February 4, 2016 – Shelved
February 4, 2016 – Shelved as: to-read
March 6, 2016 – Started Reading
March 7, 2016 – Finished Reading
March 8, 2016 – Shelved as: 2016
March 8, 2016 – Shelved as: why

Comments Showing 1-50 of 77 (77 new)


message 1: by rivka (new)

rivka
I didn’t ask the stuff any questions.
Clearly, that slowed things down. I mean, that must be the issue, right?

Thanks for helping me bump this from "probably not" to "no way".

And have you tried the FlyLady? Not everything she suggests works for me, but I did pick up a few tips that work well for me.

And purple puddles got nothin' on talking to your stuff.


message 2: by Joy (new) - rated it 1 star

Joy Great review - my thoughts exactly!


Stephanie *Eff your feelings* rivka wrote: "
I didn’t ask the stuff any questions.
Clearly, that slowed things down. I mean, that must be the issue, right?

Thanks for helping me bump this from "probably not" to "no way".

And have you t..."


You're welcome Rivka. I read it so you don't have to! Thanks! I'll check out flylady, I trust your judgement.

This book is hilarious though. It's always sad when it's meant to be serious and it's balls out funny.


Stephanie *Eff your feelings* Joy wrote: "Great review - my thoughts exactly!"

Thanks!


message 5: by rivka (new)

rivka Stephanie wrote: "I read it so you don't have to!"

Exactly!


Stephanie wrote: "I'll check out flylady, I trust your judgement."

Let me know what you think. :) (Note: The daily emails quickly got to be too much for me. I found reading stuff on the site when I had time to be less stressful.)


message 6: by Trudi (new)

Trudi A Stephanie review! A glorious treat!

Say tidy one more time, I dare you HAHAHAHA :)


Stephanie *Eff your feelings* Trudi wrote: "A Stephanie review! A glorious treat!

Say tidy one more time, I dare you HAHAHAHA :)"


Thank you! I now have an IPad, keyboard, and the Microsoft Office word app so I can finally write on my down time at work!

I now have the power!


Stephanie *Eff your feelings* rivka wrote: "Stephanie wrote: "I read it so you don't have to!"

Exactly!


Stephanie wrote: "I'll check out flylady, I trust your judgement."

Let me know what you think. :) ..."


Yeah, when I do those email things I feel the pressure too! Thanks, I'll let you know.


Nenia ✨ I yeet my books back and forth ✨ Campbell Bummer. But I'm not really a tidy sort of person, so this isn't really my cup of tea anyway. #TeamMess


message 10: by Kemper (new)

Kemper “Say tidy one more time! Do it!�

Tidy!


message 11: by Becky (new)

Becky So I read an article about this lady in some magazine at a dentist's office, and in 2 pages, it covered everything in the book, and I still thought it sounded stupid. LOL

I knew it was inane and ridiculous when it showed a before and after picture of a bookcase. The before picture was of a lovely bookcase with books on it, and the after, improved and uncluttered version had zero books, with statues and figurines and 3-ring binders instead.

I'm sorry, that's just crazy. This woman is insane.


message 12: by rivka (new)

rivka Becky wrote: "The before picture was of a lovely bookcase with books on it, and the after, improved and uncluttered version had zero books, with statues and figurines and 3-ring binders instead."

Noooooooo!



message 13: by Becky (new)

Becky I KNOW! It was traumatic.


Stephanie *Eff your feelings* Nenia *War of the Adorables* wrote: "Bummer. But I'm not really a tidy sort of person, so this isn't really my cup of tea anyway. #TeamMess"

I'm #TeamStopSayingTidy


Stephanie *Eff your feelings* Kemper wrote: "“Say tidy one more time! Do it!�

Tidy!"


Ooohohohoo, I know where you live and I'm up for a road trip.


Stephanie *Eff your feelings* Becky wrote: "So I read an article about this lady in some magazine at a dentist's office, and in 2 pages, it covered everything in the book, and I still thought it sounded stupid. LOL

I knew it was inane and ..."


I agree. She's definitely around the bend! As far as the books go, you're supposed to put them all out on the floor and sort them as you go. Then you have to pick them up and ask if each one brings you joy. No. Not doing that. That would take years and I would feel stupid doing it. Off her rocker.


message 17: by Becky (new)

Becky Umm... I have 400 unread books. How does she define "joy"? That's such a vague, nonsense concept. I buy books because I'm curious, or interested in them. I don't consider that "joy"... how are you supposed to know if a book "sparks joy" before you've read it? Is she saying that one should not own books they haven't read? Tidy Guru's ass, meet the curb. Buh bye.


message 18: by rivka (new)

rivka Even for books I have read, and keep because I am likely to want to re-read, I can't say they all bring me joy. Some make me sob buckets every time I read them. Not sure that's all that joyful.


Stephanie *Eff your feelings* Becky wrote: "Umm... I have 400 unread books. How does she define "joy"? That's such a vague, nonsense concept. I buy books because I'm curious, or interested in them. I don't consider that "joy"... how are you ..."

That's exactly what she's saying. In fact, if you've had an unread book for quite awhile (I'm not sure I know how long that is, I think I might have been screaming when she said it) then you have missed your time to read it...too bad, so sad....get rid of it. But say thank you first.


message 20: by rivka (new)

rivka Considering I recently read, and very much enjoyed, several books I got copies of 2-3 years ago, I am forced to say


Stephanie *Eff your feelings* rivka wrote: "Even for books I have read, and keep because I am likely to want to re-read, I can't say they all bring me joy. Some make me sob buckets every time I read them. Not sure that's all that joyful."

Rivka, you're supposed to get rid of books that you've read because it's unlikely to you'll ever read them again. But, please, don't forget to thank them.

And what about and iron and ironing board? I hate them both and pretty much never have to use them (thank the gods for wrinkle releaser), but there could easily be a time I really need to iron something. What do I do then? Go out and buy an iron and ironing board (because I thanked my old ones and gleefully donated them), just to turn around to get rid of those because I still loath them?


Stephanie *Eff your feelings* rivka wrote: "Considering I recently read, and very much enjoyed, several books I got copies of 2-3 years ago, I am forced to say "

Haha!!!


message 23: by rivka (new)

rivka Stephanie wrote: "Rivka, you're supposed to get rid of books that you've read because it's unlikely to you'll ever read them again."

You know, my younger daughter thinks this way. I'm hoping she'll grow out of it. ;)

As far as iron and ironing board, I declared over a decade ago that ironing is against my religion. (My rabbi is skeptical about this.) I don't own either.


Stephanie *Eff your feelings* rivka wrote: "Stephanie wrote: "Rivka, you're supposed to get rid of books that you've read because it's unlikely to you'll ever read them again."

You know, my younger daughter thinks this way. I'm hoping she'l..."


I'm religionless, but I'm behind any religion that is against ironing.


message 25: by rivka (new)

rivka We are few, but we are mighty!


message 26: by Becky (new)

Becky That's pure insanity. What would I be thanking the unread books for?

"Dear book, you did not have a chance to spark joy in me. I was interested in you, but because I am human and have many interests that unfortunately prevented me from getting to read you in an arbitrarily dictated acceptable timeframe, the only things I can thank you for is being a waste of my money and a dust collector.

Thank you for your service!"

This is honestly the most ridiculous thing I've ever heard. People actually subscribe to this nonsense?


Carol She's So Novel꧁꧂ Becky wrote: "That's pure insanity. What would I be thanking the unread books for?

"Dear book, you did not have a chance to spark joy in me. I was interested in you, but because I am human and have many intere..."


Hahahaha!

& - great review!


Andrea AKA Catsos Person Thanks to your review, I've removed this from my GR shelves!


MrsJoseph *grouchy* I read this entire review and comments section with my mouth wide open in shock and dismay.

She'd lose her mind in my library. I have multiple bookcases with books on them. And googads of unread books.

And I like it.





*mutters about stupid people who recommend getting rid of books*


message 30: by Becky (new)

Becky I know... Books are my decor of choice. Flowers? Monograms? Vinyl stickers on the walls? Bah. Give me wall-to-wall bookcases and I'm happy as a clam. :D


message 31: by CS (new) - rated it 4 stars

CS Good lord...I'm all for tidying and hey, even going through your books (I've done that a few times, due to moving), but geez, books are my thing! If I got rid of all my books, I would be depressed.

As for saying "Thank you for your service", that almost sounds like something one of those professional organizers would say to hoarders on that TLC Hoarding show.


message 32: by Ceri (new) - added it

Ceri To be fair, she doesn't say you should get rid of all books, just ones you haven't read yet and any that you have read but don't 'spark joy' as objects in their own right. If you are following her system you can keep as many as you like. I see what she means regarding unread books. With some of them I am clearly kidding myself that I'll ever find time, but in general I am just going to ignore the advice regarding getting rid of unread books because an unread book to me is a pretty joyful thing :)


message 33: by rivka (new)

rivka Becky wrote: "I know... Books are my decor of choice. Flowers? Monograms? Vinyl stickers on the walls? Bah. Give me wall-to-wall bookcases and I'm happy as a clam. :D"

Exactly!

When trying to find places to hang pictures, the trouble is that most of my wall space is occupied by bookshelves or windows. So some of the less fragile/heavy pictures are on the bookshelves, in front of the books.


message 34: by CS (last edited Mar 10, 2016 02:44PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

CS Ceri wrote: "With some of them I am clearly kidding myself that I'll ever find time, but in general I am just going to ignore the advice regarding getting rid of unread books because an unread book to me is a pretty joyful thing :) ."

Ceri, this is me too!! I was trying to say this very thing - thanks for taking the words out of my mouth (hands?! LOL).


Stephanie *Eff your feelings* Becky wrote: "That's pure insanity. What would I be thanking the unread books for?

"Dear book, you did not have a chance to spark joy in me. I was interested in you, but because I am human and have many intere..."


Now you understand the screaming!

You're welcome everyone.


Stephanie *Eff your feelings* Carol � Blinded by the Light � GR Background wrote: "Becky wrote: "That's pure insanity. What would I be thanking the unread books for?

"Dear book, you did not have a chance to spark joy in me. I was interested in you, but because I am human and ha..."


Thank you so mush!


Stephanie *Eff your feelings* Andrea (Catsos Person) is a Compulsive eBook Hoarder wrote: "Thanks to your review, I've removed this from my GR shelves!"

I feel pretty good about falling on that sword for you Andea.


Stephanie *Eff your feelings* MrsJoseph wrote: "I read this entire review and comments section with my mouth wide open in shock and dismay.

She'd lose her mind in my library. I have multiple bookcases with books on them. And googads of unread b..."


Actually, tidying (uhhh!) is her life's passion so I believe you're bookshelves would turn her on.


Stephanie *Eff your feelings* Crystal Starr Light wrote: "Good lord...I'm all for tidying and hey, even going through your books (I've done that a few times, due to moving), but geez, books are my thing! If I got rid of all my books, I would be depressed...."

She even said we should dispose of THIS book if it didn't bring me joy.

Check.


Stephanie *Eff your feelings* Ceri wrote: "To be fair, she doesn't say you should get rid of all books, just ones you haven't read yet and any that you have read but don't 'spark joy' as objects in their own right. If you are following her ..."

I get it. But she's so ridiculou. I'm not touching and talking to all my things....I'm crazy enough.


message 41: by rivka (new)

rivka Stephanie wrote: "She even said we should dispose of THIS book if it didn't bring me joy.

Check. "


Literal LOL.


Lost Planet Airman And yet, she gets paid a living to do this for people in Japan all the time.

I am kinda in the same mindset as you, though, Stephanie. Like so many self-help authors, she has taken an idea, one good in its niche (Japanese culture) and sought to put a book together around that idea.
The one idea makes the book repetitive. The cultural gulf makes the methods absurd in America.

But I promised I would make it to the end of the book (for my summer reading contest), and so make it to the end I shall.


message 43: by Lyn (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lyn About #4. Don't ball up your socks and tie your together (who does that) - The author is talking about this common method in Japan and the rest of Asia.


Stephanie *Eff your feelings* Mike wrote: "And yet, she gets paid a living to do this for people in Japan all the time.

I am kinda in the same mindset as you, though, Stephanie. Like so many self-help authors, she has taken an idea, one go..."


Did you make it?


Stephanie *Eff your feelings* Lyn wrote: "About #4. Don't ball up your socks and tie your together (who does that) - The author is talking about this common method in Japan and the rest of Asia."

Right? It's a bunch of nonsense!


message 46: by Payal (new)

Payal So I read the description of the book, and instantly thought, ya know what doesn't bring me joy? Tampons! Shall I throw them all out? Bleed freely into the wind? That'll scare old white men everywhere. On second thought, perhaps I should do that on the dotard's doorstep at Mar-a-lago.


Lost Planet Airman Oh, hey, I never saw your response. I did indeed finish and tried using her techniques. Turned out I was too ADD to stick it out.


message 48: by Stephanie (new)

Stephanie I’ve actually been using this book recently. The techniques mostly worked for me- but only when I read the book as a reference to one particular area, not as a whole (if that makes sense) 🤷🏻‍♀�. I give everyone points for taking the initiative to tidy up though lol


Stephanie *Eff your feelings* Payal wrote: "So I read the description of the book, and instantly thought, ya know what doesn't bring me joy? Tampons! Shall I throw them all out? Bleed freely into the wind? That'll scare old white men everywh..."

Haha! He will be quite upset that you would be bleeding from your wherever and sullying the steps of his precious southern White House � gag.

Do it! But he may not be there to see it since he’ll be in JAIL soon!


Stephanie *Eff your feelings* Mike wrote: "Oh, hey, I never saw your response. I did indeed finish and tried using her techniques. Turned out I was too ADD to stick it out."

Hah!


« previous 1
back to top