Trudi's Reviews > Gone Girl
Gone Girl
by
I've been completely fangirling over Gillian Flynn since her debut Sharp Objects six years ago. It remains one of my all-time-favorites, along with Flynn's sophomore novel Dark Places. No one writes the inner workings of warped and damaged human psychology better than this woman. With complete conviction I place her in the same category alongside the likes of Flannery O'Connor and Shirley Jackson. Flynn has a devilish, uncanny flair for creating memorable characters and twisty plots that drive down unexpected roads shrouded in fog the end of which you cannot see until you're smack upon it.
So you can bet I've been anxiously awaiting this latest release with agonized, bated breath. Despite missing some of the texture and nuances of her first two books, this time out Flynn has offered up a bonafide page turner of the sordid, sensationalist kind that makes summer reading oh-so-sweet. Trust me when I say, if you're only going to take one book to the beach or cottage this summer, it's gotta be Gone Girl.
I'm also going to encourage you to avoid all reviews (except this one, haha!) before you pick this up. Even more than her other novels, Gone Girl is so easy to spoil. Which is why I'm going to say very little about the actual inner workings of the story itself. And if I feel the need to get even close to doing that, be rest assured it will be put behind a spoiler tag.
A list of lovables:
Narrative voice: What makes Gone Girl such a compulsive read is the alternating points of view. Dueling voices in any novel can result in epic fail, especially when the voices are so similar as to be indistinguishable. If you're going to tell the story from different points of view, you better make sure the points of view are actually...different. I don't think I've ever seen alternating voices handled so effectively as they are here with husband Nick and wife Amy. As you read, you begin to wonder if either of these narrators are in the least reliable, if you're perhaps not getting full disclosure after all. I absolutely adored that pernicious doubt and shifting sympathies. It's like watching nature programs that can be shot to make you cheer for the wolf pack one week, and for the moose the week after.
Is this manipulative? You bet it is! But trust me, being manipulated by a master like Flynn is sheer delight.
Media as judge, jury and executioner: C'mon, we all know it don't we? Murder suspects of every sort and circumstance are tried first in the media and found guilty or innocent before the case ever makes it to trial. Before an arrest is even made, pundits, "news" anchors and bloggers put forth his or her theories and "insights" decrying yay or nay. You've seen at work, haven't you? Flynn does a wonderful job here of dissecting our at times unhealthy, obsessive appetite for the sordid. How our voracious consumption of mass media provokes sympathy or outrage, how easily we are influenced to see a person as a saint or a devil. Innocent until proven guilty? Not so much these days. And good luck finding an impartial jury. Change of venue? With the meteoric rise of social media, you would have to go all the way to Mars in some instances in order to enlist "untainted" jurors.
The only thing humans do with more abandon and conviction than fall in love is fall out of love: Love is grand, marriage can be a beautiful, wonderful thing...except when it isn't. The rise and fall of any relationship carries within it the potential to be staggering in scope and severity. What we once adored about one another, we now loathe. What we lingered over and savored to the last sub-atomic particle, we now want to obliterate from our awareness, pull an eternal sunshine of the spotless mind if you please. Oh yeah, I think we've all been there. More than anything, Flynn is putting gender relations and the perils of romance under a microscope, and her scrutiny doesn't miss a thing. It's tawdry, and titillating, and twisted, and didn't I already say the perfect effing read for this summer??? You bet.
The only fly in the ointment here is that Flynn manages heaping amounts of sensational, but only moderate traces of substance. This novel's engine runs on the nitroglycerin of shocking twists and the suspension of disbelief. Flynn largely ignores the gritty demands of realism here as they will only act as sugar in the gasoline, binding and stalling a story that has taken flight like a jet-fueled rocket bound for stratospheric heights. When you are strapped on to that rocket, you won't be worrying about realism though. Or subtleties. You'll be banging on the table like Harry's Sally screaming - yes! yes! oh YES!
Except in this case, you'll mean it. I didn't have to fake a single thing :)
by

Trudi's review
bookshelves: gillian-flynn, crime-mystery, 2012, heart-of-darkness, twss, favorites, rusa-reads, sherwood-picks, made-into-movie
Mar 27, 2011
bookshelves: gillian-flynn, crime-mystery, 2012, heart-of-darkness, twss, favorites, rusa-reads, sherwood-picks, made-into-movie
I've been completely fangirling over Gillian Flynn since her debut Sharp Objects six years ago. It remains one of my all-time-favorites, along with Flynn's sophomore novel Dark Places. No one writes the inner workings of warped and damaged human psychology better than this woman. With complete conviction I place her in the same category alongside the likes of Flannery O'Connor and Shirley Jackson. Flynn has a devilish, uncanny flair for creating memorable characters and twisty plots that drive down unexpected roads shrouded in fog the end of which you cannot see until you're smack upon it.
So you can bet I've been anxiously awaiting this latest release with agonized, bated breath. Despite missing some of the texture and nuances of her first two books, this time out Flynn has offered up a bonafide page turner of the sordid, sensationalist kind that makes summer reading oh-so-sweet. Trust me when I say, if you're only going to take one book to the beach or cottage this summer, it's gotta be Gone Girl.
I'm also going to encourage you to avoid all reviews (except this one, haha!) before you pick this up. Even more than her other novels, Gone Girl is so easy to spoil. Which is why I'm going to say very little about the actual inner workings of the story itself. And if I feel the need to get even close to doing that, be rest assured it will be put behind a spoiler tag.
A list of lovables:
Narrative voice: What makes Gone Girl such a compulsive read is the alternating points of view. Dueling voices in any novel can result in epic fail, especially when the voices are so similar as to be indistinguishable. If you're going to tell the story from different points of view, you better make sure the points of view are actually...different. I don't think I've ever seen alternating voices handled so effectively as they are here with husband Nick and wife Amy. As you read, you begin to wonder if either of these narrators are in the least reliable, if you're perhaps not getting full disclosure after all. I absolutely adored that pernicious doubt and shifting sympathies. It's like watching nature programs that can be shot to make you cheer for the wolf pack one week, and for the moose the week after.
Is this manipulative? You bet it is! But trust me, being manipulated by a master like Flynn is sheer delight.
Media as judge, jury and executioner: C'mon, we all know it don't we? Murder suspects of every sort and circumstance are tried first in the media and found guilty or innocent before the case ever makes it to trial. Before an arrest is even made, pundits, "news" anchors and bloggers put forth his or her theories and "insights" decrying yay or nay. You've seen at work, haven't you? Flynn does a wonderful job here of dissecting our at times unhealthy, obsessive appetite for the sordid. How our voracious consumption of mass media provokes sympathy or outrage, how easily we are influenced to see a person as a saint or a devil. Innocent until proven guilty? Not so much these days. And good luck finding an impartial jury. Change of venue? With the meteoric rise of social media, you would have to go all the way to Mars in some instances in order to enlist "untainted" jurors.
The only thing humans do with more abandon and conviction than fall in love is fall out of love: Love is grand, marriage can be a beautiful, wonderful thing...except when it isn't. The rise and fall of any relationship carries within it the potential to be staggering in scope and severity. What we once adored about one another, we now loathe. What we lingered over and savored to the last sub-atomic particle, we now want to obliterate from our awareness, pull an eternal sunshine of the spotless mind if you please. Oh yeah, I think we've all been there. More than anything, Flynn is putting gender relations and the perils of romance under a microscope, and her scrutiny doesn't miss a thing. It's tawdry, and titillating, and twisted, and didn't I already say the perfect effing read for this summer??? You bet.
The only fly in the ointment here is that Flynn manages heaping amounts of sensational, but only moderate traces of substance. This novel's engine runs on the nitroglycerin of shocking twists and the suspension of disbelief. Flynn largely ignores the gritty demands of realism here as they will only act as sugar in the gasoline, binding and stalling a story that has taken flight like a jet-fueled rocket bound for stratospheric heights. When you are strapped on to that rocket, you won't be worrying about realism though. Or subtleties. You'll be banging on the table like Harry's Sally screaming - yes! yes! oh YES!
Except in this case, you'll mean it. I didn't have to fake a single thing :)
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
Gone Girl.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
March 27, 2011
– Shelved
July 8, 2012
–
Started Reading
July 10, 2012
–
53.22%
"Whoah, I think she just blew my mind. Awesomeness on top of awesomeness marinated in awesomeness!!"
page
223
July 14, 2012
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-29 of 29 (29 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Arah-Lynda
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Jul 19, 2012 12:45PM

reply
|
flag


Great review, by the way.
mw

I understand that for anyone who reads GG first, Flynn's other two books may fall a little flat by comparison. They are certainly not as in your face, pedal to the metal the way Gone Girl is. This made me love her first books even more, but I realize that the quieter, more creeping experience isn't going to wow everybody the same.
Ah, readalikes for Gone Girl! I really should start thinking hard and fast about this now, because I'm sure my library patrons will start demanding them soon.
Here are a few that have really stood out to me in the last year or so Michael:
The Devil All the Time and Winter's Bone. Amazing.
Still Missing and Before I Go To Sleep are addictive, page-turners in their own way. Very satisfying.
A Simple Plan is fantastic. Has a great movie too!
But my favorite in this sort of twisty, dark, crime-mystery category would be Westlake's The Ax. A classic! I've re-read it a few times, and even when I know what's going to happen, I'm still sitting on the edge of my seat! It's a thin volume but packs a lot of punch.
And just for sheer, pageturning adrenaline, I'm going to throw out King's The Long Walk. I promise you if you pick it up, you won't be able to put it back down again. I re-read this book every other year I love it so much.
See? Never ask a librarian for reading suggestions. They'll never shut up! ;)


That's a tough question!!! It seems anyone who reads Gone Girl first, are a little let down by her earlier novels. I love them though. I'm going to vote for Sharp Objects. If you do read it, let me know what you think!


That's a tough question!!! It seems anyone who rea..."
so i read it. I felt it was predictable and uneven... though i know it is her first attempt at a novel. As lots of people said, the gore, sex, etc was more to thrill and get a reaction out of the reader. I wonder if this is a continued motif (i dont know if that is the right word...) throughout her writing. It could be a result of not knowing that she could be a bit more subtle, rather than forced. I have a few more novels to read before i jump back into her other books, but i will begin again with dark places.

For me Sharp Objects and Dark Places are the quiet novels, nuanced and careful and beautifully textured. I certainly found them to be much more literary and haunting than Gone Girl and books I look forward to re-reading. But my opinion definitely seems to be the minority!!



Hi Trudi. I just wanted to let you know that I have since read Gone Girl and loved it. Thanks for bringing it to my attention. If I knew how to link your review to my own I would have as it is decidedly the best I have read on this work. Once again my thanks.

You're so very welcome! I'm so glad you loved it. It really is a burning page-turner and one of the most tightly plotted books I've ever read :)


Thank you! Enjoy!

Thank you Cari! What a compliment :-)


In mine obviously ;)


Thanks Cindy! My praise is enthusiastic, but I don't think this is Flynn's best book, by far. It's a salacious page-turner great for summer reading, but I loved Sharp Objects and Dark Places much more.

I somehow missed this comment Maciek! Haha, thank you. It's the thought that counts my friend :-)


(view spoiler)