Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Anne 's Reviews > The Rainbow

The Rainbow by D.H. Lawrence
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
2967061
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: 1001-books, classics, britain, librivox, 2021
Read 2 times. Last read June 9, 2021 to June 12, 2021.

The Rainbow is a brilliant novel, one which I admired a bit more than I enjoyed reading. At times D.H. Lawrence astounded me with the lushness, beauty and depth of his prose but at other times I felt that the writing was overwrought and overwritten. The latter made reading this novel more of a chore at times, rather than a pleasure. This is the same problem I had with Mothers and Sons; too much of a good thing.

Lawrences uses the natural world for its beauty and for its symbolic power. The use of metaphors and allusions to the natural world abound suggestive of Biblical, religious/spiritual, psychological, sexual and other meanings. His prose are more like poetry, long on imagery of both the external and the internal (emotional) landscape.

This novel is written on a grand scale, spanning a period from the 1840s to 1905, a time of great change in societal norms and industry. We follow the changing patterns of love and marriage in 3 generations of the Brangwens. Lawrence also weaves in religion, sexuality, the natural world, industrialization, homosexuality and women’s rights, to name a few.

This novel is about many things but more than anything else what stood out were the strong women. In each of the three generations of Brangwens it is always the women who are strong and central to the story. Lydia, Anna and Ursula, you come to know very well. The character portrayal of these three women are exceptional. Lydia and Anna are happy producing baby after baby. Ursula’s story is different. It is one of psychological awakening and the struggle that requires. Her relationship with her lover is "ambivalent;" she both hates and loves him at the same time. She pulls him in and soon after pushes him away. She hates him while having sex with him. She loves him but hates what he represents to her - conventionality. (Ambivalence is a concept borrowed from Freud whose ideas can be found elsewhere in this novel). Ursula is the first Brangwen to ask herself what she wants out of life and to wrestle with this question:

“Why, oh why must one grow up, why must one inherit this heavy, numbing responsibility of living an undiscovered life? Out of the nothingness and the undifferentiated mass, to make something of herself! But what? In the obscurity and pathlessness to take a direction! But whither? How take even one step? And yet, how stand still? This was torment indeed, to inherit the responsibility of one’s own life.�

Sensuality and sexuality are suffused throughout the The Rainbow. Descriptions of nature are infused with sensuality and the most intimate and emotional encounters are often described in terms of nature and the elements. In fact, nature and sexual love are entwined for Lawrence. Lovers often have sex outdoors, surrounded by trees, under a bright moon, etc.. Lawrence beautifully conveys desire, love and passion as well as the intensity and intimacy of a sexual encounter without ever writing explicitly about sex. He doesn't need to as these quotes show:

“She lay motionless, with wide-open eyes looking at the moon. He came direct to her, without preliminaries. She held him pinned down at the chest, awful. The fight, the struggle for consummation was terrible. It lasted till it was agony to his soul, till he succumbed, till he gave way as if dead, lay with his face buried, partly in her hair, partly in the sand, motionless, as if he would be motionless now forever, hidden away in the dark, buried, only buried, he only wanted to be buried in the goodly darkness, only that, and no more.�

“Their flesh was one rock from which the life gushed, out of her who was smitten and rent, from him who quivered and yielded.�

“The lovers become one dual movement, dancing on the slippery grass�.It was a glaucous intertwining, delicious flux and contest in flux. �

“His blood beat up in waves of desire�.if he could come really within the blazing kernel of darkness, if really he could be destroyed, burnt away till he lit with her in one consummation, that were supreme, supreme.�


The novel ends with the vision of a rainbow, a sign of hope and regeneration for Ursula who has been through a lot in the course of this novel. (Her story continues in Women In Love).

"She saw in the rainbow the earth's new architecture, the old brittle corruption of houses and factories swept away, the world built up in a living fabric of truth, fitting to the overarching heaven.

I listened to this novel on an audio recording narrated by Tony Foster, one of Librivox� finest narrators. His narration was superb.
52 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read The Rainbow.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
April 4, 2011 – Shelved
April 23, 2011 – Shelved as: 1001-books
April 24, 2011 – Shelved as: classics
June 28, 2011 – Shelved as: britain
November 21, 2020 – Shelved as: read-pre-gr
February 28, 2021 – Shelved as: to-read
February 28, 2021 – Shelved as: not-so-short-list
May 16, 2021 – Shelved as: librivox
June 9, 2021 – Started Reading
June 9, 2021 –
25.0%
June 11, 2021 –
50.0%
June 12, 2021 –
100.0%
June 12, 2021 – Shelved as: 2021
June 12, 2021 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-38 of 38 (38 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

TBV (on hiatus) Anne, your excellent review has taken me on memory lane right back to the ‘seventies when I read this and the other novels, and then saw the movie in the late ‘eighties. I have the DVDs for his other novels. Thanks!


message 2: by Anne (last edited Jun 12, 2021 03:11PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Anne TBV wrote: "Anne, your excellent review has taken me on memory lane right back to the ‘seventies when I read this and the other novels, and then saw the movie in the late ‘eighties. I have the DVDs for his oth..."

TBV, I'm glad that my review took you down memory lane.
You probably watched the Ken Russel version of Women in Love. It's not available to stream now, unfortunately. There is a new TV adaptation but the reviews are not great. I'll probably watch it anyway. :))

I'm going to read Women In Love soon. I read it in school but don't remember a thing about it.


TBV (on hiatus) That novel is excellent; I look forward to reading your comments/review. Yes, it was the Russel movie. Both that one and Women in Love starred the excellent Glenda Jackson.


Anne TBV wrote: "That novel is excellent; I look forward to reading your comments/review. Yes, it was the Russel movie. Both that one and Women in Love starred the excellent Glenda Jackson."

I'm confused. The Russel movie is Women in Love. What other movie is there?


³¾²¹°ù°ì… Outstanding review Anne.


message 6: by JanB (new)

JanB I love your point that you appreciated the writing more than you enjoyed it. I see from the quotes what you mean about it coming across as overwrought. Still, I’m glad you mostly enjoyed it. Lovely review Anne.


Anne Mark wrote: "Outstanding review Anne."

Thanks so much Mark!


Anne JanB wrote: "I love your point that you appreciated the writing more than you enjoyed it. I see from the quotes what you mean about it coming across as overwrought. Still, I’m glad you mostly enjoyed it. Lovely..."

Jan, thank you for your comment. There was a lot to like about this novel but the beautiful, meaningful language sometimes got in the way.


message 9: by Gaurav (new) - added it

Gaurav Fabulous review, Anne. I am yet to read it. Your review comes as a nice reminder to amend it. Thanks for sharing :)


message 10: by Mark (new)

Mark  Porton Oh man - that's a great review Anne!! I'm interested in this quote of yours "The Rainbow is a brilliant novel, one which I admired a bit more than I enjoyed reading."......what does that mean?

I just checked out this book and it's about the Midlands, that's my home where I was born in the UK. Often voted the worst accent in the UK BTW.

Some of the other quotes you've given us are brilliant.

Anyway, this is a stellar review :))


message 11: by Violeta (new)

Violeta Stunning review, Anne! I can totally understand your feelings towards it as described in your opening paragraph. Not that I have read this but …over abundance has happened to me too more than once. Nevertheless this is such a fascinating theme. Funny, I kept thinking of that British 70s film with Glenda Jackson and Alan Bates while reading and you mentioned near the end that Women in Love was the sequel to this. THAT was the film!
The quotes you chose are real gems!


Anne Gaurav wrote: "Fabulous review, Anne. I am yet to read it. Your review comes as a nice reminder to amend it. Thanks for sharing :)"

Gaurav, thank you for your comment. I hope you enjoy this book when you get a chance to read it.


message 13: by Anne (last edited Jun 13, 2021 06:08AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Anne "I just checked out this book and it's about the Midlands, that's my home where I was born in the UK. Often voted the worst accent in the UK BTW."

Thank you for telling me that, Mark. Gave me a good laugh. 😆
You were born in beautiful country if Lawrence's descriptions are anything to go by. But he lived in Cornwall. :))

"The Rainbow is a brilliant novel, one which I admired a bit more than I enjoyed reading.".

You know the feeling when you read a book and the language is very beautiful but the author is in love with his own prose so writes 3 times as many flowery sentences as are necessary to make a point? That made reading this novel more of a chore than a pleasure. Based on your confusion I decided to make clear in my review what I admired about this book.

Update: I practically rewrote my review. Thanks for the honest heads up.


message 14: by Jennifer (new)

Jennifer Welsh Anne, this is a great review! You really captured a lot of what I felt reading Women in Love, way back when. Unfortunately, I was too young for the appreciation to win over, and I haven’t read another of his since. Do you have a favorite?


message 15: by Diane (new)

Diane Barnes I read his novels when I was much younger, and his "overwrought and overwritten" prose eventually just turned me off. I'm sure it would do the same today.


message 16: by Sue (new) - added it

Sue K H I love your lovely and informative review, Anne. I'm not sure if his overuse of inconsequential flowery prose could win me over. I believe I need to find his shortest novel to start with. Sometimes audiobooks can make that kind of thing more or less tolerable. It sounds like this great narration made it work. If I try this one I'll look for this narrator


message 17: by Lisa (NY) (new)

Lisa (NY) Excellent review Anne - sometimes the books that feel like a chore are the ones I remember the longest...


message 18: by Laysee (new)

Laysee Fabulous review, Anne. Love your exploration of Lawrence's prose and themes in this novel.


Anne Lisa wrote: "Excellent review Anne - sometimes the books that feel like a chore are the ones I remember the longest..."

I agree. If we're speaking of Shakespeare, for example, I expect the read to be a chore that I enjoy. But when the chore comes from overwriting/under-editing that's a whole other matter. Having written all that I think I will remember this story for a long time. As much as I complain about the overwriting I'm still planning to read Women in Love.


Anne Jennifer wrote: "Anne, this is a great review! You really captured a lot of what I felt reading Women in Love, way back when. Unfortunately, I was too young for the appreciation to win over, and I haven’t read anot..."

Jennifer, thank you. I also read Women in Love way back when but don't remember a thing. I plan to reread it soon. I don't have a favorite yet. :))


Anne Diane wrote: "I read his novels when I was much younger, and his "overwrought and overwritten" prose eventually just turned me off. I'm sure it would do the same today."

Yeah, it's too bad that he had the habit of writing 3 (or 10) sentences when 1 would suffice. But I appreciate what he writes about so I continue...with Women in Love soon.


Anne Sue wrote: "I love your lovely and informative review, Anne. I'm not sure if his overuse of inconsequential flowery prose could win me over. I believe I need to find his shortest novel to start with. Sometimes..."

Sue, Tony Foster is fabulous but his fabulous narration didn't make the overwrought/overwritten passages more tolerable. It's funny, I was thinking that reading it would have made this book easier to read - at least one can skim a bit. :))


Anne Laysee wrote: "Fabulous review, Anne. Love your exploration of Lawrence's prose and themes in this novel."

Laysee, thank you so much!


message 24: by Candi (new) - added it

Candi Anne, you've really given me a good feel for Lawrence's writing with this superb review! I'll know what to expect going into it. This seems to be one of those cases where I can be completely won over or a bit turned off by the prose. I'm interested to find out where I fall! I have three of his novels at home, but I think I should start with The Virgin and the Gypsy as it's the slimmest of the three ;)


message 25: by Anne (last edited Jun 13, 2021 08:08AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Anne Candi, I've never heard of The Virgin and the Gypsy. I guess I'll check it out.

Candi, I'll be interested to see how you respond to Lawrence's prose when he is overwrought and overwriting. My general impression is that you are a more patient reader than I. Plus, I think you can enjoy beautiful prose just for the sake of its beauty.

Lawrence's prose are more overdone when he's speaking about love, sex, nature or religion. This novel is full of all of those though there are a few places where you get a break and can appreciate his prose. Sons and Lovers is good until 2/3 of the way in. Then love arrives.

Ps. His prose are not the same in every book. I stared Lady Chatterley and it's completely different. The V and the G may also be different.


message 26: by Antoinette (new)

Antoinette Splendid review, Anne! I read Lawrence when I was a teenager. Not this one though. Funny story- I read Lady Chatterly’s Lover when I was sixteen and loved it. I read it again for my classics group about 10 years ago and did not like it at all. Since then, I have not picked up another of his books. May try again one day after your wonderful review.


Anne Antoinette, thank you! I think other people have said the same thing about reading Lawrence in school and loving him and then hating his novels as adults.

LCL is very different from Rainbow and Women in Love. Probably different from all of his books.

I read the beginning of LCL and was surprised by the explicit sex right from the start. Then I got bored.

I wasn't surprised by the nonchalant attitude of women about sex. That's Lawrence's point beginning with this book - specifically with Ursual whose story continues in Women in Love.

I'll be interested in reading your review if you do read L.


Anne Elyse, I've had my experiences with the not so great Librivox recordings, but lately I've found a few fantastic ones. Tony is one of those. As someone said in a review, "he could go pro." Women in Love also has an excellent narrator - Ruth Golding. I just listened for a little while. I'll get back to it after Lonesome Dove. There are others - Expatriate, Richard Kilmer, Andy Minter and Simon Evers. I found the narrators through the rave reviews of their performances.
Happy reading.


TBV (on hiatus) Anne (On semi-hiatus) wrote: "TBV wrote: "That novel is excellent; I look forward to reading your comments/review. Yes, it was the Russel movie. Both that one and Women in Love starred the excellent Glenda Jackson."

I'm confus..."


The Rainbow:



message 30: by Angela M (new)

Angela M Excellent review, Anne, as alway - thoughtful. I read some of Lawrence ages ago, but not this one.


Anne TBV wrote: "Anne (On semi-hiatus) wrote: "TBV wrote: "That novel is excellent; I look forward to reading your comments/review. Yes, it was the Russel movie. Both that one and Women in Love starred the excellen..."

TBV, I found the movie on Amazon. I tried to find it not even knowing if a film had been made of The Rainbow and didn't find a thing. So, thank you!


Anne Angela M wrote: "Excellent review, Anne, as alway - thoughtful. I read some of Lawrence ages ago, but not this one."

Thank you, Angela. I continue on my classics binge. :))


message 33: by Candi (new) - added it

Candi I'm definitely curious about my response to his writing, Anne. Sometimes I don't mind overwritten but one thing I usually shy away from is melodrama. We'll see how it goes!


Anne Candi wrote: "I'm definitely curious about my response to his writing, Anne. Sometimes I don't mind overwritten but one thing I usually shy away from is melodrama. We'll see how it goes!"

Candi, you don't need to worry about melodrama with this book.


message 35: by Ilse (new) - added it

Ilse Marvellous and utterly tempting review, Anne - I have a copy waiting somewhere at home and I look forward to read it, as I have only read two short stories of him so far. On overwrought and overwritten, I noticed my response to it is unpredictable, sometimes I tend to even enjoy it, so fingers crossed for this one :).


Anne Ilse wrote: "Marvellous and utterly tempting review, Anne - I have a copy waiting somewhere at home and I look forward to read it, as I have only read two short stories of him so far. On overwrought and overwri..."

Ilse, thank you. I think you could really like this book. Some people say it's Lawrence's best. He accomplishes so much in this book but it was too much to write about in my review and I'm not sure I could have done it justice. I wasn't turned off completely by the overwrought style - I started Women in Love as soon as I finished this one. (I put it on hold for a bit - I got side-tracked with another book that some friends are reading). I think I may have reacted more strongly to his writing style because I listened to the book on audio. I listened to Sons and Lovers recently and enjoyed the first 2/3 of the book. Then love and "sex" enter the picture and the writing changed (became overwrought) and I became impatient. :)). That book had an impact on me - I still think of the mother .....:)) I hope you get a chance to read this book. I think you would enjoy it and I would love to read your review.


Cecily I adore the lush passion of this novel infused, as you say, with natural earthiness. You've captured so much of that in your review. [Swoons]


Anne Cecily wrote: "I adore the lush passion of this novel infused, as you say, with natural earthiness. You've captured so much of that in your review. [Swoons]"

Cecily, thank you, again. I like your term "lush passion."


back to top