karen's Reviews > The Dry
The Dry (Aaron Falk, #1)
by
by

fulfilling my 2021 goal to read one book each month by an author i have never read despite owning more than one of their books.
AND pulling double duty:
fulfilling my 2021 goal to read one ARC each month i'd been so excited to get my hands on and then...never read
in short, this was a perfect mystery novel.
unaware of how harmoniously i was organizing my media consumption, i picked this up at the same time i was (finally*) getting around to watching dublin murders—a series based on tana french’s first two books. this debut has a lot in common with french’s debut, In the Woods: it’s set in a very small town where everyone knows everyone’s business, it involves two crimes separated by decades, and it features a detective with, to put it mildly, a conflict of interest.
like tana french, harper takes a very literary approach to writing genre—and i know this is a very controversial statement—all the mystery fans shaking their tiny bloody fists and shrieking, “what, mystery novelists don’t write good?� &etc, but alls i mean by that assessment is that it’s not *driven* by the mystery; there’s a perfect balance between the mystery plot and her character work, and the writing in this puppy simply glides in that prose often deemed “effortless;� a distinction which does, in fact, require considerable effort to pull off.
the atmosphere is tremendously potent—the oppressive weight of an australian heatwave during an interminable drought, the harsh landscape backgrounding the anxieties of those with crops and livestock to consider, tensions flaring in the relentless heat, everything in the natural world and the human community seems to be crackling, on the verge. it’s the perfect place to drop a murder plot.
and, yeah, ⬆️see above⬆️: this was a perfect mystery novel. both the present-day investigation and the unwrapping-the-past backstory were compelling, with plenty of folds and wrinkles and red herrings, but there was also emotional heft, and real nuance in the way she wrote damage. i loved it, and i hate that i waited so long to read this. good thing i now have THREE other books of hers to read here, although knowing me, it’ll be another year before i get around to it. someone needs to investigate the mystery of where all my time goes.
* seriously, who has starz??
**
well, now i feel stupid for waiting so long.
review to come.
AND pulling double duty:
fulfilling my 2021 goal to read one ARC each month i'd been so excited to get my hands on and then...never read
in short, this was a perfect mystery novel.
unaware of how harmoniously i was organizing my media consumption, i picked this up at the same time i was (finally*) getting around to watching dublin murders—a series based on tana french’s first two books. this debut has a lot in common with french’s debut, In the Woods: it’s set in a very small town where everyone knows everyone’s business, it involves two crimes separated by decades, and it features a detective with, to put it mildly, a conflict of interest.
like tana french, harper takes a very literary approach to writing genre—and i know this is a very controversial statement—all the mystery fans shaking their tiny bloody fists and shrieking, “what, mystery novelists don’t write good?� &etc, but alls i mean by that assessment is that it’s not *driven* by the mystery; there’s a perfect balance between the mystery plot and her character work, and the writing in this puppy simply glides in that prose often deemed “effortless;� a distinction which does, in fact, require considerable effort to pull off.
He pushed open a heavy door to a hallway that smelled like sandwiches. Along the walls, kids' paintings and drawings were pinned up.
"Jesus, some of these are depressing," Raco murmured.
Falk could see what he meant. There were stick-figure families in which every face had a crayon mouth turned downward. A painting of a cow with angel wings. "Toffee My Cow in Heaven," the shaky caption read. In every attempt at landscape, the fields were colored brown.
"You should see the ones we didn't put up," Whitlam said, stopping at the office door. "The drought. It's going to kill this town."
the atmosphere is tremendously potent—the oppressive weight of an australian heatwave during an interminable drought, the harsh landscape backgrounding the anxieties of those with crops and livestock to consider, tensions flaring in the relentless heat, everything in the natural world and the human community seems to be crackling, on the verge. it’s the perfect place to drop a murder plot.
and, yeah, ⬆️see above⬆️: this was a perfect mystery novel. both the present-day investigation and the unwrapping-the-past backstory were compelling, with plenty of folds and wrinkles and red herrings, but there was also emotional heft, and real nuance in the way she wrote damage. i loved it, and i hate that i waited so long to read this. good thing i now have THREE other books of hers to read here, although knowing me, it’ll be another year before i get around to it. someone needs to investigate the mystery of where all my time goes.
* seriously, who has starz??
**
well, now i feel stupid for waiting so long.
review to come.

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read
The Dry.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
April 14, 2016
– Shelved
January 10, 2021
–
Started Reading
January 12, 2021
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-32 of 32 (32 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Steven
(new)
-
added it
Jan 10, 2021 06:37AM

reply
|
flag




Oh boy I know the feeling!! *yes I'm looking at YOU, bookshelf, filled with multiple books of authors I have yet to read*


I've *still* not read any of her's either.... *sigh*



I've *still* not read any of her's either.... *sigh*"
oof, that's a real oversight.

hahahaha that GIF is for real.


Right? I've been on an urban fantasy/fantasy/mm romance binge the last few years and have fallen down on the job when it comes to catching up on mystery/thriller series I'm interested in.
I'll have to do better!


First, you have inspired me to read this since I wanted to Love ItW so much and the ending made it fall flat, but I’ve never read anything else like it except the sequel.
Second: Have you watched The Dublin Murders? I started but never made it past episode 2. I found it dull and slow and the characters flat. I’m curious as to how you found it
Third: I love this challenge of reading an author you’ve never read despite owning many of their novels. I may need to try that next year. This year I’m trying to read something by an author that I liked but only read one thing from.

First, you have inspired me to read this since I wanted to Love ItW so much and the ending made it fall flat, but I’ve never read anything else like it except the sequel.
Second: Have..."
was the sequel better for you? i'm excited to read the rest of her books, and was only a little disappointed to learn that the last two were standalones. but haha - that's ALSO a tana french parallel! i did finish dublin murders and i liked it - i wasn't sure how they were gonna squash two books into one show - and i'm not sure it was 100% successful, but it worked better than i thought it would going in. the only thing i didn't like was the casting of frank mackey. nothing against the actor, just a reader's possessive THAT'S NOT MY FRANK MACKEY reaction. i thought cass was really good, though. i read in the woods so long ago that i'm a little blurry on the details and i think they changed something pretty significant but i haven't researched it or anything. it did start off a little slow which made me wonder how they were gonna find time to do both books, but the mood of it was really good and i hope they do more.
i like your bookgoal - one of my monthly goals is similar to yours - to read one a month by someone i love that i haven't read yet. i both love and hate these monthly goals i set for myself. this month's gonna be a mess because i've been doing less reading because of writing stuff and tick tock month's winding down, but when i t makes me finally pick up a book like this, it's wonderful.





that's two votes for that one, so i guess it'll be my next crack at her! looking forward to it!
Gerhard wrote: "Karen, love your reading goal! I am so far behind with my monthly fiction magazines, vowed to catch up. All the best!"
good luck!!!

I did this bookgoal actually because I loved loved loved The Monsters of Templeton so hard and I ran out and bought all of her other books and never read them partially because I was afraid they wouldn’t live up to MoT. But I am biting the bullet and reading Arcadia at some point.

i would like to know what you think of arcadia when you get to it. i will zip my lips until then!
