ŷ

karen's Reviews > The Dry

The Dry by Jane Harper
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
45618
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: from-publisher-or-author

fulfilling my 2021 goal to read one book each month by an author i have never read despite owning more than one of their books.

AND pulling double duty:

fulfilling my 2021 goal to read one ARC each month i'd been so excited to get my hands on and then...never read

in short, this was a perfect mystery novel.

unaware of how harmoniously i was organizing my media consumption, i picked this up at the same time i was (finally*) getting around to watching dublin murders—a series based on tana french’s first two books. this debut has a lot in common with french’s debut, In the Woods: it’s set in a very small town where everyone knows everyone’s business, it involves two crimes separated by decades, and it features a detective with, to put it mildly, a conflict of interest.

like tana french, harper takes a very literary approach to writing genre—and i know this is a very controversial statement—all the mystery fans shaking their tiny bloody fists and shrieking, “what, mystery novelists don’t write good?� &etc, but alls i mean by that assessment is that it’s not *driven* by the mystery; there’s a perfect balance between the mystery plot and her character work, and the writing in this puppy simply glides in that prose often deemed “effortless;� a distinction which does, in fact, require considerable effort to pull off.

He pushed open a heavy door to a hallway that smelled like sandwiches. Along the walls, kids' paintings and drawings were pinned up.

"Jesus, some of these are depressing," Raco murmured.

Falk could see what he meant. There were stick-figure families in which every face had a crayon mouth turned downward. A painting of a cow with angel wings. "Toffee My Cow in Heaven," the shaky caption read. In every attempt at landscape, the fields were colored brown.

"You should see the ones we didn't put up," Whitlam said, stopping at the office door. "The drought. It's going to kill this town."


the atmosphere is tremendously potent—the oppressive weight of an australian heatwave during an interminable drought, the harsh landscape backgrounding the anxieties of those with crops and livestock to consider, tensions flaring in the relentless heat, everything in the natural world and the human community seems to be crackling, on the verge. it’s the perfect place to drop a murder plot.

and, yeah, ⬆️see above⬆️: this was a perfect mystery novel. both the present-day investigation and the unwrapping-the-past backstory were compelling, with plenty of folds and wrinkles and red herrings, but there was also emotional heft, and real nuance in the way she wrote damage. i loved it, and i hate that i waited so long to read this. good thing i now have THREE other books of hers to read here, although knowing me, it’ll be another year before i get around to it. someone needs to investigate the mystery of where all my time goes.

* seriously, who has starz??

**

well, now i feel stupid for waiting so long.

review to come.

190 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Dry.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

April 14, 2016 – Shelved
January 10, 2021 – Started Reading
January 12, 2021 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-32 of 32 (32 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Steven (new) - added it

Steven Heard so many good things about this author. I need to get to the ones I have of hers!


karen this is my exact situation! i own three books of hers and have read zero. well, except now i have read 80 pages or so, so at least i'm making progress!


message 3: by Teresa (new)

Teresa Oh geez, I'm embarrassed to say I have James Patterson but books and have never read a single one... Any recommendations for a newbie for him?


karen I NEVER READ HIM EITHER!


message 5: by Steven (new) - added it

Steven That’s more progress than I have made on a Jane Harper. I’ll have to try to get to one this year!


message 6: by Steven (new) - added it

Steven Oh, wow, that good huh?

*bumps it up my list*


karen yeah, it was fantastic. really scratched my tana french itch.


message 8: by Tia (new) - rated it 5 stars

Tia That's a great goal! I should borrow that one myself......*shifty eyes*


karen i'm hoping it is a success, for both of us! i'm dreading what will happen when i read one that i hate and then look around and find five other books by the same author and realize i could have saved a bunch of money...


message 10: by Tia (new) - rated it 5 stars

Tia karen wrote: "i'm hoping it is a success, for both of us! i'm dreading what will happen when i read one that i hate and then look around and find five other books by the same author and realize i could have save..."

Oh boy I know the feeling!! *yes I'm looking at YOU, bookshelf, filled with multiple books of authors I have yet to read*

description


message 11: by Steven (new) - added it

Steven karen wrote: "yeah, it was fantastic. really scratched my tana french itch."

I've *still* not read any of her's either.... *sigh*


message 12: by Maria (new) - added it

Maria Ralph Hmmmm I want to join you in this challenge but don’t know if I can come up with 12! Donna Tartt & Bernadine Evaristo spring to mind though. Might also do authors I’ve never read but I’ve added multiple books of theirs to my goodreads To-Read!


karen well, you can tailor-make your own monthly goals, based on your situation. in the past, i've done books i've had unread on my e-reader for years, books i got as gifts and never read, hardcovers i bought and didn't read for so long that the paperback was already out, etc. this year i'm doing this one, an arc i was so excited to get but never read, and an unread book by an author i love. i buy too many books, and choosing is hard, so this helps narrow down my options.


karen Steven wrote: "karen wrote: "yeah, it was fantastic. really scratched my tana french itch."

I've *still* not read any of her's either.... *sigh*"


oof, that's a real oversight.


karen Tia wrote: "karen wrote: "i'm hoping it is a success, for both of us! i'm dreading what will happen when i read one that i hate and then look around and find five other books by the same author and realize i c..."

hahahaha that GIF is for real.


Erica This book keeps coming across my desk and it sounds like something I would probably like but I will have to wait to see what your review says because they tell me, with 99.9% accuracy, how I'm going to feel about a story.


message 17: by Steven (new) - added it

Steven karen wrote: "oof, that's a real oversight."

Right? I've been on an urban fantasy/fantasy/mm romance binge the last few years and have fallen down on the job when it comes to catching up on mystery/thriller series I'm interested in.

I'll have to do better!


message 18: by Eric (new)

Eric Mesa Hehe, I'm going to unintentionally go along with your goal for this month. I've got 6 or more Octavia Butler books from various bundles that I've never read. But Throughline is going to do an ep on Butler, so next book up for me will be one of hers.


karen excellent! it feels good to complete bookgoals, and i hope you enjoy yours!


Jess ❈Harbinger of Blood-Soaked Rainbows❈ A few things;
First, you have inspired me to read this since I wanted to Love ItW so much and the ending made it fall flat, but I’ve never read anything else like it except the sequel.
Second: Have you watched The Dublin Murders? I started but never made it past episode 2. I found it dull and slow and the characters flat. I’m curious as to how you found it
Third: I love this challenge of reading an author you’ve never read despite owning many of their novels. I may need to try that next year. This year I’m trying to read something by an author that I liked but only read one thing from.


message 21: by Rob (new)

Rob Schmoldt Drats, another great book added to the pile of ‘to-reads�. 😀


karen Jess ❈Harbinger of Blood-Soaked Rainbows� wrote: "A few things;
First, you have inspired me to read this since I wanted to Love ItW so much and the ending made it fall flat, but I’ve never read anything else like it except the sequel.
Second: Have..."


was the sequel better for you? i'm excited to read the rest of her books, and was only a little disappointed to learn that the last two were standalones. but haha - that's ALSO a tana french parallel! i did finish dublin murders and i liked it - i wasn't sure how they were gonna squash two books into one show - and i'm not sure it was 100% successful, but it worked better than i thought it would going in. the only thing i didn't like was the casting of frank mackey. nothing against the actor, just a reader's possessive THAT'S NOT MY FRANK MACKEY reaction. i thought cass was really good, though. i read in the woods so long ago that i'm a little blurry on the details and i think they changed something pretty significant but i haven't researched it or anything. it did start off a little slow which made me wonder how they were gonna find time to do both books, but the mood of it was really good and i hope they do more.

i like your bookgoal - one of my monthly goals is similar to yours - to read one a month by someone i love that i haven't read yet. i both love and hate these monthly goals i set for myself. this month's gonna be a mess because i've been doing less reading because of writing stuff and tick tock month's winding down, but when i t makes me finally pick up a book like this, it's wonderful.


karen Rob wrote: "Drats, another great book added to the pile of ‘to-reads�. 😀"

yessssssss


Nadine in NY Jones I'm glad you enjoyed this! I highly recommend The Lost Man, I think you'll like it a lot. It's my favorite so far of her books, it's very broody and atmospheric, more of a psychological character study than a mystery (although there IS a dead body, so there's the mystery of what happened)


karen yeah, i love her writing enough that the mystery/no mystery thing is not a dealbreaker at all. i'm excited to read more by her, even though my excitement is at war with my being easily distracted by all the other books i'm excited to read.


message 26: by Gerhard (new) - added it

Gerhard Karen, love your reading goal! I am so far behind with my monthly fiction magazines, vowed to catch up. All the best!


Alienor ✘ French Frowner ✘ YAY!!! I've started here too and I liked all her books (loved a couple; my favorite is The Lost Man). Finding a new mystery author we like is just so damn satisfying!


karen Alienor � French Frowner � wrote: "YAY!!! I've started here too and I liked all her books (loved a couple; my favorite is The Lost Man). Finding a new mystery author we like is just so damn satisfying!"


that's two votes for that one, so i guess it'll be my next crack at her! looking forward to it!

Gerhard wrote: "Karen, love your reading goal! I am so far behind with my monthly fiction magazines, vowed to catch up. All the best!"

good luck!!!


Jess ❈Harbinger of Blood-Soaked Rainbows❈ So yes I did read The Likeness and liked it sooooooooo much more than ItW. I might try to go back and watch The Dublin Murders since I only made it through one episode. And see I really didn’t like Cass in the show and a big reason why I didn’t make it further. I also started it before reading The Likeness so I think maybe I decided to put my watching on hold so as not to spoil the book. I may need to revisit now that I’ve read it. I still haven’t read Faithful Place so I only know Mackey from book 2 (I know FP is your favorite, I’m planning on reading it sometime this year). I’m glad to hear that the show picks up at least because I just felt that first episode was long and slow and boring.

I did this bookgoal actually because I loved loved loved The Monsters of Templeton so hard and I ran out and bought all of her other books and never read them partially because I was afraid they wouldn’t live up to MoT. But I am biting the bullet and reading Arcadia at some point.


karen i think Broken Harbor is actually my favorite, although Faithful Place isn't too distant a second place. they're all nestled in my heart, even though The Secret Place is sorta pushed off to the side, the other books hogging the covers.

i would like to know what you think of arcadia when you get to it. i will zip my lips until then!


Janete on hiatus due health issues Karen, you're right. Really, someone needs to investigate the mystery of where all our time goes. If I could, I'd read 500 books per year but I don't know why I don't do it! It's a real mystery!


Erica I finally got around to reading this.
I may have been predisposed to getting In the Woods vibes from it due to reading your review but I think that element would have been there, regardless, because it was very much in the same vein.


back to top