ŷ

Abubakar Mehdi's Reviews > ISIS: The State of Terror

ISIS by Jessica Stern
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
14475342
's review

it was amazing

It didn't happen overnight, but the world woke up to the nightmare of ISIS in summer 2014. Before that ISIS was in the news, but not the way it wanted to be and only as an obscure offshoot of AQ. So It changed that forever, when a gruesome video of barbaric murder of James Foley (an American journalist) spread over internet like wildfire. It introduced the world to an extremist group that was more brutal, violent and powerful than any other terrorist organization. A group of terrorists who celebrated violence and mayhem, were now in control of large parts of Syria and Iraq. They still are, and for all we know it wont be easy to get rid of them.

Jessica Stern and J.M.Berger wrote this book with a profound clarity and academic neutrality. Starting from the rise of Zarqawi, the main force behind the ideology of ISIS, his ruthless tactics that inspired some sick minded terrorists and terrified the rest. A man so consumed by hatred and cruelty, that he was denoucned as “too brutal� even by the AQ main command. The story gets darker and darker, till we reach the Syrian Civil war, the catastrophic tragedy that gave ISIS a free ground for recruitment and showing its capacity as a well organized militant group. The story is that of failure, betrayal and heavy costs of monstrous mistakes.

The two most significant aspects of ISIS's tactics that this book covers in great detail, deal with its Cyber and Psychological warfare, a phenomena that exculsively belongs to ISIS.

ISIS used internet chat rooms and social media to spread its message across the globe, and the potency of message was grossly enhanced by its brutal tactics. It used shock as a technique, and told everyone that it wasn't just any terrorist organization, but one with a clear ideology of global dominance, and was prepared to go to any lengths for that. Its twitter posts had almost unfettered access to millions of users around the world, a method so effective that it threw strategists off their rockers.

By showing horrifying images of massacre and mayhem, it ensured that those with sick fetishes will rush into its fold. Its propaganda ceaselessly kept inspiring thousands. By frequently exposing people to savagery, they attenuated empathy in potential recruits, and significantly reduced their capacity to feel it. It enabled them to dehumanize others, to coalesce himself into an alternate universe of Islamist Jihad, a religious extremist narrative, with such potency as to become immune to humaneness or pity. It is by using this frequent exposure to violence as a technology to erode empathy among its followers.

The authors did not blame Islam for this mess. It came as pleasant reprieve fromt the usual rants that muslims and arabs are just inherently/genetically "bad".Instead, They think that an extremist understanding of the doctrine of Jihad has been used as a justification, an instrument to recruit gullible muslims youngsters. And the religious community has terribly failed to present a strong counter narrative. Religion is not the only culprit, and not the only motivation but it still plays a critical role.
If religion wants to save its future, it must separate itself from politics and armed violence.

A recent poll said that more than 84% of muslims in Pakistan want Sharia law to be imposed in the country. Religious seminaries and Jihadist organizations have been active, with and without state approval for decades. Thanks to American training and Saudi money, the cancer of fundamentalism founded in 80s Pakistan is still devouring its inhabitants.


Isis is incestuous child of Jihad, politics and regional instability. It is the most horrific impulses of humanity, dressed in fanatic pretexts of religiosity that have been gutted of all nuance and complexity.

Things fall apart; the center cannot hold;
Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world,
The blood-dimmed tide is loosed, and everywhere
The ceremony of innocence is drowned;
The best lack all conviction, while the worst
Are full of passionate intensity.

- The Second Comming by W.B.Yeats
31 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read ISIS.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

April 28, 2016 – Shelved
April 28, 2016 –
page 200
48.08% "This is an excellent study of how ISIS rose to such power and why its message is so potent in attracting foreign Jihadis. And what is the psychology behind such mindless mayhem, a complete chapter is dedicated to the successful media campaigns of ISIS which are unlike any we have seen in modern times."
April 29, 2016 – Started Reading
April 30, 2016 –
page 300
72.12% "ISIS's theological justification for sex: “It is permissible to have sexual intercourse with the female captive. Allah the almighty said: ‘[Successful are the believers] who guard their chastity, except from their wives or (the captives and slaves) that their right hands possess, for then they are free from blame [Koran 23:5�6].""
May 1, 2016 –
page 350
84.13% "“ISIS has established itself as a new paradigm, one that is more brutal, more sectarian, and more apocalyptic in its thinking than the groups that preceded it. ISIS is the crack cocaine of violent extremism, all of the elements that make it so alluring and addictive purified into a crystallized form.�"
May 3, 2016 –
page 350
84.13% "“What seems to be most appealing about violent fundamentalist groups is the simplification of life and thought. Good and evil are brought out in stark relief. Life is transformed through action. Martyrdom—the supreme act of heroism and worship—provides the ultimate relief from life’s dilemmas, especially for individuals who feel deeply alienated and confused, humiliated, or desperate.�"
May 7, 2016 –
page 416
100.0%
May 15, 2016 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-27 of 27 (27 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Soplada (new) - added it

Soplada Wow! well said Abubakar :) this was really informative for me I am going to quote you "If religion wants to save its future, it must separate itself from politics and armed violence. this is true, Islamic Khilafah is not required for us to achieve now. I wish this Isis terror will come to an end soon from every place in the globe.

P.s nice shot in choosing this poem at the end ;)


Abubakar Mehdi Thank you Soplada. This jihadist cult of Islamic imperialism needs to end now. And Yeats was a man ahead of his times. I am glad you liked it.


message 3: by Jibran (new)

Jibran Isis' whole Internet recruitment program with scores of media-savvy operators is too clean and well-organised to be true. I find it hard to believe that it's being led and managed from Iraq and Syria without any foreign help. Let's make a guess who is helping them to make a better show of themselves. And let's not even mention the amount of sophisticated weaponry they have got before they could capture anything from the Syrian army.


Tariq Mahmood Surely if 84% people in Pakistan want to impose Sharia, then why dont they elect religious parties? Where is the evidence?


Abubakar Mehdi @Jibran it really is startling. We must also ask where do they get all this money from, millions of dollars worth weapons and ammunition to support a standing/fighting force of thousands? Who sells them weapons ? Who buys the oil they are selling ? Why not block their supply lines ? If you can sanction countries, you sure can put sanctions on worlds most dangerous terrorist organisation and its supporters. ISIS has support both in East and West on the top level, their salafi-sunni jihadist agenda is something that resonates deeply with many rich bigots. So ISIS's rise, as I said, is not of mindless violence and destruction, but also of betrayal, deceit and monstrous mistakes. Thank you for your thought provoking comment Jibran.


Abubakar Mehdi @Tariq, you are absolutely right. Never has a religious party ever been given a majority mandate (they hardly get a handful of seats in parliament). But this does not reflect the lack of Sharia's appeal, but the bigotry that Zia infused into the mainstream discourse. The narrative is so skewed in the favour of Sharia, thanks to the abundance of hate mongering Mullahs and seminaries (and Zia ul Haq ofcourse), that no good muslim in his proper mind would say he doesn't want Sharia law. Ofcourse he'll say he wants it because he is a good muslim and he obeys what God has commanded but thank goodness the religious don't have any political capital or electable candidates. It is a very complex issue and if you are interested , I'll recommend an excellent book "Vying for Allah's Vote' by Haroon K. Ullah. It discusses the topic in great detail.
So, in short, they want it, but they don't want it. #bigotry


message 7: by Tariq (last edited May 20, 2016 04:28AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Tariq Mahmood But why do they want it? Sick and tired about looking for answers in books. I need to understand why religious people think they way they do.


Tariq Mahmood ایک سیال برادری کے فرد سے پوچھا کہ یہ ہیر اور رانجھے والا کیا قصہ ہے تو اس نے اپنی زبان میں یوں کہا
"ساہڈی چھوار دی ایڈھی غلطی تاں کائی نئیں جِنہا وارث شاہ سانوں یَدھی کھڑا اے"


Abubakar Mehdi They think it will end their sufferings, sir. They think Democracy has betrayed them, the west is only interested in bombing their homes and installing puppet leaders, they think the world is going 'West' and someday they will loose their 'East'. Above all, they have blind faith in a God who is controlling everything, who has promised them glory. They are dead tired of suffering and poverty. Indoctrination and a rhetoric of Glorious Islamic Past inspires them more than this Capitalist Democracy where justice and equity are replaced by bigotry and greed. Like everyone sir, they need two meals a day and a respectable existence. You are not the only one sir, it bothers me too, and I am afraid no one has all the answers. But this is what my humble opinion is.


message 10: by Rabeea (new)

Rabeea I agree with Jibran. The whole internet enlistment side of the story too clean-cut, far fetching and frankly ludicrous. There's definitely more to the story than is being let on. I think ISIS is just the new hot topic right now, there has been a great influx of books related to the topic - like Undercover Jihadi Bride, Submission etc which serve as only sensationalizing and cashing in on what is garnering a lot of readers interest these days. Interesting how ISIS, which is being touted as an evolution of terrorism in the Middle East, only became a frontline threat since USA started taking a keen interest in Middle East politics.


Abubakar Mehdi @Rabeea Well it is unbelievably sophisticated, not to mention the twitter app ISIS launched which was capable of generating millions of tweets per minute. But we have to see the other side of the picture too. Unlike other terrorist organisations, ISIS has been able to gather more western followers and educated middle class europeans than any other terrorist group ever has. These people are not the illiterate village folk from Kandhar or Dabiq, but tech savvy youngsters from France and England.
Yes there has been a plethora of literature on ISIS because many people were looking for answers and publishing industry has a history of cashing on every selling trend.
ISIS became a major threat only after Syrian civil war started, before that it was a group mainly based in sunni areas of Iraq. Like Al-Qaeda, selfish and myopic policies of US and its allies have been instrumental in the establishment of ISIS. But please, lets not throw it all on the west, the war mongering Jihadist narrative has been tolerated, rather encouraged in our own country too. Lets not fall for the conspiracy theories and sit back, blaming west for all.


message 12: by Rabeea (new)

Rabeea You are arriving at wrong conclusions. I never said I'm blaming the west for everything. I would never take such a reductionist approach.
Well, I'm not falling for conspiracy theories of either the west ( biased literature on the subject) or the eastern 'yahoodi saazish' version of it.


Abubakar Mehdi So who's version will you accept then?


message 14: by Rabeea (new)

Rabeea neither can be 100% true so none. I'd rather avoid making snap judgements and having rigid opinions like 'it's all western propaganda' or 'Islam is the fundamental evil'. Truth invariably lies between the two extremes.


Abubakar Mehdi Of Course it does, and that is exactly what my humble review says about the Book too. You have to read point of views and come to a conclusion Rabeea, that you feel is more correct. You just can't dismiss everything.


message 16: by Rabeea (new)

Rabeea Yes you do, but not based on just a book but on overall deductive reasoning.


message 17: by Jibran (last edited May 20, 2016 07:38AM) (new)

Jibran Actually, when it comes to identifying the backers and helpers of ISIS, the first names that come to mind are a couple of GCC countries ("dear Muslim brozzhers") who funneled the money and weapons into what expanded to become the ISIS we know today. Prior to that it was a small fringe jihadist group in Iraq like dozens others no one knew about about, but the GCC wanted to cash in on the initial public protests against the Assad government, which they did. The "revolution" in Syria was tainted right from the start. As for the Western powers, we know it was in their interest to see the back of Assad. They acquiesced in GCC + Turkey's helping the jihadists, facilitated the movement of weapons and money to "rebels" (which was mostly landing in Jihadist hands). At one point in 2014, I can't find the reference, but American and British military advisers were training "Syrian rebels" in Turkey who were then supposed to travel to Syria to fight. it is Afghanistan II, through and through, and they are now paying for it because the fire they started in Syria is now reaching Riyadh and Paris too.

It is not amiss to say that Western powers have taken full advantage of the situation to destablise the region to get what they wanted (though they haven't got it yet) and that ISIS wouldn't be ISIS without the pumping of money and weapons into it by Saudia and Qatar among other parties. And let's not forget, it is impossible for the Saudis and their lesser GCC sheikhs to move so much money and weapons without the express permission of their masters in Washington.


Abubakar Mehdi Absolutely ! And just a little fun fact, much of modern sophisticated weapons and heavy armour that ISIS has was a 'gift' by US and brothers to fight the regime. And boy, they really put everyone in this fucked up situation.
Jibran I will really recommend this book, it is neutral and very well written as compared to the usual crap we get through NYT and WP op-eds.


message 19: by Jibran (new)

Jibran Would defo check it out, Abubakar. Thanks for the rec!


message 20: by Asghar (last edited Sep 27, 2016 11:57AM) (new)

Asghar Abbas This is chilling but a brilliant review. This whole mess is sickening and saddening. You are right , only those with gross inhuman fetishes would flock to ISIS and you pointed out and aptly so, so many simple minded folks wants sharia law imposed here. You said this somewhere else , religion should be a personal matter. Nowadays even if someone sneezes , ISIS would take credit for that . Two things and they are both naive but I can't help wondering . Why can't the governments around the world shut down Isis twitters and web access , their toxic message to the depraved . And why can't KSA and to certain extent , Iran though it's relatively better , leave Pakistan alone ? I guess we are too busy watching Indian movies whilst simultaneously going to war with India to check ourselves . While religion is probably not to be blamed for Isis but some if not most religious people sure are . Disgusted by the brutality.


Abubakar Mehdi I do think mainstream narrative makes ISIS's job a lot easier, but yes I agree your point. Thank you for your thoughtful comment.


message 22: by Asghar (new)

Asghar Abbas On off topic , have you read Sunne in Splendour ? I just realized you would enjoy it .

/review/show...


Abubakar Mehdi Oh no, I haven't. Thank you, I'll definitely check it out.


message 24: by Lata (new)

Lata Brilliant, sensitive review.


Abubakar Mehdi Thank you Lata ...


message 26: by Narmin (new)

Narmin Excellent, excellent review Abubakar!


Abubakar Mehdi Thank you very much Narmin.


back to top