ŷ

Caroline 's Reviews > Missoula: Rape and the Justice System in a College Town

Missoula by Jon Krakauer
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3236194
***NO SPOILERS***

Common rape fallacies:
1) Many women “cry rape.�
2) Many rape victims are the ones who choose not to charge and prosecute their rapists.
3) Most rapists don’t know their victims.
4) Most rapists are punished.
If you think the United States is one of the most forward-thinking countries when it comes to this monstrous crime, if you think police do everything in their power to protect rape victims, if you think most people understand rape in general, you’d be sorely mistaken, and you are meant to read this book.

Drawing on rock-solid research, renowned investigative reporter Jon Krakauer expertly tore apart every myth surrounding rape and covered so much more in this crucial work of nonfiction. He began by putting a human face on a crime that affects a mind-boggling number of women (and men, but Krakauer focused on women) by opening with the story of one rape victim, then deftly moving on to a handful of others. Missoula’s hook is immediate, and thanks to Krakauer’s signature fluid writing, this book reads like an engrossing work of fiction; read the first few pages of chapter one and just try to set this aside.

He chose Missoula, Montana very deliberately. It’s a typical college town, and Krakauer wanted to highlight the widespread epidemic of campus rape. Additionally, Missoula in particular has been hit especially hard by allegations of campus sexual assault and rape. Finally, and an absolutely essential point, this is a town whose residents are thoroughly enraptured by the University of Montana football team, the Grizzlies. (In fact, the fandom is so impassioned and their loyalty so blind and all-consuming that the town is lovingly dubbed “Grizzlyville.�) All rape victims--not just those in college--rarely see justice served, but Krakauer’s decision to home in specifically on college football–obsessed Missoula couldn’t have worked more perfectly to underscore a horrifying general truth. Quite simply, it is this: if your rapist happens to be beloved, expect the worst from the criminal justice system--and scathing, inexorable torment from the public. Woe to the Missoula victim whose rapist happens to be a revered “Griz.�

Krakauer presented staggering statistics that no doubt will enrage and stun most readers to the core and painted a damning portrait of the criminal justice system. The crime is disgracefully handled almost across the board, and that is a crime in itself. So many of these failures could be prevented if the complexity of rape, and victims� often counterintuitive responses while being raped, were genuinely just understood. By the end, there’s one thing Missoula has made abundantly clear: extensive education on rape is desperately needed, for all. As things stand now, in supposedly enlightened 2016, much of the public and far too many police officers and lawyers remain disturbingly misinformed.

It must be stated that because Missoula addresses shortcomings in how the criminal justice system handles rape, it’s focused on a handful of victims. Given the topic, it has to be. This is not to say, however, that it’s biased. The other side didn’t get the short end of the stick; very much on the contrary. Every little fact was included. Both sides were depicted fully. Court transcripts were presented verbatim. All research was meticulous to a fault. Like all of Krakauer’s books in recent years, Missoula is investigative. Krakauer’s ability to remain dispassionate is one of the things that makes his writing so wondrous.

Don’t shelve Missoula on the to-read list and allow it languish alongside that forgotten book you shelved in 2008 and the “should-read� classic you know you’ll never read. The time for this book is now.

Complementary documentary viewing: "Audrie and Daisy"

Bonus: Following is a very short article about campus rape. Specifically, it concerns, “a campaign called ‘Unacceptable Acceptance Letters,� [which] is an imagining [in video form] of what it would look like if colleges owned up to the problem of rape on their campuses--and how they’re failing to address it--right off the bat.� Please read (and watch).

Update, May 27, 2016: Shades of Missoula:

Update, June 9, 2016: Judge sentences Stanford University student who raped unconscious fellow student to just six months in jail because "a harsher penalty would have a 'severe impact' on the aspiring athlete":

Update, March 25, 2017: "Nearly 15% of female undergraduates at UT Austin report being raped":

Update, November 7, 2019: "Why I Froze and Smiled During My Sexual Assault"
70 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Missoula.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

April 29, 2016 – Started Reading
April 29, 2016 – Shelved
April 29, 2016 – Shelved as: nonfiction
April 29, 2016 – Shelved as: get-smart
April 29, 2016 –
page 11
2.64%
April 30, 2016 –
page 37
8.89%
May 2, 2016 –
page 94
22.6% "These police officers are scum."
May 2, 2016 – Shelved as: important-nonfiction
May 3, 2016 –
page 143
34.38% "This is absolutely phenomenal. Already, I recommend it to all."
May 6, 2016 –
page 209
50.24%
May 8, 2016 –
page 351
84.38% "I thought the police officers were pure scum, but the lawyers� Some of the lawyers in this book are truly depraved human beings."
May 9, 2016 – Shelved as: maximum-impact
May 9, 2016 – Shelved as: page-turner
May 9, 2016 – Shelved as: he-wrote-it
May 9, 2016 – Finished Reading
March 25, 2017 – Shelved as: adored
May 17, 2018 – Shelved as: true-crime
January 5, 2020 – Shelved as: narrative-nonfiction
January 14, 2020 – Shelved as: litmus-test
October 7, 2021 – Shelved as: favorite-author

Comments Showing 1-50 of 59 (59 new)


message 1: by Lisa (new) - added it

Lisa Vegan Great review, Caroline. I do want to read it, and not let it languish forever.

I'll look at the video you linked when I get to a device that can handle it.

How horrifying. I hope that this book and other accounts help change the culture, really change how rape is handled.


Caroline Lisa wrote: "How horrifying. I hope that this book and other accounts help change the culture, really change how rape is handled."

I hope.


message 3: by Caroline (last edited May 09, 2016 11:38AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Caroline Lucille wrote: "Jerry Sandusky.

Joe Paterno.

Penn State Lions."


They came to my mind too. :|

I think you'll love this, Lucille.


message 4: by Lisa (new) - added it

Lisa Vegan I read the article and watched the video in the link. Chilling. I'm really glad it's being talked about so much.


message 5: by Carmen (new) - added it

Carmen I'm definitely going to be reading this book, but I have doubts about my ability to handle it. I agree with you that it is too important not to read, though. Great review, Caroline.


message 6: by Jeannie (new)

Jeannie Great review Caroline. You are helping me add to my TBR. I just got a copy of Into Thin Air because of your review. I want to read this one too.


Caroline Lisa wrote: "I read the article and watched the video in the link. Chilling. I'm really glad it's being talked about so much."

Lisa, it's actually not being talked about nearly as much as it needs to be. :[ Krakauer's book was desperately needed.

I'm glad you liked the short video and article. It was really serendipitous that I found it; it popped up in my Twitter feed shortly before I started this book, and I immediately felt it would work well to enhance the review.


Caroline Carmen wrote: "I'm definitely going to be reading this book, but I have doubts about my ability to handle it. I agree with you that it is too important not to read, though. Great review, Caroline."

I think you'll appreciate this, Carmen. I really do. I don't know whether you decided to read my spoiler in the group, but I clarified about the graphic-ness.


Caroline Jeannie wrote: "Great review Caroline. You are helping me add to my TBR. I just got a copy of Into Thin Air because of your review. I want to read this one too."

The two couldn't be more different, of course, but what they have in common is that they're both utterly captivating. I really hope you like them, Jeannie!


message 10: by Carmen (new) - added it

Carmen Caroline wrote: "Carmen wrote: "I'm definitely going to be reading this book, but I have doubts about my ability to handle it. I agree with you that it is too important not to read, though. Great review, Caroline."..."

I did read the spoiler, and I really appreciate you sharing that, Caroline.


Caroline You're welcome, Carmen. Happy to help.


message 12: by Lisa (new) - added it

Lisa Vegan Caroline wrote: "Lisa, it's actually not being talked about nearly as much as it needs to be. :[ Krakauer's book was desperately needed.."

Caroline, I agree, but I am seeing many stories on tv news and now a book from a popular author, so I guess I'm hopeful that this coming more to light will make a difference. I'm so sad and angry thinking of young people trying to make a good start in life and having their lives so adversely impacted by this sort of thing happening.


Debbie "DJ" Fantastic review Caroline! I too think this is a must read. Also, the unacceptable acceptance video really brought it home.


message 14: by Caroline (new) - added it

Caroline An excellent review. This book isn't available in my library catchment area, so all the more do I appreciate good reviews about it. The video was excellent too. I'm sure the book has and will make a big difference to how campus rape is viewed in America.


Caroline Thank you, DJ and Caroline. I'm glad both of you liked that video too.

Caroline, will the book be available where you live eventually? How does that work?


message 16: by Caroline (last edited May 11, 2016 05:33PM) (new) - added it

Caroline The truth is that a lot of my friends on GR are American...and many of the fantastic books you recommend are American - and British public libraries don't carry them. And I am really committed to just trying to use the library.

Via my computer & the library website I am able to order books from libraries all over the south east of England. (That is my local town library's full catchment area.)

Really I ought to try and cultivate more British contacts on GR, that way I would see more British books reviewed....


message 17: by Lisa (new) - added it

Lisa Vegan I'm always amazed at how many British and Canadian books that interest me that I'm unable to get.

I believe everyone in the world should have easy access to every book. Without GR I wouldn't even know about the many books I am missing.

I also use the library 99% of the time so I can't even get every single U.S. book.


message 18: by Caroline (new) - added it

Caroline Lisa wrote: "I'm always amazed at how many British and Canadian books that interest me that I'm unable to get.

I believe everyone in the world should have easy access to every book. Without GR I wouldn't even..."


Nice to know that you too are a library wallah Lisa!

Re. not being able to get a lot of books when you do just use libraries.... That's one of the reasons why it's so nice belonging to GR - at least we get access to excellent reviews - so even if we can't get the books, we get an idea of the gist of them.


message 19: by Lisa (new) - added it

Lisa Vegan Caroline, I agree.

I've also exchanged some owned books with Canadian and UK/European friends. I've also bought a couple books from UK bookstores, online.

There are MANY British members here. England is one of the most represented countries among GR members.


message 20: by Caroline (new) - added it

Caroline Lisa wrote: "Caroline, I agree.

I've also exchanged some owned books with Canadian and UK/European friends. I've also bought a couple books from UK bookstores, online.

There are MANY British members here. E..."


For financial reasons, I am trying to keep all my books to library books. (Especially because I never keep books - I get rid of them as soon as I have read them...) Plus I have just under 1000 books on my t-r lists which are available via the libraries...so really, that should keep me going for a while ;O)

It is great to hear there are so many British peeps on ŷ!


message 21: by Lisa (new) - added it

Lisa Vegan Caroline, For me it's mostly a financial thing too. I do keep my books. I have thousands in a way too small space. I'll need to get rid of most of them so buying more is usually silly. I have several British friends here. I wonder if there are any groups for Brits?


message 22: by Caroline (new) - added it

Caroline My priority is finding people who like non-fiction. There are far, far more people on GR who prefer fiction. But I ought to keep an eye out for groups for Brits...that's a good idea.


message 23: by Lisa (new) - added it

Lisa Vegan Yes, do. I hope you find a group that's a good fit.

I enjoy both fiction and non-fiction, many genres in each.


message 24: by Lisa (new) - added it

Lisa Vegan Caroline, Here is one. It's late and I'm in my phone so I didn't check their shelves to check for non-fiction books. I'm sure there are also other groups.

/group/show/...


message 25: by Caroline (new) - added it

Caroline I will check that out Lisa, thank you!


Caroline Caroline wrote: "There are far, far more people on GR who prefer fiction."

That's interesting to hear. I like a true mix. When I stopped to think about it, I realized, too, that the most powerful books I've read have been nonfiction. More people should read NF.


Caroline Caroline, how about, in addition to looking for a group for British members, also looking for a group for those who love nonfiction? I'm sure there are a few. (Just make sure it's active! There are so many defunct groups here. :[)


message 28: by Lisa (new) - added it

Lisa Vegan Yes, that's a good idea to look for a non-fiction group.

Also, in any British groups ask who there likes non-fiction, start some non-fiction threads, etc.

And anyone you meet compare books and if you get to know them a bit and they like non-fiction and you have book taste in common, you could make a few more friends to get ideas.

This not having books available no matter where we are in the world drives me nuts. There is no good reason for it, especially when it comes to streaming e-books and audio books, but even paper books should be able to be bought or borrowed.


message 29: by Caroline (new) - added it

Caroline Caroline wrote: "Caroline, how about, in addition to looking for a group for British members, also looking for a group for those who love nonfiction? I'm sure there are a few. (Just make sure it's active! There are..."

I must try that. I don't have time to participate in a group (real life is a bit of a bummer at the moment, and I am very stretched), but it's a good way of checking people out who may make good contacts. A non-fiction group would be a good place to start. I am s-l-o-w-l-y building up a cache of n/f fans - the situation is much better than it was this time last year :O)


message 30: by Caroline (last edited May 12, 2016 09:03AM) (new) - added it

Caroline Lisa wrote: "Yes, that's a good idea to look for a non-fiction group.

Also, in any British groups ask who there likes non-fiction, start some non-fiction threads, etc.

And anyone you meet compare books and if..."


Thank you for responding Lisa. The trouble is I don't really have time to participate in a group (see my comment to Caroline above). I did check out the British group you mentioned, and I found one thread relating to n/f stuff, but when I checked out the people leaving comments there....they were mostly fiction readers.

Things are okay. I am slowly building up a group of n/f contacts on ŷ - and thus getting access to ideas for lots of good n/f books to read. (I'm gaining momentum the longer I stay here!)


message 31: by Lisa (new) - added it

Lisa Vegan Caroline, Not all groups have group reads. Sometimes people just talk about books they like, give suggestions, etc.

But, as you said, you might find like-minded readers if you search some non-fiction and British groups, and maybe you can make a few more GR friends or members to follow as a way of finding many more appealing and accessible to you non-fiction books.


message 32: by Jill (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jill Looks like we had the exact same reaction on this one--Krakauer just pummels you with his impeccable research. It's one of the few nonfiction "page-turners" that I've come across. I read it more than a year ago but I still recall the details of some of the girls' stories. Tragedy that they and so many others can't get justice. Glad you enjoyed it, Caroline!


Caroline Jill wrote: "Looks like we had the exact same reaction on this one--Krakauer just pummels you with his impeccable research. It's one of the few nonfiction "page-turners" that I've come across. I read it more th..."

It hit me hard, Jill, very, very hard. I need a recovery period to the point where I feel I won't be able to read anything so serious for many months. I haven't felt this way about anything else sad or serious I've ever read.

By the way, I reread your incredible review and agree with everything, including your complaint. I was thinking about that too and wondering--and still mulling it over.


message 34: by Caroline (new) - added it

Caroline Lisa wrote: "Caroline, Not all groups have group reads. Sometimes people just talk about books they like, give suggestions, etc.

But, as you said, you might find like-minded readers if you search some non-fict..."


Sorry Lisa, I missed your comment before. Yes, what you suggest is what I am trying to do.... I have now gained a lot of momentum since joining GR. At first I knew hardly anyone who read non-fic....but now I know quite a few people who do.


message 35: by Lisa (new) - added it

Lisa Vegan Caroline, Good! Yes many readers here do. There is such diversity that all GR members can find likeminded readers.


message 36: by Caroline (new) - added it

Caroline It's ŷ' finest strength :O)*


Debbie "DJ" Love the update Caroline. Yes, I'd read about Kenneth Starr. After all the millions he wasted trying to impeach Clinton, his lack of action does not surprise me. Will read your link...only demoted? Unbelievable!


Caroline Debbie "DJ" wrote: " . . . only demoted? Unbelievable!"

It's wrong.

After having read this book, though, I'm not so surprised.


Debbie "DJ" Awesome...he resigned!


Caroline Debbie "DJ" wrote: "Awesome...he resigned!"

Good.


message 41: by Debbie (new) - added it

Debbie Great great great review, Caroline. I will read this. I ran across this poignant and oh so clear utube cartoon story--perfect for high school and college kids. Viewing it should be required:


Caroline Debbie wrote: "Great great great review, Caroline. I will read this. I ran across this poignant and oh so clear utube cartoon story--perfect for high school and college kids. Viewing it should be required: https:..."

That is an excellent little video. Thanks for sharing it with me.


Caroline Updated today with a news article about rape at the University of Texas at Austin.


message 44: by Lisa (new) - added it

Lisa Vegan Caroline wrote: "Updated today with a news article about rape at the University of Texas at Austin.

Update: 3/25/17. "Nearly 15% of female undergraduates at UT Austin report being raped": ..."


That's crazy. Scary.


message 45: by Karina (new)

Karina Your first paragraph captivated the truth especially in Universities by athletes in the US. It's so disgusting. You'd think we're more civilized in the 21st century but we've become more uncivilized than 100 yrs ago in many respects. Great review! I appreciate stuff like this


Caroline Karina wrote: "Your first paragraph captivated the truth especially in Universities by athletes in the US. It's so disgusting. You'd think we're more civilized in the 21st century but we've become more uncivilize..."

Thank you, Karina. This book is a major eye-opener.

I guess you saw my review in your feed...? I don't understand why this is happening. I didn't click "Add to feed" below the review, and I even turned off the "Add a book to my shelves" in settings. (That usually helps.) GRRR! It looks like I'm floating my review. :/ Sorry.


message 47: by Lisa (new) - added it

Lisa Vegan Caroline wrote: "I guess you saw my review in your feed...? I don't understand why this is happening. I didn't click "Add to feed" below the review, and I even turned off the "Add a book to my shelves" in settings. (That usually helps.)."

Caroline, I just read in the substitute Feedback group that unchecking does not work and that only doing that and unchecking in preferences as the default works when people are accessing GR via the app. It sounds as though you did though. To me it sounds like yet another bug. Good to know but I"m not happy. I don't send most of my activity to my feed.


message 48: by Karina (new)

Karina Yes it was on my feed. Did you not want it to be? But open to only friends? Sorry this is over my head. I'm a tech dummy; didn't know you could adjust. And what is floating your review? Chica! Don't be sorry esp when I'm absolutely clueless!! 😂😂


Caroline Karina wrote: "Yes it was on my feed. Did you not want it to be? But open to only friends? Sorry this is over my head. I'm a tech dummy; didn't know you could adjust. And what is floating your review? Chica! Don'..."

Karina, I didn't want it to go to the feed at all. I send my reviews to the feed once, right after I post the review (and sometimes after I write "review to come," but that's it); however, every single time I make some change--add something, edit, whatever--off it goes to the feed. There's a little check box beneath the review box that says "Add to update feed." I always uncheck that after editing or adding to the review, but it makes no difference. What can prevent this is going first to Account settings and unchecking "Add a book to my shelves," but I did that this time, and it didn't work.

Floating a review means sending a review to the feed over and over and over to garner likes. I dislike that when I make any changes to an existing review, it looks like I'm floating it because it goes to the feed every dang time.

Anyway, I like to add relevant articles to this review, and some others, from time to time, so if you see this review in your feed repeatedly, just know it's because I added something, not that I'm floating it. :}

(I do think this behavior is a bug, but when I've reported it to staff, they haven't cared.)


message 50: by Caroline (last edited Nov 08, 2019 07:05AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Caroline Lisa wrote: "Caroline, I just read in the substitute Feedback group that unchecking does not work and that only doing that and unchecking in preferences as the default works when people are accessing GR via the app."

Ah. Well, maybe I'm doing it wrong. I've been unchecking "Add a book to my shelves," but I didn't think about changing the default you mention. I'll try that next time. (Though the review is only not seen by app users...?) I wish GR cared about the broken check box beneath the review box.

Oh, and how about the fact that every single time you comment on one of your own reviews, it goes back to the feed? That's ridiculous. This review has now gone to the feed again because I commented. :/ They'll never fix that bug.


« previous 1
back to top