ŷ

VivaPalestina's Reviews > I Saw Ramallah

I Saw Ramallah by Mourid Barghouti
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3770001
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: reviewed

I had wished to be able to review the book impartially, to review it as others would read it, but I couldn't. Written by a poet, translated by an artist, was it any wonder that I wished I could quote the whole book were it in my own hands?

'Displacement is like death'

A more painful story I haven't read, one that resounded strongly within and made me shed scorching hot bitter tears for what I had lost through no fault of mine. A sharp sense of acute hurt, betrayal by forefathers who walked away from Ramallah and other cities blessing us with the name 'displaced ones', betrayal at the countries that tried to save us and yet were defeated in humility.

'..tells me that Ramallah is no longer mine and I will not return to it. The city has fallen.'

It was no longer him leaving Palestine; it was me, me that had crossed the bridge to Amman, me that was locked out, me that was sweltering in Cairo's stifling heat, me that was waiting at Jordan’s check point, staring at the dried river. I felt transported through time as though this was my own shore of memories I was walking upon, my own pages of emotions I'm flicking through. The writer’s narration has you transfixed, there with him, and the journey back to your current place and seat is long and wearisome.

'The stranger is told by kind people: "You are in your second home here and among your kin." He is despised for being a stranger, or sympathized with for being a stranger. The second is harder to bear than the first.'

I've always been fond of the English verb 'to yearn'. I felt no other language could sum up my emotions so beautifully in one word, I have a yearning to learn French, I had a yearning to walk barefoot upon the shores of Jaffa. Reading this book has made my word pale beyond comparison. If before I yearned to visit Palestine, now I'm left with a yearn-shaped hole needing to be filled with Palestine.

'I do not say thank you little bridge. Should I be ashamed in front of you? Or should you be ashamed in front of me?'

'Being forbidden to return killed him'

'For the Palestinian, olive oil is the gift of the traveller, the comfort of the bride, the reward of autumn, the boast of the storeroom, the wealth of the family across centuries'

'The Occupation has created generations of us that have to adore an unknown beloved; distant, difficult, surrounded by guards, by walls, by nuclear missiles, by sheer terror'

'All those who have been destined to exile share the same features. For an exile, the habitual place and status of a person is lost'

'We cannot grumble about it as people grumble about their tiresome capitals. Perhaps the worst thing about occupied cities is that their children cannot make fun of them'

Who would dare to affectionately complain about Palestine? Londoners can generally agree to complain about three things, the weather, the public transport and the government's taxes. When busses go on strike we are all united in ranting against TFL, people that have never spoken two words together will suddenly be united in their morning grumpiness, facebook status' are updated from around the country through phones all sharing one common theme. Palestinians have been deprived from that. Reproach is only for the beloved we say in arabic, Palestine our beloved we cannot reproach or complain because we're too busy struggling to keep it between our hands.

This boy...who has seen nothing of Palestine throughout his twenty years, burns to see it like a refugee grown old in a distant camp

'Some Palestinians wronged Lebanon. The children of the camps pay the price for this everyday. If only all who had wronged Palestine would pay the price too.'

The unjustice of it all came crashing down upon me while reading this book. My french and russian Jewish friends may wax lyrical about the beauty of 'Israel' while I, supposedly a Palestine, have never set sight on it. Arabic countries like Lebanon and Jordan are preserving our 'Right of Return' by making sure our stay is only temporary. Children born and brought up in Lebanon, marrying in Lebanon, bringing children into Lebanon, they are stamped as 'temporary'. We are still living in this state of temporariness, waiting.

'"Should we leave it to the settlers? Everyone should come back from abroad who can"'

'The fish
Even in the fisherman's net
Still carries
The smell of the sea'


Reading this book has only confirmed my memories of Palestine. Do not ask me where they came from, but they are there. I remember Palestine, it's ingrained in every cell in my body that breathes, every atom that makes me. For Palestine is no longer merely a land. It lives and breathes in us, she is us and we are her.

The pillow is the register of our lives. The first draft of our story that, each night, we write without ink and tell without a sound'

The journey that I started with Mourid started and ended on my pillow. It was a witness to the laughs I laughed, to the grins I made. It held my tears and wiped them away promising me a return. It shared my angst and frustration, my love and joy. Do not bother telling me that I'm not a Palestinian as my memory and existance denies otherwise. Do not bother telling me that Palestine will come back to me, for Palestine was never lost to us and never will be. I only hope that we will soon be reunited.

For those of you that have managed to reach the end, I only say, 'a must read'.
32 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read I Saw Ramallah.
Sign In »

Quotes VivaPalestina Liked

مريد البرغوثي
“من السهل طمس الحقيقة بحيلة لغوية بسيطة: ابدأ حكايتك من ُثانيا!”
مريد البرغوثي, رأيت رام الله

مريد البرغوثي
“غرفة حراسه عادية, الحارس فيها يحرس وطننا ... منا.”
مريد البرغوثي, رأيت رام الله

مريد البرغوثي
“الاحتلال الطويل الذي خلق أجيالا إسرائيلية ولدت في إسرائيل ولا تعرف لها "وطناً" سواها... خلق في الوقت نفسه أجيالاً من "الفلسطينين الغرباء عن فلسطين " ولدت في المنفى ولا تعرف من وطنها غير إلا قصته وأخباره”
مريد البرغوثي, رأيت رام الله

مريد البرغوثي
“أنا ابن جبل و استقرار. ومنذ تذكر يهود القرن العشرين كتابهم المقدس، أصابني الرحيل البدوي، و ما أنا ببدوي”
مريد البرغوثي, رأيت رام الله

مريد البرغوثي
“الآن أمر من غربتي إلى .. وطنهم؟ وطني؟ الضفة وغزة؟ الأراضي المحتلة؟ المناطق؟ يهودا وسامرة؟ الحكم الذاتي؟ اسرائيل؟ فلسطين؟
هل في العالم كله بلد واحد يحار الناس في تسميته هكذا؟”
مريد البرغوثي, رأيت رام الله


Reading Progress

April 24, 2011 – Shelved
April 29, 2011 –
page 71
0%
April 30, 2011 –
page 131
0%
Started Reading
May 1, 2011 – Shelved as: reviewed
May 1, 2011 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-15 of 15 (15 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Niledaughter Great :)


VivaPalestina Nile daughter wrote: "Great :)"

The copy I have is translated by Ahdaf Soueif, the one who wrote A Map of Love :)


message 3: by Niledaughter (last edited Apr 28, 2011 07:32AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Niledaughter yes she translated it and I heard the translation is very good , by the way , she is a personal friend of Radwa Ashourwho is Mourid Barghouti's wife , and her other novel In the Eye of the Sun I felt two of the characters were inspired by them!


VivaPalestina Nile daughter wrote: "yes she translated it and I heard the translation is very good , by the way , she is a personal friend of Radwa Ashourwho is Mourid Barghouti's wife , and her othe..."

Oh really? I didnt manage to find anything for Ahdaf yet, but it mentions in the foreword her excellence, as well as his wife being an extinguished Egyptian academic. I didnt know they were friends though! :D


Niledaughter Beautiful quotes and comments viva !

VivaPalestina wrote: "Oh really? I didnt manage to find anything for Ahdaf yet, but it mentions in the foreword her excellence, as well as his wife being an extinguished Egyptian academic. I didnt know they were friends though! :D

So strange , she lives in London and publish there ?!
Yes they are friends , I read several comments for Radwa about Ahdaf :) I read only one book for Radwa , may be you can give it a try

ثلاثية غرناطة


VivaPalestina Finally finished!
But no the copy I have is published by The American University in Cairo Press, and the english is all American spelling!

Nile daughter wrote: "I read only on book for Radwa, may be you can give it a try"

Your review makes it sound interesting, but there is no translated version is there?


message 7: by Niledaughter (last edited May 01, 2011 03:17AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Niledaughter VivaPalestina wrote: "Finally finished!
But no the copy I have is published by The American University in Cairo Press, and the english is all American spelling!



I see ! but her novels are published by (Bloomsbury)London .


VivaPalestina wrote: "Your review makes it sound interesting, but there is no translated version is there? "

Thanks :)

I think this is part one :

http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/21...


VivaPalestina Thank you 7abibti!


Huda :)
you asked what got to me while reading the incomplete review, everything really, but the thing that got to me most was what you said about 'yearning' and the yearn shaped hole that's needed to be filled with Palestine. That was amazingly expressed.
I can't wait to read the book!
<3


Citlalli Amazing 7abibty! You should really present us with your reviews oftener :)


VivaPalestina I hope you like it sweetie :) <3

Citlalli wrote: "Amazing 7abibty! You should really present us with your reviews oftener :)"
Cici khajaltini 7abibti <3 I am trying I promise! I've already done five, yallah go read them all :P


Citlalli :D I've read this one and the one for Vanity Fair and I found them both great!! So... 3 more to go ;) Honest, I wish I could write such good reviews too!


VivaPalestina Citlalli wrote: ":D I've read this one and the one for Vanity Fair and I found them both great!! So... 3 more to go ;) Honest, I wish I could write such good reviews too!"

Oh I just remembered you read The Great Gatsby too, khalas those three were the main ones :D

Muchas gracias querida, thank you 7abibti I love your encouragement :)


message 14: by Noor (new) - rated it 4 stars

Noor Al-Zubaidi Amazing! I want to curl up in bed, read this book and feel tenth of what u felt towards it!
Your reviews are wonderful, I'm as jealous as Citalli of them.


Suhayb Al-jawhari So funny the way that your words still affect others 10 years later, very much similar to the way Mourid's words have to both you and me. "Reading this book has only confirmed my memories of Palestine. Do not ask me where they came from, but they are there. I remember Palestine, it's ingrained in every cell in my body that breathes, every atom that makes me." This might be seen by others as an exaggeration, but for me it is not. It is real. Thank you for sharing your feelings that I share with you as well.


back to top