withdrawn's Reviews > Purgatorio: Second Book of the Divine Comedy
Purgatorio: Second Book of the Divine Comedy
by
by

withdrawn's review
bookshelves: fiction, italy, witches-gods-other-imaginaries, poetry, medieval
May 20, 2016
bookshelves: fiction, italy, witches-gods-other-imaginaries, poetry, medieval
In The Inferno, Dante used his many skills of philosophical and theological argument, poetry, knowledge of the classics and the Christian Church to both show his readers the punishments that await them if they do not change their ways, but, also, to carry forth his own political and personal polemics.
Here, in Purgatorio, he shows himself to be of even greater genius. I was expecting to encounter those who, despite their good intentions, have found themselves suffering great penance for their sins. They do so willingly in the knowledge that the time will come when they will be granted absolution and be welcomed into Paradise.
Again, Dante reveals his genius in intermingling Classical and Christian myth to create forceful stories of sin and redemption. One need not be a Christian to feel the force of the arguments.
The true genius of the work only becomes clear in Canto XXXI and beyond when Dante finally encounters Beatrice. Not just another pretty face, Beatrice in all her purity is both Dante's protector and his judge. Her initial scorn for him makes the reader wonder why she has gone to so much trouble to bring him to the edge of Paradise. He is such a lowly worm.
Dante's extensive knowledge, his poetic genius, his commitment to his message and his ability to combine and invent all bring too me a certain humbleness that most writers can never bring to the fore. It seems that Dante has gone beyond the merely human in order to put it all together.
Now on to Paradiso.
Here, in Purgatorio, he shows himself to be of even greater genius. I was expecting to encounter those who, despite their good intentions, have found themselves suffering great penance for their sins. They do so willingly in the knowledge that the time will come when they will be granted absolution and be welcomed into Paradise.
Again, Dante reveals his genius in intermingling Classical and Christian myth to create forceful stories of sin and redemption. One need not be a Christian to feel the force of the arguments.
The true genius of the work only becomes clear in Canto XXXI and beyond when Dante finally encounters Beatrice. Not just another pretty face, Beatrice in all her purity is both Dante's protector and his judge. Her initial scorn for him makes the reader wonder why she has gone to so much trouble to bring him to the edge of Paradise. He is such a lowly worm.
Dante's extensive knowledge, his poetic genius, his commitment to his message and his ability to combine and invent all bring too me a certain humbleness that most writers can never bring to the fore. It seems that Dante has gone beyond the merely human in order to put it all together.
Now on to Paradiso.
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
Purgatorio.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
May 20, 2016
– Shelved
May 20, 2016
– Shelved as:
to-read
May 20, 2016
– Shelved as:
witches-gods-other-imaginaries
May 20, 2016
– Shelved as:
italy
May 20, 2016
– Shelved as:
fiction
May 20, 2016
– Shelved as:
poetry
May 24, 2016
– Shelved as:
medieval
July 10, 2016
–
Started Reading
July 13, 2016
–
12.54%
"'.., one shade shouted: "See the second climber climb:/ the sun seems not to shine on his left side,/ and when he walks, he walks like one alive!"/ When I had heard these words, I turned my eyes/ and saw the shades astonished as they as they stared/ at me-at me, and at the broken light.' To be the freak with a shadow!"
page
38
July 14, 2016
–
17.16%
""Ah, abject Italy, you inn of sorrows,/ you ship without a helmsman in harsh seas,/ no queen of provinces but of bordellos! .... But those who are alive within you now/ can't live without their warring - even those/ whom one same wall and one's same moat enclose/ gnaw at each other." This could be 1944, not 1300."
page
52
August 15, 2016
–
95.05%
"Just like a fortress set on a steep slope,/ securely seated there, ungirt, a whore/ whose eyes were quick to rove, appeared to me;/ and I saw at her side, erect, a giant,/ who seemed to serve as her custodian;/ and they - again, again - embraced each other./ But when she turned her wandering, wanton eyes/ to me, then that ferocious amador/ beat her from head to foot; ....."
page
288
August 17, 2016
–
96.37%
"Beatrice to Dante, "But since I see your intellect is made/ of stone and, petrified, grown so opaque -/ the light of what I say has left you dazed - ..." Hardly an opinion to have of one's chosen messenger."
page
292
August 17, 2016
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-8 of 8 (8 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Ilse
(last edited Aug 19, 2016 09:24AM)
(new)
Aug 19, 2016 09:23AM

reply
|
flag

I'll be excited to see how you like Paradiso, as I found myself loving Inferno, liking Purgatorio, and not quite identifying with Paradiso at all.
I always wondered why that is, and concluded that humans are much better at depicting hell than heaven, chaos than order, dystopia than utopia. Reason being, in my (not very important) opinion: there's no storyline behind real bliss, and without stories, we are not entirely connected to humanity and its questions anymore. Paradiso is nice, but uninteresting, sort of.
"Lasciate ogni speranza, voi che entrate" - I doubt if there ever was a better advertisement for a rollercoaster adventure!

I enjoyed the imagery of Inferno thoroughly but found the theology and use of classical ideas more forceful in Purgatorio. The end of Purgatorio where Dante intermixed ideas to create a scene right out of Cirque du Soleil with Beatrice acting as ring master had to make me laugh.
So far, I'm enjoying Paradiso. It is different though.

Can't wait for your analysis of Paradiso!
