ŷ

Paz's Reviews > The Song of Achilles

The Song of Achilles by Madeline Miller
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
28910448
's review

did not like it
bookshelves: books-read-or-reread-in-2016

1.5 stars.
Aw man, where do I start with this one?
I know that the big majority of people love this book. They cried and were heartbroken and it was the best thing they ever read and shit, but for me? It was just so boring. The characters were horrendous, if I wanted to read about the most useless, passive and boring narrator being in love with this attractive, golden god, dude with no personality, and when he does have one, he just turns to a selfish prick, I would reread Twilight. Seriously, can Patroclus be any more of a Bella?

The writing was mediocre, the author clearly knows her stuff, but the dialogues were often ridiculous, the pacing was off. This story NEVER seemed to end. Now I wonder: how the hell does an epic tale become such a bland, flat story?

Ok, confession time, I never read The Iliad. I am 90% sure I read The Odyssey twice in my school years, yup, blame it on my school to make us read the same book twice just years apart. I am, however, familiar with this story. I enjoy Greek mythology and I was all for this book and its premise. But it was just not for me.

My biggest problem with the book was the characters, like I said before, they were awful characters. Patroclus is portrayed from the beginning as this weak, bland guy who can't defend himself and, throughout the book, that never changes. He is one of the most passive characters I've ever read. He is there solely to admire every physical aspect of Achilles, damn this guy had a thing for homeboy's feet. Seriously Patroclus, we get it, Achilles's feet were soft and pink and smell amazing. I got the message, and I also got how golden his skin and hair and everything in him was. Guy's hot, noted. What drove me crazy was the fact that Achilles really was the sole reason of Patroclus's existence. Without him, he didn't know how to do anything, he didn't have a reason to live and I just, ugh, really? We are going there? The whole ''if he dies, I'll die too cause there's nothing for me after him'' speech? Ugh. Even though Achilles and Patroclus had zero chemistry (seriously how many times do these guys talk, like really talk, in this book?) Do I have to believe that this good for nothing kind of guy, with no personality whatsoever, is actually the most beloved person for the best of the greeks? For this demigod? I just can't buy into this relationship that happens to be the entire focus of this book. It's like the author takes for granted that we know this is a love story between them so why bother to actually develop a relationship?

Achilles, he had no personality either until almost the very end of this book and then he turns into this selfish, proud asshole that even though is letting everyone be killed and failing to notice how dumb his decision is, is still admired and revered by Patroclus... I just...this book is just so dumb sometimes.

Of the story I can't say much because nothing happens. Seriously, we spend years in places and there's nothing to further the plot, it's like we are just waiting for the call against Troy. It is so boring and in this time, there's never a change in these characters. To me, the 8 years old Patroclus is the same Patroclus at the end. I don't know if it is because the story is told in past tense or if it's definitely a mistake from the author, but it reads the same. Through Patroclus's childhood, adolescence and adulthood, the character and his views feel exactly the same, which is ridiculous. For example, when all their greeks companions are dying and Achilles refuses to fight, even though Patroclus knows it's the stupidest decision ever, he refuses to say something and act, so what do they do? They both just consider to maybe swim or play later that day... I repeat, this book can be so dumb.

I don't understand Thetis role in here and why was Achilles so devoted to hear her and always obey her. Why was Achilles the perfect son, I don't understand because they clearly had a lot of issues.

I can't really say more, because I would be criticizing the same things over and over. I had a lot of issues with this book, this book took me more than a month to read More than a month! A book that I was planning to finish in 4 days... It seemed like it would NEVER end. The prophecy said that Achilles would die shortly after Hector, you don't know how many times I was rooting for this dude to die so everything could end soon. JUST SOMEONE COULD PLEASE KILL HECTOR NOW.

Anyway, if you liked this book, and judging by the ratings and reviews everyone and their mother loved this book, good for you! I personally had one of the most boring and frustrating experiences reading this. Maybe I would have enjoyed it more if I had read the Iliad, but I sincerely doubt it. That being said, the only thing and character I truly enjoyed was Odysseus. You go, Odysseus. You da best Odysseus!
4235 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Song of Achilles.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

June 6, 2016 – Started Reading
June 6, 2016 – Shelved
June 13, 2016 –
page 162
46.02% "Meh."
June 17, 2016 –
page 235
66.76% "I am going to kill Hector myself to speed this shit up. I'm bored out of my mind..."
July 9, 2016 –
page 284
80.68% "Just die already. I hate everyone in this book."
July 10, 2016 – Finished Reading
January 1, 2017 – Shelved as: books-read-or-reread-in-2016

Comments Showing 1-50 of 450 (450 new)


message 1: by Rohisa (new)

Rohisa One star, Paz? I was actually looking forward to reading this.


message 2: by Paz (new) - rated it 1 star

Paz Rohisa wrote: "One star, Paz? I was actually looking forward to reading this."

It didn't do anything for me. It became tedious to finish this book, but I'm in the big, big minority here.
I'd be interested to read your thoughts though.


message 3: by Rohisa (new)

Rohisa If we go by the comparative analysis of both of ours book rating pattern, you and I have striking similarity in rating books so I won't be surprise if I follow your footsteps with this book.


Lonnie I 100% agree with you on this one, the only character that i liked was Briseis lol


message 5: by Paz (new) - rated it 1 star

Paz Zara wrote: "I 100% agree with you on this one, the only character that i liked was Briseis lol"

Hah, it's been 2 years since I read this book, I still hate it with a burning passion. Glad to know, I'm not the only one who doesn't understand the hype!


ܴë "Seriously, can Patroclus be any more of a Bella?" - possible my favorite thing written in a book review, ever.


message 7: by Paz (new) - rated it 1 star

Paz ܴë wrote: ""Seriously, can Patroclus be any more of a Bella?" - possible my favorite thing written in a book review, ever."

Hahah thanks! Sadly, I still stand by that statement.


message 8: by AJ (new) - rated it 1 star

AJ Easterday I wholeheartedly agree with this review. Thank you.


kaylan 🦇 i’m only half way through and i’ve had to push myself to get this far. i agree with every statement in this review. I don’t know if i can make myself finish it it or not.


message 10: by Paz (new) - rated it 1 star

Paz kaylan 🦇 wrote: "i’m only half way through and i’ve had to push myself to get this far. i agree with every statement in this review. I don’t know if i can make myself finish it it or not."

I'm sorry to tell you, if I you feel that way halfway through it doesn't get better, I might say it's even more frustrating at the end :/


Shikha NO


message 12: by Yael (new) - rated it 3 stars

Yael I’m 60% through the book and i came here looking for the 1 star reviews because I CANT BELIEVE how BORING and BLAND this book is, i mean you dont have to like the characters in order for them to be good characters, but in this case i dont like them AND they are bad


roberta this is exactly how i feel about this book. thank you for putting my frustration into words. also i’m glad to see someone else enjoying Odysseus as much as i have!


Shilpa Chagi And also this selfish Achilles killed HECTOR only because he killed his companion otherwise dunno how long this war would go on and on and onnnnn🙂.


message 15: by Courtney (new)

Courtney 100% agree. Forced myself to finish. Wish I didn’t.


Daniela Raffa I totally agree with you. Moreover, it took 10 YEARS to the writer to write this easy peasy teen drama. Probably, it turned tedious to her too to finish it!


Keyla no literally i’m so bored..i have to push myself to read the rest


Sydney it took me FOREVER to read this book. I wanted to like it sooo bad because it was huge on BookTok (reading community on TikTok) for a while. I rated it a little higher because I thought the ending was kind of cute, but the rest just ticked me off.


message 19: by Ash (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ash C Thought of DNFing this book like 3 times so far. I think I will finally do it now lol. So boring.


Aishwarya Jaipuriar The comparison to Bella is spot on. I can't believe how flat all the characters felt and how it's only in the last 100 pages or so do we some hints of a plot existing!!


message 21: by Nicola (new)

Nicola yeah, I feel the same - The comparison to Twilight hahahahahahahahaa it's actually so real. I didn't finish it, had to return it back to the library Maybe someday when I have nothing to read I'll give it another go. Thanks for your review, it confirmed for me what I was feeling. I was so surprised by all the great reviews also.


Carolyn Green I am struggling myself, thank you for reaffirming that I am not the only one that feels this way about the book. Don’t know if I can finish it.


Danni I have read the Iliad and as a person who is well versed in Greek mythology I can guarantee that this book is BAD!


Melissa “Can Patroclus be any more of a Bella?� is one of my favorite lines ever from a review, and so entirely on-point!


message 25: by Rosa (new) - rated it 2 stars

Rosa Couldn’t agree more 🙌🏻


Carolin This comparison gives me life! I will forever use it when I describe this book


message 27: by MaJo (new) - rated it 2 stars

MaJo For real, had to come to the reviews to see if anyone else felt this way hehehehe, very well put


message 28: by Emi (new) - rated it 1 star

Emi I tought there was something wrong with me for not likinf this book. Maybe i was missing something. But Thankyou. Thankyou for putting into words everything that i felt.


Jordan I’m so glad I’m not the only one who didn’t immediately, or fully, fall in love with this book. I had such high expectations; everyone has absolutely RAVED about it. But man, did it fall flat for me.


message 30: by Tasha (new) - rated it 1 star

Tasha This is exactly how I feel


brienne I agree with basically everything you said. The story was so slow and honestly, i almost abandoned this book. The only reason I continued was that everybody liked it and the summary was interesting.


Francesca I can’t agree more!!! I’m 80% done this book and it’s like a chore at this point! Boring as hell.


Amber Omg that bit where they are doing raids every day and Patroclus just goes and stands and watches Achilles fight what was that


brienne Aman wrote: "Omg that bit where they are doing raids every day and Patroclus just goes and stands and watches Achilles fight what was that"

Exactly!


Abeerah Exactly


message 36: by Lorna (new) - rated it 1 star

Lorna My thoughts exactly. It just went on and on and on, and on. I kept speeding the audible narration up just to get it finished.


Ashley Hendrick I completely agree, I am over 50% through this book. I am struggling to continue. I only picked it up because of the hype around it. But I have to disagree with everyone. It’s so slow and even halfway, I feel no connection with the characters. I think all the good talk about it, made me go in with such high hopes. I want to like it, I think but I just can’t however I am still going to finish the book and hoping it changes my mind.


message 38: by Ari (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ari Okay I would like to argue with the Bella bit. Bella just sat there numb and diving off friggin cliffs just to think about the dude who I can't even remember his name.

Patroclus spends like 7 years trying to deal with the fact that his lover will die, and how he should react to it. He thinks about it, and is prepared to go on. Does Bella do that? No. So maybe you don't like the book, but please please please do not tell me Patroclus is a Bella.


Zachary Bell I agree, the main problem with this romance book is that there is no chemistry between the characters. It seems like that should be important for an epic love story.


Curtis ♡ slump era I just started this book and I’m extremely bored too. The narrator is boring asf, too many big words, nothing makes sense and I can’t imagine the story


message 41: by dzí (new) - rated it 2 stars

dzí THANK YOU SO MUCH for putting everything I felt into words. I had been gaslit into thinking this was peak literature and started to honestly believe something was wrong with me when I couldn’t get into it.


message 42: by Lisa (new) - rated it 2 stars

Lisa Buizer OMG YES this is exactly how I felt like? The book was boring and everyone seems to like it so much? Thank you for putting this into words xx


Rachel I enjoyed the book but i like this review. I didn’t like Patroclus. He didn’t have much character developement and you’re right. When he is first introduced there’s this tension where he wants to prove that he is a prince and I liked that but it dies down and he is simply this guy who can’t fight and extremely fragile.


Virginia I'm about half-way through, put it down and still haven't been able to pick it back up. I was on a reading streak for a while and trying to get through this one has been ROUGH to say the least.


Daniel You should check out my review of the book... ;-)


ˡAԲٲᲹˡ I think it's okay bc NO ONE should like smt that other people like! It is your thought about that book and everybidy should respect it. ;)


Sierra Reed The twooooo things I will say about Achilles and his mom: he basically grew up without her. So when she starts coming around, he wants to please her. Hello mommy issues. I can also see him as a representation of cis-straight, white men who come from privilege and grow up never having to make hard choices. They just go with the flow and assume things are fine for everyone else. They lack critical thinking and empathy. Then, he’s forced into a situation where he is the victor and eats that sh*t up…to become what should be a villain but society regards as a hero. A savior. Intelligent. Amazing. However, I still didn’t like the book as I read it. This is more of a personal opinion to TRY and make it better. Lol


Fiona I agree with this! It was so hard for me to finish this book - I wanted to love it but just couldn’t. Your review perfectly reflects all the same feelings I had about this story and characters.


julia I felt like it was just very slow and too many characters to remember even though there was the back of the book with some characters I just wanted the book to end. It would pick up, then slow down all of a sudden. I wish we saw more of Pat and Achilles love and their relationship


message 50: by Felix (new) - added it

Felix I'm looking on reading it as I'm super into Greek mythology, is it really this bad bro??? Everyone else says there's huge quantities of emotion and plot twists, which makes me eager to read it


« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
back to top