ŷ

Bill Kerwin's Reviews > We Have Always Lived in the Castle

We Have Always Lived in the Castle by Shirley Jackson
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
83582
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: fiction, gothic


This book is a masterpiece. It is short and spare and written in crystal clear prose, yet so evocative that it is richer in nuance than most good novels twice its size. It is so good I could kick myself for not reading it years ago, yet so mythic I am convinced I have known it always, like a tragic folktale or a chilling childhood dream. And yet, for all its grimness, it is essentially a comedy: darkly, transcendently, funny.

The Blackwood sisters�28-year-old Constance and 18-year-old Mary Katharine—live in a big old house on the outskirts of town. They are fitfully persecuted by the locals, who are convinced one of them is a murderer: their whole family—with the exception of scatterbrained Uncle Julian—was poisoned with arsenic six years ago. Now the three survivors—along with their black cat Jonas—are living together in deliberate tranquility, when long-lost cousin Charles arrives on their doorstep, barely concealing his interest in the lovely Constance and the Blackwood family estate.

The narrative voice of Merrycat—nickname for Mary Katherine—is perhaps the most distinctive thing about the novel. Deceptively childlike, obsessed with omens, magic words, and lucky days, Merrycat is nevertheless a clear and sharp-eyed observer of the day-to-day events of her world. Her naive shrewdness speaks to us like Huckleberry Finn’s, her quirkiness charms us like Holden Caulfield’s, yet she possesses a distance, a reserve, that is all her own.

Those of you who read novels like autobiographies will find tantalizing tidbits here. The local village resembles Jackson’s North Bennington, Vermont, a place Jackson always felt treated her family as outsiders (college eggheads, Democrats, atheists, Jews) and provided her the inspiration for her notorious early success, “The Lottery." The two sisters were inspired by Jackson’s two daughters, the placid and cautious Constance by Joanne and the superstitious and daring Merrycat by Sarah. But of course Jackson drew on herself for inspiration too, particularly from her fascination with witchcraft and sympathetic magic and her persistent, crippling agoraphobia. And Cousin Charles resembles her husband, in his critical comments about the housekeeping and his continual concerns about money. (Although husband Stanley was a literary critic, his wife Shirley was the literary cash cow of the family, and he once calculated precisely how much money was lost whenever his wife wasted her valuable time composing a letter to a friend.)

Perhaps what I like best about the book—besides the dark humor, and the voice of Merrycat of course—is its sweet and sad conclusion. After the destruction has passed and gone—a climax which reveals the full impact of the novel’s title—we witness a family rebuild an old life out of love, and even glimpse a little human compassion for a change. It is the twilight happiness of Shakespeare’s Winter’s Tale and The Tempest, the kind of happiness Lear and Cordelia might have enjoyed, if they had lived.

Here is the novel’s famous first paragraph, which gives you a good idea of Merrycat’s distinctive voice:

My name is Mary Katherine Blackwood. I am eighteen years old, and I live with my sister Constance. I have often thought that with any luck at all I could have been born a werewolf, because the two middle fingers on both my hands are the same length, but I have had to be content with what I had. I dislike washing myself, and dogs, and noise. I like my sister Constance, and Richard Plantagenet, and Amanita phalloides, the death cap mushroom. Everyone else in my family is dead.
1122 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read We Have Always Lived in the Castle.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

July 9, 2016 – Started Reading
July 9, 2016 – Shelved
July 9, 2016 – Shelved as: fiction
July 9, 2016 – Shelved as: gothic
July 9, 2016 –
page 41
26.97%
July 11, 2016 –
page 74
48.68%
July 14, 2016 –
page 89
58.55%
July 18, 2016 –
page 121
79.61%
July 19, 2016 –
page 139
91.45%
August 3, 2016 –
page 113
74.34%
August 3, 2016 –
page 115
75.66%
August 4, 2016 –
page 115
75.66%
August 4, 2016 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-45 of 45 (45 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Felice Laverne I LOVED this read! One of my favorites of all times (and one of the few that I've given 5* to)! I hope you enjoy it.


Felice Laverne Awesome review! Thanks for adding so much insight into the mind and circumstances of Jackson. This is one of my all-time favorite reads, and your review did it such justice!


Kristina Excellent review!


message 4: by Praveen (new) - added it

Praveen Nice review.. I wish to read Shirley Jackson.. I think this book could be a good choice to start with.


Erin the Avid Reader ⚜BFF's with the Cheshire Cat⚜ I love this book! I love Shirley Jackson to DEATH. Have you read "The Haunting of Hill House"?


Bill Kerwin Erin the Avid Reader ★Wiccan Girl, Too� wrote: "I love this book! I love Shirley Jackson to DEATH. Have you read "The Haunting of Hill House"?"

Yes! The best haunted house book EVER!


message 7: by Tom (new) - rated it 4 stars

Tom Excellent review Bill. You have moved this title several notches higher on my TBR list.


message 8: by Mackey (new) - added it

Mackey How is it that I've never read this book!!? Adding it to the list now.


message 9: by William (new) - added it

William WOW. On my list now!


message 10: by Dov (new) - added it

Dov Zeller Beautiful review and can't wait to get a hold of the book!


message 11: by Sharyl (new) - added it

Sharyl Fantastic review, Bill. I'm not sure why I haven't read this.


Carrie Five Star Review


Wow Bill. "...so mythic I am convinced I have known it always, like a tragic folktale or a chilling childhood dream."



Who knows how I got to this review today - thank gods for Back Arrow breadcrumbs, they've only succumbed to a drained battery twice - after all, I've already read this book once and I almost never read a book twice. Life is short etc., et.al.



But thanks to your review - thanks to you for your review, that is - it's now on a shelf where Again and Soon overlap. Hold on. On reflection I've decided to take it off the Again shelf. Not because I don't intend a second reading - it's still in the Soon queue - but because your insights & information have revealed an altogether different and no doubt better book than the one I read last time. Thanks, kudos, and respect, Bill. Keep em coming. Cheers!




Michael Fierce Another excellent review, Bill. There must be 10 of you to have read so many great books.


message 14: by Checkman (new)

Checkman Excellent. I have to read this one.


Allison Yes! A great review of a truly brilliant work.


message 16: by Carol (new) - added it

Carol Cool review. You are a fantastic writer.


message 17: by Greg (new) - rated it 4 stars

Greg Here's a twist: I did read it years ago and thought it was awesome and gave it a four star rating based on my recollection. But a recent revisit didn't live up to my recollection.


message 18: by Bill (new) - rated it 5 stars

Bill Kerwin Greg wrote: "Here's a twist: I did read it years ago and thought it was awesome and gave it a four star rating based on my recollection. But a recent revisit didn't live up to my recollection."

Hmm. I'm curious. What about that second reading disappointed you?


message 19: by Elin (new) - rated it 5 stars

Elin Great review - very interesting extra info on the autobiographical elements. This book has more atmosphere and suspense than ...well, I think any other book I've read. I loved it, and it made me dash out and grab any other Jacksons I could find. Looking forward to reading the Haunting of Hill House at some point too.


Michael Bill--this is a marvelous review. Like Elin, I especially appreciated the biographical connections to Jackson's own life, which I didn't know. This book is, for me, Shirley Jackson at her very finest. I can't wait to re-read this. Soon!


message 21: by William (last edited Aug 14, 2017 05:47AM) (new) - added it

William Bill, reading your loving review again today. Thank you again.

This is on my top-to-read list. I must promise myself, thrash my memory to action, to read this as soon as possible.

You Know how much I enjoy parallels between authors and the lives and places in their books. It’s the same feeling I got on the first day of basic integral Calculus classes so long ago:

WOW OMG! This is cheating! This is my dreams of FLYING! There is a hidden world here with a magic key, a simple key! It’s always been RIGHT HERE


Brittney Rust An excellent review of a captivating book. This book lingered with me, and I enjoyed learning more of the author’s history from this review.
I am interested in your interpretation of the ending as being sweet and sad; I found the last line to be deliciously chilling, leaving me with the feeling of being slightly haunted.


message 23: by Jan (new)

Jan Rice I somehow missed this review, Bill--and I haven't read the book, either. Even beyond what you wrote, I know the book must be fantastic, since this is just about your longest review ever. ;) Another one to aim to read some day.


Mizuki And Cousin Charles resembles her husband, in his critical comments about the housekeeping and his continual concerns about money.

Thanks for pointing this out!


Julie G Bill,
I really enjoyed this review, especially the added info about the author's life. I read my first Shirley Jackson just this week (The Haunting of Hill House) and I'm starved for more. I bought this one on Saturday and I can't wait to start it!


message 26: by Bill (last edited Oct 18, 2018 03:34PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Bill Kerwin Julie wrote: "Bill,
I really enjoyed this review, especially the added info about the author's life. I read my first Shirley Jackson just this week (The Haunting of Hill House) and I'm starved for more. I bought..."


I think you'll like it. I love "Hill House," but I think this is even better!


Danny This books has the most powerful first paragraph I have ever read. It is a literary mic drop.


Kelley I love all the extra biographical info! Just finished reading it and it has enriched my experience. "Read fiction as biography" yes I often have done that but never worded it so finely. I think I shall make a point to read up more on my authors and do it more often. Awesome review!


message 29: by Brittany (new) - added it

Brittany Lee Thank you for this rich review! Learning tidbits of the author this way makes me want to grab this title even faster! I am also kicking myself for not having picked this up sooner, I've had my eye on it for far too long!


Olibookslover I love the way you describe it as � chilling childhood dream�, which was exactly my feeling while reading the novel! Thanks a lot!


message 31: by [deleted user] (new)

Great review, Bill. Makes me want to read it even more.


message 32: by James (new) - added it

James Added to my "to read"!


message 33: by Christy (new) - added it

Christy Hall This is a beautiful review! I love Jackson’s works. This one is on my TBR pile. Very close to the top. Excited to read it!


message 34: by Alex (new) - rated it 4 stars

Alex Parham “Written in crystal clear prose, yet evocative.� THANK YOU for putting into words what I had so much trouble with!!!! Totally agree.


Lihsa I listened to this after reading her memoirs and thought I heard the voice of her daughter in Merrikat. I appreciate the confirmation. Very talented writer.


message 36: by [deleted user] (new)

I didn't think so many bits of the novel would resemble the author's life. I feel even more compelled to reread this now.


Regina Andreassen I echo your sentiments ! You articulated my view of this novella better than I did. A masterpiece indeed! I would like to thank you for the additional information your provided about Shirley Jackson.


message 38: by Reggie (new)

Reggie would this be a book for a ten year old?


message 39: by Bob (new) - rated it 5 stars

Bob No, this is not a book for a 10 year old even though Merrykat seems to be ten or twelve years old. I guess (spoiler alert) she's frozen at that age when she did that deed, although I would have to reread the book to double check this. A great read and I'm going to give it 5 stars.


Elizabeth Bob, it’s “Merricat�, not “Merrycat�.


Alissa Spot on!!!


Crisia Constantine Bill, seriously, it’s no ‘family rebuild an old life out of love,� they were both mad


Lindsey I could have never put all of this into words so well!


Lakea @Crisia With the exception of those with true antisocials (psycho/sociao paths), mentally ill people can still love.

The “lesson� at the end was that even poor and living in squalor, Merricat and Constance found a way to be happy because they still had each other.


Kathryn I found it very disappointing and the ending just daft, to be honest.


back to top