ŷ

Sidharth Vardhan's Reviews > Midaq Alley

Midaq Alley by Naguib Mahfouz
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
58296635
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: list-1001, nobel, 1-africa

I can see why it is called Mahfouz's best novel (although I personally like his 'Children of the Alley' more). It has a large number of well-developed and complex characters built with great psychological insight. The Egypt of second world war comes alive in these pages. The lower middle class characters - barbers, sweet shop owners etc which populate the book are very much like people belonging to similar classes that I have met in India.

Their psychology, their motivations which Mahfouz draws out so beautifully are universal though. The sexual desires suppressed because of social pressure, the strong desire to be move up from one's station in life, the constant consciousness of luxuries that are beyond one's reach - which also turn some people towards corrupt ways. In this novel this desire also makes the youth (among which it is felt most) take part in war as British army. Of course, once the war is over, the army lays them and their dreams out.

One feels for Hamida whose fate is similar to those who, like her, ignore their emotional needs in face of glamour of material comforts and only realise their mistake too late.

Another thing I can't help noticing, in all three Mahfouz books I have read so far, is bis refuse to take a judging tone or make social or moral criticism towards his characters, he seems to want to extend his willingness to understand to everyone - which I found sometimes pleasant and sometimes annoying.
66 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Midaq Alley.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

December 13, 2015 – Shelved
Started Reading
October 1, 2016 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-6 of 6 (6 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Lizzy (last edited Oct 06, 2016 07:35AM) (new)

Lizzy Thanks for such an amazing review, Sidharth! And for bringing it up to me. I never read anything by Mahfouz, but I will try to correct that in the near future. L.


Sidharth Vardhan Thanks Lizzy. He is an incredible writer. I have read three books from him and each is written in a different style. Hope you enjoy reading him as much as I do.


Lisa Happy to see you also love his novels, Sidharth! And I agree, Children Of The Alley is the opus magnum, but I seem to like everything he writes, and Midaq Alley is an excellent book.


Sidharth Vardhan Lisa wrote: "Happy to see you also love his novels, Sidharth! And I agree, Children Of The Alley is the opus magnum, but I seem to like everything he writes, and Midaq Alley is an excellent book."

I have grown to be his fan - three novels in less than a year and I'm already starting Palace Walk this week. There is something homely in his narrative voice. 'Children of the Alley' though is a personal book - you know the feeling? I feel it is more mine than author's.


أحمد غريب Sidharth wrote: "Lisa wrote: "Another thing I can't help noticing, in all three Mahfouz books I have read so far, is bis refuse to take a judging tone or make social or moral criticism towards his characters, he seems to want to extend his willingness to understand to everyone - which I found sometimes pleasant and sometimes annoying.
."
..."



i always find it annoying


Abdellatif Mahmoud Nope it is not even on best 10 books to naguib there's Cairo trilogy and the riffraff( harafish) idk and "Adrift on the Nile"
And children of the alley and journey of son of fatoma idk what's its name


back to top