Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Gaurav's Reviews > Jakob von Gunten

Jakob von Gunten by Robert Walser
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
8148922
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: classics-germany, favorites, swish

Jakob von Gunten
Robert Walser

Jakob von Gunten dissects the remote and vulnerable regions of human brain, the dramatic tensions between the fluctuating demons of inner self and the savage realities of outer world carves out an enigmatic reality which pierces your heart and thrusts yourself through the crests and troughs of an assorted compendium of human emotions. Written during a period which transformed German fiction, when refined, compact elementary forms of prose were taking shape, when prose was becoming more analytic, Jakob von Gunten could be said as an exemplary achievement in that sense; in fact could be named an analytic soliloquy. The prose of Robert Walser has got something very primal in nature, it reveals the naivete of an expressionist artists whose soliloquy unites the gleam of imagination and reality.

Jakob, an ambiguous creature has noble faith in simple ideas but the idea of 'God' deludes him. A pedantic, didactic, sanctimonious upstart, Jakob strangely combines arrogance and humility; an un-sleeping accurate dreamer who banters drowsing map of his routine activities. The book consists of his reflections on the education he receives in the school—an education in humility. The humility taught by the Benjamentas is not of the religious variety. Their graduates aspire to be serving men or butlers, not saints. Jakob is not like other pupils, his consciousness forbids him to surrender himself to the follies carried out in Benjamenta, for him the lessons in humility have a deep personal resonance. One learns very little here, observes young Jakob von Gunten after his first day at the Benjamenta Institute, where he has enrolled himself as a student. The teachers lie around like dead men. There is only one textbook, What is the Aim of Benjamenta’s Boys� School?, and only one lesson, How Should a Boy Behave? All the teaching is done by Fräulein Lisa Benjamenta, sister of the principal. Herr Benjamenta himself sits in his office and counts his money, like an ogre in a fairy tale. In fact, the school is a bit of a swindle. Walser's design of improvisation assumes its impression on Jakob's sensibility, his passion for surprise, paradoxes remains in a constant flux of fact and fantasy. The bourgeois runaway from elite lifestyle wants to become zero- to start from all the way down. As suggested by Sartre in Being and Nothingess - one has to get rid of his projections to reach to the core of being where from the true existence of a person emanates.

Though Walser and Jakob has much in common but the book can't be mistaken for a self-portrait. Jakob von Gunten could be said as a new creation, if not then its parody for sure, in the German wave of blending self and nobility -German Idealism- to venture social and cultural reforms. He is highly self-critical perhaps to the extent of Dostoyevsky' s character in The Underground Man and Confessions of Rousseau. One may get awestruck to note the discretion with which the pomposity of maturity and intellectualism are annihilated but without savageness. It would not be appropriate to keep Walser in the breath of literature in which we put Kafka, Sartre, Nietzsche and others since Walser has not been an 'intellectual' author- once it was said for him that he is 'comic Kafka'.

Jakob says:-
I value the way in which I open a door..... The generations of men losing the joy of life with all their treatises and understandings and knowledge.....I like running down stairs. What a lot of talk!

The prose is an escapade built around idea of tales full of surprise, adventure and paradoxes; probably a mischievous blocking of dramatic thrust, also a parody of epic breath. Walser's prose is a dance rather than a walk through words, small dialogue nuances in Jakob's monologues vibrate back and forth. The use of different vocabulary for different characters creates a distinct effect which seems to form vivid experience of nonrepresentational art. Kraus's vocabulary embodies an impression which seems to shape out his character of humility, servitude.

Kraus to Jakob:-
You, you've got yourself pregnant with silly ideas. What a notion. Do something! Work, then you won't notice anything. You snooper. Snooping around for opinions and thoughts. Go away. I'm beginning to hate the sight of you.


The reader constantly finds him/ herself in an ever-churning vortex of reality and imagination, you sometimes wonder whether Jakob himself is disturbing the holy brane of space and time to carve out something which can be taken for reality or it’s one of his fantastical follies emanating from the profundity of his brain. When he arrives in Benjamenta, he gets fascinated with the idea that there is a mystery at the heart of the institute, the mystery which, when one traverses through the deep cervices of it, may introduce oneself to the elementary realities of life. But once Jakob penetrates in to the conundrum, he finds a mere goldfish; however, an initiation seeds an enchantment before this, perhaps in Jakob’s mental space if not in physical space.
The book demands constant attention of the reader, for sometimes it may occur as highly condensed interior monologue and during other, it may simple be a mystical tale created out of contradiction and juxtaposition of words. It’s not like those creations of art which you may like or dislike instantly in entirety. One may get caught up with a strange feeling of irresoluteness about the book, it may take time to sink in.

127 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Jakob von Gunten.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

August 29, 2016 – Shelved as: to-read
August 29, 2016 – Shelved
August 29, 2016 – Shelved as: classics-germany
March 21, 2017 – Started Reading
March 21, 2017 –
page 9
4.55% "Generally, we pupils do not like to laugh, that is to say, we are hardly able to any more. We lack the requisite jolliness and airiness. Am I wrong? God knows, sometimes my whole stay here seems like an incomprehensible dream."
March 21, 2017 –
page 23
11.62% "Yes, I think of Mamma. She will be crying. Why don't I ever write to her ? I can't tell why, can't understand it, and yet I can't decide to write. That's it: I don't want to tell anything. It's too silly. A pity, I shouldn't have parents who love me. I don't want to be desired at all. They will have to get used to not having a son any more."
March 28, 2017 –
page 25
12.63% "What is the use of thoughts and ideas if one feels, as I do, that one doesn't know what to do with them?"
March 28, 2017 –
page 34
17.17% "Pain at the dreadfulness of what I had done chased me out of bed. I had seized the holy one by her respect-arousing hair and had thrown her to the ground. Oh, not to think of such things. The tears shot like sharp jets from the motherly eyes."
March 28, 2017 –
page 46
23.23% "My desire for experiences is growing into a domineering passion, and the pain which this strange man's annoyance causes me is small in comparison with my trembling wish to lead him into saying something a little revealing."
March 28, 2017 –
page 72
36.36% "Keep on being poor and despised, dear friend. Give up the money-idea, too. It's most lovely and triumphant thing, it makes one a very poor devil. Rich people, Jakob are very unsatisfied and unhappy. The rich today: they've got nothing left. They are the really starving people."
March 29, 2017 –
page 75
37.88% "Something great and audacious must happen in secrecy and silence, or perishes and falls away, and the fire that was awakened dies again."
March 29, 2017 –
page 82
41.41% "I would be attracted by deep things and by the soul, rather than by distances and things far off."
April 2, 2017 –
page 104
52.53% "One day I shall be laid low by a stroke, and then everything, all these confusions, this longing, this unknowing, all this, the gratitude and in-gratitude, this telling lies and self deception, this thinking that one knows and yet never knowing anything, will come to an end. But I want to live, no matter how."
April 2, 2017 –
page 123
62.12% "They're all alike in their rapid kindness, which just comes and goes, and I think this is because of the fear these people feel."
April 3, 2017 –
page 143
72.22% "Bare reality: what a crook it sometimes is. It steals things, and afterwards it has no idea what to do with them. It just seems to spread sorrow for fun. Of course, I like sorrow very much as well, it's very valuable, very. It shpaes one."
April 3, 2017 – Finished Reading
April 15, 2017 – Shelved as: favorites
April 15, 2017 – Shelved as: swish

Comments Showing 1-22 of 22 (22 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by [deleted user] (new)

Fantastic write-up! You have needled this book from inside out. With Walser, everything is strange and yet feels down to the earth. This review is pretty rad though- thanks!


message 2: by Samra (new)

Samra Yusuf so profound and tantalizing.............
I love to know about writers through my GR friends,you being a great source.....LOl


Gaurav Waqas wrote: "Fantastic write-up! You have needled this book from inside out. With Walser, everything is strange and yet feels down to the earth. This review is pretty rad though- thanks!"

Thanks a lot for your kind words, Waqas! You're right that Walser is a strange author- I've not read any author like him before, his prose is very unique in its own kind that you find it very hard to place it to put in any particular genres or literary forms, for it surpasses so many.


Gaurav Samra wrote: "so profound and tantalizing.............
I love to know about writers through my GR friends,you being a great source.....LOl"


Thanks a lot for kind words, Samra! It's nice to know that you've come to know about new authors due to me :)


message 5: by Samra (new)

Samra Yusuf you are most welcome Gaurav..
and yes,this is how it is......your to-read shelf is magnificent!


message 6: by Gaurav (last edited Apr 15, 2017 09:12AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Gaurav Samra wrote: "you are most welcome Gaurav..
and yes,this is how it is......your to-read shelf is magnificent!"


Thanks again Samra:) It's the speciality of GR, I've also come to know about some of the books from fellow readers.


message 7: by Nicole (new) - added it

Nicole Fantastic review! I'm really looking forward to reading this one. Thanks!


Gaurav Nicole wrote: "Fantastic review! I'm really looking forward to reading this one. Thanks!"

Thanks a lot for your kind words, Nicole! I'll be looking towards your opinion on it :)


Ellen Great review, Gaurav. I loved this book. Your review made me want to read it again.


Gaurav Ellie wrote: "Great review, Gaurav. I loved this book. Your review made me want to read it again."

Thanks a lot Ellie for your kind words, I'm looking forward towards your opinion when you get to it :)


message 11: by [deleted user] (new)

What a splendid review, Gaurav, which demanded my 'constant attention' due to its complex and highly alluring intricacy. :) Perfect analysis, and I absolutely loved your closing paragraph!


message 12: by Gaurav (last edited Apr 18, 2017 10:47AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Gaurav Scarlett wrote: "What a splendid review, Gaurav, which demanded my 'constant attention' due to its complex and highly alluring intricacy. :) Perfect analysis, and I absolutely loved your closing paragraph!"

Thanks a lot Scarlett for your generous words, I'm glad that you liked it :)


message 13: by Sh (new) - added it

Sh Kishan Another excellent review, thanks for it Gaurav.


Gaurav Jai wrote: "Another excellent review, thanks for it Gaurav."

Thanks for kind words, will be looking towards your opinion on it


Gaurav Yogita wrote: "Amazingly written !! Wonderful review.."

Thanks a lot dear for kind words, I'll be looking towards your opinion on it whenever you get to it :)


message 16: by Kumar (new) - added it

Kumar Asish Fine review, will be trying it soon.


Manfred I Think much of the review is convincing. But I would like the novel much more, when the author had considered this comment when writing:
Kraus to Jakob:-
You, you've got yourself pregnant with silly ideas. What a notion. Do something! Work, then you won't notice anything. You snooper. Snooping around for opinions and thoughts. Go away. I'm beginning to hate the sight of you.


message 18: by Gaurav (last edited Oct 03, 2017 06:32PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Gaurav Manfred wrote: "I Think much of the review is convincing. But I would like the novel much more, when the author had considered this comment when writing:
Kraus to Jakob:-
You, you've got yourself pregnant with sil..."


Thanks Manfred, I agree those words are quite powerful as they undermines need of ideas to action in a caricatural manner yet very smoothly.


Gaurav Kumar wrote: "Fine review, will be trying it soon."

Thanks a lot, missed your comment. Hopefully you'll find it interesting :)


message 20: by Steven (new)

Steven Godin Excellent review Gaurav.


Gaurav Steven wrote: "Excellent review Gaurav."

Thanks a lo Steven :)


message 22: by Komi (new)

Komi Dr


back to top